Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2018 · 420 posts · 388 votes
Ok here goes.... I’ve finally put some of the useful knowledge I’ve acquired over the years on BP into action. My strategy is buy and hold and I’ve just acquired my third deal. I now have approx $1M in rentals but am 90% leveraged. My properties barely cash flow because I’ve only put 5% down on each. Rents in my market (Phoenix) are improving drastically at the moment and appreciation has been EXTREMELY healthy over the last 5 years. Normally if I read a post like this from anyone else I’d advise caution but bear with me....
My strategy is based around maximum leverage to acquire as many rentals as I can right now. My safety net is that I carry a hefty reserve. My question to the group is, given this set of circumstances.....what kind of cash reserve would you be comfortable with?
@Account Closed I would suggest you keep 10% of what you owe in debt up to 1 million (100k in reserves). Then 5% of your debt past that (50k in reserves for each addition million you are in debt). Part of the reason for having so much in cash is if you want to really scale banks are going to require you to keep reserves in their bank in order for them to lend you millions of dollars. They call it the relationship. I have a about 4 million in loans with one of the banks I use and that bank want me to have about 250k in my accounts with just their bank.
As I started to scale, I leaned toward leveraging as much as I could in order to grow. But as I grew my portfolio more and more, the banks started looking more at my ratios for my global financial situation. In other words they started looking at all of my debts, both personal and business, and they needed it to be at a 1.2 - 1.25 ratio. That means for ever 100k that I had in expenses, I had to bring in 120k -125k in income.
So leverage is a double edge sword. On the one hand, it helps you to grow and scale, and on the other hand, it prevents you from growing and scaling if your cash flow isn’t high enough for the banks (risk managers) to feel comfortable enough to continue to lend to you. We have had good relationships with certain banks that have given us millions of dollars in loans that all of a sudden stopped lending to us because they hired a new risk manager.
So just keep in mind that leverage can help you grow and leverage can keep you from growing.
@Cara Lonsdale great advice and info on the lender requirements. I have a background in data modeling and analytics so I’m keyed in on several fluctuating metrics. I am always receptive of the lessons others have learned! Appreciate the ideas!
@Cory Binsfield thank you. I am skeptical of lines of credit for the exact reason you mentioned.
All of my loans are 30 year conventional up to this point. I'm not trying to take advantage of the FHA rules, but was pointing out that it is an option on the next quad if need be.
I'm curious why you'd deem this strategy a house of cards though. Sure, I'm taking on high leverage but from my perspective having the cash reserves to carry PITI through 24 months at 100% vacancy is the exact opposite. At 50% occupancy or 50% rent crater I'd still be able to carry all 3 investments for four years. That's why I'm here though...to watch others poke holes in my strategy so that I can correct course! Do your worst!! Seriously though, I appreciate the critique.
6 months reserve operating expenses for your business. A valid passport, and a getaway vehicle.
If the appreciation is really ballooning, maybe take your profits while the market is up, load up on liquidity and be ready to scoop up something really good when it goes to hell.
Phoenix is a very bi-polar market. When its up, its really up, but when it's down it is keying your car and trying to kill you.
@Account Closed I have 6 units. And cash in hand covers maybe an extra month of PITI. Now before you or someone else flips out. Know my W2 job covers any need I could possibly have. I don't touch profits, I have a five year no touch policy for my cashflow, everything is to buy more or repair any and everything. In 5 years I'll be completely free to do whatever it is I want to do with all the cashflow but not now.
Again I am in a very unique situation (though I’m sure others are high income earners that don’t need a huge cash pile).
If I didn’t have my income I would shot for 6 months of expenses. Why six, because of the world went to crap it would give me six months to weather the storm or sell before I run out of money.
@Andrew Syrios that was my thinking as well, $100k at minimum. My next step (hopefully 6 month from now) will be to buy a $600k quadplex with 5% down and live in one of the units for a year. Any thoughts on where I should be in reserves before making that leap? Keep in mind that my target property would be one where once I leave after that 1st year I’m able to cash flow $100/door fully leased up.
10% is probably a good amount to keep on hand (if at all possible) until you get a bit bigger. Then you can wean it down to more like 5% or so.
@Eric C. Interesting. I'd never sleep at night with only 1 month PITI cash on hand but to each their own. I've seen 6 months suggested several times now but Phoenix is soooo mercurial that even that scares me.
Most of my criticism comes when people read that I’m carrying $900k in debt and currently renting a room from a friend for $500/month. 😂
Out of curiosity, what is your strategy on leverage?
@Eric C. Interesting. I'd never sleep at night with only 1 month PITI cash on hand but to each their own. I've seen 6 months suggested several times now but Phoenix is soooo mercurial that even that scares me.
