Investor · UT · Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 3 votes
I was just looking over how to calculate NOI on a property, and when I went to fill in for insurance, I realized I have no idea what kind of insurance you get for a rental property.
My question is, what do you consider the minimum coverage, and what else do you like to cover in addition to that? (Are you just insuring the structure, or does this insurance include damage done by tenants, vacancies etc?)
Furthermore, does this change with the niche you are investing in? Single family, Multi-family or a House Hack where you reside in one of the units of a multi-family.
Thanks for any tips, I am new to running the numbers on rental properties.
Kayden, great question to ask before you buy — insurance is one of those costs that can make or break a rental. You'll want a landlord or dwelling policy rather than a homeowner's policy, since you're not living in the home; that covers the structure and your liability if someone gets hurt there. Most investors I know also add loss of rents coverage, so a fire or a major repair doesn't leave you with a mortgage and no income, and an umbrella policy once you own more than one property. The right mix does change by strategy — a house hack where you live in one unit is different from a straight rental, and short-term rentals usually need a different policy altogether. The best next step is a call with an insurance broker who works with investors in your market; they'll quote the coverages to build into your underwriting.
Insurance agent here: for a straight rental you want a landlord (dwelling fire) policy covering the structure, liability and loss of rents. Normal tenant wear and tear isn't covered, so lean on deposits and require renters insurance. Watch vacancy, since many policies restrict coverage after 60 days empty. A house hack you live in usually goes on a homeowners policy instead.
Okay, when things get a little more serious over the next few weeks, I will get ahold of some agents and start to get a better idea of what kinds of coverage, and the assosiated costs are in my state.
For now, is their a quick way to estimate what insurance usually is for a rental? I know thats a difficult question to ask, so even a vauge rule of thumb would be usfull for the next few weeks as I learn how to do the math.
There's no reliable rule of thumb, because rates swing a lot by state, roof age, construction and claims history. The quickest real number is to ask an agent for a ballpark on a listing you're actually analyzing and use that in your math. Expect a landlord policy to run a bit higher than homeowners on the same house.