HELP!!! Cash Flow Seems to Good to Be True! What Am I Missing

HELP!!! Cash Flow Seems to Good to Be True! What Am I Missing

Realtor · Monmouth County · Member since 2020 · 95 posts · 37 votes

My partner and I have been reading a lot recently about how hard it is to buy a property in New Jersey that produces positive cash flow.

We made an offer that has been accepted on a property in Perth Amboy NJ and so this sentiment has us nervous. After running the analysis we see this property is significantly cash flow positive but we can't help but feel that we might be missing something. The numbers are as follows...

Accepted Price: $275K

Units: 6

Rent per unit: $800 ($4,800 per month total)

Vacancy: $480 (10% of Gross rents); Maintenance and Repairs: $480 (10% of Gross Rents); CAPEX: $350; Taxes: $917; Insurance: $833

The tenants are paying for utilities separately so there's nothing budgeted for that. not sure what to expect for common area expenses .

Mortgage: $898

Total monthly cash flow of $842.

Would appreciate any insight on what we might be missing???

2Reply
281 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Beaumont, TX · Member since 2016 · 171 posts · 277 votes
6y

You mention: "Definitely, all the apartments needs cosmetic work and to be updated. This building was built in the early 1900-1920. I did go thru it with my contractor and roof will need to be replaced as well."

So figure ~$40,000 in roof replacement and cosmetic updates for 6 units. How much can you bump rents after the updates?

I don't see a budget for Property Mgmt, so I'm assuming you will self manage, but factor in the time you will need to do showings for lease ups and other things related to property mgmt.

Who does lawn maintenance if any? Did you factor in quarterly pest control? 

Class A area or Class C area for tenants?  If Class C and the asset is 100 years old, repairs and maintenance will be higher unless plumbing and electrical was completely re-done within the past 20 years

See this reply in the discussion

64 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Monmouth County · Member since 2020 · 95 posts · 37 votes
    6y

    @Rich Somers neighborhoodscout.com is so cool, thank you so much!

  • Member since 2019 · 7 posts · 6 votes
    6y

    @Sarah Bancob how is your mortgage $898 on a 275k property?

  • Investor · St Petersburg, FL · Member since 2014 · 231 posts · 221 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Soua Vang:

    @Sarah Bancob how is your mortgage $898 on a 275k property?

     Looks like Principle and Interest only, since she itemized insurance and taxes, and <25% down.

  • Rental Property Investor · Brooklyn NY / Upstate, NY · Member since 2019 · 52 posts · 46 votes
    6y

    @Sarah Bancob

    The only other expense besides the mentioned snow removal is landlord electric probably about $100. Everything else seems legit. I’d chalk it up nerves. Besides for 6 doors that cashflow at $850 doesn’t seem over the moon.

  • Investor · Atlanta · Member since 2018 · 65 posts · 68 votes
    6y

    @Sarah Bancob

    We need to understand why is it so cheap? It’s priced like a single-family home.

  • Realtor · Monmouth County · Member since 2020 · 95 posts · 37 votes
    6y

    @Chloey M. is not that cheap when you factor the money we will have to put into the building to renovate.  Like I said, it needs a new roof and all 6 apartments will have to be updated.  Also, the outside of the building needs painting.

  • Owen DashnerPro Member
    Lender · Omaha, NE · Member since 2008 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    If this is not a high crime/unsafe area, this looks like a great deal - even if you have quite a bit of CapEx to do. You should be able to update the exterior, then go through and update the units as they vacate, raise rents, then refi and get all your money back out. It should still cashflow like a boss! Nice find.

  • Investor · Vancouver BC · Member since 2020 · 88 posts · 60 votes
    6y

    After all that checking, you have a (almost) 2%er which is a pretty good deal.  

  • Rental Property Investor · Boston, Massachusetts (MA) · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    @Sarah B. Don’t see water and sewer on here which can be considerable. Landscaping and snow may have been mentioned. Garbage collection? Also, check current smoke situation and code, there have been lots of mandated upgrades lately in our state and maybe the same there. Another 5-15k to hardwire and upgrade panel if needed.

    But At 800 a 1 bed I’d be VERY concerned about the tenants ability to pay going forward and who is already behind.

    Not saying it’s a bad deal by any means, but u may be working fairly heard for your money

  • Realtor · Monmouth County · Member since 2020 · 95 posts · 37 votes
    6y

    Thanks everyone for your advise and pointers, I have definitely learned a lot and I am better prepared to go forward without feeling so nervous.  I will be implementing a lot of the ideas mentioned in this discussion.

