Testing contractors in small paid steps before the emergency

General Landlording & Rental Properties
2dFollow

Testing contractors in small paid steps before the emergency

Rosina Persaud
Member since 2023 · 142 posts · 45 votes

The worst time to find out a contractor is unreliable is when a pipe bursts and a tenant is calling.

We run 236 single-family rentals in Memphis, mostly Section 8, and we don't test a new contractor on an emergency. We test them in small paid steps, months before anything breaks.

The first job is small and easy to check: a faucet swap, a fence board, a lock change. We pay on time and in full, and we watch three things: did they show up when they said they would, did they communicate if something changed, and did the work hold up two weeks later?

If they pass, the jobs get a little bigger: a turnover punch list, then a full rent-ready turnover on our 21-day scheduling system. If they don't pass, we find out on a small job instead of a big one — and a turnover that drags costs us more than the repair itself, because vacancy is the expensive part.

The point is simple: your bench is built in the quiet weeks, not during the emergency.

How do you vet a new contractor before you trust them with a real job?

3Reply
413 views

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Muyees Ayilara
    Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 234 posts · 95 votes
    2d

    Rosina, this is exactly how it should work.

    I see the other side of it on the lending side — when a borrower doesn't have a tested contractor, the whole rehab timeline falls apart. The draw gets delayed, the inspection fails, the contractor goes quiet, and then the loan is sitting there burning interest while nothing gets done. Your point about vacancy being the expensive part is so true. A bad turnover that drags an extra two weeks costs way more than whatever you saved trying out a cheap contractor on a big job. The small paid test is smart because you're not just testing the work, you're testing if they show up, communicate, and come back if something doesn't hold. That's the stuff you can't tell from a bid. I tell new investors the same thing — build your bench in the quiet weeks, because when you actually need them, you don't have time to vet anyone.

    0Reply
  • Randy Schell
    Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 287 posts · 45 votes
    2d

    A contractor who calls back is worth keeping in the rotation.... I’d note the kind of job they handled well too, so when something breaks you know who’s proven for that repair and who’s only done a small test.

    Randy, Bunklow

    0Reply
  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 296 posts · 69 votes
    2d

    One thing that's helped us: ask a new contractor to send a quick before-and-after photo and a short note when the job is done. How they handle that small stuff tells you a lot about how they'll communicate on a bigger turnover.

    [email protected]949-391-1019
    Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Divin KanyamaBusiness Member
    Accountant · Seattle, WA · Member since 2025 · 684 posts · 287 votes
    2d

    This is the right approach, @Rosina Persaud. The small paid trial is the only vetting that tells you what a reference call cannot: how someone behaves when they have no reason to impress you yet. I use a similar process, and I would add a few things to the front end. Before the first job, I confirm their license and insurance (general liability and workers' comp, or a signed waiver), and I ask for one reference from another landlord or property manager rather than a homeowner, since rental work is a different pace. I also pay close attention to how they quote. A clear, itemized quote that matches what I described tells me they listened, and a vague number or a rough guess tells me they may not manage a job well.

    On the first jobs, I score the same things you do, plus whether they leave the unit clean, send photos without being asked, and fix a callback without an argument. I also give new contractors a job where a no-show is annoying but not costly, so a failure never turns into extra vacancy. The best sign for me is how they handle a problem. Every contractor eventually runs into something unexpected, and the ones worth keeping tell me early, offer a plan, and do not disappear. Once someone passes a few small jobs, I move them up to turnovers and try to keep a backup for each trade, so I am never dependent on one person when something breaks.

    [email protected]
    WEMBO CPA532 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
  • Ming Yi
    Investor · San Francisco · Member since 2026 · 58 posts · 26 votes
    2d

    My rule is small, paid, and easy to judge. A good first test is a contained repair with a clear pass or fail, like swapping a faucet, fixing a running toilet, or replacing a garbage disposal. It tells you whether they show up on time, communicate, leave the place clean, and charge what they quoted, and if it fails you are only out a small job. I ask the same few questions on every walk: what is the fix, what could go wrong, what does it cost, and when can you do it. Then I check the repair about 60 days later to see whether it actually held, because a fix that fails in six weeks is not a fix. The vendors who pass the small test get the bigger calls, and I keep one short sheet per vendor with what they do, what they charge, and whether they call back. That sheet matters more than any single job.

