Hey Family,
So, I've watched every single youtube video and ready every single article; I'm talking months on end regarding wholesaling a property but most have been on properties valued at $150,000k or less.
Today, I got a real live deal, in the millions and have no idea what a fair offer should be.
The property is valued at $2 million, the rehab budget is $600,000 the ARV is $4 million and my desired wholesale fee is $200,000.
With this info, what should a fair offer be and can you kindly break it down? Thank you so much in advance.
I don't know about the community, but I would say that you sound too green to take on this deal. Does the $2m seller understand you are a wholesaler? How many wholesale deals have you done? If any, what is the highest price point you have wholesaled? Who on your list can come in hot with this much in cash to do the deal? And who came up with the rehab numbers on this? Answer this: why is this seller even talking to you? Do you have a proof of funds or a vetted million-dollar buyer list? It seems like the ultimate reach and very unlikely to come through if you don't have experience at this price point.
@Jonathan Greene
I would love to see this proposal offer as well. Haha
@Jonathan Greene in one post you claim you don't know me, don't know what I look like and don't know my experience, yet in another post claim to know what I'm capable or not capable of. So which one is it? Do you know me or don't know? Evidently, you demonstrate traits of one who is mentally unstable.
Based on your new round of unhelpful and unwanted questions, I'll simply say if needed assistance in how to close a deal, could have shown humility and asked, nicely.
Opposed to spending your weekend replying to the thread of an "unknown" you should be preparing for tomorrow, the first business day of the week and trying to close a deal. Truly, as stated, scroll by, quietly.
@Jonny Mcknight are you trolling us, or are you being serious right now?
If you are being serious then you need to take a step back and read what @Jonathan Greene has posted multiple times. The fact you think you are going to wholesale this off the MLS as your first ever wholesale is just.....wow. I'm not sure what to say other than, these are the reasons wholesalers get bad reputations. Countless people out there just watching some youtube videos and think they can just "get rich quick" from wholesaling. I feel bad for the people who actually run a legit wholesaling business as this makes it that much harder for them.
Oh well, it's obvious you are either trolling or not willing to take advice from someone who is experienced, so I will just say, best of luck to you. Please keep us updated on this entire situation. I truly hope you crush it and prove us all wrong.
@Derrick E. I would counter argue that it's pessimist and doubters who give the industry a horrible name. I appreciate your kind remarks towards the end. As with any deal, the only two people who's opinion matters are the seller and buyer, not trolls on the internet who have nothing to do with the deal and who's approval, beliefs or opinions are NOT needed for it to happen. Thankfully @Jonathan Greene is not the buyer nor seller in this case, that I can gladly confirm!
@Jonathan Greene
OP states that
1. For the last 6 months he’s watch every YouTube video and read every article on wholesaling
2. He has no ideal what to offer
3. He wants a $200,000 fee in his first post, and a $120,000 fee in his second post
4. The rehab budget is $600,000 in his first post and $500,000 in his second post
5. He has heard of the “70% rule” but has no idea how to calculate it
Obviously someone very new to the real estate field in general, and to flipping contracts in particular.
In something that we’ve seen a million times before, an inexperienced person asks advice in his first post, and when he doesn’t like the responses he grows argumentative, hostile, attacking and begins embellishing. We who have been “in the trenches” for years know that one or more of the following is “wrong” with the deal
1. The rehab is FAR in excess of $500,000 or $600,000.
2. The property has structural, foundation, or flood damage that makes it a tear down.
3. The property has an incurable defect, such as is in a flood way, which renders the property worth substantially less than it may appear to the inexperienced
4. The property is in a “war zone” and hence worth 25% of what it would be worth in a decent location
5. The comps used to reach a FMV are not comparable.
6. The property is a “white elephant” with a layout so undesirable that nobody is interested
7. The building is in such bad shape that it’s “highest and best” use would be to tear down and rebuild.
8. The property is very large tract home and the comps being used are large high end custom homes.
9. The property is being marketed using the strategy of asking a low initial bid price expecting this will draw many bidders and result in a bidding war with the final price being far in excess of the initial “bid” floor price
10. There is a title issue that will be hard, time consuming and costly to resolve
11. The person listing the property doesn’t have full ownership rights, and needs the signature of a co owner or spouse to sell, who knows nothing about the listing and wouldn’t sell it at anywhere near the list price
It then again what would I know? I haven’t watched every YouTube video or read every book on wholesaling.
