Real Estate Crash Will Be "Different This Time" . . . Right??

Real Estate Crash Will Be "Different This Time" . . . Right??

Investor · Scottsdale Austin Tuktoyaktuk · Member since 2021 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
A closer look at the 40 housing markets at risk of a 15% to 20% home price decline



Every quarter, Moody’s Analytics assesses whether local fundamentals, including local income levels, can support local home prices. At the latest reading, Moody’s Analytics finds 183 of the nation’s 413 largest regional housing markets are “overvalued” by more than 25%. In some of those overvalued markets, Zandi says, buyers and sellers can expect to watch home prices fall by 5% to 10% amid this housing correction.

However, in America’s most overvalued housing markets, Zandi predicts a 15% to 20% home price decline.



Earlier this month, published a list of the 40 regional housing markets most likely to see a 15% to 20% home price decline amid a recession. At the top of the list, Zandi says, are Boise; Colorado Springs; Las Vegas; Coeur d’Alene, Idaho; Tampa; Atlanta GA; Fort Collins, Colo.; Sherman, Texas; Jacksonville; and Idaho Falls, Idaho.

Renters in high-cost cities like Seattle WA and Boston MA simply couldn’t pass up the affordability of markets like Austin and Tampa. The ensuing pandemic housing boom saw markets like Austin and Tampa become overvalued by 61% and 45%, respectively.

In places like Austin TX, which was overvalued by just 7% in the first quarter of 2006, this feels very new. In other places, it looks eerily similar to 2006. Look no farther than Las Vegas NV and Phoenix AZ, which Moody’s Analytics rates as being overvalued by 53% and 54% in the first quarter of 2006. Now, Phoenix and Las Vegas are overvalued by 51% and 54%. That’s not something that real estate professionals in those cities—two of the hardest-hit in the 2008 housing bust—want to hear.

6Reply
79 views

Most Popular Reply

Realtor · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2018 · 64 posts · 47 votes
4y

Hi Mike.  As an investor, you're wise to be keeping an eye on home price forecasts. As a REALTOR and investor in Phoenix. I can tell you, prices are still increasing, and thanks to record low interest rates for the last few years, many people's payments are lower than they were previously. Rents are increasing, which will be challenging for folks. In these instances, I tell my investor clients to focus more on A and B neighborhoods.  These folks tend to have salary increases along with the cost of living. This is one way to manage your investment risk.

It's important to digest balanced data as when things change, the media tends to use eye catching headlines meant to strike fear in readers. Keep in mind the data shows that there are NO similarities between this market and 2007. At most, in Phoenix we are seeing cooling, with homes no longer selling in a few days, but instead a few weeks - which is perfectly normal.  30-45 days is a normal sales cycle. What we experienced in the last few years was not. We're simply seeing a return to normalcy.

Supply is low now not high like it was 2007. We don't anticipate this changing for a while as new home build are decades behind and in Phoenix in particular, we are still seeing strong inbound migration.

Credit quality is good, thanks to tightened lending standards.

Foreclosures are low now, vs high in 2007. 

Homes are more affordable than they were in 2007, thanks to record low rates.

I have reviewed a lot of data and believe the BOTTOM line is:

Homes are more affordable today than in 2007. 

We are in a cooling market, but are NOT headed for a crash. 

Although interest rates are on the rise, they are still not as high as they were in the 80s, 90s or 20s. 

If you hold your real estate for 10 years or more, historically you would have always made money.

