Do I need to make my 1st investment in my area?

Do I need to make my 1st investment in my area?

Shelbyville, IN · Member since 2016 · 47 posts · 24 votes

The reason I ask is because I was listening to one of the podcasts here, and one of the guests said though he was from Southern California, his first investment was in Texas. So, though Denver is hot right now, would it hurt to look in Tucson, Dallas, San Antonio, and of the like (whatever other cities are steaming right now). If there's one more way to put the question, should I stay landlocked in Colorado? I would hope not, because that would only be limiting my potential. I think I should go where the deals go. 

Secondly, this is separate from the original question, but do I really need a business plan? I listened to the podcast with Grant Cardone, and he said something that seems to make sense. "Use a business plan if you want comfort," and "Most of what happens will not be in your business plan." I'm pretty apt to taking that advice from someone who has a $350 million dollar RE empire. I'm gonna be taking notes on this.

1Reply
101 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
10y

@Derik S.

A lot of people invest out of their local area, because their local area is (or they perceive it to be) cost prohibitive for them to invest in.  I've seen quite a few people on BP from the Denver area looking to invest elsewhere, because housing costs in Denver are so high.  

Personally, I would say...if you can find deals locally that meet your investment criteria, it is probably best to start closer to home.  You have a better chance of knowing and understanding the market you're investing in.  When you are investing at a distance, you must have a team in place in that market that you can trust.  I believe having successfully invested at home would put you in a better position to know what you will need from a remote team.  

But, if you can't find deals nearby, then you will likely have to expand your search.  If buy & hold is your model, looking for a scorching hot market isn''t necessary and may not even be wise.  Dallas is incredibly hot, with near record low inventory levels for almost 3-years.  The result is that deals are hard to come by and property values are outpacing rents, which makes cash flow difficult in a lot of areas.

Figure out what your goals and criteria for an investment is first.  If what you're looking for is to maximize cash flow with little regard for any kind of appreciation (as long as the property is not declining) areas like Indianapolis, KC, the midwest in general, may be better options.  Just my 2 cents.

See this reply in the discussion

18 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y

    @Derik S.

    A lot of people invest out of their local area, because their local area is (or they perceive it to be) cost prohibitive for them to invest in.  I've seen quite a few people on BP from the Denver area looking to invest elsewhere, because housing costs in Denver are so high.  

    Personally, I would say...if you can find deals locally that meet your investment criteria, it is probably best to start closer to home.  You have a better chance of knowing and understanding the market you're investing in.  When you are investing at a distance, you must have a team in place in that market that you can trust.  I believe having successfully invested at home would put you in a better position to know what you will need from a remote team.  

    But, if you can't find deals nearby, then you will likely have to expand your search.  If buy & hold is your model, looking for a scorching hot market isn''t necessary and may not even be wise.  Dallas is incredibly hot, with near record low inventory levels for almost 3-years.  The result is that deals are hard to come by and property values are outpacing rents, which makes cash flow difficult in a lot of areas.

    Figure out what your goals and criteria for an investment is first.  If what you're looking for is to maximize cash flow with little regard for any kind of appreciation (as long as the property is not declining) areas like Indianapolis, KC, the midwest in general, may be better options.  Just my 2 cents.

  • Dan MackinBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Erie, CO · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 512 votes
    10y

    Going out of state comes with its own difficulties, but it can be done with some good prep. Biggest thing is how will you actually know the area you're investing in. If it's somewhere you travel to often then that can be acceptable. Otherwise you're likely just going on word of mouth which can be dangerous. 

    For business plans I would say they aren't for everyone. If you have any sort of plan in your head then that can sufficient dependent upon how your mind functions. They can be helpful for numbers, but otherwise I don't personally find them to useful. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Downers Grove, IL · Member since 2012 · 93 posts · 57 votes
    10y

    Derik, good luck with the start of your investing career.