@Jonathan Greene
OP states that
1. For the last 6 months he’s watch every YouTube video and read every article on wholesaling
2. He has no ideal what to offer
3. He wants a $200,000 fee in his first post, and a $120,000 fee in his second post
4. The rehab budget is $600,000 in his first post and $500,000 in his second post
5. He has heard of the “70% rule” but has no idea how to calculate it
Obviously someone very new to the real estate field in general, and to flipping contracts in particular.
In something that we’ve seen a million times before, an inexperienced person asks advice in his first post, and when he doesn’t like the responses he grows argumentative, hostile, attacking and begins embellishing. We who have been “in the trenches” for years know that one or more of the following is “wrong” with the deal
1. The rehab is FAR in excess of $500,000 or $600,000.
2. The property has structural, foundation, or flood damage that makes it a tear down.
3. The property has an incurable defect, such as is in a flood way, which renders the property worth substantially less than it may appear to the inexperienced
4. The property is in a “war zone” and hence worth 25% of what it would be worth in a decent location
5. The comps used to reach a FMV are not comparable.
6. The property is a “white elephant” with a layout so undesirable that nobody is interested
7. The building is in such bad shape that it’s “highest and best” use would be to tear down and rebuild.
8. The property is very large tract home and the comps being used are large high end custom homes.
9. The property is being marketed using the strategy of asking a low initial bid price expecting this will draw many bidders and result in a bidding war with the final price being far in excess of the initial “bid” floor price
10. There is a title issue that will be hard, time consuming and costly to resolve
11. The person listing the property doesn’t have full ownership rights, and needs the signature of a co owner or spouse to sell, who knows nothing about the listing and wouldn’t sell it at anywhere near the list price
It then again what would I know? I haven’t watched every YouTube video or read every book on wholesaling.
Great job! I'm going to keep this list as a reality check anytime I run into an underpriced property. Why so cheap?
@Don Konipol for the win.
@Jonny Mcknight yes, I think for everyone who reads both your posts and mine, it is me they think is mentally unstable. I have not disparaged you at all, I've asked you questions and you grew hostile because you aren't getting what you wanted. If you want to make it real, post the contract here, signed, as well as the MLS listing so we can help show you why you aren't doing this deal. Show us the money. Now, please hold, I need to get back to my padded room where I give real estate investing advice to my dolls.
@Don Konipol no.
@Jonathan Greene you still haven't answered the question.
If you would notice, others have contributed to the thread, they offered amazing advice and as a result we had a pleasant and positive exchange and I'm well on the way to securing a deal! You and your minority band of enablers chose to be negative, rude, hostile and you got the same energy back. Perhaps you should stick to playing with your dolls and avoid being a troll on the internet. Scroll, quietly.
What we have here boys and girls is an excellent example of how not to start out in the Bigger Pockets Forums. This is a great place to give and receive advice and information but it's not for everyone.
Actually, minus a few trolls, I got amazing advice and a now an ACCEPTED OFFER, an update. The seller is motivated! Rather, this here boys and girls, is an excellent example of how those who have something positive and sensible to contribute to a thread should be allowed to do so without having those helpful posts be convoluted with other posts that are rude, unwarranted and unhelpful by those with negativity, bitterness and jealously. Those folks should just scroll by and watch as those of us who can get deals done, do so.
THANK YOU SO much to all again who's advice made this offer happen and to others, do yourselves a favor and just leave posts alone that you have nothing of value to contribute to.
I will start by stating that I agree with those that indicate your posts seem to demonstrate that you are not ready for this "potential" opportunity. It either is not an opportunity or if it is an opportunity it likely is not for a first time wholesaler.
Now to your question, you seem to have applied the 70% rule correctly. Here is something about virtually all rules in RE (maybe virtually all math rules): The result is only as good as the inputs. In this case the inputs are the ARV, the cost of rehab (including holding costs), and your wholesale fee. Now something specific about the 70% rule: when the market is hot like it is now, finding 70% rule properties are a challenge. Experienced investors can turn solid profits with higher than 70% offers. Especially this size property does not typically need to meet the 70% rule to be profitable. My market has some rehabbers that can rehab at costs that far less than I can (and I have a fair amount of experience).
Those that are being pessimistic (realistic?) are in their way telling you to be careful. They fear that you are going to lose a lot of money or time.