See this reply in the discussion

68 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2022 · 15 posts · 9 votes
    4y

    Real estate will not crash .. however our dollar will crash 

  • Troy GandeeBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Charleston, SC · Member since 2013 · 794 posts · 454 votes
    4y
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Nick Robinson:

    @Russell Brazil
    What the CPI measures is owner equivalent rent which is a survey that they give homeowners that asks them what they think rent is if they were renting out their home. Obviously, most homeowners have no clue what market rent is so the fact that it makes up a big percentage of the CPI shows that inflation is severely understated. We will not even go over hedonic indexing, substitutions, etc. If they are understating inflation and the homes drop in real terms that means it dropped a lot more in real terms. I know everyone, including myself, can get caught up looking at stats and inferring information from them. Example everyone going crazy over foreclosure numbers going up big percentage wise, well you just went through a time when they were at 0 so even a small amount will look like big increases. The current administration talking about how many jobs have been created but we are still under the number of jobs we had before the pandemic, so you just are bringing jobs back online. I think that last I saw we were 400k-500k short of pre-pandemic numbers. Look at unemployment the government uses the U3 number of 3.6% but if you look at the U6 number, which is a more accurate look at unemployment, was at 7.1%.

    Let's be honest to you just like to me it does not matter what either of us use as our reasoning. If we find something that is cash flow positive and produces returns that are acceptable to us, we are buying. I am buying if it's going up, down, or sideways. As long as it is cash flow positive, and it hits my other criteria. In terms of buying a personal home to live in the reality is if you plan on living in a home for at least 5-10 years and you have a stable job and can afford the payment even if the market "crashes" you do not lose money on it till you sell. 
    @JD Martin I do not know if you were specifically talking to me about holding on to large sums of cash, but I assume it was based on the fact you responded after I posted. I said now is a good time to hold on to more cash, I do not think you should be 100% cash or should be selling your property to take advantage of a RE "crash". Holding on to more cash might mean instead of 5% of your portfolio you go to 10%. The market is predicting a recession, along with the FED models, and a lot of bad economic data. During recessions is the greatest transfers of wealth and when things are on sale. Not saying there will be a housing crash just talking about investing in general i.e., equities, commodities, etc. My thought is you should have cash to take advantage of some of those situations. I should qualify for me personally no matter what is going on I would be saving cash waiting to refinance a 14-unit I bought last year and adding money to it to try and buy a bigger building.


     Let's, for argument sake, there WILL 100% certainty be a significant recession that really starts hitting next quarter, what does that say for Real Estate pricing/value.    How about how a recession WILL with absolute certainty drive some Real Estate prices/values UP, not down?!     Yes, that's right I said recession driving R.E. prices UP. Two words "Affordable Housing".    Recession drive mass expansion in affordable housing, and with that surge into sec8 and the entire lower strata of housing rentals.    What happens with surge of demand? Pricing goes up, and supply tries to meet demand, which means MORE allocation of units for affordable housing/sec8, which will do what? Drive those prices up, will it not?

    Again, for the I don't know, feels like millionth time, R.E. pricing/values is not a static set line across asset classes. To use the singularity of "Real Estate" is no different then saying automobile and including everything from a civic too a Lamborghini. There is a vast ocean of different economics across the spectrum. 

    So in that, if a persons focus is in the sec8/affordable housing segment, and see any drop be it recession or crash coming, THIS is the best time to buy because prices are about to surge with supply going too 0. Follow? 

     @James Hamling Great point about affordable housing being a safe bet during these times. I agree with you. I've focused specifically on affordable housing for quite some time and they're usually very safe bets for collecting rents. Rents have been climbing significantly on my affordable doors, but I suspect they'll spike again if there is higher demand than supply. Sect 8 and other subsidy providers will have to increase vouchers to get secure doors for tenants if that space becomes more competitive.

  • Member since 2020 · 19 posts · 13 votes
    4y

    Can someone define what does "crash" mean and what does "cool down" mean? When you refer to "cool down" do you still expect prices to increase but not as much? The market in many areas appears to have 4-6 months of inventory, so prices reductions have to be apparent. Whether we get back to 2021 prices, and if so, how soon remains to be seen.

  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 16k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Henry:

    Can someone define what does "crash" mean and what does "cool down" mean? When you refer to "cool down" do you still expect prices to increase but not as much? The market in many areas appears to have 4-6 months of inventory, so prices reductions have to be apparent. Whether we get back to 2021 prices, and if so, how soon remains to be seen.


