Warning Signs of a Housing Crisis?

Warning Signs of a Housing Crisis?

Investor ยท Fort Lauderdale, FL ยท Member since 2013 ยท 944 posts ยท 628 votes

๐Œ๐จ๐ซ๐ž ๐ญ๐ก๐š๐ง ๐ฌ๐ฅ๐จ๐ฐ๐ข๐ง๐ , ๐ญ๐ก๐ž ๐ก๐จ๐ฎ๐ฌ๐ข๐ง๐  ๐ฆ๐š๐ซ๐ค๐ž๐ญ ๐ข๐ฌ ๐ฅ๐จ๐ฌ๐ข๐ง๐  ๐œ๐จ๐ง๐Ÿ๐ข๐๐ž๐ง๐œ๐ž.
Three more warning signs that the housing market is in trouble.

Pending home sales are crashing.
Building permits are crashing.
Homebuilder confidence is crashing. And perhaps most telling?
Homebuyer confidence has fallen off a cliff.

NAHB Homebuilder Confidence: 25
University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment: 29
Both are flashing serious warning signals. So. . .

Builders are losing confidence in their ability to sell houses.
Buyers are losing confidence in their ability to buy houses.
And prospective buyers are increasingly sitting on the sidelines.

How exactly do we get a healthy housing market when the people building homes don't want to build, and the people buying homes don't want to buy?

From the glass-is-half-full point of view, a market with too few buyers, growing inventory, and increasingly desperate sellers creates something very different from a housing shortage. It creates OPPORTUNITY.

For those willing to think outside the traditional real estate playbook, a struggling market can be a very profitable place to do business.

The question isn't whether opportunities are coming. It's whether you'll recognize them when they do.
When the traditional real estate market stops working, it's time to stop thinking traditionally.
There are ways to put deals together that many investors never consider or are unaware of.

1Reply
135 views

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant ยท Summerlin, NV ยท Member since 2014 ยท 45k+ posts ยท 66k+ votes
    1d

    for now its interest rates.. the biggest builders are able to sell through this period by providing low rates to their buyers.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender ยท USA, Nationwide ยท Member since 2024 ยท 641 posts ยท 185 votes
    12h

    A low sentiment reading doesn't make a crisis. Forced sellers do, and they come from debt, not mood. The thing to watch is rentals bought at 2021 and 2022 prices whose loans are maturing or resetting, where the rent no longer covers the payment. Once DSCR on those slips under 1.0 and a refinance won't pay off the balance, the owner has to sell or bring cash, and that's where real discounts start. Some commercial lenders seem to be pulling back on multifamily leverage, which would squeeze the same owners. Patient sellers don't discount, stressed ones do. Which non-traditional structures do you have in mind?

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager ยท Royal Oak, MI ยท Member since 2012 ยท 13k+ posts ยท 9k+ votes
    10h

    Just wrote a blog post about this last month.

    Please comment!

    So many predicting doom & gloom for the real estate market. Some are even referencing a repeat of the Great Real Estate Crash of 2008-2010.

    While the good times of the last 10 years are over, it would take a global economic meltdown to trash the real estate market that bad โ€“ and then weโ€™d all be worrying more about food & energy prices than what the house down the street sold for.

    This topic actually came up recently while I was speaking with an associate in the industry. Ever have one of those conversations that seem to bring a lot of half-formed thoughts into focus because youโ€™re being questioned about them and forced to think quickly?

    Amazing how often you can get clarity during these moments, so I highly recommend you search out people you can have these types of conversations with that will push you outside your comfort zone!

    A Quick Recap of the Great Real Estate Crash

    The Great Real Estate Crash was caused by aggressive mortgage programs that allowed 0% down payments, low credit scores for subprime borrowers and negative-amortization mortgages โ€“ all combined.

    Most of these mortgages also had adjustable rates.

    When interest rates started rising, these borrowers could not absorb the higher payments associated with their rising mortgage rates and started defaulting in record numbers.

    These types of mortgages no longer exist.

    Interesting US Census Bureau Stats

    Thereโ€™s a LOT of interesting data in the above.

    First is the Homeownership Rate of 65.0%. That number may not seem that important, as itโ€™s been bouncing between 65-69% for the last 20 years โ€“ but, if you dig deeper the data shows almost 40% of those homeowners own their homes free and clear. Check out the below breaking this out for each state:

    Kinda interesting that the District of Columbia, with its percentage of government-related population, ranks the lowest.

