1005 Square Footage Error - Week from Closing - Any Advice?

1005 Square Footage Error - Week from Closing - Any Advice?

Buffalo, NY · Member since 2016 · 11 posts · 4 votes

Hello all - Newbie here. I'm under contract on a home I'm buying to live in and Airbnb the attached In-Law suite. The listing agent wrote that the house was 4,000 sq in his description, and the mls listing indicated 4288. One week away from closing and the appraisal comes back at value of sale price, but 1,005 sqft smaller - 3283 sqft. Asked the sellers for price reduction and they refused.

My lawyer is on vacation for the next few days and my realtor is stumped. 

What do I do? Is there any avenue for recourse or damages? 1005 sqft discrepany is signifigant, so I can not understand why the sellers would expect me to pay same price. The sellers and agent are not challenging the appraised sqft number of 3283 - just said that's what they thought it was based on city records.

Any thought? 

0Reply
274 views

Most Popular Reply

Accountant · Tulsa, OK · Member since 2018 · 312 posts · 349 votes
7y

@Sadie Bynum I understand your pain, but you've posted the same thing several times in this thread. At this point, since the seller doesn't want to drop the price, you need to evaluate if it's worth it with the current price / square footage or not. If it's still worth it, then keep the deal going, if not walk away. You're only other option is to wait to hear from your lawyer to see if you have an legal recourse, however (this is my opinion, not legal advice) I doubt the legal answer will be "force seller to lower price". Things happen in REI, you just have to deal with them and keep moving forward.

See this reply in the discussion

54 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    7y

    @Sadie Bynum I had a similar situation last year, but mine was 200 square feet. The appraiser swore he was right, the listing agent swore she was right. I met my agent over there and we measured it together. It turned out (in my case) the appraiser was wrong. However, had the seller been wrong I would have absolutely expected a concession. In my city, price per square foot is very relevant both for sales and renting. So from that standpoint, I see your point.

    However, I also think you are getting hung up on what should be, versus the situation as it is. There is only three potential outcomes here:

    1. Seller agrees to a concession

    2. Buyer agrees to pay the price as appraised.

    3. You back out of the deal.

    If you back out of the deal, you are going to have trouble recouping your due diligence costs. The seller will just claim they used city records and push blame on someone else. Plus they will argue that it appraised, so no harm to you.

    The decision you have to make is if the property is worth the same value given the smaller square feet. You can't force them to lower price. Maybe if you take steps to pull out of the deal, they may offer a concession. I would probably call their bluff. The one thing working to your advantage is if they list the property again, they have to change the square feet. They can only claim ignorance once. They know that, so they have motivation to see this deal through.

    As far as people who are saying, "who cares it appraised". That is kind of nonsense because an investor knows better. Had the house been 1000 square feet bigger, we all know it should have appraised for more. All my appraisals come out at purchase price, so in my experience an appraiser is not independently finding value, they are finding comps to support sales price. 

    In my case after the appraiser mistake was found, he refused to send a new appraisal with higher price to the bank. That just further proves my point that appraisers are only paid to substantiate value, not exceed.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2019 · 31 posts · 19 votes
    7y

    @Sadie Bynum I can only weigh in with my personal experience on this, but when we had this hiccup on a purchase, we sent two documents to the sellers. First was an amendment (not an addendum or counter-offer!) to the sellers that said "Due to the Error and Omission made by the seller, through the listing agent, of inaccurate square footage misrepresented by 1005 square feet, confirmed by 3rd party appraisal, the purchase price is to be $XXX,XXX." The second document was a Mutual Release Form. We told them they could choose which document they signed. 

    Not sure if that's helpful at all for you, but missing 1005 square feet can definitely be the difference between a great deal and a money-pit deal. So sorry you've got this problem on your hands!

    Best of luck!!

    Conner

  • Appraiser · Denver, CO · Member since 2018 · 40 posts · 58 votes
    7y

    @Sadie Bynum I scrolled through most of these responses and couldn’t see a similar response, but I apologize if someone already mentioned this.

    I work in a valuation firm and for the most part, an appraiser's measurements are going to be more accurate than the county's records or the MLS (which is usually taken from county records or potentially haphazardly measured by an agent).

    The other aspect of this is that only heated space ABOVE GRADE counts as gross living area. So basements and splits with any floor below grade don’t count as GLA.

    Don’t worry, however, this is adjusted accordingly with comps (similar 2000sf GLA properties with a 1000sf basement are better than 3000sf GLA properties with no basement, for example).

    If the appraiser did get it that wrong, then you do have some options... Including simply telling your lender that you disagree with the value for the square footage reason, and the appraiser will complete this as a revision. That’s probably your best option, in the event that it’s the appraiser’s fault.

    Please feel free to reach out if you have any questions!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.