The $500 Repair Rule That Keeps a Tenant From Waiting on a Toilet

The $500 Repair Rule That Keeps a Tenant From Waiting on a Toilet

Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes

I've owned and managed rentals in Florida for almost two decades. One thing I always walk owners through, even though they rarely ask up front, is the maintenance limit. On the homes our company manages, that limit is $500. If a tenant puts in a work order for something like a toilet or a ceiling fan that costs $300 to $400, we just fix it and take care of the tenant. For anything over $500, we contact the owner and ask how they'd like to proceed.

A refrigerator is a good example. If it dies, we don't just swap it out. We bring the owner a repair quote, a used-refrigerator price, and a new-refrigerator price, and they decide. Those prices change by house and by year, so I won't pretend there's one right number. The process is the same every time: small stuff gets handled so the tenant isn't waiting, and the bigger calls stay with the owner.

If you self-manage 50 units or less, or you work with a manager, where did you set that limit? Has a tenant ever been stuck waiting because a $300 repair needed a phone call first?

I had help drafting this and edited it myself.

1Reply
251 views

Most Popular Reply

Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
19h

That dollar amount limit should be dependent upon local pricing, and also should cover most routine items. I include standard water heater replacement, toilet, kitchen or bath sink and faucet, and major appliances...all individually of course, as "routine". Also typical waste line cabling to vertical. Our standard monthly limiting amount was generally equal to a month rent for the unit. You can't get a water heater changed by licensed and insured vendors for less than about $1100, and under cabinet units, which are prevalent here, are always more due to usual level of difficulty. We also generally maintained $1000 or more as reserve for issues that occurred after owner NET rental was disbursed. There were a handful of accounts that insisted on lower amounts, but generally their units were also B+ or A units; or they had multiple properties with us and allowed/requested us to transfer between them when necessary, and always with authorization at the time.

Our view was that the rental agreement was between the tenant and our company, so whatever happened, we were The Bad Guys, so we made sure there was no "waiting" on authorization for tenants, with thorough preps and regular inspections to keep owner apprised of conditions. Also, the management contract is clear that we are hired to "manage" the property, and we do so as if it were our own long term rent and hold. You have to also consider local law regarding timing requirements for response, which varies by locale. We did not require written estimates for routine items, but did require tech comments for findings as well as direct call from them on arrival at site to inform of findings and provide verbal estimate before proceeding. Similarly, for turnovers, most were minimal and we just processed, providing pics and line item invoices to owner. For anything truly significant, I would report to owner with email report and pics, call and discuss, but ultimately would proceed to our usual standards in most cases. Over time, the owners did understand the relationship between a quality unit and a quality tenant, and ultimately were pleased with long term outcomes of low vacancy, long tenancy, market rents, and low subsequent turnover costs.

See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    19h

    That dollar amount limit should be dependent upon local pricing, and also should cover most routine items. I include standard water heater replacement, toilet, kitchen or bath sink and faucet, and major appliances...all individually of course, as "routine". Also typical waste line cabling to vertical. Our standard monthly limiting amount was generally equal to a month rent for the unit. You can't get a water heater changed by licensed and insured vendors for less than about $1100, and under cabinet units, which are prevalent here, are always more due to usual level of difficulty. We also generally maintained $1000 or more as reserve for issues that occurred after owner NET rental was disbursed. There were a handful of accounts that insisted on lower amounts, but generally their units were also B+ or A units; or they had multiple properties with us and allowed/requested us to transfer between them when necessary, and always with authorization at the time.

    Our view was that the rental agreement was between the tenant and our company, so whatever happened, we were The Bad Guys, so we made sure there was no "waiting" on authorization for tenants, with thorough preps and regular inspections to keep owner apprised of conditions. Also, the management contract is clear that we are hired to "manage" the property, and we do so as if it were our own long term rent and hold. You have to also consider local law regarding timing requirements for response, which varies by locale. We did not require written estimates for routine items, but did require tech comments for findings as well as direct call from them on arrival at site to inform of findings and provide verbal estimate before proceeding. Similarly, for turnovers, most were minimal and we just processed, providing pics and line item invoices to owner. For anything truly significant, I would report to owner with email report and pics, call and discuss, but ultimately would proceed to our usual standards in most cases. Over time, the owners did understand the relationship between a quality unit and a quality tenant, and ultimately were pleased with long term outcomes of low vacancy, long tenancy, market rents, and low subsequent turnover costs.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    7h

    All good stuff @Adam Bartomeo and @Richard F.

    We have learned the hard way that modifying our Maintenance Owner Approval Threshold is NOT a good idea.

    The owners that want it lower, usually are the problem owners.

    We do modify our Portfolio Minimum, which usually equals the threshold, for numerous properties, as it's unlikely ALL an owner's properties will need maintenance in the same month.

    Stuff like a HWH replacement would fall under our emergency contract language.

    NOTE: a common complaint we hear from owners transferring their rentals to us is their previous PMC never told them about the under threshold work orders. They didn't find out until they got their monthly Owner Statement and saw the charges.

    Our standard procedure is to alert the owner about ALL maintenance issues as soon as we have a decent understanding of the maintenance issue. We then send them the invoice and completion proof.

    • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
      OP
      Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      5h

      Yes, we do not lower this amount but we do have owners that have increased it on their own. It is a flag for us that the owner may micromanage which effects the level of customer service that we can provide to the tenant and the efficiency of our team.

  • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
    7h

    @Adam Bartomeo, good day. The three-price choice keeps the owner in the decision without slowing the tenant down. One step that helps on top: keep each of those decisions on the house record. When the same item fails a second time, the owner sees the first repair price next to the replace price, and the call takes a minute.

    Do any of your owners set a rule like that, replace on the second failure?

  • G. Brian DavisPro Member
    Investor · Hatboro, PA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 907 votes
    6h

    The money really depends on the property and the owner. The important thing is agreeing on that limit upfront. I don’t want a tenant waiting several days for approval on a $300 repair, but I also don’t want a manager making a $1,500 decision without talking to me. The manager needs enough authority to handle the small stuff quickly, while the owner stays involved when the expense becomes meaningful. Getting that agreement upfront can save a lot of frustration on both sides.

    • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
      OP
      Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      5h

      It becomes a little difficult to manage hundreds of owners and all of their diffent requests while keeping our company expenses low enough to be profitable. Having a single maintenance limit for all owners is very efficient and lowers human error.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 282 posts · 148 votes
    6h

    Adam, I've been on a few sides of that number.

    When I self-managed my Orlando rentals, there was no threshold. They were my properties, so every call and every repair was on me.

    Today I'm on the short-term rental side. I have an STR arbitrage deal in Jacksonville: I rent the home from the owner and run it as a short-term rental, and the agreement puts every repair under $500 on me. The owner only hears about the bigger items. It's worked well: the owner isn't fielding toilet calls, and my guests aren't stuck waiting on phone tag.

    On the STRs I co-host for other owners (disclosure: that's my business), it's the same $500 line. It's written into our contract: anything under $500 I'm authorized to approve, and anything over it goes to the owner.

    I agree with Drew on telling owners about the under-threshold work anyway. A $300 charge an owner first sees on a statement feels a lot bigger than one they heard about the day it happened.

  • Monroe, Orange County · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 7 votes
    6h

    We do something close to this. Two things made it work for us: the limit is written into the lease and the vendor's scope letter, so nobody has to call for permission, and every approved repair gets a photo before and after in the tenant's file. The photos have saved us more than once at move-out when the "it was already broken" argument comes up. Do you adjust the number for older buildings?

    • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
      OP
      Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      5h

      No we do not adjust the amount for newer or older. A toilet replacement is the same no matter the age of the building. Also, we learned quickly not to allow the vendors to know how much the approval is. At one time they were able to see the limit of $250 and every repair was coming in at $240 -$250. The vendors have to communicate with us for every repair. We have a maintenance team so that helps with controlling the expenses.

  • Member since 2025 · 19 posts · 6 votes
    5h

    From the self-managing side, the owner and the approver are the same person, so the dollar limit matters less than having the decision rules written down before the call comes in. What tends to help:

    • A short repair-authorization sheet: what counts as an emergency (no heat, active leak, no water, sewage, lockout) and gets dispatched immediately, versus routine items that can wait for a quote.

    • A not-to-exceed amount you give each vendor up front, so a $300 toilet repair doesn't need a second phone call.

    • A repair reserve per property sized to the most likely big-ticket failures (water heater, HVAC part), so authorizing a fix isn't a cash-flow decision.

    • One log per unit with the date, item, cost, and photos. It shows repeat failures and doubles as the record at move-out.

    The same sheet goes into the lease packet, so tenants know which issues get same-day service.

  • Rental Property Investor · Greenville, SC · Member since 2024 · 27 posts · 14 votes
    3h

    We land in a similar spot, with the limit written into the management agreement. Even on repairs under the limit, where we don't need the owner's OK, we usually still give them a quick heads up the same day. It isn't required, but it builds a better relationship with the owner and nothing is a surprise on the statement. The piece I'd add is a separate emergency rule that ignores the dollar amount. Active leak, sewer backup, no heat on a cold night, we act first and call the owner while the vendor is on the way. Waiting on a callback over a $1,100 water heater while water is on the floor costs more than the water heater.

    • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
      OP
      Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
      2h

      We have an emergency clause built in. We have always had it there but during hurricane Ian we didn't have elec, phones, or internet for weeks. We had to make calls to protect the tenants and the property from further damage. It has happened with WH leaks in the past as well.

  • Member since 2026 · 99 posts · 33 votes
    2h

    We use a limit like this too, and the part that matters is not the dollar number. It is that the tenant does not wait while two people decide. Our rule is simple: anything that affects heat, water, safety, or a working toilet gets fixed first, then we tell the owner what it cost. For the rest, we fix it under the agreed limit and send the invoice and photos the same day. No surprise charges later. The limit only works if it is in writing before the first repair. We put it in the management agreement, with a list of what counts as an emergency, and a note that a repeat failure gets a second look instead of a second patch. The one thing I would add is a monthly summary. Even small repairs add up, and owners trust the limit more when they can see the pattern.

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 83 votes
    17m

    Thanks for sharing the process, Adam. The part I like most is that the owner still makes the bigger calls with a repair quote and a replace quote side by side. Do your owners ever want to adjust the limit for older homes where small repairs tend to snowball?

    Real Property Management Optimal 525 Reviews
  • Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 258 posts · 124 votes
    3m

    Good breakdown Adam. I run the same way, $500 limit is the sweet spot. Under $500 we just fix it and move on, tenant happy, no delay. Over $500 we call owner with 2-3 options - repair, used, or new - and let them decide. The worst thing is a tenant waiting 3 days for a $300 toilet fix because of a phone call. How do you handle it when it's a fridge? Do you still let owner pick, or you just replace to keep tenant from leaving?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.