I need a new roof on my latest flip, NEW GC said he wants the full $6100 down because its not my primary residence. He won't sign the invoice until its paid in full (and I live across the state). I called one reference and he seems to check out.
Stetchy?
DO NOT MAKE THAT PAYMENT!!!!!!!!!
It is illegal in MA for a contractor to require more then 1/3 of the cost of the job upfront unless there are custom materials that total more than 1/3, then they can charge the amount of the custom materials.
Check out line #6 ...
The following fourteen items must be included in any contract between a homeowner and a registered home improvement contractor for home improvement work. Homeowners and contractors with questions about required contract terms or the Home Improvement Contractor program, should contact the Office.
I'd agree with most of the sentiments here. It's definitely fair to pay for materials up front, because that will probably be an up front cost to his company as well, but I'd suggest withholding a fair amount of the payment until the job is done.
Anytime any sort of contractor and owner set up a contract each side has leverage on the other to make sure the other side fulfills the contract on their end. The owner's leverage is PAYMENT, and the contractors form of leverage is a lien on the property. If you pay him up front, you now have literally no leverage to ensure he gets the job done well and in a timely manner.
I 100% agree with everyone else here. In fact, I have a story about a GC in Michigan (Bay City) that will illustrate.
I paid a GC 60% for a new roof for the house and garage of a flip that I bought. He came highly recommended, was licensed, everything checked out on him. He promptly did the garage, and then kept delaying on the house. For 2 months he kept saying he would be starting it on Monday. Monday never got here. I was constantly texting him and calling him, trying to get status, progress, etc. Most of the time he would not respond at all. Then every once in a while he would reply about some problem he had, he apologized and said they would start on Monday.
When I asked for my money back, he then told me that he had bought all the shingles, so he couldn't refund all my monies. So I told him to just deliver the shingles, we would deduct that from what he owed, and I would find someone else to finish the job. Of course that didn't happen, because he didn't have the shingles. I knew that, was just trying to call his bluff. The amount owed is about $2800.
I filed a report with the police department. They did a investigation and turned it all over to the prosecutor's office. I just found out that the prosecutor's office is not going to pursue because they don't feel it's a criminal matter. So I have to file a civil suit against him.
I've also filed a complaint against him with the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs (LARA). That investigation is still underway, but I really doubt anything will happen there. However, when LARA reached out to him to let him know that he was being investigated, he sent me $600. LOL.
So the short of it, be very careful.
Who was it? This house is in Bay City MI
@Tanya H. that is a disturbing story. To hear that all the people you rely on to help protect you don't really get anything back from the person who took your money. Personally I would be at his house when he got home demanding my money or he start the job.
@Drew Denham - It's Harmon & Sons out of Caro - Jeff Harmon. And yes, the house is in Bay City.
@Brian Pulaski - Yes, I keep hoping that LARA will continue to push this - we'll see! It is super frustrating.