Lessons from 75+ flips: the pitfall that eats margin fastest

Lessons from 75+ flips: the pitfall that eats margin fastest

Member since 2026 · 21 posts · 5 votes

After 75 flips, I can tell you the pitfall that eats margin fastest is not the purchase price or the interest rate. It is rehab scope creep — the quiet gap between the rehab budget you wrote on the kitchen table and the one the house actually needs.

It usually starts small. A bathroom that was supposed to get new fixtures turns into a full gut once the tile comes up. A 'cosmetic' kitchen needs new subfloor. Each item on its own looks manageable, but together they move the budget by tens of thousands, and that money comes straight out of your profit. I have seen more deals die this way than any other.

The way I underwrite against it now is boring on purpose. First, ARV comes only from renovated, sold comps — never from active listings or a wishful number. Second, I price rehab in flat tiers by scope instead of guessing line by line, and I add a contingency on top of the tier, not inside it. Third, holding costs, selling costs, and financing costs go into the numbers before I make an offer, not after. If the margin is under my target once all of that is in, I walk away — no matter how much I like the house.

The discipline is the whole job. A flip makes its money in the underwriting, not in the renovation.

— Raul, Anchor Point Development

1Reply
55 views

1 Reply

Jump to latestLatest
  • Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 201 posts · 42 votes
    23m

    @Raul Valdivia, good day. On a showing I always step on the floor right next to the toilet 🙂 If it gives a little, that bathroom is already a gut job, whatever the listing says.

    A few other tells from the builder's side: tiles that sound hollow when you tap them with a key, fresh paint on the ceiling under the bathroom, and a fan that vents straight into the attic. Five minutes with a flashlight, and the tier is often clear before the offer.

    Which house fooled you the most, the one that looked worse than it was or the one that looked better?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.