Most of my criticism comes when people read that I’m carrying $900k in debt and currently renting a room from a friend for $500/month. 😂
Out of curiosity, what is your strategy on leverage?
Cash in hand is relative. Also I could have all my units empty forever and my W2 job would be able to continue to pay all the bills without much concern. I’d have to stop going to fancy restaurants like chic fila and go back to the dollar menu at Wendy’s and McDonald’s but I think I’d survive.
My leverage is all 80% LTV at the start. Cashflow is good. But I don't use it for my day to day living expenses so I'm happy just piling cash and making repairs to have a quality product to rent to tenants.
It's all about the amount of leverage. How much real cash flow does each door spit out and are you saving that for a rainy day? Problems in portfolios tend to come in large bunches. Everything is quiet and then all of a sudden you have 5 or 10 turn overs with evictions.
In terms of pleasing lenders, it truly ranges. Some are as low as 3 months, but for your situation, that's definitely too little. I think if you're over 80% LTV, you should have 12 months in reserves. If you have anything less than 80%, 6-9 months is solid. While some require 3 months, you don't want to have the minimum.
@Account Closed, my situation is so different from yours that I don't know if it will help any. First I also owe a $1 million, but I have over 30 doors. I don't see much appreciation or rent increase so the property MUST cash flow. The idea of only getting $100 per month in return for a $300K property would scare me to death. I try to buy properties that are disressed and fix them up for an initial value add. Then I use either a 15 or 20 year note. The scary part is that they are 5 year ARMs so the rate could change every 5 years. I try to keep 2 months of bank payments around in cash in my operating account, and about $10K in my repair account. I am actively still buying so I don't hold lots of cash on hand. My safety net is a $100K line of credit I can tap into to fix a sewer etc. I also use it to buy cash then refinance out when I make a few repairs. My second safety net is having a property or 2 paid off. I can always count on being able to have that one or 2 big rent payments with no mortgage. I had 6 units come open on Feb. 1. Ouch, couple that with I just bought 3 units that are all empty. The good thing is by having cash flow of $100 per unit I can live with it. I can spend much those months, but I don't go negative. I do have a credit card or 2 with a big limit just in case. With a 15 year mortgage in as little as 5 years I pay off about 20% of the principal so I can always tap into one of those for a refinance or to take out a second mortgage to use a down payment on a new house. Every investment plan is different, so mine may not help you much, but it can give you perspective. I think $7K is the most expensive single outlay I have had to absorb for replacing a sewer line through a bunch of other utilities. Other than a hail storm last year that took out 20 of my roofs I have never had 2 big items hit the same month. The hailstorm is a story by itself that is not finished enough to tell yet. Good luck. You are betting on appreciation and it is working, but it has danger. Figure out what makes you sleep well at night.
6 months reserve operating expenses for your business. A valid passport, and a getaway vehicle.
If the appreciation is really ballooning, maybe take your profits while the market is up, load up on liquidity and be ready to scoop up something really good when it goes to hell.
Phoenix is a very bi-polar market. When its up, its really up, but when it's down it is keying your car and trying to kill you.
I would have to respectfully disagree with your analysis of the Phoenix market. Greater Phx is one of the most steadily increasing markets in the Nation. Perhaps you were referring to our neighbors to the West...?
With the exception of the "crater" that every state experienced in 2007-2012, Phoenix is a steady Eddy of real estate. We net anywhere from 60-90K Californians and other "transplants" per year, which keep our market healthy and growing continuously for the past several decades. We don't see huge leaps and low valleys because our increase has also been slow and steady. Unless, and until we stop seeing so many new transplants into our market, our market will continue it's steady growth. Additionally, we have all but recovered from the nationwide housing crash. So, anyone holding real estate when the crash came, has recovered by now if they are still holding the property. In fact, in many instances, they may have more equity now.
I don't know where you are getting your information, but it isn't from historical data of the Phoenix market. At least not for the past 23 years that I have been a licensed Realtor with active knowledge of the market.
@Account Closed You're doing a wise thing by seeking this input and engaging with the different viewpoints well! I think a lot of this comes down to personal risk tolerance, among other factors. Like all things investing (and perhaps in life) diversification is prudent and safeguards from pitfalls, so in my personal investing when the portfolio gets a little too heavy in old properties with high CapEx liabilities I look to sprinkle in some new properties with low CapEx liabilities. For you, your future 30-years from now is lovely and bright and the prudent question is how do you "safely" weather the next three decades? With newer properties, low-equity, and a more-volatile-than-average appreciation market you may find that sprinkling in some Out 0f Area properties with extremely high equity could be a prudent move as it would increase your total equity and stabilize your portfolio. Otherwise you may find that cash on hand up to 144 years is what it takes.
