Incredible deal opportunity, nervous because it’s over my budget

Incredible deal opportunity, nervous because it’s over my budget

Member since 2022 · 3 posts · 1 vote

I've had a plan for 3 average rentals in 5 years to get started. I've been looking at $225k-$250k. I haven't looked for home runs at all. Until this deal fell into my lap, and I got my offer accepted. This home is $300k. I can barely afford it with around $150 a month left after my base pay. I just need some advice. I'm very realistically buying this home with 85k-125k equity. It needs a little work. HVAC quoted $8,800, and pool inspectors being done. For sure needs a liner. The inspection will tell me of anything else. I just need some advice. I don't need to be told about the best upside, or another 08 situation. I'm planning a 2 year flip at this moment. This one probably wouldn't be an LTR, but very real opportunity to be an STR, or a live in 2 year flip. It's an 1 1/2 from my work 4-5 days a week. It's a 4b 3.5 bath house is one of the best communities in the area. Anyone able to help me estimate real Reno cost, just help me understand what I need to know. This is my first deal I've owned. Haven't signed papers, aside from the offer accepted.

1Reply
441 views

Most Popular Reply

Josh HandlerPro Member
Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 53 posts · 57 votes
1w

You asked what you need to know rather than whether to do it, so I'll answer that literally. I'm a contractor, so I'm the guy who eventually writes these numbers, and there are four things in your post I'd want answered before your inspection period closes.

THE POOL IS THE BIGGEST ITEM IN YOUR POST AND YOU GAVE IT SIX WORDS

"For sure needs a liner" is the cheapest possible pool outcome, and liners rarely fail alone. Questions I'd want answered: has the pool been holding water, and if not, for how long has it been down. Does the equipment actually run, meaning pump, filter and heater each energized and observed running, not just present. Is there movement in the deck or coping, because a shifting deck and a torn liner are frequently the same event. And is the plumbing to the pool intact, which is a separate test from the liner and a much more expensive answer.

A pool that has sat empty or low is a different animal than one with a torn liner. Empty pools can float, crack, and have plumbing dry out and fail on startup. Get a pool company out, not the general inspector, and pay them.

The part nobody has mentioned: a pool is a permanent operating cost and an insurance item, and on a two year exit it narrows your buyer pool in most markets rather than widening it. That's a resale variable, not just a repair.

THE HVAC QUOTE MAY BE HALF A NUMBER

A 4 bed, 3.5 bath house often has two systems or two zones. Confirm in writing whether that $8,800 covers the whole house or one unit, and whether it includes any ductwork. Equipment-only pricing on undersized or leaking duct is a number that grows once somebody is on site, and a new condenser on bad duct underperforms, which your buyer's inspector will find in two years.

YOU'RE GETTING QUOTES BEFORE THE INSPECTION, WHICH IS BACKWARDS

Inspection first, then take the report to specialists for the three or four items carrying real money, then total it. Right now you have a firm number on one system and a guess on everything else, which is the exact shape of a budget that doubles. Doing it in the other order costs a few hundred dollars and a week and it's the best money in this transaction.

THE 85 TO 125K OF EQUITY IS WHAT I'D INTERROGATE HARDEST

Where did that range come from? If it came from the agent who wrote your offer, it isn't an appraisal, it's a sales aid. I'd want three actual sold comps with square footage, condition and dates before treating it as real. On a two year live-in flip that number is the entire thesis, so it deserves more scrutiny than the HVAC quote does.

THE ONE NOBODY HAS NAMED

You're planning to live in it while renovating. With $150 a month of margin, the thing that breaks you isn't a big repair bill, it's a repair that makes the house temporarily uninhabitable. HVAC replacement in the wrong season, a plumbing failure, floors going in. If any of that forces you into a hotel for two weeks, you're carrying two places to live out of $150 a month of slack. Price that scenario now rather than discovering it, and earmark a reserve specifically for it.

Last thing, plainly, since you asked for advice instead of encouragement. You haven't signed anything but an accepted offer. The ability to walk away is free right now and it is the most valuable thing you own in this deal. It stops being free when your inspection period closes. So use that window hard, get real numbers on the pool, the full HVAC scope and whatever the inspection turns up, then put the total next to your actual cash. If it holds, you go in with confidence instead of hope. If it doesn't, you spent a few hundred dollars to avoid a two year problem, which is the cheapest outcome available to you today.

Good luck with it. Being nervous rather than certain is a better sign than you probably think.

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Bradley BuxtonBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · NV · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 711 votes
    1w

    @Kevin Derrick

    Who ever is going to do the work, contractor or DIY, will be the best ones to give an accurate estimate. Also look to see what is selling in the area around and what types of finishes those homes have. What you want to avoid is over renovation and pricing your home out of the market. Have you had a general home inspection? If so bring in some specialists like the HVAC, plumbers, roofers, and electricians. You might have to pay them a bit to give you an estimate but it will help with the renovation cost estimates.

