Sell Or Keep Renting Out Home In San Francisco 2017

Sell Or Keep Renting Out Home In San Francisco 2017

Sam DogenPro Member
San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes

Howdy Folks!

I'm new to the BP community and I'm excited to be here!  I'm a real estate fanatic. But now that I'm middle-aged (40), I'd like to simplify life. San Francisco has had a great rocket ship like run and I'm strongly thinking about de-risking since I have two SFHs and one paid of 2/2 condo in SF.

Situation:

* Single family home bought in the Marina for $1.52M in early 2005.

* Have a written offer for $2.732M. Hasn't released financing contingency yet, but said bank is set to close and fund by June 20. This gives me an OUT to cancel the deal if I find something better b/c I did not give him a financing contingency extension. I accepted their offer which removed their inspection contingency after inspection was given. 

* 4 years left on a 5/1 ARM at only 2.375%. I haggled the crap out of my bank to get this rate in 2016.

* Was renting the home for $9,000 a month. Now, after one month of searching, I haven't found anybody suitable to pay that price. The conclusion: rent has gone down, and I can likely only get $8,000 - $8,500 due to a large surge in new construction luxury condos. 

* The 1% rule or the 100X rule says that I should buy a $9,000/month rental property for $900,000 or less, or sell a $9,000/month property if under 1%. I'm at 303X monthly rent, or 0.33%, which seems absurdly expensive. But that's if I can get $9,000/month, which I can't.

* At $9,000/month, I cash flow after all expenses about $4,500 a month. If the mortgage is paid off, then the property will cash flow about $7,000/month because property taxes are $21,888 / year!

Why I'm Reluctant To Sell:

* Commissions. I got the level down to 4.5%. But that's still $123,000!

* Transfer Tax = ~$25,000

* LTGT = Six figures. Haven't figured it out exactly, but will have the $250K/$500K tax free gains.

* A property for my son to live in in 23 years. Can you imagine how expensive SF will be by then? Holy hell!

* Capital appreciate. I believe San Francisco is one of the cheapest international cities in the world. 

* Uber, Airbnb, Pinterest, Dropbox will all go public in the next 3-5 years, creating a tidal wave of billions of liquidity into the ecosystem looking to buy real estate.

I'd love to get everybody's thoughts!

Thanks,

Sam

2Reply
131 views

Investor-friendly agents in San Francisco, CA

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in San Francisco, CA.

Most Popular Reply

Clayton MobleyPro Member
Birmingham, AL · Member since 2014 · 875 posts · 947 votes
9y

@Sam Dogen I saw a few mentions of the 1031 and 121 issues and I wanted to offer some clarity here.

Firstly, let me say that I agree that your first move is to determine your priorities. You have an amazingly valuable property here that could continue cashflow easily with minimal contact from you if you hired a good PM (or had your son do it as a learning exercise). Assuming you want the simplest option, keeping it and letting it appreciate while getting, frankly, some amazing monthly income, is the obvious answer. If you're more focused on increasing monthly income or getting a higher ROI in other markets in exchange for a lower rate of appreciation, that is another option, though more complicated. So, the following advice is given under the assumption that you elect to sell in order to expand your cash flow portfolio:

So, as you know, you need to have lived in the property as your primary residence for at least 24 months our of the past five years. They do not need to be concurrent months, in case that makes a difference to you. If you meet this requirement, then you can take the $250k/$500k (if married filing jointly) tax free under Sec 121. So sounds like that option is already on the table for you, great!

However, it looks like you stand to take away MUCH more than that (congrats!). In addition to CG taxes, any amount of depreciation you could have deducted on your taxes (whether you actually took the deduction or not is irrelevant) is recaptured under Sec 1250 at 25%, so your tax bill on this sale would be.... hefty. So let's look at the best way to parlay your gains into something else without giving uncle sam his cut just yet. As @Arianne L. pointed out, you can combine the Sec 121 exclusion AND the 1031 exchange if you meet some criteria. 

