Investor · San Diego, CA · Member since 2013 · 94 posts · 32 votes
How does one figure out what is a fair fee to pay architects? I am seeing ADU architects all charging about the same amount, but not really designing anything new. ADUs designs are fairly basic. An Designer/Architect has a dozen or so designs in their catalog. They ask you to pick the one you want. They take that plot in on a site map and charge roughly $12-16k per ADU. They run it through permitting etc. If you are doing multiple, they may charge around $7k/per adu for the same design.
Sure there is work involved, however, let's assume you pay the designer, $150/hour( at $16k, you would be at 106 hours). Plotting a design on a sitemap, and spending 4-8 hours with the client, for feedback, should be closer to $6k for an ADU.
@Bruce Woodruff: I would have probably charged at least 10k, but that is a rough guess. My practice was commercial and institutional architecture and I specifically avoided residential because the those clients typically had no clue how much it actually cost to produce a solid set of plans that gave contractors enough information to give solid bids.
How does one figure out what is a fair fee to pay architects? I am seeing ADU architects all charging about the same amount, but not really designing anything new. ADUs designs are fairly basic. An Designer/Architect has a dozen or so designs in their catalog. They ask you to pick the one you want. They take that plot in on a site map and charge roughly $12-16k per ADU. They run it through permitting etc. If you are doing multiple, they may charge around $7k/per adu for the same design.
Sure there is work involved, however, let's assume you pay the designer, $150/hour( at $16k, you would be at 106 hours). Plotting a design on a sitemap, and spending 4-8 hours with the client, for feedback, should be closer to $6k for an ADU.
Would like to hear what other folks are seeing?
$150 an hour would be a very low price to hire an architect at an hourly rate for.
Honestly , anyone would have the option to shop around . Civil Engineers , Architects , Plumbers , Electricians , Contractors , etc , charge what the market will bear . No one enters any of these fields to make an average income .
Search long enough and you will find the cheapest , and you will find the reason why they are the cheapest .
Yeah plotting it on a map. Are you talking full plans or just a site plan as they need to review elevations, put the adu at right entrance so the doors match entrance, they need to put plans together that meet code, coordinate with the civil, structural and MEP engineers.
This is not just a “slap some lines on a drawing”.
If you take the 5 engineers plus architect each will spend 8+ hours easy on a project so there is 40 hours and that is just to get preliminary / schematic design. Then another 8 for DD and 8 for CD’s.
Also remember there is really no difference for a ADU as there is a normal home, still needs roof foundation etc. Meaning it's not a 2000sf home is 4x a 500sf adu. Difference in price is probably only 25% more.
plus you are neglecting to take into account their overhead and profit. And other business costs. Plus the risk factor. If anything goes wrong with the job that can be made to look like it's due to the plans, they are on the hook.
if their actual cost to produce a set of plans is $5000, they should charge you about $15k IMO.
Or you can try drawing them... I've done that several times in a crunch for very simple plans. It's no fun and takes a lot of smarts and talent....
Your project may have special needs, and you may need an architect. I drew up my very basic adu plan (size, location, layout) then hired a drafter familiar with house construction to do the rest. $55/hr. I had a complete set of Adu plans accepted by building dept for under $1500 total. It would have been cheaper had I not made alterations.
I am a retired architect and current REI investor in Orange County and did an adu at my property in San Clemente recently. Here are the fees I paid:
Architect (me) : $0
Civil Lot line and topographic survey: $6700
Soils Report: $3700
Structural Engineer: $4000
T24 Energy calcs: $500
Plumbing And Electrical design: $1600
Total =$16,500 (engineers only)
These fees are only to get through permitting, as the city required certain field reports from the engineers that was billed to me hourly. Also, mine was a 2nd story ADU so a bit more complicated. You mentioned "architect fees" and not all the others that are frequently required so I am not sure what your quote includes. If it includes all engineers required for permitting, then I would say the fees are pretty reasonable, even if they are plans out of the drawer. You could run one out of the drawer set of plans through 10 different jursdictions and get 10 different sets of plan corrections and each site is different, with each jurisdiction having different site plan requirements. To get plans through my city I ended up with 40 pages of plans including engineers. If you know what you are doing you could save a few bucks and hire a drafter but that is a much more hands on approach. You will find that most cities in OC have pretty extensive plan requirements compared to other areas of the country.
How does one figure out what is a fair fee to pay architects? I am seeing ADU architects all charging about the same amount, but not really designing anything new. ADUs designs are fairly basic. An Designer/Architect has a dozen or so designs in their catalog. They ask you to pick the one you want. They take that plot in on a site map and charge roughly $12-16k per ADU. They run it through permitting etc. If you are doing multiple, they may charge around $7k/per adu for the same design.
Sure there is work involved, however, let's assume you pay the designer, $150/hour( at $16k, you would be at 106 hours). Plotting a design on a sitemap, and spending 4-8 hours with the client, for feedback, should be closer to $6k for an ADU.
Would like to hear what other folks are seeing?
I fail to see how you're going to know the complete picture of a companies business structure, maybe they'll show you their books? IDK
If you don't like their prices shop around, you might find cheaper companies.