    0Reply
  • John Cafarelli
    Member since 2026 · 22 posts · 6 votes
    1d

    Rosina, I do the same thing at a much smaller scale, and it has saved me more than once. My first job for someone new is always small, paid, and easy to judge, like a running toilet or a lock change, never a job where a tenant is waiting without water or heat. Before they start, I write down the scope in plain language, the price, and when I expect photos of the finished work. Then I watch the basics you named: did they arrive when promised, did they tell me when something changed, and did they leave the place clean? I pay the same day the job checks out, because I want to be the landlord good vendors answer first. I also keep a short note for each vendor with what they did, what it cost, and whether I would call them again, plus one backup for each trade. If a small repair fails within a month, that tells me more than a perfect quote ever could. Building that bench slowly is the only way I stay calm when a real emergency hits.

    0Reply
  • Matthew Tregoning
    Property Manager · Melbourne, FL · Member since 2019 · 561 posts · 193 votes
    1d

    I'd add the access handoff to that small-job test. Working with vacation rentals, I care about whether someone confirms arrival, tells us if the job will overrun, and leaves the property secure and ready for the next person. A technically good repair still creates work if the manager has to chase those details. I'd write those expectations into the first job brief so the contractor knows exactly what we're evaluating, then ask what they need from us to make the visit go smoothly.

    0Reply
  • Daniel Jung
    Member since 2026 · 79 posts · 28 votes
    1d

    This is the right order, and the part most owners skip is writing down the pass mark beforehand. Decide what good looks like: showed up on time, called if delayed, left the place clean, sent before and after photos, and the work held two weeks later. If any of those fail, the test failed, even if the price was low. Pay fast on the small jobs. The good contractors remember who pays on time, and that is what gets you a call back when a pipe breaks. Keep a note per contractor: trade, small job price, date, and whether they passed. That price note stops the next quote from drifting up without a reason. Build one backup per trade while things are quiet. A bench of one is not a bench. When the first choice is busy, the second one should already know your houses and your lockbox routine.

    0Reply
    • Rosina Persaud
      OP
      Member since 2023 · 142 posts · 45 votes
      1d

      Daniel, that's the piece I should have spelled out — the pass mark written down before the job starts. We score the same things you listed: showed up on time, called if delayed, left the place clean, sent before-and-after photos, and the work held two weeks later. If any of those fail, the test failed, even if the price was low.

      Your note per contractor is exactly how we keep it honest: trade, the small-job price, the date, and whether they passed. That price note stops the next quote from drifting for no reason. And one backup per trade is the bench — when the first choice is busy, the second one should already know our houses and our lockbox routine. Thanks for adding this.

      0Reply
  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 693 votes
    6h

    Everyone's covered how to score the job, so I'll add the paperwork that makes the small test count for tax too. Before the first payment, I'd get a W-9 from the contractor. Once someone is paid over the reporting threshold in a year you generally owe them a 1099, and chasing a W-9 in January from someone who already stopped answering your calls is a lot harder. Your CPA can confirm the current threshold.

    Daniel and Ming both mentioned a note per vendor, and I'd put the W-9 status on that same sheet, along with the invoice and which property it was for. Pay by check or bank transfer from the property's account, not cash, so every payment has a trail.

    The last piece is tagging the invoice as repair or improvement when it arrives. A $180 faucet swap is a repair and fully expensed. A $6,000 turnover that includes new flooring may be partly capital. If it's tagged when the invoice comes in, that decision doesn't wait until April.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
    0Reply
  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 959 posts · 344 votes
    3h

    @Rosina Persaud this is how we've had the best luck too. A small paid job first, something you can actually judge, tells you more than a reference call. Show-up time, communication, and whether the work holds up a couple weeks later are the three I watch. Paying on time matters on your side as well, because the good ones remember who does. Building that bench before the emergency is the whole point. Vacancy from a slow turnover usually costs more than the repair did.

    [email protected]484-791-6200
    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme548 Reviews
    WebsiteView Page
    0Reply
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.
Log InJoin for Free