  • Gregory AcsPro Member
    Lender · MD · Member since 2025 · 133 posts · 52 votes
    1w

    I'd be careful not to let the equity potential outweigh your monthly affordability. If you're only left with about $150 each month before unexpected repairs, I'd want to make sure you have enough reserves for the renovation, carrying costs, and surprises that almost always come up on a first project. A great deal can still become stressful if the financing leaves you with very little margin for error.

  • Nicholas FloydBusiness Member
    NY · Member since 2026 · 166 posts · 56 votes
    1w

    Kevin, the potential equity is attractive, but I’d be careful about stretching your monthly budget down to $150 on your first deal. A property can be a great investment and still be the wrong deal if it leaves you without enough reserves to handle unexpected expenses.

    Before moving forward, I’d want a complete renovation budget from qualified contractors, including the HVAC, pool liner, and anything else the inspections uncover. I’d also look closely at the carrying costs, insurance, taxes, and what happens if the property takes longer than expected to sell. A two-year flip can work, but you don’t want the entire strategy depending on appreciation.

    On the funding side, I work with investors to help them access business capital, including business lines of credit, business loans, and 0% APR business credit cards where qualified. Depending on your credit profile and LLC structure, those options may help with eligible renovation or operating expenses while preserving cash reserves. However, I’d only consider that if the repayment plan is clear and the additional debt doesn’t put you in a tighter position.

    Have you already determined the total cash you’ll need to close, complete the renovations, and maintain a comfortable reserve, or are you still working through those numbers?

  • Josh HandlerPro Member
    Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 53 posts · 57 votes
    1w

    You asked what you need to know rather than whether to do it, so I'll answer that literally. I'm a contractor, so I'm the guy who eventually writes these numbers, and there are four things in your post I'd want answered before your inspection period closes.

    THE POOL IS THE BIGGEST ITEM IN YOUR POST AND YOU GAVE IT SIX WORDS

    "For sure needs a liner" is the cheapest possible pool outcome, and liners rarely fail alone. Questions I'd want answered: has the pool been holding water, and if not, for how long has it been down. Does the equipment actually run, meaning pump, filter and heater each energized and observed running, not just present. Is there movement in the deck or coping, because a shifting deck and a torn liner are frequently the same event. And is the plumbing to the pool intact, which is a separate test from the liner and a much more expensive answer.

    A pool that has sat empty or low is a different animal than one with a torn liner. Empty pools can float, crack, and have plumbing dry out and fail on startup. Get a pool company out, not the general inspector, and pay them.

    The part nobody has mentioned: a pool is a permanent operating cost and an insurance item, and on a two year exit it narrows your buyer pool in most markets rather than widening it. That's a resale variable, not just a repair.

    THE HVAC QUOTE MAY BE HALF A NUMBER

    A 4 bed, 3.5 bath house often has two systems or two zones. Confirm in writing whether that $8,800 covers the whole house or one unit, and whether it includes any ductwork. Equipment-only pricing on undersized or leaking duct is a number that grows once somebody is on site, and a new condenser on bad duct underperforms, which your buyer's inspector will find in two years.

    YOU'RE GETTING QUOTES BEFORE THE INSPECTION, WHICH IS BACKWARDS

    Inspection first, then take the report to specialists for the three or four items carrying real money, then total it. Right now you have a firm number on one system and a guess on everything else, which is the exact shape of a budget that doubles. Doing it in the other order costs a few hundred dollars and a week and it's the best money in this transaction.

    THE 85 TO 125K OF EQUITY IS WHAT I'D INTERROGATE HARDEST

    Where did that range come from? If it came from the agent who wrote your offer, it isn't an appraisal, it's a sales aid. I'd want three actual sold comps with square footage, condition and dates before treating it as real. On a two year live-in flip that number is the entire thesis, so it deserves more scrutiny than the HVAC quote does.

    THE ONE NOBODY HAS NAMED

    You're planning to live in it while renovating. With $150 a month of margin, the thing that breaks you isn't a big repair bill, it's a repair that makes the house temporarily uninhabitable. HVAC replacement in the wrong season, a plumbing failure, floors going in. If any of that forces you into a hotel for two weeks, you're carrying two places to live out of $150 a month of slack. Price that scenario now rather than discovering it, and earmark a reserve specifically for it.

    Last thing, plainly, since you asked for advice instead of encouragement. You haven't signed anything but an accepted offer. The ability to walk away is free right now and it is the most valuable thing you own in this deal. It stops being free when your inspection period closes. So use that window hard, get real numbers on the pool, the full HVAC scope and whatever the inspection turns up, then put the total next to your actual cash. If it holds, you go in with confidence instead of hope. If it doesn't, you spent a few hundred dollars to avoid a two year problem, which is the cheapest outcome available to you today.