Now for the questions for you to consider: Do you have access the the EM? Do you have a buyers list? Can you close if the buyers are too slow or are willing to lose you EM? If you can close, at what terms and how quick must you close to your buyer to not have holding costs consume your fees? Recognizing that I indicated in this market the 70% rule is tough to find, why do you think this is available? If it is on the MLS, why is there not a plethora of other offers? Do they know something that you do not?
Hill Street Blues: "Lets be careful out there".
Good luck
As they say, pics or it didn't happen. haha. I, for one, can't wait for your final update as I'm dying to see the house (and deal) in question. Good luck.
I will start by stating that I agree with those that indicate your posts seem to demonstrate that you are not ready for this "potential" opportunity. It either is not an opportunity or if it is an opportunity it likely is not for a first time wholesaler.
Now to your question, you seem to have applied the 70% rule correctly. Here is something about virtually all rules in RE (maybe virtually all math rules): The result is only as good as the inputs. In this case the inputs are the ARV, the cost of rehab (including holding costs), and your wholesale fee. Now something specific about the 70% rule: when the market is hot like it is now, finding 70% rule properties are a challenge. Experienced investors can turn solid profits with higher than 70% offers. Especially this size property does not typically need to meet the 70% rule to be profitable. My market has some rehabbers that can rehab at costs that far less than I can (and I have a fair amount of experience).
Those that are being pessimistic (realistic?) are in their way telling you to be careful. They fear that you are going to lose a lot of money or time.
Now for the questions for you to consider: Do you have access the the EM? Do you have a buyers list? Can you close if the buyers are too slow or are willing to lose you EM? If you can close, at what terms and how quick must you close to your buyer to not have holding costs consume your fees? Recognizing that I indicated in this market the 70% rule is tough to find, why do you think this is available? If it is on the MLS, why is there not a plethora of other offers? Do they know something that you do not?
Hill Street Blues: "Lets be careful out there".
Good luck
Dan, I appreciate you! THIS, ladies and gentlemen and how to be critical of a post, yet respectful at the same time! I am glad to answer your questions:
1) Basically this deal was handed to me through connections, BUT connections I WORKED on building! The realtor and I did business years ago, and we kept in contact over the years, holidays, birthdays etc, so naturally when I mentioned I was in real estate investing, there was years of established rapport and trust. As for the buyer, same situation, we did business in a completely different industry, but again a very healthy amount of trust, good will and rapport was built and when I mentioned I had properties to add to their portfolio, they literally begged me for a deal.
Disclosure: I completely acknowledge my privilege as most persons who get into wholesaling aren't best friends with both a developer and seller right off the bat. Nor do I want anyone getting started to think this is the case. I got lucky and fully acknowledge that. These just happen to be genuine relationships I built over years, not knowing I would get into wholesaling years later. I hope that info adds a bit more perspective.
What we have here boys and girls is an excellent example of how not to start out in the Bigger Pockets Forums. This is a great place to give and receive advice and information but it's not for everyone.
Actually, minus a few trolls, I got amazing advice and a now an ACCEPTED OFFER, an update. The seller is motivated! Rather, this here boys and girls, is an excellent example of how those who have something positive and sensible to contribute to a thread should be allowed to do so without having those helpful posts be convoluted with other posts that are rude, unwarranted and unhelpful by those with negativity, bitterness and jealously. Those folks should just scroll by and watch as those of us who can get deals done, do so.
THANK YOU SO much to all again who's advice made this offer happen and to others, do yourselves a favor and just leave posts alone that you have nothing of value to contribute to.
Good stuff man. Now that it's under contract, can you share the link to the listing so we can see the deal? Congrats on getting it under contract. How much EM did you have to put down for this particular deal?
What we have here boys and girls is an excellent example of how not to start out in the Bigger Pockets Forums. This is a great place to give and receive advice and information but it's not for everyone.
Actually, minus a few trolls, I got amazing advice and a now an ACCEPTED OFFER, an update. The seller is motivated! Rather, this here boys and girls, is an excellent example of how those who have something positive and sensible to contribute to a thread should be allowed to do so without having those helpful posts be convoluted with other posts that are rude, unwarranted and unhelpful by those with negativity, bitterness and jealously. Those folks should just scroll by and watch as those of us who can get deals done, do so.
THANK YOU SO much to all again who's advice made this offer happen and to others, do yourselves a favor and just leave posts alone that you have nothing of value to contribute to.
Real estate isn't just about pulling off one deal. You sound like you don't know what you are doing. Wholesaling illegally, especially high $ houses, is a risky business. My recommendation would be to figure out how to do what you are doing legally (every state is different), so even after you close and make that $100-$200k check you don't get sued by the previous owner. Trust me I've seen this happen to wholesalers before. Multiple times, for much lower priced RE.
