What data signals do you trust most for finding off-market deals in Ohio?

What data signals do you trust most for finding off-market deals in Ohio?

Wholesaler · Columbus, OH · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 2 votes

Hey BP community,

I've been investing in Columbus for a few years and lately I've been going deeper into county data — building permits, code violations, tax delinquency — to find motivated sellers before they hit MLS.

The combination that's been working best for me: properties with 90+ days on market + a price drop + tax delinquency flags. Those sellers have usually accepted reality on price.

Curious what others are using. Anyone having luck with code violation lists? Skip tracing? I've been experimenting with pulling county ArcGIS data directly but it's a lot of manual work per county.

Markets I'm active in: Columbus, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Toledo, Dayton, Akron, Canton, Youngstown.

2Reply
1,134 views

Investor-friendly agents in Ohio, PA

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in Ohio, PA.

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2014 · 144 posts · 86 votes
    1mo

    I don’t think there’s one signal I’d trust by itself. The value comes from stacking signals that strengthen each other.

    Tax delinquency, code violations, absentee ownership, high equity, vacancy, or a long ownership period may each mean very little alone. When several overlap (and the underlying events are recent) you have a much stronger reason to prioritize that owner.

    Skip tracing is separate. It doesn’t tell you whether someone is motivated; it only determines whether you can reach them.

    Ultimately, I’d track each signal and combination through actual conversations, offers, and contracts. That’s the only reliable way to learn which data is creating opportunities versus just creating a larger list.

  • Wholesaler · Columbus, OH · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 2 votes
    1mo

    Great points on stacking signals - that matches my experience exactly. Any single flag is noise, but recency plus overlap is where the real signal lives.

    I've been scoring my lists with a composite approach: yield-weighted scoring that blends tax delinquency, time on market, price cuts, and pre-foreclosure status. The recent-event filter you mentioned made a big difference - a 2-year-old code violation means much less than one filed last month.

    On skip tracing being separate from motivation - agreed, and I'd add that it's the biggest hidden cost. Building a strong list you can't reach is just an expensive spreadsheet.

    What's your process for tracking signal performance through to contracts? I've been meaning to set up a simple feedback loop - conversation rate by signal combination - but haven't gotten further than noting it manually.

  • Wholesaler · Columbus, OH · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 2 votes
    1mo

    Great points on stacking signals - that matches my experience exactly. Any single flag is noise, but recency plus overlap is where the real signal lives.

    On tracking signal performance through to contracts - here's what's been working for me. I log every outreach attempt against the signal combination that produced the lead: which flags were present, how recent, and the source (tax delinquency list vs code violation vs DOM + price cut). Then I track three conversion points: contact rate (did they answer), conversation rate (did they engage), and contract rate.

    The pattern so far: tax delinquency alone converts worst - those owners are often in genuine hardship and hard to reach. The best performing combination is 90+ DOM with a price cut plus absentee ownership - those sellers are already motivated by the market's verdict, they just need an offer that respects their timeline. Code violations filed within the last 60 days add real signal on top of either.

    The feedback loop is simple but you have to be disciplined about logging it. Even a shared spreadsheet with signal combo, date, outcome, and next step tells you within 20-30 outreach attempts which combinations deserve more of your list budget.

    What I've found most valuable is refusing to trust any list I can't tie back to conversations. The data is only worth what the conversations prove.

  • Technology · Member since 2026 · 43 posts · 6 votes
    2w

    Hey Blake! I've actually been dealing with some of the same challenges while putting together property research for GroundVerity.

    One thing that's been particularly interesting is how much context can get lost when you're comparing county data from different dates.

    For example, when researching delinquent-tax records, I've learned that a property no longer appearing on a newer list doesn't necessarily tell you what happened. It's tempting to assume the taxes were paid, but without checking the underlying records, that would still be an assumption.

    We've also encountered situations where ownership information differs between county sources, so simply combining everything into one dataset doesn't always give you a clear answer.

