Cloudy title, but title company still willing to insure...

Cloudy title, but title company still willing to insure...

Rental Property Investor · MA · Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 0 votes

I have a property under contract. We just found out that the title isn't clear, there are other individuals that have vested interests that total a 44% ownership. These individuals were gifted their interests around 4 decades ago, so it's likely they're no longer around, perhaps they've left it to their kids/grandkids. 

Regardless of this, the title company is still willing to provide me with owner's title insurance that should cover the appraised value of the property. The title company is willing to do this because there's a very negligible chance that anyone with vested interest wins a claim to the property. 

So my question is this: the title of this property is definitely a bit sketchy, and I feel like it would normally be hard to obtain title insurance. If the title company is willing to provide insurance while knowing there are still vested interests in the property that total 44%, can I still rest easy with this deal knowing that the insurance policy will cover me in the case of a (very unlikely) future claim? 

I've searched through the forums and it seems like most others that are dealing with a cloudy title are mainly concerned with not being able to obtain title insurance because of it. But if I'm able to obtain title insurance, can I rest easy? Will this make resale in the future more difficult, or is it ok since I know that this title company will be able to insure in the future, too? 

0Reply
46 views

Most Popular Reply

Tom GimerBusiness Member
DMV · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
5y

@Reece Teramoto A title insurer cannot issue an LOI to itself so you need to clarify the title company vs. title insurer issue. Are there multiple insurers involved?

You're not going to get clear title here.

Obtaining a policy with an exception for the issue but an ALTA 34 would prevent a marketability claim, but give the insured coverage against loss caused by a challenge to title based on it.

Gimer Law518 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

12 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    5y

    I suspect the title insurer may have insured your seller and their policy does not have an exception for the outstanding interest.  I also suspect the amount you're paying and hence the amt your title policy will be for, is about the same as the prior policy.  Therefore there's little or no additional financial risk to the insurer in issuing the new policy.

    There are several things I think you need to consider before agreeing to accept the policy.

    First, if you improve the property and increase the value, or if it appreciates in value organically, then you will be self insured for that amt.  If the co-owners, be they the original parties or their heirs or beneficiaries appear and claim their interest, the insurer will make a decision based on their financial analysis.  Is it cheaper to defend against the adverse claim or pay you the amt of insurance and leave you to defend your title.

    Second, if the title insurer decides to defend and finds the adverse party can't be paid a reasonable amount to release their claim, you can wind up in litigation for awhile.  I've seen them go on for years.

    Third, if you want to sell or refinance, the buyer/lender doesn't have to accept a title policy from the same insurer and another insurer may not be willing to insure without some corrective action causing your sale/refi to fall apart.

    I hope this helps.  Good luck.

  • Tom GimerBusiness Member
    DMV · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    I would be sure to get coverage with an ALTA 34 endorsement.

    Gimer Law518 Reviews
  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:
    Originally posted by @Reece Teramoto:

    I have a property under contract. We just found out that the title isn't clear, there are other individuals that have vested interests that total a 44% ownership. These individuals were gifted their interests around 4 decades ago, so it's likely they're no longer around, perhaps they've left it to their kids/grandkids. 

    Regardless of this, the title company is still willing to provide me with owner's title insurance that should cover the appraised value of the property. The title company is willing to do this because there's a very negligible chance that anyone with vested interest wins a claim to the property. 

    So my question is this: the title of this property is definitely a bit sketchy, and I feel like it would normally be hard to obtain title insurance. If the title company is willing to provide insurance while knowing there are still vested interests in the property that total 44%, can I still rest easy with this deal knowing that the insurance policy will cover me in the case of a (very unlikely) future claim? 

    I've searched through the forums and it seems like most others that are dealing with a cloudy title are mainly concerned with not being able to obtain title insurance because of it. But if I'm able to obtain title insurance, can I rest easy? Will this make resale in the future more difficult, or is it ok since I know that this title company will be able to insure in the future, too? 

     It depends on how they write up the title insurance. If they are insuring "subject to 44% interest of unknown persons", I'd be a little concerned but not too much. 

    If they are insuring 100% "with full recognition of 44% potential interest of unknown persons", which I would be surprised if they would, then you should be fine.

