Insurance is killing my rentals

Insurance is killing my rentals

Financial Services · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2015 · 80 posts · 40 votes

Can someone tell me what a normal amount is to pay for Insurance on low end rental properties? I own two rental properties in a 50/50 partnership in Birmingham, AL. 

Rental 1: Market Value ~50k. Insurance Payments are $1,829/year and rent is $590/mo. 

Rental 2: Market Value - $120k. Insurance Payments are $2,244/year and rent is $1,100/mo. 

Carrying Fire insurance 70k on the first and 100k on the second. Personal Liability $1MM on each. 

Does this seem in line with market rates? I feel like this is an absolutely ridiculous amount of money to pay to fire, water backup, and liability insurance. What are other people paying? Anyone you guys would recommend?

No loans on either of these properties. Would it be better to just not have insurance and be out the money in the minuscule chance that these houses burn down? I can always get personal umbrella coverage to cover the liability I think. 

Thanks,
Hobie

14Reply
824 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Member since 2020 · 26 posts · 52 votes
6y

I used to own an insurance agency. You need to find a broker that can shop for commercial rates. Stay away from the name brands Allstate, State Farm, Farmers, etc. they can do it but since they dont specialize in it they charge insane prices. Also you need to shop your insurance annually and a good commercial broker that works with multiple carriers can do that for you. 

See this reply in the discussion

111 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Dan DiFilippoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Fayetteville, NC · Member since 2020 · 251 posts · 244 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King JFC, mate! That's like two insurance bills! I mean, I don't specifically know your area, but that's abhorrent. Like 25% of your gross receipts? Brutal.

    As a general rule, I tell investors to diversify insurers and property managers as soon as practically possible. Even if you use one more heavily than the other, you never want all of your eggs in one basket. Whether it's because of an emergency situation, adverse operational changes, or increase in prices, you want to have the ability to just pack up your account and walk it across the street without even needing to vet the provider. It also subconsciously gives you a confidence boost when negotiating with your existing providers because you don't have the anxiety of being wholly dependent on them in the immediate term.

    Brookdale Property Management
  • Investor · Austin, TX · Member since 2014 · 217 posts · 170 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King

    You might try moving up the deductibles. I have a couple of units where I saw a big increase in premium so I just upped the deductible from 1k to 5k. I know I won’t be filing any small claims anyway. I keep it in place just so if there is a house fire or something huge, I don’t lose my shirt.

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, GA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    Those premiums are very high. However, you didn't provide the details that can affect policy rates. Some examples are history of previous losses, type of ownership, even your credit score can play into it.

    Did you shop various companies when the property was insured? or did someone else come up with this situation? Either way, I suspect you're way overpaying based on my experience insuring multiple properties. Another thing to watch for is that many insurance companies do "cramming" which is adding things to the policy that aren't required. On an auto policy an example of this would be things like road service and towing even though you didn't request that coverage. I have my insurance people strip policies down on a regular basis to save on premiums. Selecting a very low deductible can significantly add to the premium. Also various kinds of coverage are available such as replacement cost and actual cash value. If you have an old property with replacement cost, it's based on how much it would cost to rebuild the property, not what it's currently worth. Review the line items in the policy and see what it is you're being billed for.

  • Jeff HendersonPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Huntsville, AL · Member since 2020 · 44 posts · 15 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King try to compare with policy genius it will take your policy and run it against exact coverage and get you offers from a list of companies.

  • Investor · Peoria, AZ · Member since 2016 · 114 posts · 163 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King. I have 5 rentals between Kansas City and Atlanta. I pay about $70/month for each one. I use NREIG and they’ve been fantastic.

  • Rental Property Investor · ME · Member since 2018 · 179 posts · 59 votes
    6y

    I have 10 unit in rural town of 2k people, with sprinkler system with separate water supply owned by my llc and state farm charges $519 month for 1.4m replacement policy.  

    i think thats high 

    i tried cheaper brokers but they wont insure just this building due llc ownership  they want insure all my properties together which was higher.

  • Investor · Member since 2020 · 26 posts · 52 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Nathan S.:

    @Paul Brown

    Hi Paul,

    Any suggestions for finding a broker that can shop commercial rates? Is Google the best bet?