    I thought Hattie's post was great!   I would highly highly recommend that you start within an "easy" drive of your home.  There are soooo many moving parts that makes up the machine that is a successful real estate investor...and with every part there is a chance that your machine breaks down.  So, in my opinion investing outside of an "easy" drive from your home is adding several more parts to your machine.  I believe to increase your chances of success you should have as few moving parts as possible.  

    I know that's not what you want to hear.

    Best of luck! 

  • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y

    @Derik S.  I neglected the question about the business plan...

    For us it was essential or at least we believe it to be.  Here's why...

    1.  A business plan isn't necessarily a road map.  It is not an itinerary.  Instead, it's a description of the destination and high-level plan on how you're going to get there.  (I like analogies.)  Think about it in terms of an around the world trip, to visit all 7 continents, that's going to take you the next 5-years to complete.  My trip plan is going to include things like the fact I'm starting from Dallas, TX.  I plan to drive from Dallas to New York, where I will fly to England.  I will take 6 months to drive across Europe, then take a boat to Africa and spend 10 months traveling through Africa and finish up in South Africa.  Etc.  The point for us is to have a written vision plan, so we stay true to our core purpose.

    2. Credibility. We will be looking to do syndication deals and bring on private investors. How can we possibly expect lenders, investors, JV partners, etc. to take us seriously, if we haven't even bothered to write down what it is we are doing and why? We can't, and they shouldn't.

    So...is a business plan necessary?  For us it is.

  • Investor · Denver, CO · Member since 2015 · 138 posts · 73 votes
    10y

    @Derik S.

    The question is how involved of an investor do you plan to be? Are you talking rentals for buy and holds or are you talking fix and flips? 

    I think rentals are definitely manageable from out of state, if you have someone local to manage it for you. 

     In terms of flips, I personally would not buy flips outside of a 30-45 minute radius from where I live because of how involved I am in my projects.  Unless you have a project manager or contractor you completely trust, I believe it's really hard to not be close by.  I stop by my flip project on a daily basis.  When you're less involved, costs always add up and when mistakes are made (and trust me there will be plenty) by your subs or contractors, it's best to catch them early on than wait until they are all the way done to have to tell them they did it wrong.  

  • Adam SmithPro Member
    Civil Engineer · Firestone, CO · Member since 2013 · 85 posts · 21 votes
    10y

    @Derik S.  I think it comes down to your goals which leads into the business plan question.  If you are the person who has some cash to invest and doesn't want to be involved in the day to day or month to month interaction with the tenants then investing out of state may work for you.  As others have said you have to have a team on the ground that you can trust.  This could involve some out of state travel to drive the areas, meet with people, etc.

    Personally, we don't have an official business plan (we only have one rental now) but we do have a few spreadsheets that line out our goals, rentals, etc.  This is just to have a general roadmap of where we would like to be in 10 years (ie-number of rentals, income, expenses, payoff, etc.)  We don't want to get caught up in the details of future properties.  We know our goals and minimum criteria for purchasing another rental and when we find one that meets our criteria then we buy it.  (This has only happened once but we are close to rental #2)

    I am not familiar with the Fort Collins market but it seems that you could find some areas within 1 hour that would have a cheaper price point if you wanted to be more involved in the rental.  We are in Firestone and while I don't know for sure but I am assuming that it is a cheaper market.  There are a few smaller towns not to far east of I25 that are cheaper but are "bedroom communities" to Fort Collins, Loveland, Longmont, etc. that are cheaper but current rents are high.  15-years ago I was told and I think it still holds true...if you want to find cheaper housing just go north and east of Denver.

    This is just my 2 cents.  Good Luck!  I am sure you will do well since you are asking the questions.

  • Investor · Long Beach, CA · Member since 2015 · 201 posts · 29 votes
    10y

    so far, I did all of my investments Out-of-States... because I didn't have choice! I needed to make as many deals as I can, and hire as many people as I can for my company and active income.... and California was way too expensive... Now, I even have access to 800-1200 houses every month, before and UNDER the Auction from REO Banks. Contact me if you want to have a access to that or my friend also have a team who have a FULL SERVICE Nationwide for Lease-Options buyers...