    The way to clear this all up is to do a Quiet Title action. The process varies somewhat from state to state. Ask a real estate attorney in the state of the property.

    Quiet title is a type of legal procedure, not a cause of action.  You have to have a reason why the court should quiet the title against the adverse party's interest.  It's like recommending to foreclose, but the mortgage isn't in default.

    I don't know if there's a cause of action but a quiet title action is not a panacea.  

  • Tom GimerBusiness Member
    DMV · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Peter Walther Only a fool would reach out to the 44% owners and alert them of their interest.

    Gimer Law518 Reviews
  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    5y
    Originally posted by @Tom Gimer:

    @Peter Walther Only a fool would reach out to the 44% owners and alert them of their interest.

    Since I haven't seen the chain of title I don't know if I would be concerned about the outstanding interest or not, but if the insurer is offering to write over it, I'd be reluctant to close. 

  • China, ME · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    @Reece Teramoto  I was in this situation with a buyer about 3 years ago (I was their agent).  The seller was unaware that there were 12 owners, many deceased, with un-probated wills.  We required the seller to clear the title.

    It cost him about $25,000 to rush 12 wills through probate, but we got it done.  My advice to the buyers was to either require a clear title or walk away - unless they wanted to live with the fact that one of the inheritors could come back in the future and make a claim against their property - and as real estate values continue to climb, that scenario becomes more and more likely.

    All it takes is for one of the inheritors to get a sniff of money in the air and all hell's going to break loose.

  • Rental Property Investor · MA · Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 0 votes
    5y

    @Peter Walther, @Tom Gimer, @Account Closed--thanks so much for your replies! 

    Just to clarify, yes, the title company is offering to insure with full recognition of the other interests. The insured amount will be high enough such that reasonable appreciation, both forced and organic over the years, should still be less than the policy amount.

    Peter, you're right about this title company providing insurance for this property in a past sale, which is why they are willing to do this again. 

    The title company is likely willing to do issue a policy because they think there is a very small chance any person with interest in the property comes forward. 

    However, the bigger concern that I have is the refinancing/selling process. I do plan to refinance this property after rehabbing, and I don't plan on holding it forever--likely 5-7 years. I'd hate to have this prevent me from refinancing or making it more difficult to sell. 

    I'm definitely leaning towards requiring a clear title as Charlie mentioned.

    As another update on this, the title company that's willing to provide insurance (that's handled the past sale of this property) is also able to provide a letter of imdemnity to the title company that's currently assisting with the closing. 

    Do any of you know whether a letter of indemnity would help clear up the title or provide any additional reassurance? 

    Thanks for all of your advice! 

  • China, ME · Member since 2014 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    5y

    @Reece Teramoto One more thing - just remember that when the time eventually comes to sell, you'll have an (inferior) insurable title, not a (superior) marketable title.  

    Seriously, I'd insist that the seller clears the title.

  • Tom GimerBusiness Member
    DMV · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    5y

    @Reece Teramoto A title insurer cannot issue an LOI to itself so you need to clarify the title company vs. title insurer issue. Are there multiple insurers involved?

    You're not going to get clear title here.

    Obtaining a policy with an exception for the issue but an ALTA 34 would prevent a marketability claim, but give the insured coverage against loss caused by a challenge to title based on it.

    Gimer Law518 Reviews
  • Rental Property Investor · MA · Member since 2020 · 7 posts · 0 votes
    5y

    @Tom Gimer Yes, there are two title companies involved. The original one that the seller has chosen brought up the title issues, so they've reached back to the title company that had insured the title on a past sale of the property. The old title company is willing to provide a letter of indemnity to the new title company. I will admit that I don't completely understand the policy setup that you're describing, but does that setup only allow for additional protection in the case of a future claim? 

    The main concern I have is my future ability to sell the property and my future ability to refinance the property. It seems like the only way to ease those concerns is simply require a clear title as @Charlie MacPherson mentioned, which sounds expensive / time consuming from the seller's end. Is this understanding correct? 

  • Specialist · Winter Springs, FL · Member since 2009 · 1k+ posts · 747 votes
    5y

    Unfortunately, Letters of Indem (LOIs) are fairly common in the industry though generally their use in a transaction is not disclosed to the insured.  Fortunately, for you, in this case it was.  No you just have to make a decision on whether to close or not.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.