Am I wrong? Am I expecting too much from my real estate agent?

Am I wrong? Am I expecting too much from my real estate agent?

Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes

My wife and I are planning on relocating to East Tennessee to live and invest. We don't know much about the region other than what our research churns up (numbers, market forecasts, Google Earth views) and we really need a trusted partner to fill in those blind spots. 

Recently we've engaged with a realtor in Knoxville who has been willing to show us properties and fill in some details that aren't on the MLS listing. But when we ask "Is this a good neighborhood for rentals?" or "In your opinion, how many thousands will a rehab cost?" we get nothing. To the first question it's usually, "I have no idea," and to the second question, our agent won't even offer an estimate, a ballpark. We know that estimating a firm number on a rehab is somewhat foolish (things often go way over budget) but we are looking for a starting point and find a dead end.

My question to you fine folks: Am I expecting too much? I don't want to have someone do all our work and maybe I'm being a little selfish here. But this could be a beneficial relationship for us both as we plan on buying a 4 bedroom house to live in as well as several properties to rent for cash flow. 

I really don't know. 

12Reply
187 views

Most Popular Reply

Russell BrazilBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Agent · Washington, D.C. · Member since 2012 · 17k+ posts · 30k+ votes
5y

If they comment on the quality of the neighborhood, and there is a Fair Housing tester making that call, they may end up with a $16,000 fine for illegal steering.

See this reply in the discussion

69 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Christopher B.:
    Originally posted by @Jeff Terry:

    My wife and I are planning on relocating to East Tennessee to live and invest. We don't know much about the region other than what our research churns up (numbers, market forecasts, Google Earth views) and we really need a trusted partner to fill in those blind spots. 

    Recently we've engaged with a realtor in Knoxville who has been willing to show us properties and fill in some details that aren't on the MLS listing. But when we ask "Is this a good neighborhood for rentals?" or "In your opinion, how many thousands will a rehab cost?" we get nothing. To the first question it's usually, "I have no idea," and to the second question, our agent won't even offer an estimate, a ballpark. We know that estimating a firm number on a rehab is somewhat foolish (things often go way over budget) but we are looking for a starting point and find a dead end.

    My question to you fine folks: Am I expecting too much? I don't want to have someone do all our work and maybe I'm being a little selfish here. But this could be a beneficial relationship for us both as we plan on buying a 4 bedroom house to live in as well as several properties to rent for cash flow. 

    I really don't know. 

     Hey Jeff, I am mobile and haven't had time to read through all the posts so excuse me if that has already been stated. 

    Agents have to abide by Fair Housing laws so are not allowed to answer the question "is this safe". Some may but technically they aren't supposed to. They will direct you to crime maps and data sources for your own research. DM and I will be happy to give you some insight into the different areas though (I am not agent). 

    For your 2nd question, "what is the rehab cost". Well, that is a toughy for anyone but especially agents. No offense to agents at all, there are some excellent agents out there but I have found most know little to nothing about the nuts and bolts of houses much less the cost to fix them. They're sales people. To be fair, what needs to be done or will be done isn't always 100% objective either. I am a GC, you could send me and another GC into a property  and we could come up with wildly different #'s if we're not on the same page on what the end goal is. Even if we were it still could be wildly off from eachothers #'s.

    My wife is an agent. She rarely takes on buyers as she mostly uses her license to support our real estate business but she knows the game from both angles of retail and investment. If you're looking for referrals on a good agent(s) to interview I can connect you two, she knows some excellent agents in town she could introduce you to that work both retail and investors, just DM if you want. 

    Thank you, Christopher. I think your response exposed where my communication may have failed. My question was never about the safety of the neighborhood--only about the rental market there and if the numbers worked for decent cash flow. Being from Chicago, I know there are neighborhoods that are heavy rental areas and others with few to no expectations of rental opportunities. 

    I will certainly take you up on your offer and look forward to connecting. 

  • Brie SchmidtBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jeff Terry:
    Originally posted by @Christopher B.:
    Originally posted by @Jeff Terry:

    My wife and I are planning on relocating to East Tennessee to live and invest. We don't know much about the region other than what our research churns up (numbers, market forecasts, Google Earth views) and we really need a trusted partner to fill in those blind spots. 