You've already met the criteria for the 121, so now we focus on the 1031. In order for a property to eligible for exchange, you have to be holding it with the intention of maintaining a long-term investment. Since this was a home that you converted into a rental, with the possible intention of passing it along to your son, I think you safely meet that criteria. There is no specific time limit for how long you have to hold the property, though the general rule of thumb is one year or more. So, for example, if you purchased a house to flip and sold it six months later, that's not a 1031 eligible property because there was never the intention to hold it long-term. So I'd say as long as the prop has been rented for at least a year, but not MORE than three years (because then you wouldn't have lived in it for 2 years within the past five), then you can qualify for both the Sec 121 exclusion and a 1031 exchange. If you've rented it for more than three years, then you'd still qualify for the 1031, but you couldn't take the $500k tax free under Sec 121 unless you had to move due to employment changes or other IRS-acceptable reasons.

Ok so, to defer all taxation on a 1031 exchange, you have to roll over the total value of your property into a new investment proper, or multiple props. This means that if you sell at $2.75m and take $500k tax free, you must roll the remaining $2.25m into new investment props. Any amount of profit you take  (outside of the Sec 121 excluded amount) is considered boot and is taxable. That means you can't sell the prop, take $750k in cash ($500k under Sec 121 + $250k) and then replace that additional $250k with a bigger mortgage on the replacement prop. You can put in more equity to the new properties and have less debt, but you can't have more debt and less equity, because that would result in you taking cash from the sale, which would be a taxable event. (Let me know if that wasn't very clear, people often get very confused about this rule).

Since you'll have so much value to play with and are looking for cashflow investments, it's most likely you'll reinvest into multiple properties, or into a large MFR. 1031s have a lot of rules about replacement property identification and timing (which I'm happy to go into if you need a primer, but I'll leave for now) so you'll need to be well versed and have a good Qualified Intermediary in place long before you go to market if you elect to go this route.

Given the value of your currently property, you have a million options for reinvestment, so you'll need plenty of research and vetting time before you pull the trigger on selling it. Take your time and be really honest with yourself about your priorities. The property is flowing nicely and will likely continue to appreciate, so if maximizing ROI at any cost isn't your highest priority, all the legwork involved in the 1031 process may not be worth it to you right now. However, if you decide to go that way, know that the 1031 is a powerful tool. Using this process you can expand your portfolio, and continue to use the 1031 exchange if and when you want to sell your new investment props, leap frogging this current property into who knows how many cash flow properties over the next few decades, and eventually leave the whole lot to your son. Upon your passing, the tax basis of any properties left to your heirs gets 'stepped up' to the market value at the time of your death. Basically, if you die and leave a property to your son, and he sells it right away, he'll essentially pay no taxes because his tax basis will be equal to the market value at that time, leaving him zero taxable gain. It's called the '1031 until you die' strategy and it's hugely powerful when done right. Of course, I'm not getting into estate taxes and the use of trusts here, but given the value of this prop those considerations would need to be taken into account if you elected to use this strategy, just fyi.

Ok that's enough of a ramble from me ;) You're in an enviable position and you have several great options, so do your research and take your time.

Best of luck!

Clayton

See this reply in the discussion

46 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Brent Coombs - Great response. Thanks! Do you mind sharing where you are getting an 11% gross yield or where one should be investing? I have been investing in the Heartland recently via crowdfunding and plan to invest more.

    Great NBA finals btw. Go Warriors!

    Blue and Gold Towers :)

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen, my answer to your question is: Go Cavs!...

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y
    Los Angeles and Seattle were named the top US multifamily markets for 2017 in Marcus & Millichap’s National Multifamily Index (NMI), moving up 11 spots from one year earlier.

    The West Coast cities were two of several markets with favorable supply-and-demand balances and hiring momentum that made major moves to ascend to the top spots in M&M's multifamily investment forecast.

    Story Continues Below

    Los Angeles and Seattle moved to the top of Marcus & Millichap's National Multifamily Index for 2017.


