How to work with a property manager (and when to self-manage)
One of the first decisions a new landlord faces is whether to hire a property manager or self-manage — and honestly, there is no single right answer. It depends on your time, your distance from the property, and how hands-on you want to be.
Self-managing makes sense when you live close by, you have time to take calls and handle turnovers, and you actually enjoy the work. You keep the management fee, you know your tenants, and you learn the business from the inside. For a first rental, that education is worth a lot.
Hiring a manager makes sense when you are out of state, when your time is better spent finding the next deal, or when the day-to-day is starting to cost you more than the fee saves you. A good manager screens tenants, handles maintenance calls, collects rent, and keeps records you will be grateful for at tax time.
Either way, the relationship works best when expectations are clear up front. Before you sign, ask how they screen tenants, how they handle maintenance and what dollar amount they can approve without calling you, how quickly they return owner calls, and what their fee actually covers — and what it does not. Get it in writing. A manager who cannot answer those questions clearly is telling you something.
And if you self-manage, treat it like a business from day one: written leases, documented move-in condition, a system for rent collection, and a maintenance contact list before anything breaks.
The goal is not to avoid work. The goal is to spend your time where it earns the most — and to know when paying someone else to handle the rest is the smarter investment.
What made you decide to self-manage or hire a manager — and what would you do differently next time?