I am a retired architect and current REI investor in Orange County and did an adu at my property in San Clemente recently. Here are the fees I paid:
Architect (me) : $0
Civil Lot line and topographic survey: $6700
Soils Report: $3700
Structural Engineer: $4000
T24 Energy calcs: $500
Plumbing And Electrical design: $1600
Total =$16,500 (engineers only)
These fees are only to get through permitting, as the city required certain field reports from the engineers that was billed to me hourly. Also, mine was a 2nd story ADU so a bit more complicated. You mentioned "architect fees" and not all the others that are frequently required so I am not sure what your quote includes. If it includes all engineers required for permitting, then I would say the fees are pretty reasonable, even if they are plans out of the drawer. You could run one out of the drawer set of plans through 10 different jursdictions and get 10 different sets of plan corrections and each site is different, with each jurisdiction having different site plan requirements. To get plans through my city I ended up with 40 pages of plans including engineers. If you know what you are doing you could save a few bucks and hire a drafter but that is a much more hands on approach. You will find that most cities in OC have pretty extensive plan requirements compared to other areas of the country.
Bob - how much would you have charged to draw those plans for someone? Just curious.....
How does one figure out what is a fair fee to pay architects? I am seeing ADU architects all charging about the same amount, but not really designing anything new. ADUs designs are fairly basic. An Designer/Architect has a dozen or so designs in their catalog. They ask you to pick the one you want. They take that plot in on a site map and charge roughly $12-16k per ADU. They run it through permitting etc. If you are doing multiple, they may charge around $7k/per adu for the same design.
Sure there is work involved, however, let's assume you pay the designer, $150/hour( at $16k, you would be at 106 hours). Plotting a design on a sitemap, and spending 4-8 hours with the client, for feedback, should be closer to $6k for an ADU.
Would like to hear what other folks are seeing?
No offense but you're speaking shows an ignorance to the process. The biggest factor others have alluded to is RISK. Do you question an Attorney's hourly rate or a Doctor's? Then why for Architects & Engineers? A lot of people see something a few times and want to be like "Oh I can do that!" or "That's not difficult, you shouldn't charge so much." You get what you pay for. Get a drafter and see how it differs from a design professional as @Matthew Paul said. And @Bruce Woodruff is correct in that we have to cover our expenses. We take the liability so you don't.
-Jared W. Smith, RA - Principal Architect at Architect Owl PLLC (Licensed in NY & CT)
Is this for the whole set, architectural, structural and title 24. The basic construction drawings and not the specific structural plan. If you are talking about about the whole program, 4-5k is what it should be on the low side. Average should be about 7-9k. A name plate architectural set can run you up to 12k.
Is this for the whole set, architectural, structural and title 24. The basic construction drawings and not the specific structural plan. If you are talking about about the whole program, 4-5k is what it should be on the low side. Average should be about 7-9k. A name plate architectural set can run you up to 12k.
Based on my (somewhat lengthy) experience, those numbers are waaay low for SoCal. I did high-end remodels and builds, and the plan set could easily be $30,000...
How does one figure out what is a fair fee to pay architects? I am seeing ADU architects all charging about the same amount, but not really designing anything new. ADUs designs are fairly basic. An Designer/Architect has a dozen or so designs in their catalog. They ask you to pick the one you want. They take that plot in on a site map and charge roughly $12-16k per ADU. They run it through permitting etc. If you are doing multiple, they may charge around $7k/per adu for the same design.
Sure there is work involved, however, let's assume you pay the designer, $150/hour( at $16k, you would be at 106 hours). Plotting a design on a sitemap, and spending 4-8 hours with the client, for feedback, should be closer to $6k for an ADU.
Would like to hear what other folks are seeing?
No offense but you're speaking shows an ignorance to the process. The biggest factor others have alluded to is RISK. Do you question an Attorney's hourly rate or a Doctor's? Then why for Architects & Engineers? A lot of people see something a few times and want to be like "Oh I can do that!" or "That's not difficult, you shouldn't charge so much." You get what you pay for. Get a drafter and see how it differs from a design professional as @Matthew Paul said. And @Bruce Woodruff is correct in that we have to cover our expenses. We take the liability so you don't.
-Jared W. Smith, RA - Principal Architect at Architect Owl PLLC (Licensed in NY & CT)
Jared is so right...this is from my builders point of view: What if Jared draws up a nice set of plans for a beautiful house and I build it perfectly just as he designed it. But he innocently left out the proper details for something minor...we get to rough inspection and the inspector catches this totally meaningless oooops.
Guess who it all comes back on...? Yep, Jared. Architects have an insane amount of liability...think about it....
As far as using a draftsperson...every time I worked off a plan-set from a draftsperson, there were problems...every. single. time. There is a reason that Architects have all that training and licenses and cost more....
@Bruce Woodruff: I would have probably charged at least 10k, but that is a rough guess. My practice was commercial and institutional architecture and I specifically avoided residential because the those clients typically had no clue how much it actually cost to produce a solid set of plans that gave contractors enough information to give solid bids.
I specifically avoided residential because the those clients typically had no clue how much it actually cost to produce a solid set of plans that gave contractors enough information to give solid bids.
And there it is. One of the main reasons that jobs end up having issues is because no one told that Contractor about _______ and it gets missed in the original bid. OF course it gets blamed on the Contr, but usually it's because the customer went for a Draftsperson or cheap architect....