AirDNA’s Top Cash-on-Cash Short-Term Rental Markets for 2026

AirDNA’s Top Cash-on-Cash Short-Term Rental Markets for 2026

Harrisburg/Hershey, Pennsylvania, has the best short-term rental cash-on-cash return in AirDNA’s newest data: 14.5%. Broken Bow, Oklahoma (cabin capital of the South, hot tub capital of the world, probably) comes in at 6.6%.

The average Broken Bow rental is also projected to gross about $27,400 more per year than the average one in Harrisburg/Hershey. More money, less return.

AirDNA gave BiggerPockets an exclusive look at this data: the top 10 short-term rental markets by cash-on-cash return in five categories:

  • Large cities
  • Midsize cities
  • Small cities
  • Coastal
  • Mountain

That’s 50 markets. I like this list a lot. I’m also about to spend 2,000 words telling you not to shop from it.

Every number on it is an average. The returns assume you paid cash (as in, walked into closing with a duffel bag), and expenses are a flat 30% in all 50 markets. That’s why I’d only use this list to decide where to start looking.

First, the Math (It’s Easy, I Promise)

AirDNA gives every market three numbers: average home value, average annual revenue potential, and cash-on-cash return. The first two come from homes in AirDNA’s Rentalizer, the tool that estimates what a specific address would earn as a short-term rental. AirDNA averaged those homes market by market, using the trailing 12 months of revenue.

The return isn’t very complicated to figure out on the surface. Take the revenue, deduct 30% for expenses, and divide by the home’s value. Here’s New Orleans:

  • $47,187 in revenue – 30% = $33,031, / $330,449 house = 10% cash-on-cash

There’s no mortgage in this calculation, and the denominator excludes closing costs, furnishings, and other upfront expenses. 

Despite the cash-on-cash label, this is a simplified, unlevered income yield. It resembles a cap rate calculation, but it uses an assumed expense allowance rather than property-specific operating costs. Before getting attached to a market, calculate your return using the purchase price, actual expenses, financing, and total cash you’ll invest.

Also, those home values: They’re the average of the homes in AirDNA’s data, not the typical home in town. Zillow puts the typical New Orleans home at $241,895. AirDNA’s New Orleans average is $330,449. The house you’d buy might look nothing like the average house.

All 50 Markets

Each category is ranked by AirDNA’s cash-on-cash return. Before the weird stuff, the basics:

  • Small cities pay the most. All 10 return at least 10%, and Harrisburg/Hershey leads at 14.5%. But it’s riskier going into small cities.
  • Vacation markets pay the least, on average. No coastal or mountain market cracks 9%, and Broken Bow (6.6%) and the Lower Hudson Valley (6.5%) sit at the bottom. Less risk, but less reward potentially here.
  • San Juan, Puerto Rico ($75,235) and Broken Bow ($72,786) are the two biggest earners on the list. Neither one gets above 7.1%.

Large cities

Rank

Market Average home value Average revenue potential

Cash-on-cash return

1 New Orleans, LA $330,449 $47,187 10%
2 Baltimore, MD $339,177 $45,837 9.5%
3 Philadelphia, PA $344,282 $43,844 8.9%
4 Memphis, TN $380,523 $47,550 8.7%
5 Minneapolis, MN $361,377 $44,661 8.7%
6 Chicago, IL $401,663 $48,838 8.5%
7 St. Louis, MO $374,344 $45,279 8.5%
8 Cleveland, OH $348,667 $42,099 8.5%
9 Indianapolis, IN $379,757 $44,807 8.3%
10 Detroit, MI $347,288 $40,648 8.2%

Midsize cities

Rank

Market Average home value Average revenue potential

Cash-on-cash return

1 Columbia, SC $309,556 $45,544 10.3%
2 Lancaster, PA $334,300 $47,458 9.9%
3 Baton Rouge, LA $241,753 $33,617 9.7%
4 Syracuse, NY $325,999 $43,984 9.4%
5 Rochester, NY $328,613 $43,833 9.3%
6 Montgomery, AL $333,331 $43,767 9.2%
7 Tulsa, OK $302,399 $39,570 9.2%
8 Tallahassee, FL $286,838 $35,816 8.7%
9 Birmingham, AL $341,948 $42,609 8.7%
10 Fort Wayne, IN $320,459 $39,657 8.7%

Small cities

Rank

Market Average home value Average revenue potential

Cash-on-cash return

1 Harrisburg/Hershey, PA $218,797 $45,353 14.5%
2 Abilene, TX $373,124 $60,957 11.4%
3 Flint, MI $227,821 $36,557 11.2%
4 Battle Creek, MI $274,111 $43,245 11.0%
5 Peoria, IL $264,029 $39,797 10.6%
6 Bloomington/Normal, IL $288,828 $42,846 10.4%
7 Muncie, IN $221,855 $32,712 10.3%
8 Crestview, FL $286,950 $41,251 10.1%
9 Wright City, MO $438,506 $62,870 10.0%
10 Huntington, WV $224,321 $32,089 10.0%