What we have here boys and girls is an excellent example of how not to start out in the Bigger Pockets Forums. This is a great place to give and receive advice and information but it's not for everyone.
Actually, minus a few trolls, I got amazing advice and a now an ACCEPTED OFFER, an update. The seller is motivated! Rather, this here boys and girls, is an excellent example of how those who have something positive and sensible to contribute to a thread should be allowed to do so without having those helpful posts be convoluted with other posts that are rude, unwarranted and unhelpful by those with negativity, bitterness and jealously. Those folks should just scroll by and watch as those of us who can get deals done, do so.
THANK YOU SO much to all again who's advice made this offer happen and to others, do yourselves a favor and just leave posts alone that you have nothing of value to contribute to.
Good stuff man. Now that it's under contract, can you share the link to the listing so we can see the deal? Congrats on getting it under contract. How much EM did you have to put down for this particular deal?
I will once the deal is closed! One step at a time and yes, I fully acknowledge I'm doing things in the reverse. Most start off by finding deals, finding buyers and nourishing those relationships. I'm starting off with years of existing nourished relationships and pretty much connecting my network, which is one's net worth! I'm just truly blessed that things have gotten this far! Will keep the community updated!
What we have here boys and girls is an excellent example of how not to start out in the Bigger Pockets Forums. This is a great place to give and receive advice and information but it's not for everyone.
Actually, minus a few trolls, I got amazing advice and a now an ACCEPTED OFFER, an update. The seller is motivated! Rather, this here boys and girls, is an excellent example of how those who have something positive and sensible to contribute to a thread should be allowed to do so without having those helpful posts be convoluted with other posts that are rude, unwarranted and unhelpful by those with negativity, bitterness and jealously. Those folks should just scroll by and watch as those of us who can get deals done, do so.
THANK YOU SO much to all again who's advice made this offer happen and to others, do yourselves a favor and just leave posts alone that you have nothing of value to contribute to.
Good stuff man. Now that it's under contract, can you share the link to the listing so we can see the deal? Congrats on getting it under contract. How much EM did you have to put down for this particular deal?
I will once the deal is closed! One step at a time and yes, I fully acknowledge I'm doing things in the reverse. Most start off by finding deals, finding buyers and nourishing those relationships. I'm starting off with years of existing nourished relationships and pretty much connecting my network, which is one's net worth! I'm just truly blessed that things have gotten this far! Will keep the community updated!
If its under contract then it doesn't matter as no one could take the deal from you. I'm just genuinely curious here.
Can you at least tell us how much EM you had to put down?
@Bill Brandt. Dude, I like your thought process….
@Jonny Mcknight post the contract and the listing if you want people to take you seriously. You are avoiding all proof questions or anything about reality and just talking about this story you are creating. You are also acting like a noob. The questions I am posing to you are what you need to answer to close the deal and to build whatever "business" you are allegedly building here. You should be listening to more of us who are telling you the pitfalls because if you think you are making a 200k spread with no experience, you are going to be left holding the bag on something, you just don't know it yet. Did you use the listing agent to write your offer as dual agency so now the listing agent is getting the full commissions on this "deal?" A lot of things aren't adding up here which of course is not a surprise. How about also posting a photo and a bio so people can know you are a real person, it helps in the forums for credibility.
@Jonny Mcknight "if you want people to take you seriously"
But I don't. You are NOT the buyer nor seller, nor agent. You are a unknown on the internet who decided to comment on a post with nothing meaningful to contribute. I do not care who or who doesn't take me seriously nor do I care about "crediability." I came on these forums to ask two specific questions, I got the answers needed and am enternally grateful for those who answered what was asked and were respectful. Because of them, I got an acccepted offer and I'm enternally grateful.
As for you, I do not care. I honestly don't know how many times I need to say that for you to understand. I don't know you, don't wish to know yoiu, don't care what you think, I don't care what adds up for you or doesn't, will never meet nor interact with you in real real life etc. Once my buyer, seller and agent all feel value was added to their lives and thus we can do more deals together along with the title company having my funds for this deal cleared, I am good.
You are those who chose to be negative on this posts, are simply irrelevant. I didn't join this forum to make friends or be a part of your negative club. I joined to asked two questions, thankfully there were those who saw through you and answered. To them, MUCH THANKS! As for you, I'm done. It's really that simple. Good luck to you.