  • Rental Property Investor · New York, NY · Member since 2013 · 136 posts · 101 votes
    6y

    @Yonia B. This is a 6-unit, so I would think you'll have to go with a commercial mortgage, which is not going to be 30 years fixed. You're probably looking at a 20 yr mortgage at 4%+, fixed for first 5 years, at around $1200/mo. 

  • Member since 2020 · 119 posts · 56 votes
    6y

    @Sarah B.

    Are those the monthly taxes or annual? Jersey girl here.. we own two properties and pay 15k in property taxes..

  • Member since 2020 · 119 posts · 56 votes
    6y

    @Kimberly Carver sorry I read too quickly- I see now those are monthly taxes.. sorry!

    Will you pay water/sewage?

  • Specialist · DETROIT · Member since 2019 · 116 posts · 243 votes
    6y

    We are in the process of selling a 4plex to one of our favorite clients for $185,000 and we are placing section 8 as a courtesy. Now all four units are 3 bedroom units not 1 bedroom units like yours. It's actually 5,000 SQFT Beauty. Also built in the 1920's. So much character!! SOOO BEAUTIFUL. Bricks are in great shape and all so clean also. Anyways, one of our favorite section 8 agencies is telling us that they will tenant each of our 3 bedroom UNITS (Not SFR) at $1266 a month. Soo 1266 x 4 + 5,064! We were originally thinking $1000 a unit section 8 but nope $1266! They did just tenant one of our duplex units at $977 so $1266 does make sense. WE LOVE THEM LOL :))) So talk about to good to be true.. So what you are discussing doesn't sound to far fetched after all! Our deal is well above the 3% rule yours sounds like its almost the 2% rule. A Perhaps money is just not that important to him. Orrr he might not have any children who deserve it and he realizes he cant take it to the grave lol .. O well, Happy Hunting everyone !!

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2018 · 15 posts · 1 vote
    6y

    I'd triple your maintenance and repairs on a building from the early 1900's. 

  • Specialist · DETROIT · Member since 2019 · 116 posts · 243 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Isaura Orellana:

    We are in the process of selling a 4plex to one of our favorite clients for $185,000 and we are placing section 8 as a courtesy. Now all four units are 3 bedroom units not 1 bedroom units like yours. It's actually 5,000 SQFT Beauty. Also built in the 1920's. So much character!! SOOO BEAUTIFUL. Bricks are in great shape and all so clean also. Anyways, one of our favorite section 8 agencies is telling us that they will tenant each of our 3 bedroom UNITS (Not SFR) at $1266 a month. Soo 1266 x 4 + 5,064! We were originally thinking $1000 a unit section 8 but nope $1266! They did just tenant one of our duplex units at $977 so $1266 does make sense. WE LOVE THEM LOL :))) So talk about to good to be true.. So what you are discussing doesn't sound to far fetched after all! Our deal is well above the 3% rule yours sounds like its almost the 2% rule. Anyways, we could have raised the price but because we love our clients and they've purchased a handful of properties from us already in the past year we were happy to give them such a good deal. Same might be true with the old man. Perhaps money is just not that important to him. Orrr he might not have any children who deserve it and he realizes he cant take it to the grave lol .. O well, Happy Hunting everyone !!

     Don't forget to mention that 4plex is in Detroit, isn't it. 

    With your own money, do you personally buy and hold in Detroit as well? or do you just sell them to other people. 

  • Specialist · DETROIT · Member since 2019 · 116 posts · 243 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Isaura Orellana:

    We are in the process of selling a 4plex to one of our favorite clients for $185,000 and we are placing section 8 as a courtesy. Now all four units are 3 bedroom units not 1 bedroom units like yours. It's actually 5,000 SQFT Beauty. Also built in the 1920's. So much character!! SOOO BEAUTIFUL. Bricks are in great shape and all so clean also. Anyways, one of our favorite section 8 agencies is telling us that they will tenant each of our 3 bedroom UNITS (Not SFR) at $1266 a month. Soo 1266 x 4 + 5,064! We were originally thinking $1000 a unit section 8 but nope $1266! They did just tenant one of our duplex units at $977 so $1266 does make sense. WE LOVE THEM LOL :))) So talk about to good to be true.. So what you are discussing doesn't sound to far fetched after all! Our deal is well above the 3% rule yours sounds like its almost the 2% rule. Anyways, we could have raised the price but because we love our clients and they've purchased a handful of properties from us already in the past year we were happy to give them such a good deal. Same might be true with the old man. Perhaps money is just not that important to him. Orrr he might not have any children who deserve it and he realizes he cant take it to the grave lol .. O well, Happy Hunting everyone !!

     Don't forget to mention that 4plex is in Detroit, isn't it. 

    With your own money, do you personally buy and hold in Detroit as well? or do you just sell them to other people. 

