Landlord and Rehabber · Newton, MA · Member since 2010 · 2k+ posts · 877 votes
Seems frivolous and my attorney agrees so I'm not all that worried about it.
Basically a homeowner that had(chose) to replace a heating system not long after she bought the place.
Looks like they are just throwing stuff against the wall to see if it will stick, but of course if they actually file suit you never know what could happen.
Anyway not looking for opinions on my "case" as much as would like to hear people's stories about the time someone threatened to sue them.
Seems like a fun topic to let people vent about! :)
While I agree with Ibrahim that reputation is important, I don't see that you did anything wrong here. First, you made some repairs to the existing older unit which functioned properly at close if escrow. Secondly, buyers own inspector basically put her on notice that the unit was older and would need replacement sooner rather than later. Hence, full disclosure was given to buyer by her very own inspector she hired. Now, by choice, she wants to replace, she will have to do so at her own cost. My take is this. Had you replaced the unit new to begin with, your ask price would likely have been greater than what she paid.
My response letter o her would simply state, and place her on notice, of these facts along with the fact hat the likely prevailing party in this case would be you who would then seek reimbursement of your court costs for the frivolous suit.
Congrats on finally making it Shaun! Seriously though, it seems like in these days it is just a matter of time. I haven't threatened to be sued (yet), but hopefully some others will chime in. Let us know the outcome.
Threats to sue? LOL, that's a book! No one was ever successful! Sometimes it's better to settle than fight, but never got the short end of the stick really. :)
James Vermillion good luck with not having to deal with it.
Bill Gulley I hope to still be in the threat with out it happening categorey. Unfortunetly in my state having the actual Law on your side isn't always a lock to win something...
Ibrahim S Yes that is basically the situation. We did a rehab on the lower end of the market (ARV ~$200K) and since the system was functional we decided to keep it. Her inspector recommened it be replaced (as inspectors do) but SHE didn't even request it. There was some venting we added and a dianostic run on some components that came out were working fine that she did ask for.
She apparently had some issues soon after closing and CHOSE to replace it about a month later.
Ibrahim S Yes that is basically the situation. We did a rehab on the lower end of the market (ARV ~$200K) and since the system was functional we decided to keep it. Her inspector recommened it be replaced (as inspectors do) but SHE didn't even request it. There was some venting we added and a dianostic run on some components that came out were working fine that she did ask for.
She apparently had some issues soon after closing and CHOSE to replace it about a month later.
Shaun I know everyone's thoughts are different on this. But my thinking is that she didn't push the replacement and allowed you guys to upgrade the components because she trusted you that your solution would fix the situation. It didn't. My personal opinion is that you should work to protect your name and reputation at all costs. 'Lower end' market or not. Every customer (home buyer) deserves a working quality product.
I always put new heating systems in unless they were recently replaced. I once did a rehab on a 2 family (duplex for everyone outside of NJ - LOL) where I instructed my plumber to install two new boilers. Instead he installs one new boiler and one used one that was about 5 years old. It looked good so I didn't sweat it. But I warned him that if there was a problem with it, I didn't want it fixed, I wanted it replaced with a brand new one. He agreed. Sure enough about a month after the closing I get a call from the Buyer's agent that the boiler failed. My plumber went right over there with a new one. Both the buyer and agent were pleasantly surprised that I replaced it so quickly and without a fight.
But I usually warrant ALL of my rehab components up to a year after I sell a home. I wouldn't want someone going online and talking about it's a bad idea to buy from me because I'm a crook. That can end up costing a lot more than the $5k it could cost me to replace a boiler. And honestly I'd want the same treatment if my Mother was the one who purchased the house and the heating system failed.
And that's my 'story'. I took care of it before anyone had a chance to talk about suing :)
I'm curious why you need a lawyer for this. Isn't this a small claims case? How much are we talking here?
I've had people threaten to sue me over frivilous stuff before. I currently have my first lawsuit coming up in two months. A tenant broke her lease and wants her security deposit back. She did everything wrong. I can't wait to go to court. I like playing the lawyer role. We are talking about a very small amount of money, but there is no way I will ever pay her a dime.
In my state, houses are sold as-is subject to an inspection. Your buyer had an inspection. Unless you knew the furnace was bad, or you were hiding something (sounds like that's not the case), I don't think this person would have a claim.
While I agree with Ibrahim that reputation is important, I don't see that you did anything wrong here. First, you made some repairs to the existing older unit which functioned properly at close if escrow. Secondly, buyers own inspector basically put her on notice that the unit was older and would need replacement sooner rather than later. Hence, full disclosure was given to buyer by her very own inspector she hired. Now, by choice, she wants to replace, she will have to do so at her own cost. My take is this. Had you replaced the unit new to begin with, your ask price would likely have been greater than what she paid.