    Recently we've engaged with a realtor in Knoxville who has been willing to show us properties and fill in some details that aren't on the MLS listing. But when we ask "Is this a good neighborhood for rentals?" or "In your opinion, how many thousands will a rehab cost?" we get nothing. To the first question it's usually, "I have no idea," and to the second question, our agent won't even offer an estimate, a ballpark. We know that estimating a firm number on a rehab is somewhat foolish (things often go way over budget) but we are looking for a starting point and find a dead end.

    My question to you fine folks: Am I expecting too much? I don't want to have someone do all our work and maybe I'm being a little selfish here. But this could be a beneficial relationship for us both as we plan on buying a 4 bedroom house to live in as well as several properties to rent for cash flow. 

    I really don't know. 

     Hey Jeff, I am mobile and haven't had time to read through all the posts so excuse me if that has already been stated. 

    Agents have to abide by Fair Housing laws so are not allowed to answer the question "is this safe". Some may but technically they aren't supposed to. They will direct you to crime maps and data sources for your own research. DM and I will be happy to give you some insight into the different areas though (I am not agent). 

    For your 2nd question, "what is the rehab cost". Well, that is a toughy for anyone but especially agents. No offense to agents at all, there are some excellent agents out there but I have found most know little to nothing about the nuts and bolts of houses much less the cost to fix them. They're sales people. To be fair, what needs to be done or will be done isn't always 100% objective either. I am a GC, you could send me and another GC into a property  and we could come up with wildly different #'s if we're not on the same page on what the end goal is. Even if we were it still could be wildly off from eachothers #'s.

    My wife is an agent. She rarely takes on buyers as she mostly uses her license to support our real estate business but she knows the game from both angles of retail and investment. If you're looking for referrals on a good agent(s) to interview I can connect you two, she knows some excellent agents in town she could introduce you to that work both retail and investors, just DM if you want. 

    Thank you, Christopher. I think your response exposed where my communication may have failed. My question was never about the safety of the neighborhood--only about the rental market there and if the numbers worked for decent cash flow. Being from Chicago, I know there are neighborhoods that are heavy rental areas and others with few to no expectations of rental opportunities. 

    I will certainly take you up on your offer and look forward to connecting. 

    We can answers those questions, things about market rents, vacancy, time to lease ect.  We just can't tell you what we think about the area or anything with crime, schools, demographics 

  • Rental Property Investor · Erie, PA · Member since 2018 · 84 posts · 462 votes
    5y

    So taking a 1,000 foot view from what you have described, and being a Realtor myself, it sounds like they are trying not to get themselves into trouble. Technically as a real estate agent, we are not supposed to give you advice outside of our expertise which is real estate sales. For instance I have over 130 doors, most of which needed full rehabs so I am very familiar with renovation costs. However I'm not a licensed contractor so am not an expert in that field. To give an example of how this could be a problem. I know a foundation issue could be fixed for 5-10k with a repair, and I tell you that it isn't that big of an issue and what I think it should cost, and then you hire a foundation guy who will only rebuild the whole wall which now costs 30k you could turn around and sue me. What an experienced agent should do is say "in the experience I have had this has what I've paid to correct the issue, however you need to speak with a proffesional in the field", and then I would give you the phone number for said proffessional.

  • Real Estate Agent · Reno / Sparks, NV · Member since 2013 · 174 posts · 59 votes
    5y

    Cost of repairs is relative to the renovations the investor is accustomed. I've seen some of my investors do a complete overhaul with top of the line, while others are extremely frugal. As an agent, I can give ranges, but it is really up to the investor-buyer to come up with a repair cost. We, the realtors, can come up with an estimated ARV for you, however, the repairs list should be evaluated by a contractor or handyman of the investors choice. Unless the agent is employed by your project (has skin in the game) it would not be wise for an agent to start throwing out numbers when that is such a subjective evaluation, in my opinion.

    An agent can education on the areas and certain factors that indicate desirability, like days on market and historical appreciation.

