First Lien HELOC Strategy

First Lien HELOC Strategy

Developer · New York, NY · Member since 2016 · 50 posts · 7 votes

What does the BP community think about 1st lien HELOCs as a way to free up equity in your primary home for investment purposes? If anyone has gone through the process, can you give any advice as to whether you recommend the strategy or if it is not worth it?

HELOCs usually have a 10 year draw period interest only before amortizing out. 

  • If you have a 1st lien HELOC, what happens to escrow for taxes and insurance, can it be waived and paid out of your own pocket or is it tied up into the monthly payment?
  • With regards to recourse vs. non-recourse loans, would putting the HELOC in 1st position allow a bank to come after personal assets in the event of a default?
  • Are there any banks/credit unions that charge LIBOR instead of Prime on HELOCs?
1Reply
1,513 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2014 · 942 posts · 1k+ votes
9y

@Roberto Westerband on the investment property I will pull a standard commercial loan and have the property stand alone. At that point my current HELOC will be free to be used on the next property and I will rinse and repeat, so "yes" this is a financing variation of BRRR.

@Christopher Winkler I live in the SF Bay Area so I have had a great run of appreciation over the past 13 years of ownership, almost 3x to be exact. I had also been building a relationship up with my lender over the past half decade, so they allowed me to add the value of a second property to my HELOC. There is nothing tying the loan to that property, everything is against my primary residence. My total debt to value on my primary is still less than 30%. I kept the monthly payments the same from my original 30 year fixed to the HELOC, but the pay down rate is substantially higher with my new loan. In my case, on all of my properties, appreciation is the "steak and all of the sides" of my investments and the cash flow is the Merlot that goes with the meal. I do not go after properties that cannot support both sides of the equation: appreciation + cash flow = wealth.

I really like the idea of using a HELOC because it is essentially a giant credit card. No more rushing and fighting for a loan during the purchase phase of a property. I now have the luxury of shopping a commercial loan at my own pace. It also allowed me to act as a "cash buyer" when I went after the 6 plex and it will do so into the future.

The obvious key to this strategy is that you have to be able to buildup to a large enough HELOC. This is not a "get rich quick" strategy. It literally took me years to get all of the pieces into place, but now I have a huge amount of freedom and flexibility.

See this reply in the discussion

168 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @David Ward:

    Hello, I've read up on the using the Heloc to finance rather than the traditional mortgage. I'm in Texas and so far, I've not found any lenders that will do a first position Heloc. 

    I'm at about 22% equity in my home based on value and only 10% based on appraisal at the time of purchase. If I paid down 80% of the loan then obtained a 2nd position Heloc, is there anything to prevent me from paying off the 20% remainder on the first lien, then paying myself back the 80%, essentially leaving me with a first position Heloc?

    Thanks in advance for any expertise.

    If you "paid down 80% of the loan"? How on earth are you able to consider doing that?

    I don't understand your fascination with the idea of having a first position HELOC, rather than having the current similar amount owing on your low interest rate mortgage?

    ie. If you have plenty of extra income each month (or indeed, if you do have the ability to pay down 80% of your mortgage now) - you can easily make extra principal-only payment/s! 

    (Or, use that money to invest! Your idea seems so convoluted, even if it could theoretically work).

    [Please read the whole thread]. Cheers...

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Brent Coombs

    This perfectly highlights the difference in the strategies. He's only considering doing that in order to end up with a first position HELOC that would give him back access to the funds he put in. No sane person would do that and leave their bank account critically low for an extended period of time and keep the mortgage.

    As has been said countless times throughout all these forums, putting more money towards the balance will effectively reduce the amount of interest paid.  The "extra principal-only payments" that you are suggesting will lag behind in terms of interest saved relative to the lump sum payment to get to 80% equity.  I've shown this spreadsheet to you many times and all you do is nitpick the numbers I used. However, it is clear that the "solution" you propose will never be as effective as putting it all in at once. No matter if you "easily" put an extra $100/mo, $200/mo, or $1000/mo, the bottom line is if you don't put 100% of your excess money towards your mortgage, you will not save as much as the first lien HELOC strategy. So please explain how this is better (I'm assuming since you're suggesting it you think it is better) from the numbers perspective you keep insisting on focusing on.

