Ok here goes.... I’ve finally put some of the useful knowledge I’ve acquired over the years on BP into action. My strategy is buy and hold and I’ve just acquired my third deal. I now have approx $1M in rentals but am 90% leveraged. My properties barely cash flow because I’ve only put 5% down on each. Rents in my market (Phoenix) are improving drastically at the moment and appreciation has been EXTREMELY healthy over the last 5 years. Normally if I read a post like this from anyone else I’d advise caution but bear with me....
My strategy is based around maximum leverage to acquire as many rentals as I can right now. My safety net is that I carry a hefty reserve. My question to the group is, given this set of circumstances.....what kind of cash reserve would you be comfortable with?
@Account Closed I would suggest you keep 10% of what you owe in debt up to 1 million (100k in reserves). Then 5% of your debt past that (50k in reserves for each addition million you are in debt). Part of the reason for having so much in cash is if you want to really scale banks are going to require you to keep reserves in their bank in order for them to lend you millions of dollars. They call it the relationship. I have a about 4 million in loans with one of the banks I use and that bank want me to have about 250k in my accounts with just their bank.
As I started to scale, I leaned toward leveraging as much as I could in order to grow. But as I grew my portfolio more and more, the banks started looking more at my ratios for my global financial situation. In other words they started looking at all of my debts, both personal and business, and they needed it to be at a 1.2 - 1.25 ratio. That means for ever 100k that I had in expenses, I had to bring in 120k -125k in income.
So leverage is a double edge sword. On the one hand, it helps you to grow and scale, and on the other hand, it prevents you from growing and scaling if your cash flow isn’t high enough for the banks (risk managers) to feel comfortable enough to continue to lend to you. We have had good relationships with certain banks that have given us millions of dollars in loans that all of a sudden stopped lending to us because they hired a new risk manager.
So just keep in mind that leverage can help you grow and leverage can keep you from growing.
@Cara Lonsdale
https://www.cnbc.com/2014/07/18/volatile-phoenix-housing-a-cautionary-tale-for-rest-of-us.html
https://www.fortunebuilders.com/phoenix-az-real-estate-market-trends-analysis/
Wow. A link from 2014, when the whole nation was recovering. You are really reaching there, my friend. And your second link says how strong the Phx market is growing and sustaining. So, again, I don't really think you have a grasp on the Phoenix market. However, by all means, don't invest here. Leave it all to the rest of us to make our money here. :)
@Cory Binsfield I appreciate the encouragement and your perspective on the market. Assuming $5500 PITI, I mentioned I would cover 4 years with 50% occupancy or 50% rent crater. Here is how I came to that:
$5500 Income/Month becomes $2750 Income/Month in either scenario leaving me to cover $2750/month from reserves (I self manage and my properties are fairly new so capex is limited). $2750 * 12 months * 4 years = $132k in reserves to cover either scenario.
As has been mentioned, I find the Phoenix market has changed drastically since the crash. What was once a market highly dependent on construction, is now a market poised for industry. Several noteworthy employers have already migrated here. Obviously there is no crystal ball which can predict how the job market reacts in the event of an unforeseen catastrophic event like the GFC.
@Account Closed, I want to add to what I said earlier. While your method of investing is risky in the event of a market correction, I also envy it a bit. Your market is appreciating at a pretty rapid rate and so are rents apparently. I have to manage 30+ doors to get over a million in value and to be honest you will see more appreciation and rent increases with just handling 3 units. The cost of replacing 3 water heaters or 3 roofs is negligible compared to what me replacing 30 of each will be. If I was 30 I would probably be all over that if I was near your market. No great gains without great risk. If you can project to have enough reserves to pay your PITI for a few years at only half occupancy plus say $5K for emergency repairs you have done a lot to reduce the risk. I would not pursue your strategy at my age due to risking what I have spent 25 years building up. If you can get a 4 plex using the same method great, but you might also consider really looking hard for some good positive cash flow to offset some of your risk. I made a lot of mistakes early in my career, but a rising market and some rent increases were very forgiving of some mistakes. Good luck.