    Good luck with it. Being nervous rather than certain is a better sign than you probably think.

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    1w

    If you’re sure about your numbers just turn around and it list it for sale ASAP. Making $60k out of that minimum $80k equity for doing NOtHiNG is the home run, not fixing it up and hoping you don’t run out of money or find a hidden problem. You could easily sink $20k in to the deal and add $25-30k in value. You make 10% more for taking on a boatload of risk and wasting time. Take the money and run. But be sure. Because the way you’re going to find out you were wrong about the equity is when it doesn’t sell. BUT. It’s way better to find that out before you fix it up rather than after. Imagine sinking in all that time and money in to repairs and then you can’t sell for you have in to it? That’s what happens if you can’t sell today for that estimated equity.

  • Member since 2022 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    6h

    Thank you guys so much for the reply. I originally posted this out of fear of just the biggest decision.

    For clarity, I’ve received the home inspection, most of the items were such as one 13 year old HVAC replacement, railing height, garage door springs, obvious pool issues he couldn’t test, and a few things he pointed out as I walked it with him. Did a really good job being detailed. Home inspection actually really made me feel a lot better.

    As for the pool, I did my due diligence but I’m not an expert at all. I had a specialty company come out and pressure test the lines, and it verified there was no issue with them. However they couldn’t test the main drain due to the natural rain water collecting in the bottom of the deep end. I asked for his professional thoughts (as he said he’d been doing this 10+ years) and he said he’s not seen a main drain issue from a pool in this good of condition. The liner is ripped to shreds. Home owner drained the pool this spring, and that’s when the liner ripped. Their words. But he seemed to kinda agree with that statement the best he could. My mom works for Tara pools. She sent me someone with a reasonably priced quote for liner replacement and a steps fix kit repair. Only $3500, and the liner is going to cost me $1400. The pool is what my biggest concern was. So thank you guys for catching that, honestly.

    The only repairs I’m looking at making are one HVAC 2 ton gas/electric(8k), flooring in the master and upstairs bedrooms plus bonus room (7k), pool liner and fixes (6k) as well as a couple electrical outlets($500) It checked out way better than I anticipated. I wasn’t sure the cost of anything, so I had budgeted 15k hvac, 10k pool, 8k flooring, and 8k contingency.

    The home is an asset, and it’s in a premier neighborhood on the lake. The idea of Equity didn’t make me jump to irrational decision. I close early October and I just now let myself get excited. Reno loan still has a few kinks to work out, but that’s just my inexperience and lack of my own research there. I have the ability to work plenty of OT, and roommates are a real option. Either long term tenants or as an MTR. The $150 was base pay, no roommates, very high gas budgeted, very high utilities budgeted both for worst cases. And I have 12k cash in reserves for this home. My plan is to work that back to 30k before letting up and really buying random stuff.

    Means a lot for you all to reach out, and answer realistic and logical. Please if you have any advice for me, I’m never the smartest man in the rooms I put myself in.

  • Member since 2022 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    6h

    Also, I’m not trying to just carry this home as a flashy home. I plan on house hacking as safe, but as well as I can.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2h

    Kevin, the part I’d pay the most attention to is not the projected $85K–$125K of equity, it’s the fact that you’d only have about $150/month left from your base pay after buying it.

    That is a very thin margin for a first deal, especially when you already know about the HVAC, pool liner, and there may be more once the inspection is complete. Equity is great, but it doesn’t pay for an unexpected $8K repair next month unless you can access it.

    Before moving forward, I'd pressure-test the deal under three scenarios: living there for two years, operating it as an STR if local rules and insurance allow, and eventually selling or flipping it. I'd also make sure you still have a real emergency reserve after closing, not just enough cash to get the keys.

    For the STR angle, I would not assume the larger home automatically works just because it sleeps more people. I'd look at realistic occupancy, ADR, cleaning, utilities, pool costs, furnishing, management, insurance, and whether the local regulations actually support the plan.

    From the tax side, if you live there first and later convert all or part of it to rental use, depreciation and placed-in-service timing become important. If you eventually treat it as a flip, that activity is generally active business income, and if flipping becomes consistent and profitable, I’d also evaluate whether an S-Corp makes sense based on profit level, activity volume, payroll, and reasonable compensation.

    There can also be a strong planning opportunity if you eventually combine active flip income with rental real estate. Depending on participation, depreciation, entity structure, and whether the rental losses are actually usable, those losses may sometimes offset active real estate income. In the right fact pattern, taxable income can potentially be reduced very significantly, even to zero, but it has to be planned correctly.

    I’d rather see you buy a slightly less exciting property with strong reserves than win a deal that leaves you financially boxed in.

    Feel free to DM me, I'd be happy to send over a few resources that might help with deal analysis, STR planning, and downside scenarios.

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®5241 Reviews
    TaxMD™ | AI-Powered Tax Planning
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.