    Who is saying you can't invest by using the first Lien HELOC strategy? I think (hope) anyone out there using the strategy will tell you that if someone were to offer them a significant ROI for their money they would pull out of their HELOC in a heart beat. I (sort of) understand your insistence on deflecting conversations of alternative investments in the other forums since 95% of the debate is about taking a second position HELOC to move the debt to a different vehicle and accelerating the pay down. However, this forum is titled First Lien HELOC Strategy so there shouldn't be any strung out arguments relating to the distributive property of multiplication.  I'll admit that I didn't read every post relating to this strategy, but I hope no one promoting the strategy  has implied that "at no point should you draw from your available balance if an investment opportunity presents itself". 

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki, did you notice that I used the word "payment/s"? ie. One lump payment of 80% of the loan if so wished, and/or continued extra payments as income permits.

    ie. I didn't say his idea couldn't be done; but was just questioning his fraught way of desperately trying to get a first position HELOC (when his Lenders didn't want to make it easy to do so). I was just suggesting to David that he chill out about the term "HELOC", when (given his massive savings) there's ample alternatives for him that will accomplish the same end (and most likely - cheaper)...

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, did you notice that I used the word "payment/s"? ie. One lump payment of 80% of the loan if so wished, and/or continued extra payments as income permits.

    ie. I didn't say his idea couldn't be done; but was just questioning his fraught way of desperately trying to get a first position HELOC (when his Lenders didn't want to make it easy to do so). I was just suggesting to David that he chill out about the term "HELOC", when (given his massive savings) there's ample alternatives for him that will accomplish the same end (and most likely - cheaper)...

    And again I ask, what sane person would drain whatever liquid money they have currently and then dump everything going forward into the mortgage?  That is what you are suggesting.  All in order to match the savings from the first lien HELOC strategy. I agree, that is an alternative that will yield similar results, but I see no supporting evidence that it is better and/or cheaper.

  • Member since 2019 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    7y

    Nick's spreadsheet demonstrates the HELOC advantage. The draw period, the interest rate, any rate increase(s), amount of monthly free cash flow, and discipline all are factors for consideration. My target was a payoff in under 10 years without drastically changing expenses. The math indicates the HELOC would be the least expensive pay down method to achieve that *IF* all the necessary requirements were met.

    I'm no expert by any means, I've just spent time trying to understand the approach. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Honolulu, HAWAII (HI) · Member since 2011 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki banks are a lot more conservative here. I see helocs as only a way to kick the can down the road but at some point you have to sell to effectively get the equity working.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, did you notice that I used the word "payment/s"? ie. One lump payment of 80% of the loan if so wished, and/or continued extra payments as income permits.

    ie. I didn't say his idea couldn't be done; but was just questioning his fraught way of desperately trying to get a first position HELOC (when his Lenders didn't want to make it easy to do so). I was just suggesting to David that he chill out about the term "HELOC", when (given his massive savings) there's ample alternatives for him that will accomplish the same end (and most likely - cheaper)...

    And again I ask, what sane person would drain whatever liquid money they have currently and then dump everything going forward into the mortgage?  That is what you are suggesting.  All in order to match the savings from the first lien HELOC strategy. I agree, that is an alternative that will yield similar results, but I see no supporting evidence that it is better and/or cheaper.

    To quote you from a few posts ago: "I’m starting to learn that HELOCs are a much different product on the mainland than they are here". 

    Keep learning. Cheers... 

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, did you notice that I used the word "payment/s"? ie. One lump payment of 80% of the loan if so wished, and/or continued extra payments as income permits.

    ie. I didn't say his idea couldn't be done; but was just questioning his fraught way of desperately trying to get a first position HELOC (when his Lenders didn't want to make it easy to do so). I was just suggesting to David that he chill out about the term "HELOC", when (given his massive savings) there's ample alternatives for him that will accomplish the same end (and most likely - cheaper)...