@Jerry W. Thanks for the perspective! I realize it’s not a strategy for those nearing the end of their journey, congrats to you on managing 30 units! That is quite a feat!
In Phoenix the median home price is $250k so a large number of units isn’t an option when you’re targeting Class A&B.
I’ve been very deliberate about my approach because it has to fit my lifestyle. These first few years I am certainly going to be relatively vulnerable, even at my level of reserves. The idea of having $50k skin in the game and being able to potentially yield $45-50k per year in equity with 3% appreciation and principle pay down blows my mind. Three years ago I was convinced that I’d work the rest of my life as an engineer to retire with maybe $1M at the age of 65. BP has exploded my mind surrounding the prospects.
@Joe Splitrock I never said I had $1M in net worth. I think I made it pretty clear that I’m highly leveraged which kind of implies that I have low net worth in these investments. Maybe you just needed to get some criticizing off your chest?!
Following it up by saying I only need a couple months in reserves is literally insane.
People who were highly leveraged with hefty cash positions during the crash did not foreclose unless it was a strategic foreclosure. I think people all too often consider all debt as bad debt. Debt that is insured by hefty cash reserves is still good debt IMHO. The question is, what kind of reserves do I need as an insurance policy to make sure I’m in that same position in the event of a massive disaster?
My point is you don't have a million dollars in rentals - you have a million dollars in debt. I am just trying to illustrate that without equity there is nothing to protect. If you owned those properties prior to the crash, you would have been upside down on all the mortgages after the crash. So if they went vacant for months or a year, it would not make sense to pay a mortgage that long on a property with negative equity.
Cash reserves should be built around worst case recoverable scenario. You should never have more than a couple months vacancy on a property. If you do, it is either some type of management issue or a serious disaster in your market.
I am not sure how you do a "strategic foreclosure" with massive cash reserves. The people I know who lost rental properties to foreclosure ten years ago ended up filing bankruptcy. It is not as simple as walking away and keeping your cash.
Having cash reserves to cover 2 years full vacancy is very excessive. You would be far better off putting most that money to work in a cash flowing property.
@Account Closed - I glanced through some of the advice you’re getting in this thread and I would just say take them with a grain of salt.
As usual on BiggerPockets, folks give tips that overgeneralize and pertain only to their specific real estate situation. One example is @Joe Splitrock who mentioned that acquisitions should meet the 1% rule. Sure maybe you can find deals like that in midwestern areas. But good luck finding properties that meet that rule in coastal cities where you tend to find higher priced homes with higher appreciation rates.
@Joe Splitrock respectfully, I could not disagree more. The reality is that I could dump my cash reserves into these properties, recast the mortgages and be cash flowing each one tomorrow if I wanted to. I think that it’s a far better strategy to have that option and not exercise it unless it becomes necessary.
Having excess reserves gives me MANY more recoverable scenarios than 2 months reserves would. In the event of a crash everyone with 2 months reserves gets roasted, cash flow be damned because a you won’t have it come a 50% crater.
Strategic foreclosures ran rampant in 2008. Your mortgage is a contract and like any contract you can choose to break it. If you’re suggesting that having liquid assets would disqualify you from executing that strategy somehow....then make them illiquid.
@Ana Marie B. I’m sure there are 1% deals to be had in almost every market if you look hard enough..but that doesn’t mean they are in the Class A neighborhoods I’m targeting for my investments. It’s still very interesting to hear the perspective of others.
@Account Closed - I glanced through some of the advice you’re getting in this thread and I would just say take them with a grain of salt.
As usual on BiggerPockets, folks give tips that overgeneralize and pertain only to their specific real estate situation. One example is @Joe Splitrock who mentioned that acquisitions should meet the 1% rule. Sure maybe you can find deals like that in midwestern areas. But good luck finding properties that meet that rule in coastal cities where you tend to find higher priced homes with higher appreciation rates.