In general, a lot of this will come down to your personal comfort level and your downside forecasting and knowing exactly how you should weather those storms. At any rate, though, diversification is a boon!
@Account Closed as others pointed out, being 90% leveraged, you would be lucky to to not owe money if you sold those properties today (after selling expense). So you don't have $1M, you have $0 net worth in those properties. Honestly if the economy went to hell and you couldn't rent the houses, you would probably be better off just letting them go to foreclosure. That is what over-leveraged investors did back in 2009/2010.
Have enough reserves to cover the mortgage for a couple months and for a major repair. Maybe $15,000 or so is probably enough.
For new acquisitions you should target the 1% rule, so the rent is 1% of the purchase price. Right now you are at 0.59% which tells me you paid too much or the properties do not make good rentals.
You are in a good market, so assuming nothing really bad economically happens, you should be fine. Rents and values will go up and you will have a better position in five or ten years.
@Joe Splitrock I never said I had $1M in net worth. I think I made it pretty clear that I’m highly leveraged which kind of implies that I have low net worth in these investments. Maybe you just needed to get some criticizing off your chest?!
Following it up by saying I only need a couple months in reserves is literally insane.
People who were highly leveraged with hefty cash positions during the crash did not foreclose unless it was a strategic foreclosure. I think people all too often consider all debt as bad debt. Debt that is insured by hefty cash reserves is still good debt IMHO. The question is, what kind of reserves do I need as an insurance policy to make sure I’m in that same position in the event of a massive disaster?
For someone that’s not active in real estate investing (by that I mean flips and brrr type Value add construction type things) the strategy your using is my favorite. I think I have a similar view of leverage as you basically the more long term fix low interest debt the better as long as you have proper reserves.
I  prescribe to a 3,000 year old investment  Philosophy that basically says divide your wealth in 3 even parts 1 part real estate 1 part business 1 part reserves.
I do this with my business being flipping and vacation rental management. Plus owning rentals. Plus reserves.
I also think that having reserves in a depreciating currency long term isn’t that smart play so I would maybe even hold reserves in something like gold and silver so you hedge your reserves against inflation.
As for your reserves I would say be conservative and go 100k plus. If you have 10% reserves and 90% leverage in my opinion your a lot better off that 82% leverage and 2% reserves.
@Zachary Beach I could not agree more with your last statement about leverage vs. reserves. I love the idea of hedging against inflation with something like holding my reserves (or a portion thereof) in gold, thank you.
People see 90% leverage and just love to light you up disregarding all other factors. Personally I want to have enough reserves to be as passive as possible about my investments. I know everyone loves the idea of flipping, BRRRR, value add, forced appreciation, etc. My trade off is moving every year. This is what I love about REI, no two situations or sets of goals are the same.
@Will Fraser I’ve dabbled with the idea of focusing on a VRBO property to supplement my cash flow issue. I understand the Phoenix market and the Phoenix market alone so out of state investing is a bit out of my wheelhouse. Same concept though, increased cap rate. Thanks for the insight!
@Cory Binsfield thank you. I am skeptical of lines of credit for the exact reason you mentioned.
All of my loans are 30 year conventional up to this point. I'm not trying to take advantage of the FHA rules, but was pointing out that it is an option on the next quad if need be.
I'm curious why you'd deem this strategy a house of cards though. Sure, I'm taking on high leverage but from my perspective having the cash reserves to carry PITI through 24 months at 100% vacancy is the exact opposite. At 50% occupancy or 50% rent crater I'd still be able to carry all 3 investments for four years. That's why I'm here though...to watch others poke holes in my strategy so that I can correct course! Do your worst!! Seriously though, I appreciate the critique.
I mention a house of cards because you are 95% leveraged in a cyclical market.
The difference is I'm in a linear market. During the big sub-prime bust, my market only fell by 20% or so. Leverage is far less risky in my market due to strong rental demand and high barriers to entry when it comes to the new housing stock.
Yet, I knew I was juggling a house of cards as I continued to scale up with 5-10% down. I just want you to be aware of the risks and consider trying to create stronger cash flow so you won't have to carry large reserves or feed the Aligator with out of pocket cash.
Check out this chart.
I don't know your exact PITI, but I'm assuming it is around $5,500 per month on 30-year fixed. At 4 years (no vacancy, no CAPEX, management, maintenance) how do you come up with a 4-year cushion?
Again, nothing wrong with leverage. This is how I got started and your reserves are much higher than when I started out!