    What areas have 4-6 months of inventory? I don't remember seeing a report of *anywhere* that had that level of inventory using historical sales data. 1-2 months at most is what I'm seeing, unless I've missed a report somewhere. 
    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    4y

    some more observations :

    - we hit the record low level of unemployment, less than 1% even, with (almost) nobody layoffs in retail industry
    - we hit a new record low of home delinquency, and there's almost no forced selling
    - San Francisco bay area market has a flat/up appreciation from May's data. It's obviously still much higher than Jan 2021. This market is very important as usually very sensitive to appreciation/depreciation.

    Also, there are more intermediate data that show that we may not even recession at all. Oil prices already went below a hundred bucks. GS HYI performs well recently.

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Joseph Henry:

    Can someone define what does "crash" mean and what does "cool down" mean? When you refer to "cool down" do you still expect prices to increase but not as much? The market in many areas appears to have 4-6 months of inventory, so prices reductions have to be apparent. Whether we get back to 2021 prices, and if so, how soon remains to be seen.


     See that's the problem Joseph, "crash" in Real Estate is not a set universally defined parameter, and I believe that is why so many "media-4-profit" persons are throwing it around like confetti; because it get's views and is not easily noticed as false.    I have seen some using terms like "crash" and mark a 15% price drop as that, lol, which is childish at best. 

    I would stand with standard investment area of what a "crash" is defined as and that's generally a 30% or more drop in a short time period and not reflective of a industry action but that of a economic wide action.     For example, let's say Canada hit's the Power-Ball and decides "mehh, tariff's are dumb" and removes ALL lumber tariff's on U.S. exports. And in response all Canadian produces quadruple output over-night (ok, I hope all can tell this is wayyy into fantasy land). Point is, housing cost could see a sizable drop from such Industry Action, that is not a "crash", that's a industry correction, or adjustment. 

    A "crash" is like '08' when mortgage finance all but completely stopped, in a matter of hours, across the economy, and finance as a whole came to a complete screeching halt, as the $ source for finance stopped, and EVERYTHING stopped. That, with a foundational pillar of the economic engine gone, that is a "crash". The drop in housing prices was just a result of the "crash". 

    The Great Depression was a RESULT, not a cause, the accepted cause was a run on the banks, which has been identified down to exactly what 1 single bank it all started at. And hence the FDIC came to life to prevent such potential again. So was the cause a run on the bank, or the actions that lead too the run on the banks?

    Similarly the entire catalyst for '08' no longer exists. '08' will not happen again, just like a run on the banks is not possible as it happened before. But could something else happen, could a flaw be found that spirals into a "crash", who knows. 

    Make sense?

  • Investor · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Joseph Henry:

    Can someone define what does "crash" mean and what does "cool down" mean? When you refer to "cool down" do you still expect prices to increase but not as much? The market in many areas appears to have 4-6 months of inventory, so prices reductions have to be apparent. Whether we get back to 2021 prices, and if so, how soon remains to be seen.


     See that's the problem Joseph, "crash" in Real Estate is not a set universally defined parameter, and I believe that is why so many "media-4-profit" persons are throwing it around like confetti; because it get's views and is not easily noticed as false.    I have seen some using terms like "crash" and mark a 15% price drop as that, lol, which is childish at best. 

    I would stand with standard investment area of what a "crash" is defined as and that's generally a 30% or more drop in a short time period and not reflective of a industry action but that of a economic wide action.     For example, let's say Canada hit's the Power-Ball and decides "mehh, tariff's are dumb" and removes ALL lumber tariff's on U.S. exports. And in response all Canadian produces quadruple output over-night (ok, I hope all can tell this is wayyy into fantasy land). Point is, housing cost could see a sizable drop from such Industry Action, that is not a "crash", that's a industry correction, or adjustment. 

    A "crash" is like '08' when mortgage finance all but completely stopped, in a matter of hours, across the economy, and finance as a whole came to a complete screeching halt, as the $ source for finance stopped, and EVERYTHING stopped. That, with a foundational pillar of the economic engine gone, that is a "crash". The drop in housing prices was just a result of the "crash". 

