Pay off car loan or buy first rental?

Pay off car loan or buy first rental?

Lockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 41 posts · 8 votes

So I have a car loan with about 4 years left. The interest rate is at 24%. I have been building my credit up and I'm around 700 now but when I tried for a refi i was denied. Should I pay off my car loan first before I pursue getting my first rental with a VA loan? It seems to mathematically make sense that I payoff the loan first because of the high interest rate but if someone has a strong argument for acquiring my first property then i'm all ears!

0Reply
364 views

Most Popular Reply

Guy with Great Hair · Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 4k+ votes
10y

Pay the difference between what it's worth, and what you owe. Then sell the car, buy a $1500 beater, the FLOURISH.

I drive such a beater that when I went to leave my last closing, where I paid cash for a house, my truck wouldn't start and I was out front of the law office with the hood popped trying to finagle the thing to start.

cars will always lose 100% of their value, pay as little as you can for one.

See this reply in the discussion

68 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 41 posts · 8 votes
    10y

    Yes, I'm interested in multifamily. I would rent out any other units and possibly the other rooms for the unit that I occupy.

  • Lockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 41 posts · 8 votes
    10y

    If I get rid of the car payment that would help tremendously. Also i know they can consider the rents as income which also helps. I'm very much not concerned about whether I can get refinanced for a car. Your comment is coming off as pretty negative regarding being denied for a refi and if I were to let that one issue stop me then I don't deserve to get involved in real estate. 

    Feel free to apply that negative thinking to your own life but keep it away from mine.

  • Investor · Gaithersburg, MD · Member since 2013 · 660 posts · 441 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Daniel Lehman:

    So I have a car loan with about 4 years left. The interest rate is at 24%. I have been building my credit up and I'm around 700 now but when I tried for a refi i was denied. Should I pay off my car loan first before I pursue getting my first rental with a VA loan? It seems to mathematically make sense that I payoff the loan first because of the high interest rate but if someone has a strong argument for acquiring my first property then i'm all ears!

    Holy Crap!  Go refinance that car loan.  One denial doesn't mean anything.  If you truly have a 700, you should be able to find someone to Refi.  I have a 3.1% interest rate on my car now (used car) and the most I ever paid (when I was young and had no credit) was 8%.  If you only have a few thousand left on your loan, pay it off.  If it's a significant chunk, refi, knock your payment down a ton, and go buy a house.  Based on your post (and I didn't read all the replies), I'm assuming it's a decent amount because your comparing it to the cost of buying a property.  If you pay off you car loan, I also assume that would delay you being able to buy a property (potentially for years).  So without having every detail, I'd say, refinance the car long to a decent rate and go get your first property.

    There are other options as well.  Get a new car (new to you) through a dealer (You'll get a good rate), py off that old loan.  Just make sure the new car is the same value as the one you have and that's a way to get around a refi problem as well.

  • Rental Property Investor · Ripon, WI - US · Member since 2015 · 70 posts · 16 votes
    10y

    @Daniel Lehman From what I have heard you don't usually get to use future rent that you should be getting from the property as income to help with qualifying for a mortgage. From what I've heard/understand you usually need 2 years of rental income before the bank will consider it as income.

  • Rental Property Investor · North Conway, NH · Member since 2016 · 69 posts · 16 votes
    10y
    I would say as long as your debt/income ratio would still allow for a mortgage, keep the cash and the loan and use it to put down on a house. Do you have a few credit cards? Having three helped my credit significantly. I'm assuming you meant to say 2.4% interest)
  • Lockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 41 posts · 8 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    I would say as long as your debt/income ratio would still allow for a mortgage, keep the cash and the loan and use it to put down on a house. Do you have a few credit cards? Having three helped my credit significantly. I'm assuming you meant to say 2.4% interest)

     I wish I meant to say 2.4% :( lol. It's not the end of the world. It's just a bad situation I need to get myself out of is all. I'm currently using 2 credit cards for everyday purchases.

  • Rental Property Investor · North Conway, NH · Member since 2016 · 69 posts · 16 votes
    10y
    Daniel Lehman Wow! I would say trade the car in for a lease. They have extremely cheap lease deals on civics and corollas.
  • Rental Property Investor · Ripon, WI - US · Member since 2015 · 70 posts · 16 votes
    10y

    @Account Closed Why would he want to get a lease? He would then be paying to use the car every month and would never own the car but must keep in near perfect condition(and paying near the same amount as a normal car payment).

  • Investor · Wendell, NC · Member since 2014 · 189 posts · 54 votes
    10y
    I would not lease a car with your 70 minute drive. That would almost certainly void the lease. Plus,in my opinion a lease is not the best solution to your problem.
  • Investor · Corpus Christi, TX-Texas · Member since 2015 · 81 posts · 56 votes
    10y

    Definitely sell the car no matter what it costs you and get out from under the payments.  Buy a cheap car with cash and be done with it.  24% is ridiculous!  I haven't had a car payment in years and have paid off all of my debts as of two months ago (outside of rental mortgage) and its UNREAL how much extra money you will have coming in when you get rid of unnecessary payments.  

