When you read section 1031 it is very clear that personal property is not included in this type of exchange. Homeowners that qualify though can take the section 121 exchange.
There are circumstances though that a 1031 exchange can be done on a personal residence. I want to put this out here to increase fellow investors awareness of some of the exceptions.
Any thoughts of when or if a 1031 exchange could be done on a personal residence.
G'morning all ... in response to the posts relating to when a personal residence could be used in a 1031 exchange, I thought I'd pitch in with some additional information. It's important to remember that for 1031 applicability, the property must be used "in a trade or business, or for investment" at the time of closing. Section 121 (principal residence rule) does not require this - it's a 2 out of 5 rule.
The IRS gave guidance on Revenue Procedure 2005-14 on how to report exchanges of property used as a principal residence and for business/investment use in the last five years. A property owner can convert a principal residence to a rental property and later sell it and benefit from both IRC §121 (principal residence tax exclusion rules) and IRC §1031 (investment property tax deferred exchange rules). Property owners must comply with all the rules in both sections to qualify.
APPLICATION OF SECTIONS 121 AND 1031
If a property owner has owned and lived in a principal residence for at least 2 out of the last 5 years preceding the sale of the principal residence, $250,000 if filing as a single ($500,000 on a joint return) of the gain from the sale, except for any depreciation taken on the property since May 6, 1997, can be excluded. IRC §121 does not require the owner to live in the property at the time of the closing to qualify for the gain exclusion. A principal residence does not qualify if it was purchased in a §1031 exchange within the previous five years.
In essence, the Treasury has declared that if an owner lives in the residence long enough to meet the principal residence requirements, they may then convert the house into a property “held for investment†which can qualify for a §1031 exchange. (Note: Although there is no defined “holding period†to be considered “held for investment,†many tax/legal advisors believe 1-2 years is sufficient barring any factors which contradict an investment intent.) The property owner can perform an IRC §1031 exchange and still be eligible for gain exclusion under IRC §121, even if it is presently being used as a rental.
When the owner sells the home as an investment property, they must still meet all the necessary requirements for a §1031 exchange. This includes hiring a Qualified Intermediary prior to closing on the relinquished property and adhering to all the time requirements of an exchange, such as identifying the replacement property within 45 calendar days from the sale date and purchasing all replacement properties within 180 days, or the owner’s tax filing date, whichever is earlier.
DEPRECIATION
The property owner can exclude gain up to $250,000 (filing as a single) or $500,000 (filing jointly) under IRC §121 except for any depreciation taken on the property after May 6, 1997. Realized gain is first excluded under IRC §121 and then is eligible for deferral under IRC §1031.
The revenue procedure provides six examples that include illustrations of the treatment of depreciation and boot in which both the benefit of §121 exclusion and §1031 deferral could be used. Please visit the “Tax Code/Legal References†section at [LINK REMOVED] to read the full text of Revenue Procedure 2005-14.
MOVING INTO PROPERTY ACQUIRED IN AN EXCHANGE
One of the posts also dealt with how long you would need to use the property acquired in an exchange as investment or as a rental. Again, while there is no written period stated in Section 1031, a fairly recent case will shed some light on the answer. In Goolsby v. Commission (April 1, 2010); T.C. Memo. 2010-64, the taxpayer moved into the new property after only two (2) months. The IRS ended up disallowing the Goolsby's exchange based on a number of points, but this case would be a good read for you. Here's a link: http://apiexchange.com/index_main.php?id=8&idz=239.
I hope this helps.
Cris Anderson, Esq.
Good one Charles, if I lived in the property 2 of the last five years, I believe I could do a 1031.
Buy it, live in it 2 years, then rent it for 3 and sell before my 5th anniversary. Does that count?
I thought that if you lived there 2 out of 5 last years then you do not pay capital gains up to $250k but if it becomes a rental or you lived only 1 of 5 years then you can do a 1031 because now it's not a primary residence and if you sell it you gotta pay cap gains thats why 1031 is ideal way to go. Am i missing something?
John
I'm not sure what the purpose would be for a 1031 exchange on your personal residence unless your capital gains exceed the homeowner's tax exemption limits of $250k for a single person and $500k for a married couple.
If not, forget deferring the taxes and simply avoid them.