    The Great Depression was a RESULT, not a cause, the accepted cause was a run on the banks, which has been identified down to exactly what 1 single bank it all started at. And hence the FDIC came to life to prevent such potential again. So was the cause a run on the bank, or the actions that lead too the run on the banks?

    Similarly the entire catalyst for '08' no longer exists. '08' will not happen again, just like a run on the banks is not possible as it happened before. But could something else happen, could a flaw be found that spirals into a "crash", who knows. 

    Make sense?

    Agreed and great points   However even though there's been no Bank run, we are in similar scenario as 2008.  The MBS market has had several weeks of 'No bid'', so the Fed has had to jump back and buy these.  It's keeping the mortgage market on life support.  
  • Real Estate Broker · Portland, OR · Member since 2018 · 123 posts · 71 votes
    4y

    I'm with @JD Martin. No crash is coming. Inventory levels are SO severely anemic and we don't have enough new construction in the pipeline to meet demand. We will likely be dealing with housing shortages for years. So if we have a housing shortage, how exactly can we have a crash? Furthermore don't expect some massive wave of foreclosures. It's not going to happen. If an owner gets sideways on their payments they can sell it as they likely have enough equity gain over the last few years to get out from under it. All this media nonsense is Fake News. Garbage. 

    There continue to be good opportunities in every market. They may not be flying out and smacking you in the face - you might have to look a little harder but they are there. Go out and find them. Be a hunter, not a gatherer. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Chad U.:
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Joseph Henry:

    Can someone define what does "crash" mean and what does "cool down" mean? When you refer to "cool down" do you still expect prices to increase but not as much? The market in many areas appears to have 4-6 months of inventory, so prices reductions have to be apparent. Whether we get back to 2021 prices, and if so, how soon remains to be seen.


     See that's the problem Joseph, "crash" in Real Estate is not a set universally defined parameter, and I believe that is why so many "media-4-profit" persons are throwing it around like confetti; because it get's views and is not easily noticed as false.    I have seen some using terms like "crash" and mark a 15% price drop as that, lol, which is childish at best. 

    I would stand with standard investment area of what a "crash" is defined as and that's generally a 30% or more drop in a short time period and not reflective of a industry action but that of a economic wide action.     For example, let's say Canada hit's the Power-Ball and decides "mehh, tariff's are dumb" and removes ALL lumber tariff's on U.S. exports. And in response all Canadian produces quadruple output over-night (ok, I hope all can tell this is wayyy into fantasy land). Point is, housing cost could see a sizable drop from such Industry Action, that is not a "crash", that's a industry correction, or adjustment. 

    A "crash" is like '08' when mortgage finance all but completely stopped, in a matter of hours, across the economy, and finance as a whole came to a complete screeching halt, as the $ source for finance stopped, and EVERYTHING stopped. That, with a foundational pillar of the economic engine gone, that is a "crash". The drop in housing prices was just a result of the "crash". 

    The Great Depression was a RESULT, not a cause, the accepted cause was a run on the banks, which has been identified down to exactly what 1 single bank it all started at. And hence the FDIC came to life to prevent such potential again. So was the cause a run on the bank, or the actions that lead too the run on the banks?

    Similarly the entire catalyst for '08' no longer exists. '08' will not happen again, just like a run on the banks is not possible as it happened before. But could something else happen, could a flaw be found that spirals into a "crash", who knows. 

    Make sense?

    Agreed and great points   However even though there's been no Bank run, we are in similar scenario as 2008.  The MBS market has had several weeks of 'No bid'', so the Fed has had to jump back and buy these.  It's keeping the mortgage market on life support.  

     Well, on that note, let's just look at how many securities the Fed is the solo bid/buyer for, it's much more expansive then just MBS. And before all run to google and freak out, it's been happening for a considerable amount of time, the Fed as primary buyer for the securities, which include how the U.S. dollar and Gov. as a whole sustains life actually. 