Coastal markets

Rank

Market Average home value Average revenue potential

Cash-on-cash return

1 Destin/Fort Walton Beach, FL $457,811 $55,805 8.5%
2 Michigan East Coastal, MI $298,432 $33,707 7.9%
3 Gulfport/Biloxi, MS $368,357 $39,855 7.6%
4 Gulf Shores/Mobile, AL $427,448 $46,153 7.6%
5 Norfolk/Virginia Beach, VA $447,555 $46,146 7.2%
6 Panama City, FL $523,803 $53,273 7.1%
7 Charleston, SC $532,827 $54,118 7.1%
8 Corpus Christi, TX $449,566 $45,561 7.1%
9 San Juan, PR $742,542 $75,235 7.1%
10 Michigan West Coastal, MI $534,726 $54,101 7.1%

Mountain markets

Rank

Market Average home value Average revenue potential

Cash-on-cash return

1 Pocono Mountains, PA $438,177 $53,359 8.5%
2 Hot Springs, AR $382,167 $43,913 8.0%
3 Finger Lakes, NY $455,963 $50,926 7.8%
4 Wisconsin Dells, WI $424,486 $46,634 7.7%
5 Joshua Tree, CA $596,451 $61,273 7.2%
6 Ozark Mountains, MO $524,332 $51,193 6.8%
7 Broken Bow Lake, OK $770,084 $72,786 6.6%
8 Lower Hudson Valley, NY $679,441 $63,469 6.5%

New Orleans Is No. 1—If It Lets You In

New Orleans has the best cash-on-cash return of any big city on the list: 10%. The city has spent years trying to shrink its short-term rental market, and it got serious in the months after hosting the Super Bowl in 2025.

The quick version:

  • 2023: The city limited residential short-term rentals to one per city block, with a lottery when more than one owner applies, per WWNO and the New Orleans City Council.
  • Feb. 9, 2025: Super Bowl LIX at the Superdome. (Good weekend to be a host in New Orleans.)
  • Feb. 14, 2025: Five days later, Airbnb sued the city over its rules.
  • Aug. 1, 2025:As reported by Hotel Online, platforms had to verify permits before facilitating bookings. Unpermitted properties could no longer legally accept bookings through those platforms.
  • Sept. 8, 2025: A federal judge threw out Airbnb’s lawsuit.

AirDNA had been tracking about 7,750 New Orleans listings before enforcement. One local estimate put the drop at 16% to 20%.

Then there’s the houses themselves. From mid-2022 to mid-2026, home prices in the New Orleans metro went up about 1% according to FHFA data via FRED. Prices in the U.S. rose about 17% over the same period. Insurance is a big part of why. Louisiana’s average homeowners premium is $5,185 a year, about 80% above the national average according to Insurance.com.

My theory: Fewer legal competitors means more bookings and better rates for the hosts who are left. Flat home prices keep the bottom half of the fraction from running away. And since AirDNA uses the trailing 12 months of revenue, that 10% mostly reflects New Orleans after the crackdown, not before it.

This is great news if you already have a permit. If you’re trying to get one now, you’re signing up for this according to Steadily:

  • Residential permits are generally limited to one per square block. If multiple eligible applicants compete for that permit, a lottery determines who gets it.
  • A licensed operator must be physically present during guest stays.
  • One STR permit per owner (an LLC can hold it, as of October 2025).
  • No STRs at all in the Garden District, and most of the French Quarter is closed to residential STRs.
  • Commercial-zone STRs are possible again, but each needs a conditional-use permit.

Michigan Has Two Coasts and Almost the Same Return

Michigan put two markets on the coastal list, and they finished within a point of each other: 7.9% on the Lake Huron side, 7.1% on the Lake Michigan side.

The average Michigan West Coast house costs $236,294 more (79% more) and generates $20,394 more in annual revenue (about 60% more). The revenue doesn’t keep up with the price.

The West side (Saugatuck, South Haven, Grand Haven, and Traverse City) is the established vacation coast, and its southern towns are an easy weekend drive from Chicago. Buyers know that, and they’ve paid for it. The East side (the Thumb, Tawas, Oscoda, Alpena) is cheaper and quieter, and so is the revenue.

Which coast is better depends on what you’re trying to do (annoying, I know):

  • West: More revenue per door and deeper demand, but more competition and a much bigger check to get in.
  • East: A cheaper way in. Two average East Coast houses cost $596,864 and gross about $67,400 combined, versus $534,726 and $54,101 for one on the West side. (Two doors also means two roofs and twice as many guests texting you about the Wi-Fi.)

Small Towns Are Where the Guests Went

In AirDNA’s January 2026 numbers, nights stayed in small cities and rural destinations grew nearly 6% from a year earlier, faster than any other location type. Nationally, nights stayed grew 2.5% year over year according to GlobeSt.

