Waiting on a half-point rate drop? 5% off the price does the same today

Waiting on a half-point rate drop? 5% off the price does the same today

David LurveyPro Member
Technology · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2026 · 36 posts · 7 votes

Follow-up to last week's thread on how fragile DSCR 1.25 is at 20% down. That one asked what pushes a deal under 1.25. This one asks the opposite: which lever gets a near-miss over it.

Same screen: 33,376 homes for sale with a rent estimate across 8 markets (Indianapolis, Kansas City, Houston, Dallas, Springfield MO, Sarasota, Crestview and Panama City FL). Site-built only, 20% down, 30-year at 7.25% (7.625% on 2-4 units), full PITIA. 507 clear 1.25 today.

What each lever does on its own:
- 5% off the price: 732
- Half a point off the rate: 726
- 25% down instead of 20%: 813
- $100 a month more rent than the estimate: 990
- 10% off the price: 1,059
- A full point off the rate: 1,033
- 5% off and half a point together: 1,032

Half a point and 5% off land on almost the same number because they cut the payment by the same amount. A $150k house with $120k borrowed is $819 P&I at 7.25%. At 6.75% it's $778. At 7.25% with 5% off the price it's also $778. One of those you can ask a seller for this week.

Rent is still the biggest lever. $100 a month is worth about 10% off the price, which is the flip side of last week's thread: $100 less wipes out over half the list, and $100 more almost doubles it.

It doesn't work everywhere. Sarasota goes from 15 to 16 with 5% off, and to 20 with 10% off; most homes there miss by more than a price cut can close. Kansas City goes from 241 to 347.

668 more homes sit between DSCR 1.15 and 1.25 right now. Those are the ones where an offer under asking, or a second rate quote, is worth the effort.

I held taxes and insurance where they are. In states that reassess on sale, a lower price lowers the tax too, so the price-cut counts are, if anything, a little low.

For anyone buying at 1.25 now: which do you actually get more often, a seller cut or a better rate quote?

Disclosure: I built NetsPositive, which is where these counts come from.

0Reply
437 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 504 posts · 156 votes
    6d

    In the deals I shop, the seller cut shows up a lot more often. Shopping lenders rarely finds a full half point on an otherwise identical file, and the gaps I do see usually come from prepay structure, points or the credit tier rather than the base rate. A seller sitting on a stale listing is the one most likely to take an offer 5% under asking. There's a middle route too, a seller credit used to buy the rate down, which most DSCR programs allow up to a capped percentage of the price. Running both directions of this screen is what makes the 668 band useful, since the lever you control is the one to work first. Have you modeled how those 668 shift if a seller credit toward points is used instead of a straight price cut?

    • David LurveyPro Member
      OP
      Technology · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2026 · 36 posts · 7 votes
      5d

      Good call, Noah, and it changes the math more than I expected. Same 8 markets, 20% down, assuming a point buys 0.20-0.25% off the rate:

      - 2% seller credit toward points: 718-797 clear 1.25 (499 do today)
      - 3% credit: 864-982
      - Straight 5% price cut: 724
      - 2% price cut, the same dollars as the 2% credit: 579

      Of the 675 sitting between 1.15 and 1.25, a 2% credit moves 219-298 over the line and a 3% credit 365-483, against 225 for 5% off.

      Dollar for dollar the credit does 2-3 times what a cut does. On a $150k house, a $3,000 credit takes P&I from $819 to $768-778; the same $3,000 off the price gets it to $802. The limits are the program's cap on seller concessions, and you're putting 20% down on the higher price.

      What is a point buying on the DSCR files you're shopping right now?

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 425 posts · 143 votes
    3d

    David, this is a really useful way to frame it, and it matches what I see on the agent side in Memphis. A seller cut is the lever I can actually negotiate — I can ask a seller for a price cut or a credit this week, and I can't ask anyone for a lower rate. The rate quote depends on the lender, the buyer's credit, and the market, so shopping lenders helps, but it rarely finds a full half point on its own, just as Noah said. In practice, the price cut is the one I get more often, and a seller credit is the one I like most when the buyer is short on cash to close, since it can buy the rate down or cover costs. Your point about rent being the biggest lever is the one I'd underline twice — that's the number that decides whether any of the other levers matter. Which lever are you seeing move deals in Sarasota right now?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.