    Fun item for those not in the know, we the U.S. Gov. which is we the people, we contract (ie pay) for the fed to issue (ie print) $ into existence. To do this we issue (ie sell) bonds/ securities, which the Fed is generally the primary buyer of such nowadays, not long ago China was among primary buyers. So we pay the Fed to create currency that we then pay the Fed a interest rate upon which they "bought" with payment from creating such $ into existence. It's genius really, you gotta appreciate the beauty with there getting real $ from theoretical $. 

    When Bernie Madoff got hit with biggest Ponzi scheme in human history he responded that he is nothing in contrast to the Fed and the Ponzi there pulling off, and that he was just following suite. And it is, by definition, a Ponzi, it really is. So in that, our U.S. dollar is really a Ponzi based currency, lol. 

    Ponzi-Fiat. Sounds like some really cool Italian speed boat doesn't it. Lol. 

    side note, the Fed is neither Federal nor a Reserve. It is a private bank in 4-profit operations, formed in the meeting of Jekyll island. If want to get lost down an interesting rabbit-hole do some googling there. Point is, not a part of government at all. 

  • Investor · Boca Raton, FL · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    @James Hamling well said.  And the Creature from Jekyll Island is one of my all time favorite books!

  • Suzanne PlayerPro Member
    Attorney · New York City / Long Island, NY · Member since 2020 · 597 posts · 248 votes
    4y

    @James Hamling
    You bring up a great point that things alter in response to each crisis. After the Great Depression we made changes like the Securities & Exchange Act of 1934 & the creation of the FDIC. So, bank runs shouldn't happen again and although people will try to do certain things with stocks (like market manipulation), we have regulations to use to shut it down.

    Likewise 2008’s housing crash shouldn’t happen the same way again any time soon, banks seem to have gotten stricter with their requirements.

    This is what makes it so hard to make predictions - any future crash/correction will happen differently.  But certain fundamentals should apply regardless.  For example, inventory gets too high, when the average homeowner gets too deep in debt, etc., it’s always a bad sign.  We don’t seem to have that right now.. A lot of people paid down credit card debt while in quarantine & there’s a lot of equity in the market.

    @Kelly Asmus

    Be a hunter not a gatherer - well said.  Reminds me of the Francis Bacon quote:

    “A wise man will make more opportunities than he finds.” (Now, off to Google bc I probably should know who exactly was this dude…)

  • Real Estate Broker · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Suzanne Player:

    @James Hamling
    You bring up a great point that things alter in response to each crisis. After the Great Depression we made changes like the Securities & Exchange Act of 1934 & the creation of the FDIC. So, bank runs shouldn't happen again and although people will try to do certain things with stocks (like market manipulation), we have regulations to use to shut it down.

    Likewise 2008’s housing crash shouldn’t happen the same way again any time soon, banks seem to have gotten stricter with their requirements.

    This is what makes it so hard to make predictions - any future crash/correction will happen differently.  But certain fundamentals should apply regardless.  For example, inventory gets too high, when the average homeowner gets too deep in debt, etc., it’s always a bad sign.  We don’t seem to have that right now.. A lot of people paid down credit card debt while in quarantine & there’s a lot of equity in the market.

    @Kelly Asmus

    Be a hunter not a gatherer - well said.  Reminds me of the Francis Bacon quote:

    “A wise man will make more opportunities than he finds.” (Now, off to Google bc I probably should know who exactly was this dude…)


     Stocks and the NYSE I would say is the greatest corruption and manipulation action in human history, without doubt. HFT (high frequency trading) which is now being ran by ai accounts for the vast majority of trades now. Not to mention the main HFT operation is, I kid you not, 35 feet from the NYSE trading floor, it is in the same building down the hall from it. Reason being it can intercept transaction orders in play and pre-empt those with it's own trades to then complete buy/sell orders in conjunction with to affect a net profit position. Time is measured in nano-seconds for trades now and profit per share in fractions of cents, but multiply that by millions of shares repeated hundreds of thousands of times, we are talking a lot of money. Not to mention things like recent "flash-crash" which was said a "hiccup" in ai programing lead to HFT tanking the market a few hundred points in a day. If that isn't manipulation I don't know what is. 