    And again I ask, what sane person would drain whatever liquid money they have currently and then dump everything going forward into the mortgage?  That is what you are suggesting.  All in order to match the savings from the first lien HELOC strategy. I agree, that is an alternative that will yield similar results, but I see no supporting evidence that it is better and/or cheaper.

    To quote you from a few posts ago: "I’m starting to learn that HELOCs are a much different product on the mainland than they are here". 

    Keep learning. Cheers... 

    So.... no answer?  

    And for the record, banks handling HELOCs differently in different places doesn’t disprove the concept. Maybe you should take your own advice and “focus on the numbers”?

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Lane Kawaoka:

    @Nick Moriwaki banks are a lot more conservative here. I see helocs as only a way to kick the can down the road but at some point you have to sell to effectively get the equity working.

    Really? Curious what banks you are referring to. Banks here give great promo interest rates and most offer at least 80% LTV and I know a couple as high as 89.99% LTV.

    Also, I would argue that this HELOC strategy is an excellent way put your equity to work and maintain passive income.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, did you notice that I used the word "payment/s"? ie. One lump payment of 80% of the loan if so wished, and/or continued extra payments as income permits.

    ie. I didn't say his idea couldn't be done; but was just questioning his fraught way of desperately trying to get a first position HELOC (when his Lenders didn't want to make it easy to do so). I was just suggesting to David that he chill out about the term "HELOC", when (given his massive savings) there's ample alternatives for him that will accomplish the same end (and most likely - cheaper)...

    And again I ask, what sane person would drain whatever liquid money they have currently and then dump everything going forward into the mortgage?  That is what you are suggesting.  All in order to match the savings from the first lien HELOC strategy. I agree, that is an alternative that will yield similar results, but I see no supporting evidence that it is better and/or cheaper.

    To quote you from a few posts ago: "I’m starting to learn that HELOCs are a much different product on the mainland than they are here". 

    Keep learning. Cheers... 

    So.... no answer?  

    And for the record, banks handling HELOCs differently in different places doesn’t disprove the concept. Maybe you should take your own advice and “focus on the numbers”?

    Nick, as I've reminded you on at least one other thread, I don't suggest that HELOCs can't "work". But in this cycle of low interest rate mortgages, there is no pressing need to transfer such mortgages into HELOCs. (The argument about "74% of your first year's payments going towards interest-only" is completely irrelevant, because if you converted the whole loan to a first position HELOC, your Lender would still require the same - if not more - money out of your wallet each month, and you'd only be accelerating your pay down if you were forced to pay it back quicker, or if you volunteered to, because of all your excess income!)

    And, I'm not against the flexibility of the relatively cheap Credit Card call a HELOC.

    But please don't try to confuse "flexibility" with "pay down". You either end up with one, or the other!

    And if your goal is pay down, you don't need flexibility! Just pay off your mortgage quicker, folks!

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, did you notice that I used the word "payment/s"? ie. One lump payment of 80% of the loan if so wished, and/or continued extra payments as income permits.

    ie. I didn't say his idea couldn't be done; but was just questioning his fraught way of desperately trying to get a first position HELOC (when his Lenders didn't want to make it easy to do so). I was just suggesting to David that he chill out about the term "HELOC", when (given his massive savings) there's ample alternatives for him that will accomplish the same end (and most likely - cheaper)...

    And again I ask, what sane person would drain whatever liquid money they have currently and then dump everything going forward into the mortgage?  That is what you are suggesting.  All in order to match the savings from the first lien HELOC strategy. I agree, that is an alternative that will yield similar results, but I see no supporting evidence that it is better and/or cheaper.

    To quote you from a few posts ago: "I’m starting to learn that HELOCs are a much different product on the mainland than they are here". 

    Keep learning. Cheers... 

    So.... no answer?  

    And for the record, banks handling HELOCs differently in different places doesn’t disprove the concept. Maybe you should take your own advice and “focus on the numbers”?

    Nick, as I've reminded you on at least one other thread, I don't suggest that HELOCs can't "work". But in this cycle of low interest rate mortgages, there is no pressing need to transfer such mortgages into HELOCs. (The argument about "74% of your first year's payments going towards interest-only" is completely irrelevant, because if you converted the whole loan to a first position HELOC, your Lender would still require the same - if not more - money out of your wallet each month, and you'd only be accelerating your pay down if you were forced to pay it back quicker, or if you volunteered to, because of all your excess income!)

