Real Estate Agent · Rutherford, NJ · Member since 2015 · 18 posts · 6 votes
My client had been in contract with a seller who had won an auction bid at a sheriff's sale.
Half-way through the AR period, he raised the price by 4K stating that due to holding costs with the sheriff, blah-blah .My client agreed and was scheduled to close. Seller then calls him and says there are tax liens that have come up on the property and he wants him to split the difference .My client does not want to proceed with the deal anymore and asked for a cancellation. Seller is not letting go stating the contract is in force. He is willing to give it without the cost of the tax liens . But my client is no longer interested . WHat are his options considering the following:
1) He has not signed the amended contract for the extra 4K seller wanted
2) I have the text messages from the seller stating that the deal is off since buyer is not willing to split tax liens
3) He has already put in an offer for another property
If you're just looking for an uneducated opinion from this particular BiggerPockets Forum Monkey...than I would say your client is in a position to enforce the original signed contract, since he never signed the new contract. However that having been said I do know that in some states a verbal commitment constitutes a contract whether its in writing or not. Hence the reason you need to check with an attorney, because unless the conversation was recorded or there is some sort of communication in writing which would indicate that your client agreed to some other form of contract.
I also imagine the fact that your client has put in an offer on another property would be irrelevant with regards to this specific contract dispute.
Again these are just my opinions and as I am not an attorney I would strongly encourage you (or your client) to get in contact with one if an agreement cannot be reached between the seller and your client.