Investor · Birmingham AL · Member since 2026 · 1 post · 1 vote
Hey everyone! I'm the Finance Director at Cadillac of Birmingham and have been in automotive finance for 10 years. I currently have two doors in the Atlanta market and one in Birmingham that is about to close. I'm looking to expand my portfolio, connect with other investors, build relationships, and learn from their experiences.
My first deal in Birmingham is a seller-financed property in the 35215 ZIP code. I consider this a home run deal, but I'm looking for another property in the same ZIP code and keep running into a brick wall.
The competition for 3/2 family homes under $125K is tough, and I keep getting outbid by cash buyers. Despite hearing that we're in a buyer's market, it certainly doesn't feel that way at this price point.
Does anyone have any strategies for overcoming this problem? I'd love to hear from other investors who have experienced similar challenges, especially those investing in the Birmingham market.
You don't beat cash buyers on price. You beat them on certainty and speed. Cash wins because it closes fast and clean, no financing contingency — so make your offer do the same thing, even if you're not all cash.
In Memphis I buy single-family under $100K, ARV $180K-$265K, and I never put earnest money down. My earnest money is my track record — 236 closed properties. Wholesalers and sellers who know me know if the numbers work, I close fast. If they don't, I walk. That reputation gets me deals cash buyers don't see, because sellers bring me off-market houses first.
Two moves for you in Birmingham: build that same reputation with wholesalers and sellers in 35215, and underwrite to the 1% rule so you can close on a DSCR loan at 70-80% LTV without stretching. Don't waive inspection and don't overpay to win a bid — deal flow is the bottleneck, and the next deal is cheaper than a bad one.
As a cash buyer what I felt made my offers superior was no financing contingency and a quick closing. To compete with cash offers you may need to pay more and consider waiving inspections. If you increase the sales price when you are shopping would it weed out the hardcore investors and perhaps buy you a better neighborhood and higher quality tenant? That would be uncomfortable on front end but could make landlording and resale easier over the long term.
William, your first deal being seller financed is the part I would lean on here. I am still learning, but I try to talk to sellers direct before a listing and ask what matters most to them, price or timing or terms. Cash buyers win on speed, so I look for sellers where speed is not the whole story. I wrote more on this here: https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/16509/107237-time-kills-deals-every-time
You don't beat cash buyers on price. You beat them on certainty and speed. Cash wins because it closes fast and clean, no financing contingency — so make your offer do the same thing, even if you're not all cash.
In Memphis I buy single-family under $100K, ARV $180K-$265K, and I never put earnest money down. My earnest money is my track record — 236 closed properties. Wholesalers and sellers who know me know if the numbers work, I close fast. If they don't, I walk. That reputation gets me deals cash buyers don't see, because sellers bring me off-market houses first.
Two moves for you in Birmingham: build that same reputation with wholesalers and sellers in 35215, and underwrite to the 1% rule so you can close on a DSCR loan at 70-80% LTV without stretching. Don't waive inspection and don't overpay to win a bid — deal flow is the bottleneck, and the next deal is cheaper than a bad one.