    Yes, I am an active WS investor. 

    As for '08', it will never happen again, Dodd-Frank Act saw to that. 

    Liquidity in the system has nothing to do with consumer spending or consumer finance. Actually consumer debt is at record highs, currently sitting around $92,727 per person as median, $15.84 Trillion as a whole. This is why there has long been talk of the next collapse being "The Debt Bubble" which speaks to the collapse of consumer financing and ripple effects across finance. I don't see that happening as a source action, as a ancillary amplifier effect from a different catalyst like say a Dollar Default, yes, but not standalone action, too easy to keep kicking that can. 

    According to NAHB it's estimated that if new home unit production is allowed to continue without impact to current production levels or growth rate, they will achieve parity (supply meeting demand) in the next 10 years. That's how net short we are, not just in units but in production. One must remember there is an even more significant shortage of skilled labor, we call it "the lost decade" or "lost generation" because there was near to no new entries into the trades for that entire time and now today, still a trickle. So it's all got to start with production, without that capacity supply will remain constrained. 

    All really serious about REI should know there local NAHB group, check in with it, go to the meetings. Every year the NAHB economist's come out to the various markets to meet face-2-face and discuss the #'s. It's mind blowing how few go. Last one I went to in Minneapolis the head economist for NAHB was there to talk, and maybe 40/50 people were in the room to listen, that's it. This is "THE" guy and only 40/50 came to ask what's going on and where things are going for future.

  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @James Hamling:
    Quote from @Suzanne Player:

    @James Hamling
    You bring up a great point that things alter in response to each crisis. After the Great Depression we made changes like the Securities & Exchange Act of 1934 & the creation of the FDIC. So, bank runs shouldn't happen again and although people will try to do certain things with stocks (like market manipulation), we have regulations to use to shut it down.

    Likewise 2008’s housing crash shouldn’t happen the same way again any time soon, banks seem to have gotten stricter with their requirements.

    This is what makes it so hard to make predictions - any future crash/correction will happen differently.  But certain fundamentals should apply regardless.  For example, inventory gets too high, when the average homeowner gets too deep in debt, etc., it’s always a bad sign.  We don’t seem to have that right now.. A lot of people paid down credit card debt while in quarantine & there’s a lot of equity in the market.

    @Kelly Asmus

    Be a hunter not a gatherer - well said.  Reminds me of the Francis Bacon quote:

    “A wise man will make more opportunities than he finds.” (Now, off to Google bc I probably should know who exactly was this dude…)


     Stocks and the NYSE I would say is the greatest corruption and manipulation action in human history, without doubt. HFT (high frequency trading) which is now being ran by ai accounts for the vast majority of trades now. Not to mention the main HFT operation is, I kid you not, 35 feet from the NYSE trading floor, it is in the same building down the hall from it. Reason being it can intercept transaction orders in play and pre-empt those with it's own trades to then complete buy/sell orders in conjunction with to affect a net profit position. Time is measured in nano-seconds for trades now and profit per share in fractions of cents, but multiply that by millions of shares repeated hundreds of thousands of times, we are talking a lot of money. Not to mention things like recent "flash-crash" which was said a "hiccup" in ai programing lead to HFT tanking the market a few hundred points in a day. If that isn't manipulation I don't know what is. 

    Yes, I am an active WS investor. 

    As for '08', it will never happen again, Dodd-Frank Act saw to that. 

    Liquidity in the system has nothing to do with consumer spending or consumer finance. Actually consumer debt is at record highs, currently sitting around $92,727 per person as median, $15.84 Trillion as a whole. This is why there has long been talk of the next collapse being "The Debt Bubble" which speaks to the collapse of consumer financing and ripple effects across finance. I don't see that happening as a source action, as a ancillary amplifier effect from a different catalyst like say a Dollar Default, yes, but not standalone action, too easy to keep kicking that can. 