There are plenty of people in the Phoenix market that buy within the 1% rule or closer to it. Even at 0.9% or 0.8% you can make the numbers work. The problem is at some point the monthly payment is more than rent collected.
There is higher appreciation on the coasts, but also considerably more volatility. If you are buying when prices are low, it is a grand slam. If you are buying when prices are high and barely covering the mortgage, that is highly risky.
Two things often happen when people buy personal homes and convert to rentals:
1. They buy a personal home for their needs, not realizing it may be too nice to make a good rental house. Higher end properties return a lower rent per purchase price.
2. People buy their primary home emotionally off the MLS, which means they often pay retail. This can be avoided by doing a live-in flip then convert to rental.
The other thing to consider is just because you live on the coasts, doesn't mean you need to buy rental properties there. Read David Greene's book on long distance investing. He lives in CA and sells real estate in CA, but invests in other parts of the country. I normally advocate investing locally, but not if the investment is low return.
I agree there is definitely different rules for different parts of the country. However, no matter where you live, investments need to make money. If you bleed money every month, it is a bad investment or hobby.
@Joe Splitrock respectfully, I could not disagree more. The reality is that I could dump my cash reserves into these properties, recast the mortgages and be cash flowing each one tomorrow if I wanted to. I think that it’s a far better strategy to have that option and not exercise it unless it becomes necessary.
Having excess reserves gives me MANY more recoverable scenarios than 2 months reserves would. In the event of a crash everyone with 2 months reserves gets roasted, cash flow be damned because a you won’t have it come a 50% crater.
Strategic foreclosures ran rampant in 2008. Your mortgage is a contract and like any contract you can choose to break it. If you’re suggesting that having liquid assets would disqualify you from executing that strategy somehow....then make them illiquid.
You asked how much you need for reserves. The answer boils down to what situation are you trying to ride through? Reserves have two purposes, cover vacancy costs and cover repairs. So to calculate your reserve, you need to plan out the worst case recoverable scenario. In my 15+ year rental property experience through two recessions, my worst case is two months vacancy (lower during bad economic times than good times). I just don't think a year is likely. Even banks, who are very conservative, only require 6 moths reserves per property for underwriting. It doesn't even have to be cash, so they consider retirement funds to be part of that 6 months. My point is being overly conservative comes at an opportunity cost. If you could deploy that extra cash into a cash flowing property, it would benefit you more over time.
As far as strategic foreclosures, remember that a foreclosure often comes with a deficiency judgement. Hiding assets can be difficult. You often can't just walk away from a contract without financial consequences. Of course mortgage insurance and other factors play into this, but ultimately many people end up filing bankruptcy after foreclosure.
I feel like we are arguing and have no idea why. Leverage is wonderful. Protecting from risk is smart. There just has to be a balance. That is a personal choice. If you want a years payment in the bank per property, go for it. You have to live with what makes you feel comfortable. It is as much an emotional debate as a logical one.
@Account Closed - I glanced through some of the advice you’re getting in this thread and I would just say take them with a grain of salt.
As usual on BiggerPockets, folks give tips that overgeneralize and pertain only to their specific real estate situation. One example is @Joe Splitrock who mentioned that acquisitions should meet the 1% rule. Sure maybe you can find deals like that in midwestern areas. But good luck finding properties that meet that rule in coastal cities where you tend to find higher priced homes with higher appreciation rates.
I agree. Having owned rentals in Phoenix for over 10+ years I can say that the 1% is impossible. Sellers know that the market is hot. I get random texts, mailings and calls from “investors” who want to buy my properties
As far as the OP is concerned, it depends on what you want your reserves to cover. Being in Phoenix, I haven’t had any issues finding tenants despite rents jumping significantly every year so vacancy isn’t an issue for me. This leads to costs associated with turnover. Since turnover has been rare for me, this is also not a big deal
What HAS been important for me are capital expenditures. Roof. AC. Specifically. For the Phoenix market I would focus your attention on these items when deciding on how much reserves you need
Good luck!