    The important takeaway here is that around 40% of US homeowners wonโ€™t be impacted by any economic fluctuations of the real estate market.

    In addition to that, more than 27% of homeowners have over 50% equity in their homes:

    So, thatโ€™s a total of over 68%.

    How hard would the real estate market have to crash to seriously impact these homeowners enough to walk away from their homes?

    We couldnโ€™t find any statistical data on the percentage of US homeowners with at least 20% equity in their homes, so we did an . AI referenced CoreLogic and ICE Mortgage Technology to answer that, โ€œroughly 80% to 85% of active mortgage holders possess tappable equityโ€.

    So, letโ€™s be conservative and say that 80% of homeowners have at least 20% equity in their homes. Again, what would it take to force them to walk away from their homes?

    A Frozen Real Estate Market

    According to all the experts, the real estate marketโ€™s biggest current challenge is home affordability. And mainstream thoughts are that lower interest rates or lower new home prices would solve the problem.

    But, itโ€™s not that simple.

    A large percentage of homeowners are โ€œfrozenโ€ in their current homes by their low interest rates.

    If you bought a home between 2013-2020 and got a mortgage with a 3%-4% mortgage rate, you could actually afford a higher priced home. But if you now want to move with mortgage rates around 7%, you may be looking at buying a less expensive home.

    This is because you really buy a home with a payment you can afford. Letโ€™s look at a simple example:

    Principle & Interest Payment of $2,000 @ 3% mortgage => $474k mortgage amount

    Principle & Interest Payment of $2,000 @ 4% mortgage => $419k mortgage amount

    Principle & Interest Payment of $2,000 @ 5% mortgage => $373k mortgage amount

    Principle & Interest Payment of $2,000 @ 6% mortgage => $334k mortgage amount

    Principle & Interest Payment of $2,000 @ 7% mortgage => $301k mortgage amount

    Every 1% increase in the mortgage rate lowers the corresponding mortgage amount by 10-12%!

    How is a homeowner going to upgrade from their current home with a 3% interest rate, when rates today are around 7%?

    Well, to have a chance theyโ€™ll need every dollar out of their current home when they sell it. Unfortunately, the number of buyers that can afford the price of their home with rates at 7% is a lot less than when rates were lower.

    So, until someone blinks, a large part of the real estate market is frozen.

    An interesting observation about the graph is the number of homeowners with low rates is falling. This is due to some owners refinancing, some selling and the increasing number of buyers taking out new mortgages with higher rates. Overall, itโ€™s a positive sign that the market is slowly thawing.

    Want to know the real reason the housing market is frozen and we have affordability issues?

    Take a long look at this graph. Itโ€™s why the average age of first-time home buyers is going up:

    Until incomes start increasing, the real estate market is highly likely to remain somewhat frozen.

    How Safe are Real Estate Investors?

    So, owner-occupied homes have a lot of equity in them.

    What about real estate investors?

    Well, according to a February, 2026 US Census Bureau , roughly 63% of 1-4 unit rental properties have no mortgage on them.

    A word of caution, many of these rentals were probably bought with funds from a line of credit against the ownerโ€™s primary residence. So, even though there is no lien on the rental, there is a debt involved.

    Where the Danger Lies

    So, other than the real estate market being frozen, it doesnโ€™t appear homeowners are likely to be all that impacted by any bad news for the real estate market. Most homeowners can probably absorb up to a 20% drop in the value of their homes.

    Whoโ€™s exposed are real estate investors:

    20% is a significant percentage of the US home market. The question then is, what percentage of investors are likely to default and under what circumstances?

    First, the good news. In the lead up to the Great Real Estate Crash, an investor could buy a rental property with 0% down โ€“ imagine that!

    Again, those programs are no longer available. Investors usually have to put down at least 20% since 2010.

    So, investors would have to walk away from their 20% down if they defaulted. Or would they?

    One of the most popular investing concepts pushed since 2012 (or so) is that of the BRRRR. Which is an abbreviation for, Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat.

    The Holy Grail of the BRRRR concept is an investor being able to pull all their money out of the property, and often even more, when they do the refinance step. This was actually fairly easy to do from 2010 to around 2024 when real estate prices and rents were steadily rising โ€“ often at double-digit percentages. Tens of thousands of newbie real estate investors did this with hundreds of thousands of homes.