My response letter o her would simply state, and place her on notice, of these facts along with the fact hat the likely prevailing party in this case would be you who would then seek reimbursement of your court costs for the frivolous suit.
While I agree with Ibrahim that reputation is important, I don't see that you did anything wrong here. First, you made some repairs to the existing older unit which functioned properly at close if escrow. Secondly, buyers own inspector basically put her on notice that the unit was older and would need replacement sooner rather than later. Hence, full disclosure was given to buyer by her very own inspector she hired. Now, by choice, she wants to replace, she will have to do so at her own cost. My take is this. Had you replaced the unit new to begin with, your ask price would likely have been greater than what she paid.
My response letter o her would simply state, and place her on notice, of these facts along with the fact hat the likely prevailing party in this case would be you who would then seek reimbursement of your court costs for the frivolous suit.
Good point Will but while his asking price may have been different if he replaced the unit in the beginning of his rehab (which I sort of doubt since many rehabbers will price close to the top of the market anyway after doing a rehab, new unit or not), the price would NOT have been any different had the buyer insisted after attorney review that the unit be replaced (and Shaun agreed). And if Shaun was smart and wanted to close this deal so that he could move on, he would have likely replaced that unit, closed the deal and moved on.
I think what we're really talking about here though is it worth the risk? Does Shaun want to risk the buyer (or the realtor) relaying her bad experience to his potential customers in the future? All the public will know is that this woman purchased one of his 'renovated homes' and got left with a lemon of a heating system. Personally, if I'm buying a home and looking at one of his I don't care about the details of a home inspection and who disclosed what. I'm not trusting this guy and his homes. It's a slippery slope here if you ask me.
Will Barnard that is pretty much my thoughts on the situation and more or less what our response to her letter will be. One small correction is that the only work we did was add a vent pipe and some wall venting. We did some diagnostic tests on the exchanger that said it was working. If she had asked that I replaced the system and if I had actually done repairs and claimed that improved the condition of the system and it then failed I would probably have replaced it without any real hestitation. It is the fact she never asked until post closing and I didn't do any repairs to it which is why it is distasteful.
Ibrahim S I also agree that I should take my reputation into account. That being said I also don't like people threatening me and claiming that I willfully defrauded them. At this point I could pay for the heating system and the other like $20K of work her inspector had recommended and she would still tell everyone she knows that I'm an a$$hole.
As for her Realtor she actually CCed the letter to him and threatened to name him in the lawsuit as well (Apparently it was a massive conspirecy to screw her involving me/my company, the GC, the plumber, my agent and her agent) so I'm not too worried about him bad mouthing me based on what happened to his client. :)
This s a clear case of a person grasping at straws and blaming anyone they can to get something for nothing. I don't personally give in to people like this. As a result, they learn they can't get away with dishonesty or threats and hopefully that saves someone else from a similar experience with that person.
$6500 is quite expensive in my book for a new unit. How many tons is it and. What sear rating? Not hat it matters but this buyer had all the info upfront before she closed. There is no cooling off period in home sales!
Will Barnard another reason it is annoying is that if she had asked for it and I eventually agreed I am SURE that I would have been able to do it for $1-2K less easy.
I have no idea what she purchased for this. What I know is that it only needed to heat 800-900sqft. In 2004 someone just ploped a 2nd floor on a tiny house and put electric heat up there. Again low end rehab so we left the electric heat.
I also do not have the impression she got any other bids. Looks like she brought someone out to fix the gauge on the oil tank, they told her she should replace the unit, she hired them and paid them what they asked plus 10% above the initial quote.
I actually think she got screwed, but not by me!!!!
Be careful. Just because you are right doesn't mean you will win in court.
Remember that you are the shady big time real estate investor shark. She is the poor little old home buyer.
It might be better to just pay her and make the problem go away. That is what I ended up doing in a similar situation a few years ago on the advice of fellow BP posters.
Robert Steele I agree that the only worry I have is that they rule against me despite being in the right.
My plan is to respond decisively with a lot of support for my position (Unlike the zero support they sent) and see if they back down as I will not be an easy mark.
If she does move forward then I probably would look at settleing as I could get screwed by a judge that doesn't feel that the law and acutal facts are all that important.
But isn't that just legal extortion? I wish someone with more power than I would take up this cause. Lawyers just threaten to sue and the other side caves just to make it go away. No matter what the lawyers get paid. This just raises prices for insurance and other goods and services for all of us.
A little off topic, but I wanted to express my relief that this is one area where our two societies/countries actually do differ ... and hopefully it stays that way :-)
I have horrible lawsuit against me . . . they could essentially steal everything I own and worked for. It scares me sometimes, panic attack! Read more at my blog: http://sycamorevista.org/