@Joe Splitrock hiding assets is not what I’m suggesting! You seem to have a knack for twisting my words. If I were to say....buy another house....with my cash reserves and strategically foreclose on the property with the worst performance I’d be within my legal rights to do so. That’s what strategic foreclosure is, it has nothing to do with hiding assets.
BK and foreclosure are NOT synonymous. You’re conflating the two.
I think this is where we just agree to disagree...you still seem to be advocating for me to tie up most of my cash to earn $100 a door. I simply don’t see any safety net built into your suggestion.
@Ana Marie B. I’m sure there are 1% deals to be had in almost every market if you look hard enough..but that doesn’t mean they are in the Class A neighborhoods I’m targeting for my investments. It’s still very interesting to hear the perspective of others.
You’re right. If you find something in Phoenix that hits the 1% rule it’s not going to be in a place where you can collect your rents very easily
Even Sunnyslope is gentrifying. Anything approaching the 1% rule is being turned over and sold at a 3% cap. At best. Sellers know they have buyers buy the short hairs in Phoenix
Very risky and very expensive. I am surprised a bank allowed you to do this. Are you paying PMI? How's your credit? Can you refi into a portfolio loan? All-in-all, I always recommend to have around 25% in liquid savings to handle the murphy's law situations. They can also be in credit lines (though, those can be called) or securities. So for you, 250,000+. If not, you're really skating on very thin ice.
@Calvin T. I am paying PMI on the second two. On the first I've reached 25% equity so PMI was removed at my request. My credit is great, I haven't missed a payment in 20 years.
I'm not sure why you're surprised. I've had approval by multiple lenders on each of these deals. Each lender's underwriting considers my rental history, the active leases, and my tax returns to dictate net income (or loss) to add to my DTI ratios. And my reserves of course.
I have no reason at this point to refinance into a more costly portfolio loan. I have W2 income and am not asking for anything outside of conforming loan limits. My DTI is always within normal range for approval.
$250k seems high. By my math that would carry me almost 4 years PITI at 0% occupancy. Do you have a particular reason this? Definitely curious to learn from others.
@Calvin T. I am paying PMI on the second two. On the first I've reached 25% equity so PMI was removed at my request. My credit is great, I haven't missed a payment in 20 years.
I'm not sure why you're surprised. I've had approval by multiple lenders on each of these deals. Each lender's underwriting considers my rental history, the active leases, and my tax returns to dictate net income (or loss) to add to my DTI ratios. And my reserves of course.
I have no reason at this point to refinance into a more costly portfolio loan. I have W2 income and am not asking for anything outside of conforming loan limits. My DTI is always within normal range for approval.
$250k seems high. By my math that would carry me almost 4 years PITI at 0% occupancy. Do you have a particular reason this? Definitely curious to learn from others.
Simple, you are over-leveraged. When, not if, you have a major issue at one of your buildings, then you will not have the reserves to cover it w/o effecting your life. Yes, everything is honky dory during the good times, but have you weathered a tough market or a recession? We've have to replace roofs, main line sewage failure, fires, evictions, etc. You need reserves, and 25% is a safe number. It's your choice if you want to consider the advice of people who've been through the tough times for the last few decades. In addition, I do not know of any bank who will under-write a loan, let alone a commercial loan (5+ units) for just 5% down. I just locked down a 4.2% loan with 15% down on 3m. Congrats if you can can get a 4% loan with just 5%.
@Calvin T. I consider the advice of EVERYONE who has taken the time to chime in here. I haven’t weathered a recession or a downturn which is the reason I’m seeking advice in the first place.
It’s worth noting that I’m not seeking commercial loans. I am buying these rentals as a primary residence, living in each for a year and converting them to rentals.