    Check out the graph below which shows that at the end of 2024, investors accounted for over 30% of home sales:

    While many of these investors took out FNMA/FHLMC conforming type mortgages, an increasing number started using DSCR type mortgages. DSCR is an abbreviation for Debt Service Coverage Ratio. The big difference? DSCR is more aggressive by allowing an investor to use 100% of a property's rents to qualify, whereas conforming mortgages only allow 75% of the rents. DSCR also doesn't care about the borrower's income or personal debt-load. The tradeoff is higher interest rates, with prepayment penalties.

    How investors are getting into trouble with DSCR loans is by overleveraging. We've spoken to several investors in the last 2 months that were looking to sell their rentals. Their challenge โ€“ they owe more than they're worth, so they're "upside down".

    First question is, why do they want to sell?
    Answer: because the rentals arenโ€™t performing to their paper calculations. Many newbie investors are being taken advantage of by the BRRRR system. From 2010 to about 2016 an investor could buy a Class A rental and it would immediately cashflow. As prices rose though, investors were forced to switch to buying Class B rentals if they wanted to immediately cashflow. The problem was they kept using Class A rental performance expectations for their Class B acquisitions. Their mistake was hidden by rising property values & rents, so they rarely actually had to deal with it. Then around 2022 property values rose high enough that investors were pushed into buying Class C rentals if they wanted immediate cashflow. But again, they kept using Class A performance expectations! Up until around 2024, rising property values & rents again hid their mistake โ€“ but, then their mistake of using the wrong rental performance metrics came back to haunt them.

    BTW the actual metric that should NOT be used across all rental classes is tenant payment performance. Lower class tenants have lower credit scores. Just like the mortgage market found out with the Great Real Estate Recession, lower credit scores mean higher performance defaults.

    So, once newbie investors started experiencing tenant payment performance defaults of their Class C rentals, they had to keep making their rental mortgage payments from their personal income or use their reserves.  Eventually, many ran out of reserves or couldnโ€™t or didnโ€™t want to keep paying from their income. So, they decided to sell.

    Well, if they put down 20% to buy the property, why would they have a problem selling?

    Second question, why canโ€™t they sell?

    Itโ€™s a combination of the real estate market flatlining, even dropping in some areas, and how the appraisals were done.

    For 1-4 family properties, appraisals are done using sales comparables of similar properties and the appraised value is supposed to be the market value, or sales value, of the property.

    That process works fine if the buyer plans to live in, or owner-occupy, the property.

    For properties with tenants though, a buyer can NOT owner-occupy as most confirming mortgages require a buyer to occupy within 60 days of the purchase.

    So, that means only other investors can buy a tenant-occupied property. Smart investors though, do NOT pay market value!

    It's our opinion that DSCR mortgage lenders should modify their appraisal requirements and only allow rental property sale comparables โ€“ which will usually be much lower than owner-occupied property sales. DSCR lenders should also have their own property class rating system to adjust rental rates to account for tenant payment nonperformance issues.

    We've used this chart hundreds of times to warn investors about including nonperformance metrics in their ROI calculations.

    FICO Score

    Pct of Population

    Default Probability

    800 or more

    13.00%

    1.00%

    750-799

    27.00%

    1.00%

    700-749

    18.00%

    4.40%

    650-699

    15.00%

    8.90%

    600-649

    12.00%

    15.80%

    550-599

    8.00%

    22.50%

    500-549

    5.00%

    28.40%

    Less than 499

    2.00%

    41.00%

    The investors that were able to rehab their rentals enough and increase they value to pull all their cash-invested back out โ€“ are in even more trouble if they want to sell.

    Still, just under 2% of DSCR mortgages are currently 90+ days behind on payments:

    Summary

    We just covered a lot and you may be asking what does it all really mean?

    Well, hereโ€™s the quick summary:

    • Around 40% of US homeowners own their homes free & clear

    • Another 40% have at least 20% equity

    • A high percentage of 1-4 unit rental properties are also free & clear

    • So, weโ€™re highly unlikely to experience another real estate collapse like in 2008

    • The pain will probably be limited to real estate investors

    • Watch DSCR mortgage defaults for the "canary in the coal mine"

  • Investor ยท Fort Lauderdale, FL ยท Member since 2013 ยท 944 posts ยท 628 votes
    10h

    Great insights and breakdown, Drew. Appreciate you taking the time to share all that.
    The ho.using market is, indeed, frozen. Something's gotta give. If I'm pushing my chips into the pot, I'm betting on seller's eventually accepting that prices have peaked. The halcyon days of 2021-22 are long gone.
    Bottom line: either wages rise 30%; prices decline 30%; or rates decline to 5%. Since none of these are going to happen, the Great Freeze continues.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.