Out-of-state newbie, $22K loss on a duplex. Is this on me or on my PM?

Out-of-state newbie, $22K loss on a duplex. Is this on me or on my PM?

Member since 2026 · 6 posts · 6 votes

I'm an inexperienced out-of-state owner with one duplex in small-town Alabama (slightly outside of Birmingham), bought in 2021 and run by a property manager since day one. This year went badly and I honestly can't tell how much of it is my fault. I'd like blunt opinions.

Quick summary

- A long-term tenant kept a lot of cats in one unit (my realtor counted 20+).

- Total hit is about $22K: $12,700 cash out of pocket, $5,500 in rent lost while it sat vacant, and $4,400 the tenant never paid.

- The PM says the management agreement puts all of it on me.

What happened

- May 2025: PM recommended not renewing this tenant because of late rent. We chose to keep her. That one is on us....

- Aug 2025: my realtor found the cats and the urine smell, not the PM.

- The PM's "annual inspections" on file for 2024 and 2025 were self-inspections the tenant did on a phone app. The 2025 one showed nothing wrong.

- PM staff first walked the unit in Aug 2025, after we asked. They confirmed cats and odor and told us a fine, a removal deadline and a re-inspection would follow. I can't find a record of a re-inspection.

- Tenant stopped paying after Nov 2025 and left in March 2026. Deposit was $675.

- Repairs: new flooring and subfloor (about $6,400), then an odor specialist (about $3,100) after the PM's ozone treatments failed twice. We had to find the specialist... the PM gave up on fixing the issue.

- The unit sat vacant about 7.5 months while trying to get the smell out.

Where I think I messed up

- Kept a tenant the PM told me not to renew.

- Never asked how inspections were actually done, or read the reports.

What the PM says

- The agreement only requires "reasonable efforts" and does not warrant tenant behavior.

- It also has a hold-harmless clause and mandatory arbitration, so I've mostly ruled out legal action.

My questions

1. Is a tenant self-inspection a normal substitute for the PM walking the unit once a year?

2. As an out-of-state owner, what should I have been doing that I wasn't?

3. Is this just the cost of doing business, or would a good PM have caught it or shared some of the cost?

4. Leaving costs me 8% of the remaining rent on both leases. Is that worth paying to switch?

5. Is it worth chasing a former tenant like this for a judgment?

Thanks in advance. Tell me straight.

5Reply
1,418 views

Most Popular Reply

Virtual Assistant · Remote · Member since 2020 · 158 posts · 67 votes
1w

Steven, the $22K number is doing a lot of work here, and it helps to split it into three buckets, because the books treat each one differently.

The $12,700 cash out is the only part that is really a cost. The new flooring and subfloor will probably land as a capital improvement, not a repair, which means it gets depreciated instead of deducted all at once. The odor treatments are repairs. Same job, different tax treatment, and the CPA can only sort that out if the invoices are tagged when they arrive.

The $5,500 of lost rent and the $4,400 never paid are not deductions. That money just never showed up. On a cash basis the unpaid rent never existed on the books at all.

And the $675 deposit matters more than it looks. Whatever is kept for damages becomes income when it is applied, with a written disposition to the tenant, so keep that paperwork with the repair invoices.

The habit that would have caught the unpaid rent months earlier is the rent ledger. Read it every month, unit by unit. A tenant sliding behind shows up in weeks, not at move-out.

See this reply in the discussion

48 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Technology · Vancouver, BC · Member since 2026 · 274 posts · 75 votes
    6d

    Hi @Steven Harris,

    The detail that you didn't know the annual inspections were tenant self-inspections until July has really stuck with me. I think a lot of out-of-state owners are in exactly the same spot and just haven't found out yet.

    I hope you don't mind, but I started a discussion built on what you shared, asking owners and managers what they actually read in their monthly reports. Rosina Persaud has already shared how she reviews hers, including asking for dated photos from the manager rather than a checkbox: https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/899/topics/1319721-what-do-you-actually-read-in-your-property-managers-monthly-report

    If there's anything you'd now check on your own reports after this year, I think it would help a lot of people to hear it from you.

    Lee

  • Travis TimmonsPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Ellsworth, ME · Member since 2021 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6d

    I actually side with @Steve K. here - the core issue is that you are renting to a tenant pool that would house 20 cats. I would venture to guess that the venn diagram of 700+ credit score, good income, responsible tenant AND owns 5+ cats is 0. You can blame the PM, yourself, processes, etc...fact of the matter is that you are probably renting to a crappy tenant pool, and you have to because the property is not in a location where people with options want to live.

    I am painting with broad strokes and making some assumptions. I could be WAY off, but that class of rental can work, but it usually only works well for local, experienced operators who know how to manage them well. Leverage + appreciation is what makes real estate worth the hassle. I doubt that there is a lot of appreciation of rents or value. Index funds outperform that class of rental by a long shot (if you are honest about expenses) without all of the hassle.

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 123 posts · 29 votes
    5d

    Drew — fair challenge, and you're right on the main point.

    I can't guarantee I catch everything on a walkthrough, and I'm not a licensed inspector or builder. My point wasn't that my annual walk replaces a professional inspection — it's that a tenant self-inspection isn't a substitute for independent eyes on the unit.

    In Steven's case, the cats and the damage went on for a year because no one independent walked it. A trusted person with dated photos and video would have caught that, even without going into a crawl space.

    A professional inspection has its place — at purchase, and for bigger systems — and I'd never argue against it. I just wouldn't rely on the tenant to report their own lease violations. Appreciate the pushback — happy to connect, my DMs are open.