    I think that's been one of my biggest takeaways from the research so far. Sometimes, knowing what the data doesn't establish is just as useful as knowing what it shows.

    And yeah, I can definitely relate to the amount of work involved in pulling information from different county systems!

  • Wholesaler · Columbus, OH · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 2 votes
    1w

    Hey Mark - this matches what I've run into. A parcel dropping off the newer delinquent list feels like 'taxes paid', but it can just as easily be a posting lag, a parcel split, or a purge of aged entries, so I've stopped treating list membership as evidence. Confirming the change against a recorded event - a deed transfer, a sheriff's sale entry, or the payment ledger - is the only thing that settles it for me. Same story with ownership conflicts between the auditor and the recorder: the recorded instrument wins, not whichever site is fresher. Your last point is the one I'd underline - asking 'what would confirm this?' before 'how do I score this?' has saved me from more bad lists than any scoring tweak. And the county-by-county grind never fully goes away either; the skill is knowing your assumption window and checking the recorder before acting on anything older than it.

  • Wholesaler · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2014 · 27 posts · 8 votes
    1w

    Blake, for Ohio I have learned to trust stacked signals way more than any single list. One signal alone is usually noise. A property that is tax delinquent and absentee owned and has been held 10 plus years is a much better bet than just absentee by itself. Code violations and probate filings stack well with that too.

    On where to pull it, I start with the county auditor and tax records to confirm who actually owns it right now before I spend anything on outreach. That one check saves a lot of wasted skip traces on properties that already sold.

    For skip tracing itself, the mailing address is the key input, especially on vacant or out of state owners. Do not just trace the property address. I test a small batch first, like 50 to 100 records, and check how many come back with multiple working wireless numbers and an email, and whether LLC or trust owned properties actually get traced or just come back blank. A lot of cheap traces look good until you hit those. Then I track which stacked signal actually produced conversations, not just contacts, and I put more weight on that signal next pull.

  • Jordan FioreBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Cincinnati, OH · Member since 2020 · 209 posts · 153 votes
    1w

    Blake, this matches what I'm seeing from the buyer side in Cincinnati. The single-signal lists are mostly noise — the combinations that actually turn into conversations for me are absentee ownership plus a long hold plus real equity. That's the tired-landlord profile: someone who's owned a small multifamily for 10-plus years, hasn't touched the rents, and is ready to be done managing it. Tax delinquency alone has been the weakest signal in my experience — those owners are often in genuine hardship and hard to reach.

    One thing I'd add on skip tracing: test a small batch first and check how many come back with a real mailing address and a working number, especially on LLC- or trust-owned properties. A cheap trace that returns blanks on the exact owners you most want to reach isn't cheap. And the mailing address is the key input — tracing the property address on an absentee owner just gets you the tenant.

    The feedback loop point in this thread is the real discipline. I track which signal combination produced each conversation, not just each contact, and that tells you within a few dozen touches which stacks deserve more of the list budget. Happy to compare notes on what's converting in Cincinnati versus Columbus.

    Jordan Fiore, Realtor - eXp Realty568 Reviews
  • Wholesaler · Columbus, OH · Member since 2026 · 9 posts · 2 votes
    5d

    Jordan and Jarred — thank you both, this is the cross-check I was hoping for.

    Jordan, your tired-landlord profile is what converts best on my Columbus lists too — absentee + a 10+ year hold + real equity, and the rents untouched. One Columbus twist I keep seeing: since early fall the buyer pool has softened, so those owners entertain more creative/seller-financing asks than a straight cash offer, and they know it. Would gladly compare Cincinnati vs Columbus notes on that.

    Jarred, on batch testing: agreed, and your failure case is exactly mine — one strong signal on paper, then half the LLC/trust traces come back with nothing usable. I now make "verified mailing address + one working wireless" a pass/fail gate before a record earns any outreach budget. And delinquency-only keeps converting worst for me too — hardship owners are the hardest to reach. +1 on list age not mattering as long as ownership and sale status get rechecked right before the spend.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.