How do you pick a vacancy number instead of just using 5%?

How do you pick a vacancy number instead of just using 5%?

Realtor · Washington state · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 2 votes

Something I keep seeing in deal analysis threads: everyone plugs in 5%
or 8% vacancy because that's what the calculator defaults to. But
that's a percentage, and what actually hurts is how many days a unit
sits empty between tenants.

So I try to think in days, not percent. Turnover time is basically
cleaning and repairs, then marketing, then screening, then the new
tenant's notice at their old place. Each of those can stretch longer
than people expect.
My buddy has been trying to rent his place in Bothell WA for MONTHS and no renter.. He has a very nice townhome in one of the most desirable cities in Washington State. He has been lowering his rents to no success. So keep this one in mind..

My rule is pretty simple:

- Look at how long similar rentals near me actually sit before they go pending
- Add the time I'd need to turn the unit and screen someone
- Run the deal with that many empty days every lease, not a flat percentage

If the deal falls apart with an extra month empty, I treat the thin
cash flow as a risk, not a margin.

0Reply
367 views

Most Popular Reply

Brian AsaroPro Member
Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2022 · 25 posts · 18 votes
4d

Hi Peter,

The vacancy rate can be converted to days. 5% of 365 is 18.25 days. The percentage is used when running numbers. If a property can be rented for $10,000 per year and the vacancy rate is 5%, the actual rent collected would be $9,500.

Brian

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brian AsaroPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · San Diego, CA · Member since 2022 · 25 posts · 18 votes
    4d

    Hi Peter,

    The vacancy rate can be converted to days. 5% of 365 is 18.25 days. The percentage is used when running numbers. If a property can be rented for $10,000 per year and the vacancy rate is 5%, the actual rent collected would be $9,500.

    Brian

  • Real Estate Broker · Sacramento, CA · Member since 2021 · 556 posts · 427 votes
    4d

    Use days, not a flat percent. I underwrite 30 days vacant, which is about 8% (30/365), and 14 days is about 4%. The tradeoff is a low vacanncy number makes a weak deal look good, and a high one kills a good deal. Match it to the actual turnover and lease-up time for that property type. Hope this helps!

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    4d

    Using days IS using a percent, just divide by 365. Otherwise you’re diving rent by 365 and then multiplying by days. Why add an extra step?

    Your buddy with months of vacancy is an example of “saving money by not using a PM.” Not counting hidden costs. (At least I hope he’s not using a PM. If he is, then he’s an example of losses because being loyal or not shopping around.). A LONG vacancy should be 2-3 weeks. That’s happened to me twice in 30 years with a dozen properties. It’s never taken a month, not even with a trashed property. That’s an upside of using a PM. It’s made ready in 5-7 days while being advertised with previous pix which are updated when ready. By then someone’s usually approved and preparing to move in within 7-10 days.)

    He’s paid more than 16% in lost rent if by months you mean just 2. It comes down to price/advertising. If he’s solo it’s his fault. If he’s using a PM they don’t seem to have a clue.

    It's also going to be based on the type of property and tenant. If you're renting SFR to families like me you can expect a vacancy every 4-8 years. That means a vacancy rate of 0.6-1.2%, call it 1%. I don't use days as it will be zero most years and 14-21 days the "bad year". If you're renting out studio/1bedroom apartments with a transient tenant you could easily hit 4-8%.

    TLDR: Percents work better/easier for calculations. If you want to reduce vacancy percent. Property type is the most important, turnover and screening are tied for second. A vacancy longer than a month better be a once in 10+ years event. Vacancy should be one of the least important “expenses” and barely worth worrying about. Take a deep dive in to anything exceeding 8%. Good luck and carry on. You’re probably only looking at the people doing better than you. Take a minute to realize how well you’re doing.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 247 posts · 122 votes
    4d

    Peter, I'd add one thing to thinking in days: the empty days are only part of what a turnover costs you.

    When I owned long-term rentals in Orlando, a single turnover ran anywhere from about 35% to 100% of a month's rent, depending on the property and the tenant it was aimed at. That number covers the empty days plus the cleaning, repairs and time to re-rent.

    Bill's point about property type is the big one. My duplexes in a rougher part of town were a different business from my single-family homes. Those tenants often paid weekly, and I went through several evictions there. Florida let me get a tenant out in about 25 days, so each one generally cost about a month's rent, on top of the turnover. Same city, very different vacancy numbers, and one flat 5% would have been wrong for both.

    So I'd underwrite two numbers per property: how often it turns, and what each turn really costs (empty days plus make-ready). Multiply them and you get a vacancy and turnover line that fits that property, not the calculator's default.

  • V.G JasonPro Member
    Investor · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4d

    These numbers(along with other opex, and capex) items are top line numbers not bottom line. You don't underwrite with some arbitrary percentage you read from some BP homie or frontpage scrub-- too many to list to call them all out.

    You literally see the cost PITI and multiply that by about 9 months; 3 to keep as you start the property(to give it runway) and 6 as you go. You add to that progressively. You'll owe the PM a month, and 50-100% of the month to retain or bring anew.