  • Real Estate Broker · pensacola, FL · Member since 2010 · 50 posts · 4 votes
    10y

    As mentioned before, yes I think the 1st couple should be near home due to the fact that you wanna be close to your project to oversee things and make sure deadlines are being met. Depends on how particular you are. 

  • Shelbyville, IN · Member since 2016 · 47 posts · 24 votes
    10y

    Thanks all for your replies, 

    To answer Dorothy's question, I'm looking o buy and hold, and deal primarily with multi-family homes, apartment complexes

    In terms of involvement, I want to build a multi-million dollar portfolio. I want to be on these properties like flies on sandpaper. Over the long term, I want to come as close to a real estate mogul as I can (who says anybody can't?). Gather the reputation that the tenants best interest, as long as their piggy banks are oinking, are kept in mind, with a fruit bowl as a welcome gift. 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Myrtle Beach, SC · Member since 2014 · 95 posts · 35 votes
    10y

    Great advice @Hattie Dizmond !  I think you should expand a little on syndication that you mentioned in the last comment.  Being on the investor side of syndication would be a great way to start for anyone who lives in a hot market and can't exactly pick up and move to start full time in RE, heck just reading an executive summery that was put together by a half way decent RE syndicator is excellent education in and of itself!  @Derik S. I would recommend reaching out to syndicators on the site and getting the convo going with them, most of them will basically give you a free education over the different conversations you will have with them and you will get to make a buck or two.  I also recommend getting in touch with some turn key operators.  I have personally never used them and wouldn't even know where you send you, but I have always liked the idea of turn key real estate for someone in your situation...  Anybody who has experience in this please feel free to weigh in...

    Good Luck! 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Myrtle Beach, SC · Member since 2014 · 95 posts · 35 votes
    10y

    @Adam Smith Great post as well, theres no reason to be afraid of an hour long drive.  Get some contacts that are there locally, find a deal, analyze and make sure the numbers work, buy it and put it under good property management.  Then all you have to do is make sure you check the place out every so often to ensure things are running smoothly.

  • Sterling WhitePro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2014 · 554 posts · 153 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Derik S.:

    The reason I ask is because I was listening to one of the podcasts here, and one of the guests said though he was from Southern California, his first investment was in Texas. So, though Denver is hot right now, would it hurt to look in Tucson, Dallas, San Antonio, and of the like (whatever other cities are steaming right now). If there's one more way to put the question, should I stay landlocked in Colorado? I would hope not, because that would only be limiting my potential. I think I should go where the deals go. 

    Secondly, this is separate from the original question, but do I really need a business plan? I listened to the podcast with Grant Cardone, and he said something that seems to make sense. "Use a business plan if you want comfort," and "Most of what happens will not be in your business plan." I'm pretty apt to taking that advice from someone who has a $350 million dollar RE empire. I'm gonna be taking notes on this.

    I would recommend for your first investment try and stay as close to home as you can. Then once you gain experience start venturing into other markets. Unless you have trusted boots on the ground in those outside markets. 

    It's great you are listening to Grant. He is a do-er. A business plan is good to have for guidance, but it is highly likely that it will change. Just have to take action

  • Lenexa, KS · Member since 2015 · 206 posts · 53 votes
    10y
    That's what I did and what I would recommend. Good luck finding the right deal!
  • Investor · Coppell, TX · Member since 2008 · 2k+ posts · 646 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Nadine Lajoie:

    so far, I did all of my investments Out-of-States... because I didn't have choice! I needed to make as many deals as I can, and hire as many people as I can for my company and active income.... and California was way too expensive... Now, I even have access to 800-1200 houses every month, before and UNDER the Auction from REO Banks. Contact me if you want to have a access to that or my friend also have a team who have a FULL SERVICE Nationwide for Lease-Options buyers...

