Spec builder wants to build on an expensive ski lot I own. He is willing to pay full price (even 5% over price in a year), but give me nothing today. He wants to take my lot with what I guess is an option, along with getting a construction loan to build on. His plan is to build a spec home on my lot, sell it within a year and pay me off.
I asked if I would be in front of or behind the bank ... and as I thought he'd say ... I would be behind the bank in terms of loan position. I said that I wouldn't do this deal if I weren't covered as far as either his mistakes, market timing, other myriad things that could go wrong; he seemed to think this could be overcome. Is he crazy to say this can be overcome to protect me? Has someone done something like this and have advice on how it could be structured to protect my downside? I am not interested in losing this property due to a deal gone south.
short answer you CANT highly risky. for this situation you should get full market for your lot and 20 to 40% of the profit on top or sell your lot for 100 to 200k more than your asking.. I assume this is a multi million dollar deal.
the builder of course NEEDS YOUR equity to get his loan.. now the good news is if he can get a loan means he is somewhat to fully qualified..
you can do a participation mortgage in second position calling out for an interest rate and a bonus you just put it right in the note.. or
lets say your lot price is 500k.. you simply write your note for 650k plus interest.. this assure you of profit.
I would not do this though if you have no means to step in and complete or cash out the first.. nothing is worse than taking over a build project from a builder that failed mid stream
short answer you CANT highly risky. for this situation you should get full market for your lot and 20 to 40% of the profit on top or sell your lot for 100 to 200k more than your asking.. I assume this is a multi million dollar deal.
the builder of course NEEDS YOUR equity to get his loan.. now the good news is if he can get a loan means he is somewhat to fully qualified..
you can do a participation mortgage in second position calling out for an interest rate and a bonus you just put it right in the note.. or
lets say your lot price is 500k.. you simply write your note for 650k plus interest.. this assure you of profit.
I would not do this though if you have no means to step in and complete or cash out the first.. nothing is worse than taking over a build project from a builder that failed mid stream
To add to Jay's great points.. what part does this lot represent of your portfolio or nest egg? A smidgen? All? Does it have payments? High ones?
Proper advice should vary significantly depending on whether this is a free and clear one-off lot on the side or a huge portion of your portfolio with a massive payment.
In general, I'd say no. Why do large companies or developers look to the little guy to give up or take the risk for them? I'd at least ask for my cost basis up front. You could lose this thing as Jay mentions...
To add to Jay's great points.. what part does this lot represent of your portfolio or nest egg? A smidgen? All? Does it have payments? High ones?
Proper advice should vary significantly depending on whether this is a free and clear one-off lot on the side or a huge portion of your portfolio with a massive payment.
In general, I'd say no. Why do large companies or developers look to the little guy to give up or take the risk for them? I'd at least ask for my cost basis up front. You could lose this thing as Jay mentions...
this was far more common coming out of the deep dark recession.. but now a days builders don't need to do this and if they need to do this means they are either long on jobs or short on capital. and they might should go find a money partner and leave the poor land owner alone LOL... But in my lending days I did a lot of participation mortgages with small developers.. were I would fund 100% but I took upside .. it was risk but we made some spectacular returns..
To add to Jay's great points.. what part does this lot represent of your portfolio or nest egg? A smidgen? All? Does it have payments? High ones?
Proper advice should vary significantly depending on whether this is a free and clear one-off lot on the side or a huge portion of your portfolio with a massive payment.
In general, I'd say no. Why do large companies or developers look to the little guy to give up or take the risk for them? I'd at least ask for my cost basis up front. You could lose this thing as Jay mentions...
this was far more common coming out of the deep dark recession.. but now a days builders don't need to do this and if they need to do this means they are either long on jobs or short on capital. and they might should go find a money partner and leave the poor land owner alone LOL... But in my lending days I did a lot of participation mortgages with small developers.. were I would fund 100% but I took upside .. it was risk but we made some spectacular returns..
I like your participation mortgage idea, as well as your bloat the note mention. I do that with my small business lending. Sure, I'll lend you $5k against that truck, but the note will be for $6k, expiring 2 years from now.
The OP scenario is like the fortune 500 co asking the employee to travel on their own dime, then be reimbursed. On a much larger level, of course, but why does Joe worker have to lend the fortune 5 money at all??
Lets ask this guy, whose only asset in the entire world is this lot, to front it for me so i can potentially make a killing. Probability of us both losing it all is 50%, more if it hits the market in April. Who does that? I'd tell the speculator to stick it just as a matter of principal.
I appreciate everyone's advice. This is pretty much what I thought I'd hear. I'm curious (if there is a range to be given). What kind of return can a spec builder make on a build like this if everything goes right?
And a little bit more info on the area. It's a ski town where homes on the street sell for about 1.2 mm - 1.4 mm. I'm asking 275k for the lot, but I'm convinced even that is likely low given the direction homes are going. What range should a lot be selling for relative to finished SFR's in the same area? I've heard ranges before but I'd like to hear from you guys.
I appreciate everyone's advice. This is pretty much what I thought I'd hear. I'm curious (if there is a range to be given). What kind of return can a spec builder make on a build like this if everything goes right?
And a little bit more info on the area. It's a ski town where homes on the street sell for about 1.2 mm - 1.4 mm. I'm asking 275k for the lot, but I'm convinced even that is likely low given the direction homes are going. What range should a lot be selling for relative to finished SFR's in the same area? I've heard ranges before but I'd like to hear from you guys.
your in the ball park lots are usually 1/4 to 1/5 th of the sale price unless your in the SF peninsula and there they are inverted