    Oh, and by the way, I bought my first property 12 months ago while I still had student loan debt and while we were saving up for a wedding 4 months later so it was a TERRIBLE decision for me, but I dont regret it at all, ha!  I was so tired of reading and talking about investing instead of actually doing and I couldn't wait anymore.  Pull the trigger as soon as you can on a property!  You cant truly learn until you go through the process, no matter how much you read about it.  You will make it work. 

  • Rental Property Investor · North Conway, NH · Member since 2016 · 69 posts · 16 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Erik Johnson:

    @Account Closed Why would he want to get a lease? He would then be paying to use the car every month and would never own the car but must keep in near perfect condition(and paying near the same amount as a normal car payment).

     Because it would get him out from underneath that ridiculous interest rate. I know buying a junky car for under $3000 would be the last thing I would do if I was using it to commute to my job. 

  • New Haven, CT · Member since 2016 · 90 posts · 99 votes
    10y

    Sell your car immediately and get the heck out of that. 24% on a car loan?? did you buy it on a credit card at least to collect your 1% cash back?? Yikes.. Go buy a $1000 beater and the $300 you would have spent on a car everyday you can save for a decent car down the road. I was only making $44,000/yr when I got out of school with a relatively small student loan payment and I bought a 2 year old Infiniti coupe, no credit history at 4.49% with BOA. Not sure how a bank or someone can justify charging 24%, especially since they have your title and the car would be worth something if you default. Not to mention, a car that's worth 1 or 2k, will most likely not depreciate anymore, and you could maybe sell it higher.

    Either way, go take your loss right now and sell your car. You shouldn't pay 24% interest on anything, let alone a car payment.

    Good luck, 

    Matt 

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    10y

    Good decisions. Wasting money on a depreciating asset is ridicules at this stage of your investing plans.  

    Having expensive car loans, even having expensive cars is for fat cat rich investors. 

    I own a 2006 Dodge Caravan With now 450,000 K on it that I bought 7 years ago for $5000 and it has served me very well. I am now looking to buy a 2009 caravan as is for $1000. Reliable is the key, appearances are irrelevant. That is the kind of approach you should be taking when starting out. A vehicle is only transpiration designed to get you from A to B. Don't waste money, be frugal, save ever penny for investing.

  • Rental Property Investor · Ripon, WI - US · Member since 2015 · 70 posts · 16 votes
    10y

    @Account Closed If he were to lease a car he would still have a car payment but this one would be never ending. And he would probably have to pay some crazy fees at the end of the lease term because he puts on 3k miles a month so he would exceed the 12k-15k miles per year on the lease terms in 4-5months.

  • Lockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 41 posts · 8 votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Thomas S.:

    Good decisions. Wasting money on a depreciating asset is ridicules at this stage of your investing plans.  

    Having expensive car loans, even having expensive cars is for fat cat rich investors. 

    I own a 2006 Dodge Caravan With now 450,000 K on it that I bought 7 years ago for $5000 and it has served me very well. I am now looking to buy a 2009 caravan as is for $1000. Reliable is the key, appearances are irrelevant. That is the kind of approach you should be taking when starting out. A vehicle is only transpiration designed to get you from A to B. Don't waste money, be frugal, save ever penny for investing.

     I shouldn't have gotten the car at such a high % interest rate, but it's not like I went out and bought a Dodge Viper lol. I bought a 2009 Honda Civic. But yea, i need to get out from this bad decision.

  • Investor · Houston, TX · Member since 2014 · 35 posts · 13 votes
    10y

    Is it insured!? Just sayin... Maybe it rolls down a hill into a lake. 24%?? Who was the friend that gave you that loan!? Maybe they were in the trunk when the accident happened. Just sayin...

  • Specialist · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    10y
    How reliable is a $1000 beater these days, really? He drives 70 miles to work every day. All these suggestions of getting a car for $1000-2000 will either leave him with his car in the shop every other month or broken down on the highway.
  • JD MartinBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Rock Star Extraordinaire · Northeast, TN · Member since 2015 · 10k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    10y

    @Daniel Lehman

    I'm normally the guy saying "no car payments", so typically I would just be a voice in this choir.

    Whether you sell it really depends on what it takes to get out from under it and what you can replace it with. The cost of the car at this point is not what you paid for it but what it costs at this immediate point in time. Based on what you've put up you just bought a 2009 Civic for $8,900, and your financing costs push the cost of the vehicle to $14,000. So the question is not what your interest rate is now, it is the cost of financing the vehicle to the end versus selling the vehicle and obtaining another reliable vehicle. There is a point in time in most car payment purchases, especially fairly far in, that you've essentially reached the point of no return if you need to keep a reliable vehicle, i.e. you've absorbed the bulk costs of interest and are only swapping like for like, known for unknown. 

