I will apologize for the overly-condescending nature of my response. I was hoping to illustrate how unpleasant being on the receiving end of such a heavy-hearted counter point can be, but it was not meant as an attack against you personally.
As for your claim that I was 'insulting the OP' and in essence insulting @Account Closed, I believe you misunderstood, or perhaps I did not do a good job explaining, what it is that I was saying.
I was stating that OP had actually used the term 'cash-flow neutral' correctly, and appeared to understand what it meant in the context of REI. As for how Bob ties into this, I can't seem to figure out your premise here.
No, cash flow is key. Do you have enough set aside for CapEx? Have you estimated maintenance accurately? Can you cover vacancies? Without any cash flow you have no room for anything to go wrong. And something will go wrong. Murphys Law.
Counting on appreciation is nothing but speculation. Ask those who lost their shorts in the recession. Even with 4-5% appreciation, the stock market would be a better place to invest your money. There are better deals out there. You just have to be patient and look harder.
I will not look at anything that will not cash flow for $150 unit or $200 for SFH.
I respect your diligence. However.........if you have 500K cash to invest in the stock market and could find a +5% return I hear you. But if you have No Capital, acquiring a 500k asset with creativity maybe the play, if it's your only play. Granted the expenses are factored in with an adequate cushion. I structured the question understanding the, "no cash flow-no deal" opinions will definitely prevail but does $150 a month cash flow limitation really cancel the deal in your opinion? Probably could get 100 more in a year or so anyways.
Hey Ryan,
I applaud you for your intuition here. To further your point that the cash-flow-or-bust way of thinking is misguided, at the very least; don't forget that the CF from operating activities is taxed just like all of your other income, whereas cash you pull out from a refi is not. When you look at after-tax CF the $150/month can really end up being closer to $90 ($1,080/year), depending on which tax bracket you find yourself in. So, what the CF guys are arguing here is that what makes or breaks a half-million dollar + investment deal essentially boils down to the cost of a new refrigerator.
I will apologize for the overly-condescending nature of my response. I was hoping to illustrate how unpleasant being on the receiving end of such a heavy-hearted counter point can be, but it was not meant as an attack against you personally.
As for your claim that I was 'insulting the OP' and in essence insulting @Account Closed, I believe you misunderstood, or perhaps I did not do a good job explaining, what it is that I was saying.
I was stating that OP had actually used the term 'cash-flow neutral' correctly, and appeared to understand what it meant in the context of REI. As for how Bob ties into this, I can't seem to figure out your premise here.
I was responding to where you wrote: "it's pretty silly (boy are there other words I could use here) to think that the OP would ask whether it makes sense to invest in property that is cash-flow neutral after accounting for cash from leveraging equity/selling the home] In essence, they'd be asking: "should I invest in something that effectively offers a return of $0 over the lifetime of my investment?" Personally, I'd like to think that anyone dumb enough to ask that question is too dumb to find their way onto this forum".
Psst. That's close to what the OP DID ask (GAMBLING on 5%/y appreciation)!
Borrow $500k, with zero return until he sells (or is FORCED to sell)!
And Bob B wrote: "I'll take all you got of those".
Hello! I am so sorry that it took me so long to get back with you but I just found out about this option. Trust me, I hope to get back to you much sooner next time. Please ask me about construction or real estate in general. Best wishes!