    Los Angeles moved up 11 places in the firm's ranking from one year ago based on a forecast for further tightening in apartment vacancy and minimal supply growth. Meanwhile, prospects for continued robust job growth moved Seattle-Tacoma and Boston into the second and third spots.

    Minneapolis-St. Paul was the highest-ranked Midwest metro, while former hot tech markets San Francisco and San Jose dropped from the top of last year's ranking as their growth cycles mature. NYC's apartment market rounded out the top 10.

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Matt R. - Thanks. I need to diversify away from the coasts. I know we're in a hot zone now... but I'm literally all-in for all my physical real estate currently. Good chart!

    Minneapolis here I come! :)

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Sam Dogen:

    @Matt R. - Thanks. I need to diversify away from the coasts. I know we're in a hot zone now... but I'm literally all-in for all my physical real estate currently. Good chart!

    Minneapolis here I come! :)

     Never been and it might be equally as hot. Good luck!

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Amit M. -  thanks for your thoughts. In 10 years, I believe the house will be worth maybe $3.5 million. But in 10 years, I believe I will be able to generate more than $650,000 it takes to get to $3.5 million with other investments. 

    One of the key things I've noticed is that this area I want to buy in Oahu continues to be weak for the past three years.  I need this liquidity to buy the dream house in a couple years time.

    If i didn't have an online business that generates multiple times what my rental property portfolio generates, I probably would cut it out and keep the house.  But I'm lucky to experience this online income growth, which I find to be way superior of than  rental property income now. I realize not everyone has this opportunity so I'm very grateful.

    I will give you this quick example. It's taking me 12 years of ownership and of course a original $304000 down payment to be able to generate $4800 a month in positive cash flow.  It took me six months to replicate the same amount with my online business. The efficiency and scale of an online business is just unmatched. 

    I have little doubt San Francisco property prices will continue to go up. The engine here is just too amazing Lee strong. I just want to simplify life now because of family and more efficient ways to make money.

    What do you do for a living? That's awesome your five properties here in San Francisco. Property manager?

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen no, I just made good investments and basically live off the rental income, all in the city :). First purchase was a tic to condo conversion back in 1994 in Noe valley. Then with the equity build up I refinanced and reinvested actively starting in 2003. I brought value added properties, so I increased their value and income via expansions, adding a unit, condo conversion, legalizing inlaws, etc.  I also invested in gentrifying neighborhoods and benefited from their transformation. I'm basically done now, just a couple of final projects to get everything to highest and best use. 

    I agree that primarily relying on passive appreciation is a slower route, and if you want to buy in another area it may be worth it to sell. In my case I have so much equity in each bldg and they cash flow well, I might as well just refi if I want something else. Which is what we will probably do for a second home in Tel Aviv eventually. My ROE is 4.7% now and will be closer to 6.6% when I finish. I feel that is decent for a blue chip portfolio I want to hold on to long term, and one that has solid prospects for equity appreciation. 

    Curious what your take on that is. 

  • Professional · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 876 posts · 301 votes
    9y

    Hi @Sam Dogen, if you ever want to take your appreciation out of CA and defer your capital gains, you might want to also consider syndications if you qualify as an accredited investor. If you like to be somewhat active, great, do that locally but for distance and diversification, it's worth looking at being a part of institutional grade $50-125M projects in strong markets that offer potential cash flow, tax shelter and appreciation.

  • Clayton MobleyPro Member
    Birmingham, AL · Member since 2014 · 875 posts · 947 votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen So sorry for the delayed reply! To answer your question (though I think by now you've likely moved on ;) the $250k in that equation was just as an example. Just showing that, if you wanted to take more than the $500k under Sec 121, the extra would be taxable. No special significance to worry about ;) And yes, if you are eligible to take the $500k tax-free under Sec 121, you only need to roll the remaining value into your new replacement prop(s) under the 1031. So if you take $500k and sell for $2.75m, you only need to roll over $2.25m. 

