House not selling, delist and put back on market as rental for now?

House not selling, delist and put back on market as rental for now?

Rental Property Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes

I have a rental in Bonney Lake that I listed for sale in August when my tenant moved out after a rent increase (they were going to move anyways this year. I'm paying $2,600 a month mortgage at 3.62% rate while it sits vacant, plus utilities. I'm slowly getting out of real estate but it took me 5-6 months to sell another property earlier this year and I'm wondering since I've had no tours in a month or two despite dropping the price by a total of 50 twice, if I'd be better off renting it back out for now on Zillow. I have it listed on FB marketplace and Craigslist but it's rare I ever get a tenant let alone quality tenant on those platforms, like once have I had a tenant on CL. The rest are unqualified tire kickers usually with 5 pit bulls and weird income.

I think rather than carrying the cost with profits from other rentals right now, I'm better off delisting it on zillow so I can list it for rent there instead. Get a tenant in there are try selling some of my rentals again when the market is better. I was luckily able to get rid of one bad money pit rental that had 100K capex coming up. Took a few months, price cuts and a full 3% realtor fee.

0Reply
328 views

Most Popular Reply

Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
9h

my post was for other BP members to take into consideration .. I know you have millions of dollars of Seattle area real estate etc etc.. And this is a very basic question from someone of your experience to answer for yourself you dont need the BP members advising you on what to do with your real estate. No lecture just a learning moment for the newbies which we know you are not.

I seem to recall a thread you started that you mentioned you made millions in Real Estate ask me anything type of post so you asking for such junior league advice Is kind of wild..

See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    1d

    this is a good example for folks getting into SFR rentals.. and thinking there operating costs up front will hold throughout the ownership.. Investors never realize that when they think they have equity that it usually takes a few months of negative cash flow till a property sells 3 to 6 months in an average market. Not mention to retail it usually means some updating a property that has been a rental for an extended period of time. So in markets with a lot of appreciation this is not a big issue as it more than makes up for a few months of negative cash flow but in markets were the values did not or do not move by much it means a good portion of whatever was made on cash flow will just be eaten up at the exit.. Very few folks can sell a property without paying at least a 4 to 5% commish plus closing costs which is usually another 2 to 5k..

    So for now its just a math problem and a personal decision to stick out the resale market or rent it back out no magic answer here. U could always get creative and sell on contract or lease option I have some of my clients doing LO s to move product.

    • Rental Property Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      1d

      Huh? Did you even read the post? There is no negative cash flow. First off, I have 40K in reserves every 2 years from all rentals banked and barely spent 20K in the last 4 years out of 120K in reserves banked in the last 6 years. The profits from other rentals are covering this mortgage without even touching reserves.

      This is one of many properties I own, I'm getting out of real estate slowly, have sold half a dozen over the last few years. I don't need to do lease options, most of those people never buy anyways. I'm asking if I should wait and see if I get a buyer in the new year or just list it as a rental on zillow again, not a lecture about something that doesn't apply here.

    • JD MartinBusiness Member
      Moderator
      Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
      16h

      I doubt many of us know your market well enough to really answer this definitively. In general the market is froze up everywhere, and that applies to renters as well. I have definitely noticed within the last 2 years that the number of applicants for our properties is less than where it was. Now where it was, it was insane, so for my market that just means coming back to normalcy, but nevertheless it's a lot slower than it had been.

      Knowing nothing about your market, but knowing how I feel about the markets in general right now, I would re-rent and wait for a better market unless you really want to get aggressive in dropping the price. You said you dropped by 50 but that has no context so there's no way to know what that means for your market.

      Skyline Properties
      View Page
    • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
      Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
      9h

      my post was for other BP members to take into consideration .. I know you have millions of dollars of Seattle area real estate etc etc.. And this is a very basic question from someone of your experience to answer for yourself you dont need the BP members advising you on what to do with your real estate. No lecture just a learning moment for the newbies which we know you are not.

      I seem to recall a thread you started that you mentioned you made millions in Real Estate ask me anything type of post so you asking for such junior league advice Is kind of wild..

  • Vaibhav PuranikPro Member
    Member since 2025 · 118 posts · 59 votes
    1d

    @Jack B. I agree with your instinct. There are two timing issues - this season - the holiday season is slow in general and high interest rates are making it even more difficult. One another thing you may do is to try a mid-term rental - like 3 months or 6 months rental. The only issue with that is it might need you to furnishing the house. If you don't want to do that, then renting now is the best option. If you don't have to sell then don't sell, time is not right for selling right now.

  • Investor · Augusta · Member since 2024 · 44 posts · 30 votes
    1d

    Jack, personally, I'd lean toward renting it back out.

    I believe we're seeing more of a buyer's market in many areas, and sometimes patience is what wins in this business. You have the reserves and other properties producing income, so you're not in a position where you have to sell.

    My thought would be this: If you haven't already invested money into getting the property retail-ready after your last tenant moved out, why not put another qualified tenant in place and let the property cover its own expenses?

    Of course, finding the right tenant comes with its own challenges, and I'd be selective rather than rushing someone in just to fill the vacancy.

    With a 3.62% mortgage, that's financing I'd be reluctant to give up unless selling made financial sense.

    Since your goal is to gradually exit real estate, I'd focus on moving the properties that are creating the biggest headaches or have significant capital expenses coming up.

    Let the better-performing properties carry themselves while you wait for a more favorable selling opportunity.

    The only thing I'd consider is how the new lease might affect your ability to sell when you're ready.

    Sometimes the best investment decision isn't making another move. It's having the patience to make the right one.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 262 posts · 135 votes
    18h

    Jack, I don't know the Bonney Lake market, but I'm with @Christian Wamsley. With a 3.62% loan and your other rentals covering the payment, you're not forced to sell into a slow market, and that rate is hard to give up. I'd also agree with @Vaibhav Puranik that the holidays are a tough time to find a buyer.

    Sell with creative financing. That 3.62% rate may be the most marketable thing about the house right now. Where it's allowed, a buyer could take over your loan subject-to, or you could carry the financing on a wrap at a higher rate. Either way, you're selling a payment a buyer can't get from a bank. Go in knowing your name stays on the loan and the due-on-sale clause is a real risk, so use an attorney who does these deals.

    Mid-term rental. Building on Vaibhav's point: you'd have to furnish it, but on my units, 30+ day stays consistently bring in more than a long-term lease would, even after utilities. I price between what the house would rent for long-term (the floor) and what it could gross short-term (the ceiling). Before you buy any furniture, check Furnished Finder and Airbnb for 30+ day listings near you to see whether the demand is there. Work crews are my biggest group of guests.

    Long-term at the new rent. If comps support the rent you raised it to, relist it there, and like Christian said, be picky about the tenant rather than rushing to fill it. If you're getting little interest at that number, that tells you something about the price too.

    Since you're slowly getting out, I'd pick whichever of these gets you to the exit with the least hassle.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    9h

    We haven't listed anything on CL in almost 10 years.

    We can't list on FB Marketplace because they keep banning us for spamming if we list more than one rental per user:(

    Your obvious options:

    1) Rent it

    2) Keep dropping price until sells

    3) Bite the bullet and list with an agent hoping their commission will be cheaper than your price cuts

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.