I asked Bill Exeter about this last year and here's what I concluded: 1031 your rental property into a place you would like to live in yourself, but first rent it to a tenant for at least a year. After that, you can pretty much "change your mind" about renting it out and, after re-evaluating your personal situation, decide to live in the property yourself.
The key is to satisfy the "exchange into a like-kind" of property. About a year should make those looking happy.
A homeowner that rents out their home is going to have capital gains based on the time it was a rental property. If the homeowner lived in the home 2 out of the last 5 years they are eligible for the sec 121 exclusion.
If the property has been used as a rental in now is also eligible for a 1031 exchange. Any capital gains on the period the property was a rental would be then the basis for the 1031 exchange.
It is important to handle this correctly though.
Sounds like you need an appraisal when you convert from rental to primary home.
I do not claim any expertise in tax matters, I haven't done my taxes for a loooong time. Close, but no cigar, lol.
Basis doesn't change but it is necessary to look at how long the property was held as a primary residence vs used as a rental property.
Also a property might be used as both a rental property and a primary residence simultaneously. A duplex or a property that has a mother-in-law that is rented out.
If you use a portion of your home for business this portion could also have a 1031 exchange.
It is very important to discuss your particular circumstance though with a 1031 exchange facilitator.
G'morning all ... in response to the posts relating to when a personal residence could be used in a 1031 exchange, I thought I'd pitch in with some additional information. It's important to remember that for 1031 applicability, the property must be used "in a trade or business, or for investment" at the time of closing. Section 121 (principal residence rule) does not require this - it's a 2 out of 5 rule.
The IRS gave guidance on Revenue Procedure 2005-14 on how to report exchanges of property used as a principal residence and for business/investment use in the last five years. A property owner can convert a principal residence to a rental property and later sell it and benefit from both IRC §121 (principal residence tax exclusion rules) and IRC §1031 (investment property tax deferred exchange rules). Property owners must comply with all the rules in both sections to qualify.
APPLICATION OF SECTIONS 121 AND 1031
If a property owner has owned and lived in a principal residence for at least 2 out of the last 5 years preceding the sale of the principal residence, $250,000 if filing as a single ($500,000 on a joint return) of the gain from the sale, except for any depreciation taken on the property since May 6, 1997, can be excluded. IRC §121 does not require the owner to live in the property at the time of the closing to qualify for the gain exclusion. A principal residence does not qualify if it was purchased in a §1031 exchange within the previous five years.
In essence, the Treasury has declared that if an owner lives in the residence long enough to meet the principal residence requirements, they may then convert the house into a property “held for investment†which can qualify for a §1031 exchange. (Note: Although there is no defined “holding period†to be considered “held for investment,†many tax/legal advisors believe 1-2 years is sufficient barring any factors which contradict an investment intent.) The property owner can perform an IRC §1031 exchange and still be eligible for gain exclusion under IRC §121, even if it is presently being used as a rental.
When the owner sells the home as an investment property, they must still meet all the necessary requirements for a §1031 exchange. This includes hiring a Qualified Intermediary prior to closing on the relinquished property and adhering to all the time requirements of an exchange, such as identifying the replacement property within 45 calendar days from the sale date and purchasing all replacement properties within 180 days, or the owner’s tax filing date, whichever is earlier.
DEPRECIATION
The property owner can exclude gain up to $250,000 (filing as a single) or $500,000 (filing jointly) under IRC §121 except for any depreciation taken on the property after May 6, 1997. Realized gain is first excluded under IRC §121 and then is eligible for deferral under IRC §1031.
The revenue procedure provides six examples that include illustrations of the treatment of depreciation and boot in which both the benefit of §121 exclusion and §1031 deferral could be used. Please visit the “Tax Code/Legal References†section at [LINK REMOVED] to read the full text of Revenue Procedure 2005-14.
MOVING INTO PROPERTY ACQUIRED IN AN EXCHANGE
One of the posts also dealt with how long you would need to use the property acquired in an exchange as investment or as a rental. Again, while there is no written period stated in Section 1031, a fairly recent case will shed some light on the answer. In Goolsby v. Commission (April 1, 2010); T.C. Memo. 2010-64, the taxpayer moved into the new property after only two (2) months. The IRS ended up disallowing the Goolsby's exchange based on a number of points, but this case would be a good read for you. Here's a link: http://apiexchange.com/index_main.php?id=8&idz=239.
