Registration is now open for our Wholesaling and Fix & Flip Bootcamps. Register Now!

Hide this

Jump to Category View All

Click a category below to view different forum categories.

BiggerPockets

General Info

Rss10 BiggerPockets Q&A, Site Questions, & Announcements

964 topics, 7692 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 05:05AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area

10 topics, 73 posts — Last Post 02/06/12, 09:15PM

Rss10 New Member Introductions

4490 topics, 25663 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 07:18AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Success Stories

142 topics, 1632 posts — Last Post 01/28/12, 09:34AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit

16 topics, 560 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 04:23PM

General Real Estate

General Real Estate

Rss10 Buying Real Estate

1195 topics, 9022 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 08:03AM

Rss10 Selling Real Estate

303 topics, 2364 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:05AM

Rss10 Renters

189 topics, 1529 posts — Last Post 12/28/11, 05:55AM

Rss10 Get Foreclosure Help - Help Stop Foreclosure Forum

218 topics, 1728 posts — Last Post 02/02/12, 10:07PM

Rss10 Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum

105 topics, 662 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 09:42AM

Rss10 Do it Yourself

312 topics, 2699 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 07:25PM

Reviews & Feedback

Rss10 Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice

1554 topics, 12278 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:00PM

Rss10 Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions

677 topics, 6767 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 04:25AM

Rss10 Ask About A Real Estate Company

309 topics, 4634 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 03:12PM

Real Estate Investing

Real Estate Strategies

Rss10 Wholesaling

2406 topics, 18098 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:20PM

Rss10 Rehabbing and House Flipping

1478 topics, 12679 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 11:27AM

Rss10 Real Estate Development

190 topics, 1025 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:14AM

Rss10 Pre-Construction & New Home Construction

85 topics, 530 posts — Last Post 01/10/12, 07:04PM

Rss10 Innovative Strategies

328 topics, 2304 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 06:41PM

Rss10 Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion

435 topics, 2411 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:29AM

Rss10 Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options

341 topics, 2086 posts — Last Post 02/07/12, 07:38PM

Rss10 1031 Exchanges

58 topics, 316 posts — Last Post 12/17/11, 05:10PM

Foreclosure Investing

Rss10 General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums

1096 topics, 6537 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:07AM

Rss10 HUD, VA, and Tax Sales

197 topics, 1221 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 12:34PM

Rss10 REOs

922 topics, 7646 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:54PM

Rss10 Short Sales

1220 topics, 10051 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 02:43AM

Landlord & Tenant Forums

Rss10 Rental Property Questions & Landlording Issues

2940 topics, 26276 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:44AM

Rss10 Land & Farm Investing

116 topics, 728 posts — Last Post 01/29/12, 06:46PM

Rss10 Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing

391 topics, 2864 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:32AM

Real Estate Dealmaking

Rss10 Make Deals, Find Partners, Mentors & BirdDogs, etc.

