Home Sales Just Hit Their Lowest Since 2010. The Demand Is Waiting, Not Gone

Home Sales Just Hit Their Lowest Since 2010. The Demand Is Waiting, Not Gone

Derek BrickleyBusiness Member
Lender · Ann Arbor, MI · Member since 2021 · 707 posts · 239 votes

October brought hotter inflation, louder talk of a December rate hike and the slowest existing home sales pace since 2010, and the way those three fit together matters a lot for how you underwrite this winter.

Inflation Picked Up

CPI rose 0.4% in October with core up 0.3%, both above forecasts. Energy was the big driver on the headline number, up 0.7%, while shelter rising 0.3% pushed core higher. There are no year-over-year figures this round because of last year's shutdown, so the market is reacting to the monthly prints alone. On the wholesale side, PPI rose 0.3% as expected, but it's up 6.5% from a year ago, the biggest annual gain in nearly four years, with core PPI up 5%. That's a lot of cost pressure sitting in the pipeline.

The Fed Sounds Ready to Hike

Within days of the CPI release, Governor Christopher Waller and Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan both said they support another hike at the December 8 and 9 meeting. The Fed already raised a quarter point in September before holding in October. Jobless claims don't give them a reason to wait either. Initial claims rose to 200,000, still historically low, and continuing claims sit near 1.7 million.

Resale Volume Hit Its Lowest Since 2010

Existing home sales fell 5.5% in October to a 3.75 million annual pace, down 8.8% from a year ago and the slowest since 2010. Inventory kept climbing to 1.59 million homes, up 4.6% from last year, which works out to 5.1 months of supply. The median price barely moved at $417,000, up 0.4% year over year. Days on market are at 35, only 11% of homes are selling above list, and first-time buyers made up 29% of sales. Volume is falling hard but prices aren't, which tells you sellers aren't under pressure to dump properties. Buyers are simply waiting on rates. NAR's Lawrence Yun said there "could be sizable pent-up demand if mortgage rates decline."

Where I'm Less Sure

The consensus coming out of this week is that a December hike is close to locked in. I'm not as convinced. The headline CPI jump was mostly energy, which can reverse quickly, and wholesale inflation actually came in right where it was expected. The labor data is also softer than the claims numbers suggest, since some laid off workers are moving into gig work and some of the drop in continuing claims is benefits running out, not people finding jobs. If Wednesday's Fed minutes show the committee was split before this report, December could be closer than the market thinks.

Investor Takeaway

I'd underwrite at today's rates and treat any December relief as upside, not a plan. The more interesting opportunity is on the acquisition side. With volume at its lowest since 2010, inventory up and only about 1 in 10 homes going over asking, there's more room to negotiate than we've seen in a while, without prices actually falling. When rates do ease, the pent-up demand Yun is talking about should show up quickly, which favors buying before it does rather than after. In the meantime, a big pool of would-be buyers waiting on the sidelines keeps rental demand firm.

Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group548 Reviews
0Reply
425 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    1d

    I don't think it goes that way at all. I think the "pent up demand" is a mirage and Yun has zero credibility anyway IMO as he's just an NAR shill (and I say this as a licensed broker). I talk to a lot of people who are not going to swap from renting to buying unless housing prices come significantly down or they start making a whole lot more money. And the younger generation are totally comfortable with owning nothing and renting everything. I think we are seeing a real paradigm shift where homeownership is just not as important to people any more, many of whom don't see a home as an investment so much as a daily expense to be managed, and from that perspective they'd rather keep their money in the market.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
    • Derek BrickleyBusiness Member
      OP
      Lender · Ann Arbor, MI · Member since 2021 · 707 posts · 239 votes
      1d

      Right that’s true too, affordability is an issue. I know Dave Meyer did an episode on affordability levels in housing. The problem then is still that people need a place to live and millennials and Gen Z are getting to the age for household formations. So either they form a household where they rent or buy. So it’ll increase demand for one or the other or both. A lot of people don’t even have the extra cash to invest in the market though that’s the scary part is they’re just scraping by and in some cases even if they want to buy rent is all they can afford.

      Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group548 Reviews
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 438 posts · 148 votes
    1d

    Derek, this matches what I see from the agent side, and I agree with both you and JD — the demand is real, but it's affordability that decides whether it becomes a sale. The buyers I talk to aren't waiting because they don't want a home; they're waiting because the monthly payment has to work, and that means rate, price, taxes, and insurance together, not just the rate. The sellers who price to the market still move, while the ones who price for last year's market sit, which is exactly the days-on-market picture you describe. Your takeaway is the one I give first-time investors too: underwrite at today's numbers and treat any rate relief as a bonus, not the plan.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.