AirDNA saw the same thing when we went over this dataset with them: Rural listings are growing more than twice as fast as the country as a whole, and big-city listing growth is slowing.

Some of this is macro because money has gotten expensive again. According to Freddie Mac, the 30-year average was 7.24% the week of Oct. 29, up from 6.17% a year earlier. When borrowing costs that much, investors want to get paid for their risk, and right now, the cheap houses with real revenue are mostly in small towns.

Two warnings before you go buy a farmhouse, though:

  1. Everybody else can read this data too. As Short Term Rentalz notes, AirDNA expects the fastest supply growth in more affordable rural, small-city, and midsize markets, which are the exact places at the top of this list. An 11% market can turn into an 8% market when 40 new listings open up down the road.
  2. Small towns have fewer reasons to visit. A big city has a hundred. A small town might have three (a hospital, a college, a lake). Lose one, and you’ve lost a third of them.

The Beach Pays Less (on Purpose)

Every small city on this list beats every coastal and mountain market. Not one beach market cracks 9%. That sounded backward to me at first.

One possible explanation is that buyers pay more for established vacation destinations, pushing acquisition costs up faster than rental revenue. But this ranking doesn’t establish that coastal markets are less risky. It also doesn’t isolate the effects of property mix, operating costs, or resale demand.

There are also two things a flat 30% expense line can’t see at the beach:

  • Insurance: The cited homeowner’s insurance comparison puts Florida at $8,471 a year and Pennsylvania at $1,434. Those are standardized homeowner’s policy benchmarks, not STR insurance quotes. Actual premiums depend on the property, coverage, location, and rental use. A flat 30% expense allowance doesn’t account for those property-level differences.
  • Supply: Proven markets get crowded too. In January 2026, the markets adding listings fastest, Florida beach towns among them, had 5% to 15% more listings than a year earlier, plus the biggest occupancy declines according to GlobeSt.

Wait, Why Is Abilene on This List?

Abilene, Texas, is the No. 2 small city on the list at 11.4%. Its average revenue ($60,957) beats every coastal market on the list except San Juan. A West Texas city of more than 131,000 people according to WTOC is outearning Charleston and Destin.

A major demand driver to investigate here is Stargate, the AI data center campus about eight miles outside town. Crusoe developed it, Oracle supplies the cloud capacity, and OpenAI is the customer. Building it brought 7,000 to 9,000 temporary workers to town, and all of them needed somewhere to sleep:

  • Some $1,200-a-month rentals started bringing in $3,000 as short-term housing for workers.
  • Hotel taxes alone rose $2 million.
  • Average rent hit almost $2,600 a month, up nearly 50% in a year, according to KUT reporting on Zillow data.

In Abilene, AirDNA’s trailing 12 months were marked by heavy construction. The project is slated for completion in 2027 and expected to create about 1,000 long-term jobs, according to Oracle, a fraction of the 7,000 to 9,000 people building it.

And supply is catching up. Mayor Weldon Hurt says single-family permits are up 73%, with about 900 apartment units expected within a year.

The home value gap shows up here too. According to Zillow, Abilene’s typical home value is $223,853. AirDNA’s Abilene average is $373,124. Those are not the same houses.

AirDNA’s Abilene average is $373,124. Those are not the same houses.

So if you buy in Abilene, underwrite what the house earns after the crews go home.

What I’d Do With This List

To get from “huh, interesting” to an actual deal, I’d do six things:

  1. Run the specific address you’re interested in, then check it against real comps nearby.
  2. Find out what’s driving demand, and when that factor goes away. A data center build ends. A theme park usually doesn’t.
  3. Read the rules before you read the listings. I’m talking about permits, caps, lotteries, operator requirements, and local taxes. (Hi, New Orleans.)
  4. Plug in your own expenses and financing. Insurance and property taxes vary widely by state, and if you’re not paying cash, add in the loan and see what’s left.
  5. Zoom in on the submarket. Harrisburg/Hershey’s 14.5% cash-on-cash return is three full points better than anything else on the list, and when one number laps the field like that, I want to know why. A submarket that pairs a state capital with a theme-park town can average cheap houses from one with bookings from the other. Same idea in Wright City, Missouri, whose school district serves Innsbrook, a private, gated resort community.
  6. Watch for one-time years. These are trailing-12-month numbers, and Philadelphia hosted World Cup matches this summer. Don’t underwrite a second World Cup.

One Last Thing

I love a list: best barbecue in Texas, best cash-on-cash markets in America—I’ll read all of it. But a list doesn’t know your loan or your city’s rules. Check both before you make an offer.

If a market here caught your eye, start by running the address through AirDNA’s Rentalizer. Then match with an investor-friendly agent there through the BiggerPockets Agent Finder, and find a lender who specializes in investment properties through the BiggerPockets Lender Finder.