3648 topics, 13401 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 09:40AM

Rss10 Promote Your Real Estate Buyer's List

152 topics, 669 posts — Last Post 01/23/12, 12:35PM

Rss10 Property Wanted

626 topics, 3019 posts — Last Post 01/19/12, 02:47PM

Rss10 Seeking Financing, Money, or Loans

1218 topics, 7344 posts — Last Post 02/03/12, 11:21PM

Rss10 Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Dealmaking

273 topics, 1990 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:30AM

Rss10 Bulk REO Discussion and REO Dealmaking

845 topics, 5917 posts — Last Post 02/02/12, 04:20PM

Investor Basics

Rss10 Starting Out

4060 topics, 29633 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 07:38AM

Rss10 Investor Psychology

289 topics, 4281 posts — Last Post 01/26/12, 07:52PM

Rss10 General Real Estate Investing

3057 topics, 20771 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 12:54PM

Rss10 Real Estate Investor Marketing

868 topics, 7051 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 04:09AM

Commercial Real Estate

Rss10 Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum

718 topics, 3839 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 09:28PM

Rss10 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing

141 topics, 1347 posts — Last Post 02/07/12, 05:47AM

Rss10 Office Investing

3 topics, 36 posts — Last Post 11/15/11, 02:42PM

Rss10 Industrial Property Investing

3 topics, 12 posts — Last Post 07/05/11, 10:41AM

Rss10 Retail Property Investing

6 topics, 42 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:19AM

Rss10 CRE Financing and Lending

17 topics, 188 posts — Last Post 01/26/12, 05:55PM

Rss10 CRE Syndication and Fundraising

25 topics, 208 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 12:57PM

Rss10 CRE Property Management & Leasing

2 topics, 11 posts — Last Post 12/11/11, 05:05PM

The Business of Real Estate

Real Estate Technology and the Internet

Rss10 Technology, Social Media, Real Estate & The Web

244 topics, 2018 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:20AM

Rss10 Real Estate Blogs & Blogging

23 topics, 278 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:01AM

Business Basics

Rss10 Goals, Business Plans & Entities

400 topics, 3913 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 07:12PM

Real Estate Finance & Legal

Financial, Tax, and Legal

Rss10 Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA

1210 topics, 8252 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 05:36AM

Rss10 Credit & Credit Repair

177 topics, 1444 posts — Last Post 01/25/12, 06:56AM

Rss10 Property Insurance

117 topics, 753 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:33PM

Rss10 Bankruptcy

21 topics, 110 posts — Last Post 12/09/11, 10:01AM

Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines

Rss10 Private & Conventional Lending Discussion

1244 topics, 7159 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:23PM

Rss10 Creative Real Estate Financing

623 topics, 3989 posts — Last Post 01/30/12, 05:35PM

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Professionals

Rss10 Real Estate Agents

611 topics, 3290 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 06:32PM

Rss10 Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers

351 topics, 1252 posts — Last Post 02/03/12, 06:47AM

Rss10 Contractors

117 topics, 626 posts — Last Post 02/08/12, 10:17AM

Local Real Estate

International Real Estate

Local Real Estate

Rss10 Local Real Estate Networking

573 topics, 3013 posts — Last Post 02/07/12, 04:58PM

Rss10 Americans & International Real Estate

138 topics, 499 posts — Last Post 12/24/11, 07:44AM

Rss10 Foreigners Buying in the USA

54 topics, 281 posts — Last Post 01/18/12, 09:33PM

Rss10 Canadian Real Estate

25 topics, 117 posts — Last Post 02/06/12, 05:17PM

Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

Rss10 Mortgages & Lending

388 topics, 1730 posts — Last Post 01/23/12, 02:23PM

Rss10 Residential Property, Land, & Farms For Sale

756 topics, 1414 posts — Last Post 12/26/11, 01:22PM

Rss10 Real Estate Events & Happenings

113 topics, 453 posts — Last Post 01/11/12, 05:36PM

Rss10 Commercial Properties for Sale or Lease

223 topics, 668 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:59AM

Rss10 Domains & Website Reviews

44 topics, 334 posts — Last Post 11/15/11, 09:55AM

Rss10 Classifieds - Promote your Website, Newsletter, or Product

582 topics, 2646 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 04:56PM

Off-Topic

Off Topic

Rss10 Off-Topic

1769 topics, 18865 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 07:29AM

Rss10 Housing News & Real Estate Market

647 topics, 6308 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 08:59AM

BiggerPockets Resources

Forums » Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum » Investing with an LLC/Corp

Investing with an LLC/Corp Subscribe to Investing with an LLC/Corp

14 posts by 6 users

Signup

Real Estate Investor · Lake Almanor, California


It is my understanding that if an LLC is formed in Nevada and I buy property in another state I will have to register as a foreign entity. I believe that in CA this is the same annual fee, 600.00 that is charged to an LLC formed in CA. Wouldn't this get to be a big expense? Also, would you have to have a registered agent in each state? With an LLC do you have to get the checking account in the state where formed and would each foreign entity have to have the checking account in that state?


SFR Investor · Scottsdale, Arizona


Can I ask why you want to form an LLC in Nevada if you are in CA?


Real Estate Investor · Phoenix, Arizona


Nick, a lot of people do that. CA is a high-tax jurisdiction so many small business owners incorporate in Nevada, Wyoming, etc. The problem, as Charlotte noted, is that it is not easy to avoid CA taxes if you are doing business in California.

Charlotte, I am pretty sure you will have to register as a foreign LLC and pay taxes in Californiaa for California source income. If the only asset of your LLC is a California rental property, then there may not be much point in doing this. But if you have rental properties in multiple states, then it might make sense to have them owned by one entity. Perhaps someone like Rich or Jim, who own properties in multiple states, can answer this.

Regarding the bank account, I have always had a Nevada bank account for my Navada corporations (BofA) and never had a problem receiving payments from throughout the country and depositing it into the account. We used to have an office in NYC where we received all checks and we made the deposit locally at the NYC branch of our bank.

Finally, I must mention that saving taxes need not be the only reason for setting up an entity in Nevada. Nevada also offers easier rules regarding management, privacy of information, etc. Nevada courts are also more cautious in piercing the corporate veil, although this benefit might not accrue to you if you get sued in California for liability arising from your CA rental property.


SFR Investor · Scottsdale, Arizona


really?

so if you're going to be taxed in CA, why not just incorporate in CA?


Real Estate Investor · Lake Almanor, California


Thanks to everyoine. My LLC is in Nev and so far I have not purchased any property in CA but what if I purchase in OK or TX. Guess I have to register as a foreign entity there and hopefully they are not as expensive as CA. Am currently checking properties also in Nev.


Real Estate Investor · Northeast TN, Tennessee


Charlotte,
You are spot on with your guess. Any state that you are going to do business in (and that includes owning property) as an LLC will require that you register as a foreign entity. Most of these registrations will be just as much, if not more, than registering as a domestic.

regards,

Bill


SFR Investor · Scottsdale, Arizona


Bill, so would that make it not worth living in and doing business in CA but creating an entity in NV?