    If you don't have 9(ideally 12) months of PITI as reserves right when you acquire the property, for just vacancies, you're starting behind the track. Anyone that tells me otherwise has sweat bullets during vacancy periods, tells you RE Is too hard, or bought at the most opportune time and govern by luck than any iota of skill. First hiccup on that front, and they'll fall in the former two buckets.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 425 posts · 143 votes
    3d

    Peter, I like the days-not-percent approach, and it's the one I use when I'm helping a buyer underwrite a rental in Memphis. A flat 5% hides the thing that actually hurts, which is a unit sitting empty for six weeks while you still pay the mortgage, taxes, and insurance. What I'd add is to get the number from the local market, not from a calculator default: ask a property manager how long similar rentals actually sit before they go pending, and how long a turn takes once you add cleaning, repairs, and screening. And think about who the tenant is — a family that stays for years turns over very differently than a short-term tenant. The test I use is the same as yours: if an extra month empty breaks the deal, the cash flow was too thin to begin with. What kind of property are you underwriting?

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3d

    I like the concept, and that is something I need to get better at on a personal level, but to some other points here, its all really guessing unless you have a track record or data from the vendor about their operations. the percentage can be a decent solid guess, but much of vacancy is really up to how prepped and ready you are to turn it, and that's something I'm personally still figuring out, but got one coming in december so we shall see how we do on that one.

  • Crystal SmithPro Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    3d
    Quote from @Peter J Kim:

    Something I keep seeing in deal analysis threads: everyone plugs in 5%
    or 8% vacancy because that's what the calculator defaults to. But
    that's a percentage, and what actually hurts is how many days a unit
    sits empty between tenants.

    So I try to think in days, not percent. Turnover time is basically
    cleaning and repairs, then marketing, then screening, then the new
    tenant's notice at their old place. Each of those can stretch longer
    than people expect.
    My buddy has been trying to rent his place in Bothell WA for MONTHS and no renter.. He has a very nice townhome in one of the most desirable cities in Washington State. He has been lowering his rents to no success. So keep this one in mind..

    My rule is pretty simple:

    - Look at how long similar rentals near me actually sit before they go pending
    - Add the time I'd need to turn the unit and screen someone
    - Run the deal with that many empty days every lease, not a flat percentage

    If the deal falls apart with an extra month empty, I treat the thin
    cash flow as a risk, not a margin.

    We use local data to determine vacancy rate based on location and type of asset. With AI there's no need to guess anymore. It doesn't really matter which AI tool you want to use.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2d

    One thing to add on vacancy, especially for your buddy in Bothell: the empty months don't stop the deductions. As long as the townhome is actively listed and held out for rent, the mortgage interest, property taxes, HOA, utilities, and depreciation are all still deductible with no tenant in place. Depreciation actually starts the day the place is available and listed, not the day someone signs a lease. Where people get tripped up is when it sits long enough that they start using it themselves or stop actively marketing it, because then the IRS can argue it wasn't really a rental during that stretch. He should keep the listing history and the rent reductions documented.

    The turnover costs you broke out, like cleaning, repairs, listing fees, and screening, are deductible in the year they’re paid, so track them separately from the vacancy itself. And if your buddy lived in the townhome for at least two years before renting it out, and he ends up selling instead, he has up to three years after moving out to sell under the home sale exclusion. Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 752 votes
    2d

    Peter, you are thinking about it the right way. A percentage hides the real cost, and days are what you feel. On a 3-bedroom at $1,395 to $1,950 a month, every empty week is roughly $350 to $490 in lost rent, and a three-week turn can cost more than most repairs I ever do. That is why our turnovers run on a 21-day schedule, and the clock starts before move-out, not after. I underwrite the deal with the real turn time in it, not a flat 5%, and if an extra month empty breaks the deal, I treat the thin cash flow as a risk, not a margin. The rent still has to cover vacancy, repairs, CapEx, property management, taxes, insurance, and the DSCR payment at 70 to 80% LTV. If it does not, I pass.

  • Investor · miami · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 6 votes
    2d

    On your buddy in Bothell: when a nice place sits for months, it's almost always the price. And small cuts don't help much, because renters filter by price brackets. Going from $3,100 to $3,025 still leaves it above a $3,000 search cutoff, so the same people still never see it. The math usually favors one real cut. A $100 a month cut costs $1,200 a year. One extra empty month on a $3,000 rental costs $3,000. My rule of thumb: if good photos haven't brought a qualified application in about two weeks, the price is wrong, not the market. Also count how many similar rentals are listed near you right now. If there are 15 and you're the most expensive, that's your answer. For underwriting, I'd check three things for the specific property: how often it will turn (families in houses stay longer than singles in 1-bedrooms), how many days it takes to fill similar listings near you in a slow month, not a busy one (winter is slower in most markets), and what each turnover costs on top of the empty days. Then run the deal with one bad turnover in year one. If it only works with zero empty days, it's too thin.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.