    Let's say the vehicle is worth $8,900 and you can find a buyer for that price. Your savings is $8,900, and you can probably find a good reliable vehicle for $5-6k that you would trust driving that much, maybe cheaper if you are enterprising or know how to fix cars. In that case, you would definitely want to sell, because even financing the $5-6k is going to save you $5-6 thousand. But let's say you can only find a buyer at $5,900. If you magically have $3k sitting around somewhere that you didn't use to lower your total payout on the current car, you'd have to use that money to make up the difference, and go find another vehicle. If we assume the same $5-6k for a reliable vehicle, financed, you are now saving only $2-3 thousand. If the Civic was new, or a known entity, or low miles, that becomes a riskier swap to another vehicle of unknown history. If you need even more money to get out from under the vehicle, you could actually be going the wrong way. On the other hand, if the car already has 200k miles on it, you might be getting out just in time. 

    In almost all cases with cars, the cheapest car you can own is the one you already own. People get in trouble with cars (aside from buying cars far too expensive in the first place) because they are constantly swapping depreciated assets for assets that will also be depreciating. If you bought a brand new car for $10k at the beginning of driving, and kept it forever, even pumping $1k/year into repairs (forget maintenance, that is every car), you would be so far ahead of the average person that gets bored with their vehicle and constantly swaps out - and I say this as a "car guy", who has owned more than 20 different vehicles in my life. I love cars, but buying different ones is a drag on my net worth. Cars happen to be my golf, or boating, or fine cigars or jet-set holiday, so I'm OK with it, but if the car is just your transportation, the cheapest thing you can do is settle on one and keep it forever. If you can do like Greg and get a 200k mile beater and keep it running forever, even better. 

    Skyline Properties
    View Page
  • Lockport, NY · Member since 2015 · 41 posts · 8 votes
    10y

    The car has 112,000 miles on it. At the rate I drive I put around 3,000 miles/month on it. The payoff amount is $8,900. I did the Kelly Blue Book value for it and trade-in value is around $4,800 and the private-sale amount is $6,200. I actually just listed the car on craigslist for $7,000/bo so if I could sell that for no less than $6,200 I could use that towards paying off the car and I have a credit card with a $3,000 limit that I could pay the rest.... Oh wow... just realizing that that won't work. That would be enough to pay off the car but then I won't have the money for a car around $2-3,000. UGH!

    Maybe I'll just keep trying to refi with other places but they're going to keep running my credit which is what I wanted to avoid.

  • Apollo Beach, FL · Member since 2016 · 11 posts · 2 votes
    10y

    Refinance the car with a credit union. If your scores are in the high 600s you should be able to get a 5-7% rate. Or sell it and pay cash for a beater that you have to pay tax, tag, and title for all over again. 

  • Penny ClarkPro Member
    Sacramento, CA · Member since 2014 · 513 posts · 319 votes
    10y

    Lots of wise advice here. I'd sell the car, buy a beater with cash (look for one with sound mechanics and is ugly - sometimes you can find these at garage and/or estate sales), and save your principle,interest,taxes and six months worth of reserves with the money you save. If you're using a VA loan, I'd look for a duplex, triplex or 4plex to invest in and reside in it for at least a year.

    And, from now on, put your money into appreciating assets. Anything that has a motor goes down in value. With time your credit score will improve; I would find also find out from your lender what requirements are to get approved underwriting. 

    Hope this helps!

  • !! · Member since 2015 · 17 posts · 1 vote
    10y

    I am with Michael McGinnis and a few others.  That car is a reliable model and will last....You DO need a reliable car to commute 70 minutes so be careful about buying a clunker.

    There are plenty of credit unions that will refi you at 6% or under if your credit score is really 700. Go out and get the refi, then you can start looking into investing.

    Jmo

  • Northborough, MA · Member since 2015 · 57 posts · 10 votes
    10y

    Is it really 24%?  I have never seen one that high.  Maybe it is 2.4%?  

    If it is 24%, payoff that car loan.  

    If it is 2.4%, look at your personal cash flow.  If you have a car payment, how much money could you put in your rental for repairs or payments?  If thats a large number, get a rental.  If that is not a large number, pay off the car first.  With that said, make sure you have some emergency funds for your personal health or job emergencies, or for your rental property emergencies.  I would hate to have a rental costing you money putting your car and life at risk.  

  • IA · Member since 2015 · 304 posts · 152 votes
    10y

    Looks like you need to clean up this car loan mess before you even think about investing. Good luck!

  • Investor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2014 · 65 posts · 29 votes
    10y

    Getting your first rental property may or may not be as exciting as sex for first time.. But please slow down,  being upside down on a 10,000 car is a real downer, being unprepared and unable to support a rental home of 75-100k can ruin your next 10 years or longer.    Please, Read a few books on rental property/ finance, money management.  

     I love: The wealthy barber,  Rich dad books and Dave Ramsey.  

    You have a huge support group here, lot of questions can be answred or ideas given.  

    Cheers and happy investing 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.