Real Estate Investor · Phoenix, Arizona


Nick, I am not sure if I understood you correctly, but setting up an entity in NV or WY makes sense for a lot of businesses that are not tied to a specific location. For example, if you are offering services (e.g. an eBook on subject2.com!) and wish to avoid income taxes in your home state, you could set up a NV corporation with a NV mailing address and NV bank account.

I think a corporation would be better than an LLC for this purpose because it is a separate tax entity that does not pass-through taxes to the owners. (C Corp)


SFR Investor · Rancho Cucamonga, California


Vikram is right.

If you have a business that is online etc and does decent volume, it might make sense to setup out of California. So you'd pay yourself very little and have the C-Corp hold and invest the profits. But when you personally touch those profits you will be paying taxes on them.

LLC is a pass through entity and you'd end up paying CA tax on your profits anyways. All these sites and services (AKA Legal Zoom) that recommend out-of-state incorporation (Deleware and Nevada mostly) are over thinking things for most small businesses (in my opinion). If you're going to be investing on a small scale (under 1-2 million), I would just make a CA entity and pay taxes on it. Once you get big enough for your accountant/laywer to recommend something more creative you can cross that bridge.

And yes, say you have a Deleware Corporation (like I do), that does business in California, you still have to pay $800/year to "do business in California."


Real Estate Investor · Lake Almanor, California


Thanks to everyoine. My LLC is in Nev and so far I have not purchased any property in CA but what if I purchase in OK or TX. Guess I have to register as a foreign entity there and hopefully they are not as expensive as CA. Am currently checking properties also in Nev.


Real Estate Investor · Northeast TN, Tennessee


Nick,

Both Vikram and Steve are spot on with their answers. I would only say that if your only business at this time is real estate and you live and invest in CA, then establish your entity there as a domestic entity. It will save you a lot of extra paperwork and expense.

regards,

Bill


SFR Investor · Scottsdale, Arizona


makes a lot more sense now guys! thanks for answering.


Real Estate Investor · Lake Almanor, California


I was off saying it would cost 600.00. Did not know that the cost had gone up to 800.00 to do business as a corp in CA until I checked today. Poor CA.


Private Money Lender · Los Angeles, California


With due respect to all, there appears to be some mis-information in this thread.

Originally posted by Vikram C
… Charlotte, I am pretty sure you will have to register as a foreign LLC and pay taxes in Californiaa [sic] for California source income…

This is only half right. You do have to register but California taxes you on your worldwide income, not just "California source income."

Originally posted by Vikram C.
… For example, if you are offering services (e.g. an eBook on subject2.com!) and wish to avoid income taxes in your home state, you could set up a NV corporation with a NV mailing address and NV bank account.

Also incorrect. Owning a foreign (i.e. out-of-state) entity does not absolve you of your CA state tax liability. The minimum tax California charge is $800 per year per entity. This is not a fee; it's the minimum tax. If you are doing business in California, you must register your foreign entities there. I know you're going to say all your business is conducted in Nevada and I wouldn't argue with you, but the Franchise Tax Board would. As a CA resident, which I assume you are, if you receive mail here, make phone calls, or otherwise direct any part of your Nevada business from California, you must be registered and file taxes here.

Originally posted by Vikram C.
Nick, I am not sure if I understood you correctly, but setting up an entity in NV or WY makes sense for a lot of businesses that are not tied to a specific location. For example, if you are offering services (e.g. an eBook on subject2.com!) and wish to avoid income taxes in your home state, you could set up a NV corporation with a NV mailing address and NV bank account.
I think a corporation would be better than an LLC for this purpose because it is a separate tax entity that does not pass-through taxes to the owners. (C Corp)

It appears to me Vikram, you need to speak to a CPA. Your Nevada C-corporation or LLC must be registered in California, declare its income, deduct expenses, and pay taxes appropriately. Again, $800 would be the minimum.

Originally posted by Steve L.
… If you have a business that is online etc and does decent volume, it might make sense to setup out of California. So you'd pay yourself very little and have the C-Corp hold and invest the profits. But when you personally touch those profits you will be paying taxes on them. …

All this strategy will do is cause you to pay taxes twice. Profits held in a C-corporation are taxed annually at the state and federal corporate level and then further taxed at the private level when you disburse them to yourself personally. Wouldn't it be nice if you could shelter money from taxes by setting up a foreign c-corporation, not declare it to any state (or the feds), and pay no taxes until the profits are disbursed personally?

Originally posted by motiv8td
really?
so if you're going to be taxed in CA, why not just incorporate in CA?
Bingo.

I don't know why Charlotte, you chose to set up your LLC in the first place, but if it was merely to avoid taxes then I'm not sure you did yourself any favors. Right now, you have incurred an $800 state tax liability with no income to offset it. From whom are you getting this advice?

Sign up