    Hello and welcome to BP!  This might be a bad time because prices are high.  If I was looking out of state I would be considering a turnkey company with a good reputation.   Some town that you are within a two hour drive there ought to be something you could justify.  It has to be diverse and have a growing population.  Location is real important.  Know the neighborhood, the market, nearby amenities, and decent schools.  It all depends on whether you try to lease to families.  Schools may not matter.  I am 59 years old and I have been in the construction business since I was 17.  I have a college business degree with emphasis in real estate.  My Dad was in real estate for about 40 years and I learned a little from him.  I graduated college and I got a broker license in 1980 and did a few deals for other people.  If you think I could help you in any way please contact me at any time.  Good luck!

  • Equity Raiser and Turnkey Provider · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Derik S.:

    The reason I ask is because I was listening to one of the podcasts here, and one of the guests said though he was from Southern California, his first investment was in Texas. So, though Denver is hot right now, would it hurt to look in Tucson, Dallas, San Antonio, and of the like (whatever other cities are steaming right now). If there's one more way to put the question, should I stay landlocked in Colorado? I would hope not, because that would only be limiting my potential. I think I should go where the deals go. 

    Secondly, this is separate from the original question, but do I really need a business plan? I listened to the podcast with Grant Cardone, and he said something that seems to make sense. "Use a business plan if you want comfort," and "Most of what happens will not be in your business plan." I'm pretty apt to taking that advice from someone who has a $350 million dollar RE empire. I'm gonna be taking notes on this.

    Hello Derik,

    Congratulations on starting your path into REI! I can tell you from experience, you do not need to invest in the state you live in. Many people start off thinking that would be best, but as long as you have a great way to manage the property, you do not need to be there.

    We see tons of out of state investors who are interested in the Midwest market. Many people from Texas or California have been interested in investing in the Midwest for years now. If you find a market that looks viable for you, the go for it! Like you said, if you feel comfortable, then it is okay!

    Please let me know if you have any questions. Feel free to reach out to me personally. I can share with you experiences I have working with out of state investors.

  • Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2015 · 143 posts · 82 votes
    10y

    @Derik S.

    Hey Derick if you can find good cash flowing deals where you live then I just don't see the point of going out of state.   If that is not the case, then absolutely its okay.  

    It will be scarier and harder since it would be your first but that is how it is for everyone.

    I am about to start looking for my 5th rental property out of state and im excited about it.   Need to find me a good winner!

    Feel free to PM me if you want more details.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Crown Point, IN · Member since 2009 · 482 posts · 216 votes
    10y

    Derik,

    I have investors buying in my area that live all over the country. However, these are typically investors that have experience in the business and have already have purchased several properties. Investors come to us, because we rehab the homes for them and manage them as well, for buy and holds. So that allows them to purchase outside of their area.  But I would suggest you stay in your area for the first few deals, until you're comfortable and then branch out. Learn  "what's going on" with a property you buy. What I mean by that, is if they're rehabbing the home, watch what they do. Hang around a while. You'll learn quite a bit. Ask the rehabber for his scope of work. That shows you everything he'll be "fixing" or "changing". That will also help you when you look at properties that you might be interested in. It'll open your eyes when you walk into a house as to what needs to be updated or repaired. Experience is key!

    If you do go outside of your area, be careful. You can get burned. It's a matter of checking everything out.  My first time investors usually fly out here to Chicago, after the rehabs are completed. Once they're satisfied, they rarely come out a second time. We send pictures to show our progress, when rehabbing. So take it slowly and I wish you the best of luck!

  • Crystal SmithPro Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Derik S.:

     If there's one more way to put the question, should I stay landlocked in Colorado? 

    Secondly, this is separate from the original question, but do I really need a business plan? 

    If you're going to treat it as a business, then you need a business plan.  It can be as simple as your current Income Statement w/ a Balance Sheet followed by your future income statement & Balance Sheet.  The future financials essentially establishes the goals for your business from which you can then make decision on how to accomplish those goals.  Example:  Your original question on do you make an investment in your area or not?  If you can find deals that meet your financial goals in your backyard then stay in your backyard.  If not, then look elsewhere.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.