    Thanks

    Hi Nathan,

    Brokers are local and state by state. I am in Illinois so I can't really help with state specific details but here is some info. I am not sure how much you know about insurance so if I am giving you too basic of information then I apologize in advance. There are 2 types of "agencies / brokerages" in the insurance world. The first is “captive agents” who only represent one carrier "brand" like Allstate, State Farm, Farmers, American Family, etc. Most of the time the companies “carriers” they represent focus primarily on personal lines of insurance and they don't do alot of commercial. I want to be clear that these are good companies but often their hands are tied and since they don’t write a lot of commercial insurance policies they underwrite it hard and err on the side of caution meaning they often charge a lot to cover unexpected losses. It’s common that they offer commercial insurance to accommodate their personal lines customer base but price it high since it’s not their bread and butter. It's worth getting a price from them but they usually need all of your other insurance to make it competitive.

    "Brokers" on the other hand represent alot of different carriers which most you will have probably never heard of (which isn't a bad thing but always do your homework on the carrier and their ratings). To make it more confusing there are different types of "brokers" in the insurance world. Some focus on niches like medical, small business, personal etc. So you may call a broker and they don’t even do commercial real estate but ask them who does and get a referral. Note that when I say “commercial real estate” that is a generic term for non-personal insurance including landlord policies for single family and multi-family residential as well as typical office, industrial, etc.

    Here is my suggestion. I would call some local Captive agents and get some quotes. After you talk to the first one write down all of the millions of pieces of information they ask for and put a form / spreadsheet together listing all the details of your properties (ie: address, size, age, brick/frame, alarms, age of roof, etc). other brokers are going to need the same info. Having a “list” that you can send to others and on an annual basis to shop for rates is key…future you will thank present you for doing this! To find brokers I would start by checking with local real estate agents (commercial agents might be preferred), bankers, local Chambers of Commerce and obviously other local investors. Note that most brokers offer policies in their state or neighboring states due to licensing requirements. If you call a broker and they don’t handle commercial real estate ask for referrals as they probably know who in the area handles that type of risk. When you start working with brokers who are giving you quotes ask what carriers they represent and let other brokers know what “carriers” you are already getting quotes from so multiple brokers don’t submit your info to the same carriers. Again…these brokers represent multiple carriers so there will be some overlap here and there. Since you should now have all of your info in a single document you can just email it to all the brokers so you don’t have to spend hours on the phone with them. Carriers’ rates change year to year depending on their losses so you should repeat this process every year or so. It’s important to note though that having a solid relationship with an insurance agent/broker is key for building a good team so I wouldn’t switch or hop around each year unless the savings was substantial as a good insurance agent is worth his/her weight in gold. What you are paying for is not only coverage from the carrier but advice, guidance and service from the agent/broker.

    ***NOTE: I AM NO LONGER AN INSURANCE AGENT AND HAVEN'T BEEN FOR YEARS BUT THIS IS MY PERSONAL OPINION/RECOMMENDATION

  • Rental Property Investor · Lehigh Valley, PA · Member since 2017 · 200 posts · 191 votes
    6y

    That sounds extremely high. I pay as little as $550 in AZ and $900 in PA for 3-4-bedroom rentals. Did you call your agent and ask them to explain the factors that are driving up the price? I have a few pre rehab properties that were canceled after the exterior inspection because they were vacant and in disrepair. Are your rentals in good shape?

  • Rental Property Investor · Boston, MA · Member since 2019 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Nadia O. I tried getting a quote from Lemonade and the Virtual Assistant said they do not cover properties that are rented out?

  • Member since 2020 · 20 posts · 9 votes
    6y

    @Stephen DeThample

    Sean Halpin - MJH Insurance mjhins.com

    Do you have an agent you are working with? I found a great agent who found me a killer deal.

    Krista Ybarra - RE/MAX Premiere

  • Member since 2020 · 82 posts · 100 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Bud Gaffney:

    @Nadia O. I tried getting a quote from Lemonade and the Virtual Assistant said they do not cover properties that are rented out?

    You’re right! I bought it as a homeowner insurance. I was living there a few years ago. I just never change to a diff one. Even I have renters living there now, I never bother to change to a new one. Honestly I have never made claims on my insurance. Therefore I want to cheapest ins as coverage so that at least if something big happens, my place is insured

  • Rental Property Investor · Amityville, NY · Member since 2018 · 351 posts · 441 votes
    6y

    @Ryan Cleary

    Who is your carrier for property here?

  • Rental Property Investor · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2020 · 15 posts · 10 votes
    6y

    @Nadia O.

    Hi Nadia, thanks for the info.

    I’d recommend speaking with an insurance professional licensed in your state. I don’t think an insurance company would pay out for a claim if it’s an old policy from when you lived there. So, in an effort to save money, you are instead paying premiums for potentially no coverage.