    Finding a real estate agent who is also a real estate investor is always a good idea. 

    Ginger

  • Karen MargraveBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Realtor, General Contractor, and Developer · Redding, CA · Member since 2009 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    Obviously most of the agents on here answering are not from CA. We have so many things we are not allowed to answer for fear of complaints, lawsuits, etc. Things like "is it a good area" are subjective. Good area for what? To live in or for child predators and drug addicts? Are there a lot of homeless in the area? Crime? Asking an agent if they would live somewhere or their family members, again is subjective, as you have no idea what their tolerance for different types of people are, it may be vastly different from yours.  I'd suggest driving around the area and looking at what you observe at different times of the day. Look at crime maps, read local news posts, etc.

    As to remodeling, the saying "you don't know what you don't know" applies.  I have been in real estate and construction for 30 years. We've developed new homes, office buildings, etc. However; we had never remodeled a home before, until we went to Oregon. It was  HUGE learning experience. There were things behind the walls that even being a licensed contractor didn't help me to anticipate. There were challenges due to weather that we hadn't experienced before (frozen ground and extremely short season for building) Giving someone any advice at all in regard to the cost to rehab a home is foolish, as there are too many unknowns. If you tell them x amount and it runs over by the thousands, are you going to make it up?  

    People buying real estate and rehabbing need to know the local markets, costs involved, familiarize themselves with the neighborhoods, etc. and be comfortable with their calculations. An agent doesn't necessarily know your financial situation, the cost of money you're using, your abilities, etc. only you know that. 

    The more information you know, the more you educate yourself about the local market before buying, the less risk. 

  • Realtor · Denver, CO · Member since 2019 · 5 posts · 3 votes
    5y

    @Jeff Terry

    As a realtor we legally aren’t supposed to talk about quality of neighborhood(at least in Colorado). With that being said, it’s a hard thing not to discuss and there are resources the agent probably has they could provide about the neighborhoods.

    Estimating costs is also difficult if they haven’t done many deals themselves or worked with other investors. I learned a big chunk of what I know from watching clients and asking questions.

    I would say you should talk with a realtor comfortable in investment real estate, or if you really like the realtor you are working with, see if there is opportunity to grow with your current realtor if they are interesting in learning more.

    Good luck!

  • Investor · Member since 2020 · 401 posts · 86 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Marc A. Thurston:

    One great source of locating knowledgeable agents is to talk to the local real estate appraisers in a given market. They will have first hand experience with which agents are dealmakers and who is an expert in the investing market.  Appraisers seek out and rely on the agents who have the most knowledge in a specialty.  

    Do the buyer choose the appraiser or the lender?How can find  an appraiser in my farm area? 

  • Crystal SmithPro Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Chicago, IL · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Jeff Terry:

    My wife and I are planning on relocating to East Tennessee to live and invest. We don't know much about the region other than what our research churns up (numbers, market forecasts, Google Earth views) and we really need a trusted partner to fill in those blind spots. 

    Recently we've engaged with a realtor in Knoxville who has been willing to show us properties and fill in some details that aren't on the MLS listing. But when we ask "Is this a good neighborhood for rentals?" or "In your opinion, how many thousands will a rehab cost?" we get nothing. To the first question it's usually, "I have no idea," and to the second question, our agent won't even offer an estimate, a ballpark. We know that estimating a firm number on a rehab is somewhat foolish (things often go way over budget) but we are looking for a starting point and find a dead end.

    My question to you fine folks: Am I expecting too much? I don't want to have someone do all our work and maybe I'm being a little selfish here. But this could be a beneficial relationship for us both as we plan on buying a 4 bedroom house to live in as well as several properties to rent for cash flow. 

    I really don't know. 

    In my opinion- Your first question- Is this a good neighborhood for rentals, could be answered by just giving you some data on rentals in the neighborhood so you could form your own opinion on whether it's good or not. What you consider good versus what I consider good could be 2 different things so ask for the data and form your own opinion. This naturally assumes that your agent's MLS has Residential Rental information.

