Investor · Boise, ID · Member since 2026 · 12 posts · 3 votes
We just got an engineered cost seg study back on a 45-unit we bought this year (1960s to 2000 vintage, about 75% loan to value). With bonus depreciation, the year-one deduction came to about 89% of invested capital.
For those who've run studies on multifamily since bonus came back:
- What did year-one depreciation come to as a % of invested capital?
- How much did leverage drive it vs the study itself?
- Engineered or desktop study, and what did it cost?
Trying to figure out whether high 80s is typical for a leveraged older garden-style deal or on the high end.
Hi Brent, quick disclaimer, I have not run one myself. I look at these from the tax side as a CPA, so take it as analysis, not field experience. But I would bet most of your 89% is leverage, not from the study. Depreciation is figured on the whole building, including the part the loan paid for, while you're measuring it against your equity. At 75% LTV your equity is only about a quarter of the price, so the same study reads about four times bigger as a percent of invested capital than it would all cash. All cash, you're probably in the low 20s. The study itself mostly sets how much basis moves into the 5, 7, and 15 year buckets, and bonus front-loads that. So high 80s on a leveraged older garden deal sounds normal to me, not high end.
One thing I wouldd watch out for: that percent isn't the same as benefit. It only counts if the investor can actually use the loss this year, and some of it comes back as ordinary recapture when you sell.
Kasing nailed the leverage math — I'll add the study side. On a 1960s–2000 garden deal, the vintage spread is doing real work too: older buildings usually carry more 5-year property (carpet, appliances, specialty finishes) and 15-year land improvements (parking, sidewalks, site utilities), so seeing 20–30% of depreciable basis land in 5/7/15-year buckets is normal. With 100% bonus, that plus year one of the 27.5-year schedule is where the big number comes from — leverage just multiplies it against a small equity check.
One cleaner benchmark: year-one deduction as a % of depreciable basis (building + land improvements, land excluded), not of invested capital. That strips out the LTV noise so you can compare studies apples to apples.
On cost: for a 45-unit engineered study, $8k–$15k is the range I see most often. Desktop runs a fraction of that, but on a deal this size I'd want the engineered report in the file if the numbers ever get questioned.