    According to NAHB it's estimated that if new home unit production is allowed to continue without impact to current production levels or growth rate, they will achieve parity (supply meeting demand) in the next 10 years. That's how net short we are, not just in units but in production. One must remember there is an even more significant shortage of skilled labor, we call it "the lost decade" or "lost generation" because there was near to no new entries into the trades for that entire time and now today, still a trickle. So it's all got to start with production, without that capacity supply will remain constrained. 

    All really serious about REI should know there local NAHB group, check in with it, go to the meetings. Every year the NAHB economist's come out to the various markets to meet face-2-face and discuss the #'s. It's mind blowing how few go. Last one I went to in Minneapolis the head economist for NAHB was there to talk, and maybe 40/50 people were in the room to listen, that's it. This is "THE" guy and only 40/50 came to ask what's going on and where things are going for future.


     I am guilty of that our HBA is quite robust here in Northern Oregon..  And they do a good job lobbying for builders thats for sure. 

  • Investor · Member since 2021 · 591 posts · 695 votes
    4y

    @Account Closed I think that the metrics they use to determine which markets are "overvalued" are pretty blunt, and often miss the nuances of local markets.

    For instance, within a particular city that is rated as "overvalued", there can be neighborhoods that are highly prone to a market downturn, and neighborhoods that may not be affected at all by a market downturn. 

    In my city, there are natural barriers (rugged mountain ranges and public land) that prevent development in certain directions, and neighborhoods near those natural barriers where everyone wants to live (i.e.; very high demand, very low supply). These neighborhoods are the highest income areas in the city, and most properties are A grade. It's conceivable that these neighborhoods might not be affected at all in a downturn that does affect other (less desirable) neighborhoods within the city.

    In fact, I think that historical data shows that this occurred in the '08 downturn --generally speaking, a lot of the higher income A grade neighborhoods were minimally affected or not affected, while the lower income neighborhoods got hit hard (another example of the "Matthew Effect" where the rich get richer, and the poor get poorer).

    As they say, "real estate is local", and "location, location, location!"

    Good luck out there!

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Leo R.:

    l", and "location, location, location!"

    Good luck out there!
    >>>

    Sometimes is not even location , location , location. Today inventory in Vegas is up 22% YoY. Bay Area Inventory went down -22%.
    It's liquidity, liquidity, liquidity... lol :)


  • Member since 2020 · 19 posts · 13 votes
    4y

    Thoughts on this? Not sure if it lets me post youtube links.

    So much talk makes you wonder what is reliable.

  • Real Estate Agent · Jacksonville, FL · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y

    Not an economist, did not stay in a Holiday Inn last night.

    I do a have data point that is not published anywhere.  My civil engineer, he works out of Jacksonville, FL, has remained busy.  There has been no slow down in his work load.  He currently has 4 backlogged projects with over a 100 new single family homes.  This is significant since projects of that size take between 1-2 years to start building and continue to cost money with no immediate return.  Builders are still investing in projects that will kick off in 2023-2024.

    The word CRASH is tossed around.  I don't think that is the case.  Are we moving to a more normalized pattern, yes!.  Is that a decrease from the price growth and frenzy we have seen, YES!

    Collectively, we are at a disadvantage to know what is really happening.  We know after the fact.  The government wants to paint a rosy picture so elected officials win re-election.  Case in point, can someone identity anything that is up only 9% annualized?  Food? Fuel? Rent? Building Materials?  Those number are meaningless.  The media, just wants eye balls on their content, regardless of its validity or relevance. crisis and mayhem attracts a crowd.

  • Investor · Jacksonville, FL · Member since 2013 · 89 posts · 22 votes
    4y

    There is an opinion for everyone out there. The question has always been what is true and what is not. Of course, no one can predict exactly what is going to happen in the market, but numbers don't lie. I say keep investing. There is never a bad time for investors, only for speculators. Do your own research and modify your strategy depending on the market. Remember the most money is made during a recession/recovery/repositioning or whatever you call it. We have to ask ourselves if we are going to be a guppy who is easily fed and easily reproduces or a salmon that goes against the flow and ensure the survival of our descendants.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.