  • San Diego, CA · Member since 2026 · 19 posts · 4 votes
    5d

    Richard, I'm an out-of-state buyer looking at occupied duplexes in Columbus. If the seller won't let anyone see the occupied side until after contract, what do you ask for in the contract so a bad surprise gets priced in or lets you walk?

  • Amit PatelBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Bartlett, IL · Member since 2025 · 191 posts · 75 votes
    5d

    Straight answer: it’s shared. Keeping a tenant your PM said not to renew is on you, and you already own that. But a lot of what happened after August 2025 is on the manager.

    On the inspections, a tenant self-inspection on an app can be a nice check-in between visits, but it’s not a substitute for someone walking the unit at least once a year. Especially with a long-term tenant who was already paying late. That’s exactly the unit you want eyes on.

    Where I think the PM really fell short is the follow-through. They confirmed 20+ cats and odor in August and then there’s no re-inspection on record. The tenant stopped paying in November and stayed until March. In most places a nonpayment case should move faster than that if someone files right away. And 7.5 months vacant is a very long time, even for a bad odor job. A good manager escalates and brings in a specialist after the first failed treatment, not after you go find one.

    As an owner, the lesson isn’t that you should have done the manager’s job. It’s to ask how inspections are done, ask for photos, actually read the reports, and expect a written plan with dates when something goes wrong.

    Will they share the cost? Contractually, probably not with that language. But it’s fair to ask them to waive management fees for the vacant months or the termination fee given how this went. Worst case they say no.

    On leaving, 8% of the remaining rent is usually a small number compared to another year like this. If the trust is gone, I’d pay it and move on. Interview the next manager on how they handle inspections and evictions specifically.

    On the tenant, getting a judgment is usually cheap and worth doing so it’s on record. Actually collecting is another story, so I wouldn’t spend much more chasing it.

    Sorry you went through this. It’s a painful lesson, but you’re asking the right questions now.

    Casanomy Property Management562 Reviews
  • Monroe, Orange County · Member since 2026 · 20 posts · 5 votes
    5d

    Before deciding who's at fault, get three things from the PM in writing: the tenant ledger (every charge and payment), the move-in and any mid-lease inspection reports with photos, and the screening file.

    Then compare that to your management agreement. Most say how often they inspect and when they have to tell you about nonpayment. If they skipped inspections or sat on months of unpaid rent without telling you, that's a real conversation and a good reason to switch. If they did what the agreement says, the loss is mostly on the tenant.

    On the tenant: a judgment is easy to get and hard to collect. A collections agency that works on contingency is often worth it at $22K since it costs nothing up front.

    The lesson most of us learn once: get a monthly owner statement and actually read the delinquency line.

  • New to Real Estate · CA · Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 4 votes
    5d

    Hi Steven,

    Thanks for sharing those specific experiences. I would have assumed that an annual inspection meant someone from the property management company would physically visit the property and inspect the home, rather than relying entirely on photos submitted by the tenants.

    In my opinion, a property management company isn't necessarily responsible for everything a tenant does, but that's separate from whether they're responsible for following through with the inspection process and promptly reporting any issues to the property owner.

    If I were in your position, I'd carefully review the property management agreement, inspection records, and communication history before deciding whether to continue working with the company or find a replacement. Having to pay an additional fee for early termination is certainly frustrating, but reliable property management seems especially important when investing out of state.

    I hope things go more smoothly with your property management moving forward and that your future investment experiences are much more positive!

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5d

    Steven, thanks for laying it out so plainly. Keeping a tenant the PM flagged was a judgment call, but the bigger gap was the inspections. A tenant's phone-app walkthrough isn't an inspection, and a re-inspection that never shows up in the file is a process failure you can raise with them directly.

    Read the agreement's hold-harmless and "reasonable efforts" language with a local landlord-tenant attorney before you decide anything. I'm not a lawyer, so treat this as general guidance, but an attorney can tell you whether the missing re-inspection and the inspection records give you any leverage.

    Whatever you decide on the PM, here's what I'd want from any manager going forward: staff-conducted inspections with dated photos sent to you, written escalation steps for lease violations, and a vacancy timeline with a spending limit that needs your approval. Asking for a sample inspection report before signing tells you a lot.

    Happy to connect and compare notes on vetting managers.

  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1d

    Not all of the $22K will show up as a loss on your return, and it’s worth knowing which parts do. The $5,500 of vacancy and the $4,400 the tenant never paid aren’t deductible. You never reported that rent as income, so there’s nothing to write off. The $675 deposit you kept counts as income. The real deduction is in the $12,700 you paid out, and even that splits two ways. The odor specialist is a repair, so it’s deductible this year. The new flooring and subfloor are usually treated as a replacement and depreciated: carpet over 5 years, hard flooring and subfloor over 27.5. The upside is that a partial disposition lets you write off the remaining basis of the old flooring you tore out, which recovers some of what you lost.

    If you switch managers, the termination fee is a deductible rental expense in the year you pay it. The same goes for any legal or collection costs if you go after the tenant, and anything you collect later is income when it comes in. Since you made the call on keeping the tenant and you approve the major decisions, you count as actively participating even with a PM. If your income is under $100K, that means you can use up to $25K of the rental loss against your other income this year. That allowance phases out completely at $150K.

    Happy to connect!

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
  • Ashish AcharyaBusiness Member
    CPA, CFP®, PFS · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2017 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    1d

    .

    INVESTOR FRIENDLY CPA®4.9242 Reviews
    TaxMD® | Tax Planning Software
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.