    Regarding your 2nd question- How many thousands would a rehab costs? You're expecting too much from the agent unless that agent promoted themselves as someone that has a track record of being an investor themselves and completing renovations. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Providence, RI · Member since 2020 · 41 posts · 29 votes
    5y

    I think you have to find the right agent that can meet your needs and demands. I am an agent in RI and I specialize in working with investors because I am an investor myself as I can speak their language and I love helping people finds deals and walking them through the process. However, many agents are not interested in investing and they may not even own a home themselves. Interviewing multiple agents will be worth your while AND even more importantly no one is going to know everything, but if they are a good agent they will say "let me get back to you on that, I am not exactly sure" and they will follow through and find the answer. This in my opinion is just as important as knowing everything, it shows you they care and are willing to go the extra mile to learn something new to support you and your buying needs. 

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Brandon Penn:

    So taking a 1,000 foot view from what you have described, and being a Realtor myself, it sounds like they are trying not to get themselves into trouble. Technically as a real estate agent, we are not supposed to give you advice outside of our expertise which is real estate sales. For instance I have over 130 doors, most of which needed full rehabs so I am very familiar with renovation costs. However I'm not a licensed contractor so am not an expert in that field. To give an example of how this could be a problem. I know a foundation issue could be fixed for 5-10k with a repair, and I tell you that it isn't that big of an issue and what I think it should cost, and then you hire a foundation guy who will only rebuild the whole wall which now costs 30k you could turn around and sue me. What an experienced agent should do is say "in the experience I have had this has what I've paid to correct the issue, however you need to speak with a proffesional in the field", and then I would give you the phone number for said proffessional.

    Thank you for that example, Brandon. I can see how that situation would make a realtor hesitant about sharing info. I think I'll just ask for any contacts she might be willing to share and avoid the conversation with her entirely. Despite my reassurances that I'm just looking for a non-binding opinion, she may not feel comfortable. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Providence, RI · Member since 2020 · 41 posts · 29 votes
    5y

    I think you have to find the right agent that can meet your needs and demands. I am an agent in RI and I specialize in working with investors because I am an investor myself as I can speak their language and I love helping people finds deals and walking them through the process. However, many agents are not interested in investing and they may not even own a home themselves. Interviewing multiple agents will be worth your while AND even more importantly no one is going to know everything, but if they are a good agent they will say "let me get back to you on that, I am not exactly sure" and they will follow through and find the answer. This in my opinion is just as important as knowing everything, it shows you they care and are willing to go the extra mile to learn something new to support you and your buying needs. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Arvada, CO · Member since 2020 · 23 posts · 8 votes
    5y

    @Jeff Terry You need an investor agent. I can connect you with someone who is knowledgeable and specific to off market deals. I’d be glad to help & have linked a few individuals doing this same thing. Plus, it is a market I have been looking into so I have been screening some agents as well. Tough times because so many agents are money hungry and offer no value nor have any clue about the investment world. Be glad to link you up with some potential agents. Take care and be safe. Safe travels

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes
    5y

    @Joshua Christensen thank you for the thoughtful response! This absolutely helps.

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes
    5y

    @Nick Walts that’s amazing! Thank you. I’ll take you up on your offer.

  • Real Estate Broker · Albuquerque, NM · Member since 2015 · 285 posts · 232 votes
    5y

    @Jeff Terry Absolutely.  I'm happy to help.  Feel free to reach out any time.

    Joshua Christensen

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes
    5y

    @Wale Lawal Thanks for the great response, Wale — I really appreciate that approach and a great way to remember all those details!

  • Investor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2021 · 31 posts · 22 votes
    5y

    @Marc A. Thurston. Great advice- adding local appraisers to our list of people to contact.

  • Alecia S.Pro Member
    Mandeville, LA · Member since 2018 · 42 posts · 7 votes
    5y

    @Jeff Terry

    I would find a different agent. Not all real estate agents are created equally.

  • Member since 2021 · 1 post · 0 votes
    4y

    @Damaso Bautista

    Can you share the name of your Bloomington realtor?  I live in Bloomington and I'm trying to get started building a great investment team!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.