    With regard to your take on the hassle of lower-cost markets, you're right and you're wrong. Yes, the more properties you have under your belt, the more moving parts there are. However, investing in lower cost areas with lower property taxes and higher cash flow does typically mean a higher ROI compared to pricey markets like HI and CA, where you'll be buying for appreciation, if anything. However, you wouldn't really be the one dealing with those hassles. I would never recommend that you try to manage that kind of portfolio yourself, especially from a distance. You'd hire a PM or go the turnkey route (where one company takes care of everything, from finding the prop to rehab to management).

    Again, this is all about priorities. If your goal is simplicity, conservation of capital, and having a dream home to move into down the road, then by all means just go for the high end rental in HI, if you can find one that cash flows. You'll need to wait to move in, and I'd recommend more than a year, more like 18 months, to be on the safe side since you'd be purchasing with a 1031, but sounds like you wouldn't be moving in until later anyway. 

    If, however, your priority is wealth creation and maximizing returns, buying a single fantastic A prop in HI is not the way to go. As many have pointed out, you'll be much better served by rolling your capital into multiple lower cost properties in other markets. Given the amount you have to work with, you could have a sizable portfolio that would provide long-term cashflow and leave a nice legacy for your heirs. But, you are correct, there is more work involved. I wouldn't recommend that you manage these properties, definitely go turnkey or hire a PM, but you'd need to put in the legwork to figure out where you want to invest, with what process, and who you want to work with. That's a lot of research and some serious vetting to be done, but once the investment is made, your PM or turnkey company should handle everything for you.

    It sounds like you know where your priorities lie. I'd recommend still looking at your HI investment like you would any other. Of course, cash flow won't likely be impressive in that market, but if it were me, I'd still try to maximize that however possible.

    Best of luck!

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Clayton Mobley Thanks for the response!

    "So if you take $500k and sell for $2.75m, you only need to roll over $2.25m." - This was the key clarification I was looking for, so thanks!

    I'm probably going to regret selling my rental home in SF 20 years from now, so to counteract the regret, I just need to redeploy the capital and try to beat a 5% compounded annual return for 20 years. I think it can be done, since many other asset classes have done that in the past. 

    I'm de-risking now and simplifying life. My master plan is to move back to Hawaii and buy a sweet home to enjoy life. That's all I've ever wanted. I luckily have an online income stream that doesn't need to be managed, so that's the way I plan to go.

    Thanks a lot for your help. You ROCK!

    Sam 

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Amit M.My take is that you should hold on for as long as possible until you can't take it anymore.

    I personally can't take being a landlord of more than one property anymore. AND, the $9,000/month in rent I was getting isn't attainable right now anymore. I looked for 35 days and couldn't find great tenants. Even 5 dudes just backed out this morning at $8,500.

    So maybe my market rent is really only $8,000 - $8,500 now, which is a 5% - 12.5% hit, which is what the statistics say. And given that's the case, my offer looks even that much better, for now.

    I know the prices will be higher in 10-20 years. But I need to live for the now. 

    Do you have any other sources of income i.e. job?

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    I haven't worked a w2 since 1999 dot.com :). Then I had a consulting business until 2004. Essentially living off the RE since 2004, which is just the way I like it. 

    Yeah rents have definitely dropped, so 9k down to 8k, especially for the high end is in line with market reality. 

    I manage 13 nice units, and even though almost all my tenants are class A professionals, it's still a PITA!  OTOH it gives me something to do. It's just the uncertainty of tenant needs that is annoying. Like you said, I'll do it until I can't stand it anymore. I'm definitely hoping to ride the next appreciation wave in 5-10 years. 

    Not sure what I'd do then, hand lover to prop manager, 1031 into some NNN, etc. But I doubt I want to buy more property to manage myself! Guess it depends how much we are still living in SF. Yes it's a great city, but I've been here since 1994 and slowly getting burned out...been there, done that, seen all the cool sights,, etc. but if feel kind of stuck, as I can't see myself living in a non urban environment, even one in a beautiful natural setting. I love that stuff, but not sure I can live there full time?!?