I hope this helps.
Cris Anderson, Esq.
Excellent points, Chris.
A section 1031 exchange is for business and investment property. There are several situations in which a personal residence can qualify.
1) It is converted to a rental property. If the timing is right it is also then possible to combine the sec 121 exclusion with the 1031 exchange.
2) Simultaneous use of your property both as a primary residence and as a business or rental activity.
In some situations it might make sense to do this kind of exchange. It is important to plan well ahead if you are thinking of this kind of exchange.
If the property has been used as a rental in now is also eligible for a 1031 exchange. Any capital gains on the period the property was a rental would be then the basis for the 1031 exchange.
It is important to handle this correctly though.
The problem here is that the property must be currently in use as a rental to meet the qualified use requirment to participate in a 1031 exchange. If the property would also be eligible for the 121 exclusion under the two of the prior five year rules, then any cash boot taken out of the exchange could be sheltered by the 121 exclusion.
If the property had been in service as a rental, then converted to a primary residence, and is being used as a primary residence or second home at the time of sale, then the portion of the sale profit attributed to periods of non-qualified (rental) use would be taxable and the capital gains tax can not be deferred through a 1031 exchange. Additionally, unrecaptured depreciation would also be taxed.
For mixed use property, where a portion of the property is used as a residence and a portion of the property is held for business or investment use, then upon a sale of the entire property, the sale can be bifurcated. That portion of the profit allocated to the residential use property is eligible for the 121 exclusion, whereas, that portion of the sale profit allocated to the busines/investment use property could become exchange proceeds to be reinvested in another business/investment property.
Legislation a couple of years ago allowed homeowners with mixed use property to treat all of the sale profit as profit on the sale of a primary residence, so in this instance bifurcating the sale to participate in a 1031 exchange could be unneccessary for most.
Just how I see it.
Very true Dave. The property must have a current history of being a rental property to qualify for the 1031exchange. I would say at least a year. This is a transaction that someone would want a good 1031 exchange facilitator to help with.
The beauty of any and all law is that it is open to interpretation. That is why we have the courts. It is their duty to explain the laws. When you read things written in the law, you not only have to ask, "What did they mean?", but you should also ask "What could it mean?"
"contradict an investment intent."
Aaron, I agree. Laws are subject to interpretation. Over time case law is developed which can clarify issues or make issues more muddy.
I would think the IRS would be less flexible. The 1031 exchange rules tell us that property used primarily for personal use, like a primary residence, does not qualify for like-kind exchange treatment.
This means to me that "current history" of rental use for your primary residence is not sufficient to meet the qualified use test for an exchange. The property must be in current service as investment or business use property to be qualified property for an exchange.
Just want to be clear.
I've done many 1031's, both for myself and as an re attny. It's been 6 yrs so I don't remember all the ins and outs. If I was selling a personal residence that qualified for the 250/500K exemption, that's a no-brainer - take your money tax free.
I have 1031'd out of a rental and into a future retirement home. I would agree with the necessity to lease the new place out for at least a year. A 1031 is no free lunch. The basis of the acquired property (ies) is lowered by the deferred gain. This is valuable to an investor because the tax is deferred and paid in future dollars. The issue now is the very low cap gains rate and the uncertainty of what this rate will be in the future.
It's critical to have a facilitator (I use my title company) to prepare the proper doc's, advise on the required dates, and make sure your hands never touch the proceeds of sale.
It's my understanding that you can designate up to 3 acquisition properties when selling one.
My understanding was if you had to sell early in an owner occupied situation, you could do it with a good reason and still get the tax break. Provided this was not a pattern. I am not a CPA, and have never sold a primary residence, so this is just my half cocked opinion from what I have heard in the sandbox! LOL!
Rob, there is no hard set rule about how long your home must have been a rental property. The key is not getting it disallowed which can have serious tax consequences.
It's my understanding that you can designate up to 3 acquisition properties when selling one.
This is the most common approach and usually the easiest to achieve. There are a couple of other approaches - the 200% rule and the 95% rule.
Under the 200% rule you can identify more than 3 properties. It is not necessary to purchase all of them but the aggregate can not exceed 200% of the market value of the property you want to exchange.
Under the 95% rule no limit is place on the number of properties identified or on the dollar amount of the properties identified. It is much harder to comply with because it is necessary to close on 95% of them.