I have the reserves to cover the kinds of issues you mentioned to a degree, I’m just not sure I need the reserves to replaces 20 roofs when I only own 3 properties 😂. For all the hard and fast rules on BP, there doesn’t seem to be one on cash reserves relative to leverage.
@Calvin T. I consider the advice of EVERYONE who has taken the time to chime in here. I haven’t weathered a recession or a downturn which is the reason I’m seeking advice in the first place.
It’s worth noting that I’m not seeking commercial loans. I am buying these rentals as a primary residence, living in each for a year and converting them to rentals.
I have the reserves to cover the kinds of issues you mentioned to a degree, I’m just not sure I need the reserves to replaces 20 roofs when I only own 3 properties 😂. For all the hard and fast rules on BP, there doesn’t seem to be one on cash reserves relative to leverage.
I'd be careful on continuing to do that. Eventually, banks might see that and may cancel the loan. It's technically legal, but many banks don't like that. I've always found out that it is best not to give a bank a reason to look at you. Besides, the money and growth is in multi-families, not single families' in my opinion. In the next recession, the SFH are going to go down, where the MFH, not so much. You've not faced an eviction yet, but they are not fun. Lastly, when you go through your eviction, no money is being received. So, those payments and financial responsibilities fall on your personal shoulders (and savings). Thus, this is why I say you are not well funded for an emergency. Sadly, emergencies seem to happen when you least expect it. Imagine having two evictions and no R.E. income? Could you float those two other homes for a few months? What about the repairs after they are officially evicted? What if they literally destroy the place?
Quick story. I took over this building a few years ago, since sold it for a 30% profit, but it was a headache. This one tenant destroyed the walls, put bicycles into the wall, smashed all the windows and rubbed feces all over the place. Oh, he also attacked the sheriff during the eviction. It cost over $3k to repair a 800 sq. ft. unit. Another two months of lost rent, plus lawyer fees, court fees, insurance, mortgage, taxes, and everything else.
Could you handle that times 2 plus your own residence? As another person put it, you are building a house of cards. You need more security or you will be putting your personal financial life (and family) in fiscal jeopardy.
@Calvin T. I have imagined all those scenarios and the answers is yes, I could afford to carry those kinds of problems with the amount of reserves I’ve got. I don’t expect the tenant issues to be as prevalent in the class A range, but you never know.
I disagree with your statement about the bank being able to call those loans. What I’m doing is perfectly legal and my loans specifically state owner occupancy for a minimum of one year is required. I’ve met the terms of my loan to the letter.
I don't think you can make a blanket statement that all SFH is going downhill in the next downturn. Every market is different. My research indicates that it was the class C units that suffered worst in the GFC. Those that kept their jobs upgraded to a better place when rents plummeted and class C experienced a massive increase in vacancy as a result.
@Calvin T. I have imagined all those scenarios and the answers is yes, I could afford to carry those kinds of problems with the amount of reserves I’ve got. I don’t expect the tenant issues to be as prevalent in the class A range, but you never know.
I disagree with your statement about the bank being able to call those loans. What I’m doing is perfectly legal and my loans specifically state owner occupancy for a minimum of one year is required. I’ve met the terms of my loan to the letter.
I don't think you can make a blanket statement that all SFH is going downhill in the next downturn. Every market is different. My research indicates that it was the class C units that suffered worst in the GFC. Those that kept their jobs upgraded to a better place when rents plummeted and class C experienced a massive increase in vacancy as a result.
Been through many recessions since the 70s, and unfortunately, you are mistaken. Every home gets hit, it just depends on how much. If you say you have the savings, then you are golden. Just in case, I'd highly recommend taking out some lines of credit, both personal and business, just in case for extra insurance with different banks and credit unions. You do not have to use them, but they are nice to have in an emergency.
@Whitney Bowling
I think you'd have to look at what the age of the properties are and in what condition they're in as far as capex goes. I'd also keep at least 3-6 months worth of PITI as someone above mentioned.