    Good evening David, Yes it is in Detroit! Thank you for pointing that out. Bit of a personal question there but yes my husband and I hold a considerable amount of property personally but our motto is everything is always for sale. It’s a constant revolving door with us so we are buying and selling week in and week out so we are always holding a significant amount of property at any given time. Why do you ask? Were  you thinking we should have hung onto the 4 unit? We seriously did think about it but we have an awesome 21 & 22 unit we are targeting at the moment and these particular clients really are dear to our hearts. So if it’s a win win we take it and just keep it moving!

  • Specialist · Portland, OR · Member since 2019 · 81 posts · 88 votes
    6y

    I would recommend spending ample time in the neighborhood, walking the streets, talking to neighbors etc.
    Sometimes if something seems too good to be true... it actually is.

    Years ago when my wife's company got moved to UT we moved and tried to use it as an investment/advancement opportunity (because homes were selling at a fraction of what they were in Portland)... We bought our first 4plex in what appeared in our visit/search to be a good "up and coming" neighborhood. 

    The numbers were great, we got it for a steal and felt AMAZING!! 
    Until... we showed up, the place was full of squatters, every pipe in the building had burst because it hadn't been winterized and we found out that it and the 4plex next door that shared the driveway/parking had literally been used as the drug house/brothel in town (in UT??  Hadn't seen that coming).

    What we thought would be a cosmetic fixer turned full gut and mid-reno we ended up having to buy the 4plex next door to have any chance of renting our places.  We now found ourselves renovating 8 very bad units (with time we didn't have and we hadn't counted on borrowing/spending), chasing off prostitutes, watching people literally fight each other for the scraps of copper pipe we were tossing into the bin, and waking up at 1am each night to chase away people showing up to buy drugs as soon as they got out of the local penitentiary... 

    Nightmare is probably the best description, and even after the blood sweat tears (and absurd cash we dumped into it), we broke even or lost money for years before finally admitting it was a massive mistake and ditching it to break even a couple years ago.

    All that said... we learned a TON, and we proved to ourselves that if we could make it through that we can make it through anything! ;)

    Biggest lesson: If there's one thing you can't control, upgrade or buy your way out of it's a bad neighborhood/reputation.  Spend some time on the ground making sure, and then if you still feel good about the place and the type of tenants you're likely to get - go for it!!

    Hope it turns out as good as it looks on paper!!

  • Member since 2020 · 2 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    We own multiple units in Detroit as out of state investors. My business partner and I are actually the people who are buying the 4-plex mentioned in the original post by Michigan Cash Flow Properties. Their deals are legit and this company is 100% honest and straightforward. I don’t put my trust in just anyone. They have delivered exactly what they were selling every time and that is the reason why I continue to do business with them. Detroit is a cash flow market and it’s delivering on it’s promise for us.
    We know that we will never live in Detroit so we look at it through a different lens. Having boots on the ground in this market is invaluable. The money is there to be made. We are seeing it hit the bank account every month. I have no problem with all of the advice about doing your due diligence but at some point, all investments are a leap of faith. Finding Michigan Cash Flow Properties on BP has transformed my real estate investment business and raised my profits beyond my expectations. Their deals are 100% legit. Darren Foy and his wife Isaura are killing it with Michigan Cash Flow Properties! I can’t put it any more clearly than that!

  • Rental Property Investor · Amityville, NY · Member since 2018 · 351 posts · 441 votes
    6y

    What is the arv on this? New Yorker here and this seems like a great deal!

  • Member since 2020 · 2 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    The ARV is 250K.

  • Rental Property Investor · Amityville, NY · Member since 2018 · 351 posts · 441 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Amy Burkholder:

    The ARV is 250K.

     That can't be right...

  • Investor · Marin County California · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    We all know that "You can't have **** in Detroit."  

  • Specialist · DETROIT · Member since 2019 · 116 posts · 243 votes
    6y

    Looks like all the haters came out to play Amy. Not even worth responding to. We will just keep raking in the cash flow and best rent to value ratios in the country while they roll around in there sandbox hating when they have zero experience with us, our properties or our city. Def, no need in sharing with them our countless references from around the country and world of our happy clients who are both thrilled with there properties, section 8 rents and tenants/covid cash paying tenants and rents as well as our management, oversight, placement and transparency. We LOVE Detroit!!

  • Member since 2020 · 9 posts · 5 votes
    6y

    @Sarah B. 2 questions 1) that property tax is monthly, correct? 2) the insurance must be for the year, but seems low for a 6 unit. When I run NJ numbers, they are usually cash flow positive, just not by a lot. Keep in kind, I’m still looking for my first.....

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.