    I am not an insurance agent, but do know that it was very important for me to have a new policy written when my use changed from primary to rental.

  • Rental Property Investor · Rockford, IL · Member since 2014 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    @Hobart King,

    Those numbers do sound a bit high. That said, your chances of damage due to hurricane / tropical storm remnants look to be considerable, especially with what we've seen this year. The outlook going forward is, well, less than "rosy".

    My $0.02 ...

  • Title Representative · Denver, CO · Member since 2020 · 126 posts · 66 votes
    6y

    Thank you all for this thread. I didn't realize there were better rates. I searched a couple of times, but you've given me more sources to check.

  • Investor · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2016 · 315 posts · 206 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King

    I have homes in C neighborhoods. Homeowners insurance are about $1150 a year each with Progressive.

    Add taxes makes it $2168 and $2028 and $2145 each annually.

    Two years ago I bought brand new all brick house for 150 k that cost $575 a year insurance plus 1600 for a total of $2167 annually.

    So I pay the same amount for taxes and insurance on a house that is half of new brick home. The reason is the city and county each are in.

    Good luck

    G

  • Investor · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2016 · 315 posts · 206 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King

    It also depends on the zip codes. Some C neighborhoods in Birmingham/ Jefferson County are ok. Some are stealing zones and the worst are shooting and stealing. When you are looking at a property be sure to ride around the neighborhood and talk to the people who work it such as postmen utility workers first responders. Insurance companies do know these high risk zones due to claims. Good luck JP

  • Property Manager · Conway, AR · Member since 2020 · 29 posts · 4 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King - What insurance carrier are you with?

    My girlfriend is actually the territory manager for the entire state of Arkansas for State Auto.  I have ALL my rentals through that company and they are awesome to deal with.  Best Price, Awesome Service!  I know a few others investors in the Alabama area and I know a few of them use State Auto but I'm unsure of the others.

    Reach out if you need a good local contact and I'm sure I can help you out!

    Good luck

  • Financial Services · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2015 · 80 posts · 40 votes
    6y

    @John Patton

    It’s not that bad of an area. It’s adjacent to Crestwood North and south of the tracks of Woodlawn. There’s definitely poverty and vacant houses there but I think crime is low (closer to CW North than Woodlawn). I think I may be getting screwed somehow by it being close in proximity to Woodlawn and East Lake. I’ve gotten high quotes from virtually every insurer I’ve looked at. The one I have is high but actually LOWER significantly than other quotes I’ve got. Seriously it’s just insane.

  • Financial Services · Birmingham, AL · Member since 2015 · 80 posts · 40 votes
    6y

    @Marc Rice

    Good idea I’ll reach out and see what the savings are.

    I see you are from Columbus! Nice city lived there 6 years prior to moving back to Bham, AL. Boy do I wish when I moved there in 2013 I had bought a house in Italian Village (rented an apt there).

  • Marc RiceBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Originally posted by @Hobart King:

    @Marc Rice

    Good idea I’ll reach out and see what the savings are.

    I see you are from Columbus! Nice city lived there 6 years prior to moving back to Bham, AL. Boy do I wish when I moved there in 2013 I had bought a house in Italian Village (rented an apt there).

    Small world! Columbus is crazy hot right now. Italian Village has definitely changed immensely since then! Hot market.

    Marc Rice | Investor Friendly Agent at Reafco Tailwind Team574 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · Frederick, MD · Member since 2020 · 14 posts · 10 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King

    That seems like a lot. Are you sure those are monthly rates?

    Have you shopped around? Try to find a good independent agent

  • Member since 2019 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    6y

    Use NREIG for rental property...

  • Member since 2020 · 1 post · 0 votes
    6y

    @Hobart King we are on the same boat. Six unit complex. Commercial insurance via Statefarm.

    $247/mo 2m liability- 5k deductible- 350k cash value. Property appraised at 210k - 5900sqft

    Property under Llc located in near Wilkesboro, nc.

    I feel like we are paying way too much.

    If anyone has any suggestions please let us know. I checked Lemonade Insurance and they are not in that area. Thanks in advance.

  • Andrew SyriosPro Member
    Moderator
    Residential Real Estate Investor · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2014 · 10k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    6y

    All bills suck so yeah, I agree. You could self-insure although I wouldn't recommend it (and no bank will allow it either, instead they'll put forced insurance on and you'll pay even ****ing more for your insurance).

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.