How to work with a property manager (and when to self-manage)

How to work with a property manager (and when to self-manage)

Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 162 votes

One of the first decisions a new landlord faces is whether to hire a property manager or self-manage — and honestly, there is no single right answer. It depends on your time, your distance from the property, and how hands-on you want to be.

Self-managing makes sense when you live close by, you have time to take calls and handle turnovers, and you actually enjoy the work. You keep the management fee, you know your tenants, and you learn the business from the inside. For a first rental, that education is worth a lot.

Hiring a manager makes sense when you are out of state, when your time is better spent finding the next deal, or when the day-to-day is starting to cost you more than the fee saves you. A good manager screens tenants, handles maintenance calls, collects rent, and keeps records you will be grateful for at tax time.

Either way, the relationship works best when expectations are clear up front. Before you sign, ask how they screen tenants, how they handle maintenance and what dollar amount they can approve without calling you, how quickly they return owner calls, and what their fee actually covers — and what it does not. Get it in writing. A manager who cannot answer those questions clearly is telling you something.

And if you self-manage, treat it like a business from day one: written leases, documented move-in condition, a system for rent collection, and a maintenance contact list before anything breaks.

The goal is not to avoid work. The goal is to spend your time where it earns the most — and to know when paying someone else to handle the rest is the smarter investment.

What made you decide to self-manage or hire a manager — and what would you do differently next time?

1Reply
120 views

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Technology · Amsterdam · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    4h

    Good topic. One thing I’d add, since I’ve spent the last couple years setting up software for property management companies: whatever you decide, make sure you always have your own copy of your records.

    I’ve seen a lot of owners switch managers and then realize they can’t easily get their leases, payment history or maintenance records back. They end up digging through old emails to piece it together.

    And if you self-manage, honestly the tenant stuff is usually fine. It’s the admin that gets you. Leases in one folder, receipts in another, rent tracking in some spreadsheet. Worth picking one simple system early before you have more units.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 621 posts · 177 votes
    3h

    Distance decides it more than anything else, and your checklist of questions for a manager is the right one, Ametria. The thing I'd add is for out of state owners. Self-managing from far away usually isn't self-managing, it's managing a handyman and hoping, because you can't see the property, walk a turnover or meet the person filling out the application. The rentals that go bad from a distance are rarely about the fee. They're about a vacancy that ran long or a move-out nobody inspected. So what I'd do differently is put a management fee in the numbers from day one, even on a local rental you plan to run yourself. If the deal only works without that 8 to 10 percent, it doesn't work, and you'll find out the first time you move or get busy.

  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 483 posts · 162 votes
    3h

    Alexander and Noah, thank you both — these are exactly the additions I was hoping for. Alexander, keeping your own copy of the records is such an important point. I have seen owners switch managers and spend weeks chasing leases and payment history, and a simple system from day one avoids all of it. Noah, you are right that distance decides it, and your rule about putting the management fee in the numbers from day one is one I will borrow — if a deal only works without that fee, it does not really work. Really appreciate you both adding to this.

  • Member since 2023 · 200 posts · 85 votes
    3h

    Ametria, good question, and I'll answer it from the manager's seat since we run 236 doors in Memphis. Self-manage while you can still see every house yourself — once leasing, turns, and collections start eating your week, that's the point to hand it over. Before you sign with anyone, ask how they screen (we look for verified, repeatable income and consistency between the story and the paperwork, not just a credit score), how they run a turnover (we work on a 21-day scheduling system), and how rent gets collected (one payment method, written into the lease, same for every house). Ask to see a monthly owner statement too, and ask what it doesn't show — the cost of the empty weeks is what matters. If the answers are vague, keep looking.

  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 282 posts · 148 votes
    3h

    Ametria, I've been on both sides of this one. I self-managed my first five rentals in Orlando. Not bad, not great, but very educational. When I moved to California, I turned my Orlando home into a rental and hired a property manager, because I didn't want to be a long-distance landlord.

    What I didn't expect was how much those self-managing years helped once I had a manager. I knew what a turnover should take and what a repair should cost, so I could actually manage the manager instead of just reading the statement.

    Two things I'd add to your list:

    - Ask local investors before you sign. I found my manager through the local REIA, and it worked very well for me. A referral from someone who's used them for years tells you more than a sales call.

    - Read the management agreement line by line. A lot of it is CYA language. I understand why managers want some of it, but know which clauses only protect them and which ones protect you too, before you sign.

    If you're local, self-managing even one property first makes you a much better client later.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 621 posts · 177 votes
    1h

    Borrow it, and take it one step further for out of state rentals, because the monthly percentage is only part of what a manager costs. Most also charge a leasing fee each time they place a tenant, commonly half to a full month's rent, and it sits outside the 8 to 10 percent. A full month's rent on a tenant who turns over every year adds about another 8 percent of that year's rent, so the real cost can run close to double the headline fee. An owner who lives far away can't show the unit or sign the lease themselves, so they pay it on every turn. You already ask what the fee covers, and this is the line hiding behind that answer. Do your out of state buyers usually budget for the leasing fee, or just the monthly cut?

  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2021 · 796 posts · 510 votes
    1h

    @Ametria Chaney - I'm a believer in that starting out most should self manage, but once it becomes more of a time kill than actually continuing to scale/grow I think that's when most should look towards outsourcing to some degree. I self-managed the first 10 units, but then started to use a combination of property management from that point on. Good Luck!

  • Leo SteinBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 343 posts · 83 votes
    16m

    Nice breakdown, Ametria. I'd add that whichever route an owner picks, it helps to write down up front who approves what, such as a repair dollar limit, so nobody is guessing when something breaks. Clear expectations make either setup run smoother.

    Real Property Management Optimal 525 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.