Brainstorming: Would you owner-finance a Texas rental if the paperwork was handled?

Brainstorming: Would you owner-finance a Texas rental if the paperwork was handled?

Real Estate Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2017 · 142 posts · 35 votes

Brainstorming only. I haven't built anything, and there's no product or link. I just want a gut check from people who've been in this seat.

I'm a Texas landlord with a few rentals, and I keep getting unsolicited owner-finance offers. I ignore them because doing it myself means being the bank: underwriting the buyer, getting the note and deed of trust right, servicing payments and the annual statement, and if the buyer defaults, navigating Texas forfeiture vs. foreclosure rules (40% paid or 48 months flips the remedy) with strict notice deadlines.

Here's what makes it tempting right now: many of us locked in at 3-4% in 2020-21, and market rates are 6.5-7%+. Carrying a note at ~6% is a solid spread for the seller and a better rate than the buyer can get from a bank on an investment property.

The idea I'm kicking around is software that handles the whole thing: buyer screening, Texas docs, e-sign, monthly servicing, and walking you through the right default path with every deadline tracked. Rough cost on a $500K sale with a $400K note: about $7-9K upfront plus $20-25/month, versus ~$30K (6%) to a broker.

Questions for you:

1. Have you gotten owner-carry offers? What did you do with them?

2. What rate spread over your own mortgage would make selling this way a no-brainer?

3. Would that cost be a yes, a no, or "only if…"?

4. What scares you most about carrying a note?

5. What am I getting wrong about Texas seller-financing law?

Honest "I'd never do this" answers are just as useful as yeses.

0Reply
340 views

Most Popular Reply

Member since 2025 · 5 posts · 1 vote
2d

Sagiv, from the lending side, a couple of things worth building in. Most buyers on a seller note plan to refinance later, and the new lender will usually look at the payment history on the note, the buyer's credit and debt-to-income (or, on a rental, the property's rental income for a DSCR loan), and the loan-to-value at that time. Clean, documented payments through a servicer help both sides when that day comes. Rules on seller-financed notes depend on whether the buyer will live in the home and how many notes the seller carries, so it's worth a quick check with a Texas real estate attorney or a licensed loan originator before setting one up. Amran Musaid, Loan Officer, NMLS #2242463

See this reply in the discussion

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    3d

    Well, if you already have a bank note then how would you seller finance? Unless you're talking about doing a sub2.

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
    • Real Estate Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2017 · 142 posts · 35 votes
      3d

      Good question — honestly, the cleanest version is a property that's paid off or has a small enough balance that the buyer's down payment retires it at closing. With an existing mortgage you're really looking at a wrap: I carry a new note to the buyer and keep paying the underlying loan from their payments. Same due-on-sale risk as sub2, and Texas added extra disclosure and servicing rules for wraps a few years back, which is part of why doing it by hand scares me. For the 3% loans, the play would likely be a wrap that captures the spread rather than paying the loan off. Would you touch a wrap on a rental, or is due-on-sale a dealbreaker for you?

  • Chris ColtonPro Member
    Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2026 · 229 posts · 90 votes
    3d

    Hi Sagiv, thanks for putting this out there. I am still learning, and what I have seen here in San Antonio is that the paperwork is what makes an owner finance offer real or not. I would want to see who is collecting the payments, how the payments are tracked, and what happens if a payment is missed, all in writing before I moved forward. The part I keep coming back to is that the paper trail is the value, because that is what a future buyer or lender will ask to see. I would not rush this one, and I would get clear answers on the servicing and the records first.

  • Member since 2025 · 5 posts · 1 vote
    2d

    Sagiv, from the lending side, a couple of things worth building in. Most buyers on a seller note plan to refinance later, and the new lender will usually look at the payment history on the note, the buyer's credit and debt-to-income (or, on a rental, the property's rental income for a DSCR loan), and the loan-to-value at that time. Clean, documented payments through a servicer help both sides when that day comes. Rules on seller-financed notes depend on whether the buyer will live in the home and how many notes the seller carries, so it's worth a quick check with a Texas real estate attorney or a licensed loan originator before setting one up. Amran Musaid, Loan Officer, NMLS #2242463

  • Fort Worth / Dallas, TX · Member since 2026 · 13 posts · 12 votes
    1d

    The biggest correction to your Texas assumptions: that forfeiture vs. foreclosure switch only exists when the seller keeps title on a contract for deed. Most Texas owner-finance deals are done the other way, and that changes a lot of your product.

    On your question 5, the Texas law pieces I'd build around:
    - A contract for deed (executory contract) falls under Property Code Chapter 5, Subchapter D. That's where the 40 percent or 48 payment rule lives (5.066), along with recording requirements and an annual accounting statement to the buyer. Plenty of Texas sellers and attorneys avoid this structure for exactly that reason.
    - The more common structure is a deed to the buyer with a promissory note and a deed of trust back to the seller. Default then runs through ordinary nonjudicial foreclosure under Property Code 51.002, with its notice to cure and notice of sale. One path, one set of deadlines.
    - If the seller still has a mortgage and wraps it, Texas Finance Code Chapter 159 (wrap mortgage loans) adds its own disclosure and licensing rules, on top of the lender's due-on-sale clause. That's the piece I'd want a Texas real estate attorney to sign off on before any software touches it.
    - Residential owner financing also runs into the federal SAFE Act and Dodd-Frank seller-finance rules, and Texas has its own residential mortgage loan originator licensing. A lot of small sellers have a licensed RMLO handle the buyer's ability-to-repay review for that reason, so your screening piece would need to fit that.

    On question 4, what worries the sellers I talk to is less the paperwork and more the buyer who stops paying the note, the taxes and the insurance, and lets the house slide while the foreclosure clock runs. Escrowing taxes and insurance and confirming coverage every year would sell me faster than e-sign would.

    Disclosure: I'm a broker at Summit Cove Realty in DFW. Not legal advice.

  • Property Manager · Fort Worth, TX · Member since 2020 · 14 posts · 2 votes
    5h

    Interesting idea. From the property management side, the paperwork usually isn't what scares owners. It's what happens when payments go sideways. A third-party servicer with clean payment records, plus a clear plan for insurance and taxes, would go a long way toward making owners comfortable carrying a note. I'd still have a Texas real estate attorney review every deal.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.