    How about you, Hawaii?  You want to check out too?  Still keep a pied a terre in SF? Aren't you worried about being bored sh*tless too ;)

  • Clayton MobleyPro Member
    Birmingham, AL · Member since 2014 · 875 posts · 947 votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen happy to help! And congrats on having a hands-off income stream - you really did some things right along the way, didn't you? Best of luck in wherever life takes you...seems like you're going to end up on your feet no matter what ;)

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen another (non trivial) thing to keep in mind is that your SF rentals are not subject to rent control. That's big. Imagine being subject to RC and getting stuck with a squatter-tenant that want to milk their below market rent!  Having cash flowing, non RC property in SF (as I do too) is basically like printing money long term :)

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Amit M.Indeed,  which is why I will keep my other single-family home and condo, both not under rent control forever. I just wanted to do you risk and simplify with the sale of this one house. 

    Also, I found an easier way to print money  and that's through my website, Financial Samurai. If I didn't have my website, I would've held onto my rentals forever.

    But I am looking to buy a dream house in Honolulu Hawaii. So I do need capital.

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen so have you already sold the marina home?  If you haven't, another calculus would be to weigh keeping the marina home vs the GG one. (Lots to consider there- future appreciation, rentability, primeness...) We're also looking at a second home in a couple of years, but I think I'll just leverage and refi, as I'll have enough extra rental income to cover the added debt.  I'd consider selling off a condo, but in my case my portfolio is intricately tied together and I'm loathe to do that. 

    I have a lot more thoughts on this topic wrt long term strategy, but probably easiest when talking in person. Since you're also in the city if you want to meet up for coffee, friend me on my profile and we can coordinate via email. I would also be interested in hearing more about your blog biz success, its sustainability, etc.  (I mean, people with first world problems have to commiserate too :) Cheers

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    @Amit M. Yeah, the online media business is multiple times more lucrative than RE. I would highlight some posts here, but don't think I'm allowed. Google "blogging for a living financial samurai" for insights. And "why blogging is the best business in the world."

    Haven't sold the Marina house yet, but maybe end of this week.

    What do you do for a living?

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Sam Dogen I've already hit my number with my real estate, so it's basically a life of leisure while managing my properties. That and I still have a couple of development projects to legalize sq ft, basically worth $100PSF now, spend another $100PSF on development, to gain $800PSF in value (highest and best use.)  That's mostly working with the city for entitlements and managing a GC. 

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 25 posts · 6 votes
    9y

    This thread is pretty much over it seems, but I just wanted to thank @Sam Dogen for starting this discussion. Reading through everyone's responses has really helped me decide whether I should sell my SF condo (after receiving a tempting $$$ offer) and figure out my priorities and longterm goals. So grateful for the points people brought up, and I'm especially appreciative of @Amit M. sharing his experience and insights as a San Francisco investor. Thank you.

  • Sam DogenPro Member
    OP
    San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 40 posts · 17 votes
    9y

    no problem @Anne Chiramberro.  What did you end up doing? I decided to take the offer and simplify my life. I'll be running a post about it on my site within the next 30 days. Hope you stop by. 

  • SoCal · Member since 2018 · 24 posts · 11 votes
    8y

    I'd say take a step back from all the fun equations and data and math. You probably realize that there's a whole other component to building wealth...time.

    I'm guessing you don't need the money, so why does it matter if you lower your rent to still pull money in for your rental? It's a competitive market for rentals, so price it competitively.

    Another thing, why would you buy a listing that big on an ARM? Unless you went into this thinking you were going to only hold for a short time. Real estate has long ebb and flow trends. While an ARM may have seemed like the right idea at the time, now rates will climb. But, by how much?


    There are certainly opportunity costs being missed by selling, but I've realized there are also costs missed by not selling. You have a great dollar cost avg baked into your price, why sell?

    Like the stock market, there are some long term investments that just grow overtime. Coveted holdings that scream hold me for a very long time.

    I'm in a similar boat in SF and NYC, and have contemplated a 1031. I will likely do one of them, but keep the other.

    There are just some investments you shouldn't sell.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.