Real Estate Agent · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2024 · 56 posts · 37 votes
Quick refresher, since I get this question from newer investors a lot. A seller credit doesn't lower the price. It reduces what you bring to the table, usually closing costs or prepaids. On a DSCR loan, that can matter a lot, since you're often putting 20-25% down on top of closing costs and reserves.
A few things worth knowing before you go in:
DSCR lenders qualify the property's rent against the payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance), not your personal income.
Rates and fees usually run higher than conventional, so run cash flow at the real rate, not the teaser one.
Ask about prepayment penalties up front. They vary a lot between lenders.
Lenders often want reserves in the bank, so cash to close isn’t always the whole picture.
For those using DSCR loans, what's the biggest thing you wish you'd asked your lender before closing?
Hi Aiden, I am still learning this too, and this is the question I am asking every lender right now. Who pays the points on a funded loan, and is the rate they quote the rate I actually get? I am also asking about prepayment penalties and how much they want left in reserves after closing, since that changes the real cash I need. Thanks for laying this out so plainly.
Hi Aiden, good breakdown, and the question at the end is the right one.
The part I would add for newer investors is a simple way to see the cash to close, because that is where the surprises usually show up.
Here is a round-number example. Say the price is $200,000 and the down payment is 25 percent, so $50,000.
Say closing costs and prepaids come to $8,000. A $5,000 seller credit goes toward those costs, not toward the down payment, so the cash to close is $53,000.
That is the down payment plus the $3,000 of costs left after the credit.
And the reserves stay on top of that, in the bank, after closing.
So the real number to plan around is cash to close plus what stays behind, not cash to close alone.
Three questions I would put in front of a lender before closing, in writing:
First, is this rate locked, what are the points, who pays them, and is this the rate I will actually close at.
Second, how exactly will the seller credit be applied, and what happens to any part of it that is not used.
Third, how many months of reserves do you need left after closing, and in what form.
The prepay question you raised is worth asking early too, how long it runs and what it costs to exit. On a DSCR loan those answers can move the real cost as much as the rate itself.
Run the math at the real rate, get the answers in writing, and compare the same questions across lenders. Happy to talk through the numbers if it helps.
Aiden, great refresher — and the point that a credit reduces what you bring to closing, not the price, is the part I see confused most.
From the agent side, the biggest thing I'd add is timing. The credit has to be written into the agreement and agreed with the lender early, not added at the last minute. If it shows up late, or if it is larger than the actual costs and prepaids it can cover, the unused part can disappear — and the buyer has already counted on it.
I find a credit is sometimes easier for a seller to say yes to than the same amount off the price, which can make it a useful negotiation tool on a deal that is close but not quite there.
My question back to you: do you usually ask for a flat dollar amount or a percentage of the price?