    And, I'm not against the flexibility of the relatively cheap Credit Card call a HELOC.

    But please don't try to confuse "flexibility" with "pay down". You either end up with one, or the other!

    And if your goal is pay down, you don't need flexibility! Just pay off your mortgage quicker, folks!

    And as I've reminded you in this thread and the others as well - nothing in the strategy says you can't use your equity. Nor have I argued that moving your balance to a HELOC will magically save you interest. Your main focus is on proving that there's nothing different in the math with mortgages and HELOCs. I'd challenge you to find a single post where I've refuted that claim. You then use that logic to say that swapping a mortgage for a HELOC in first position is not a valid strategy because the numbers can be replicated by keeping the mortgage. But you still haven't answered the question I keep asking:

    What sane person would drain whatever liquid money they have currently and then dump everything going forward into the mortgage?  

    This is the scenario where the numbers match.  I completely agree with you there.  But I’d take my scenario over yours any day because I’m not one car problem or home repair from needing to refi my mortgage.  That is insanely risky.  But should people just ignore that too just because the numbers match?  So I’ll try again (for like the 5th time) - how is what you’re suggesting better? 

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki, seems that every time you promote HELOCs, you do so by using the example of people paying off as much of their mortgage as they can with their $20-50k savings before taking out their HELOC, so that their first position HELOC is already lower than their original mortgage. But of course, they can then redraw any or all of that lower amount (but, at a higher interest rate -on the mainland- than their original mortgage). Meantime, they have spent all their emergency funds.

    Whereas, anyone who does have high income plus $20-50k, needn't put it on their mortgage at all. Or they could, and just use normal Credit Cards or personal loans for those other emergencies you're so concerned about!

    Remember - in every scenario you've presented, folk have a much higher income than they need for their normal expenses! So why would they be insane if wishing to put all their current savings directly into an extra principal-only lump payment? You think they don't relate well with their own Lenders?...

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, seems that every time you promote HELOCs, you do so by using the example of people paying off as much of their mortgage as they can with their $20-50k savings before taking out their HELOC, so that their first position HELOC is already lower than their original mortgage. But of course, they can then redraw any or all of that lower amount (but, at a higher interest rate -on the mainland- than their original mortgage). Meantime, they have spent all their emergency funds.

    Whereas, anyone who does have high income plus $20-50k, needn't put it on their mortgage at all. Or they could, and just use normal Credit Cards or personal loans for those other emergencies you're so concerned about!

    Remember - in every scenario you've presented, folk have a much higher income than they need for their normal expenses! So why would they be insane if wishing to put all their current savings directly into an extra principal-only lump payment? You think they don't relate well with their own Lenders?...

    There are so many issues with what you just said.

    First off, when you say "spent" all your emergency funds you do realize you can take it back out with the HELOC strategy right? Unlike when you dump it into the mortgage. You even said it yourself. If not using the HELOC, you would use personal loans or CC as excess credit. More financing or 18%+ APR if for some reason life happens and you overspent for the month. Again, still not seeing why that's what you're advocating for.

    Second, I never said you take out the HELOC after applying all of your income. You can apply for a HELOC and pay off your mortgage simultaneously. Hence why in David's case I said he could get a HELOC in first position of 80-90% of his current value of 300K with his current mortgage as the balance. As I've mentioned before, this is a much higher amount than you could ever get by using your "equivalent" method of pulling a second position HELOC and dumping your savings in. You benefit by having what I call "instant refinancing" by having access to essentially as much equity as you could ever have without selling. And you never have to go to the bank to request it after you open up your HELOC.

    Third, why are you now throwing out higher interest rates for the HELOC than the mortgage? The discussion has always been about using interest rates that are equivalent. Hence why you folks always say "the math doesn't lie, it comes out the same." Is this the only way you can advocate against the strategy? Who's to say someone doesn't have their personal residence paid off and takes out a first position HELOC to pay off a rental property?

    You are right however when you keep saying the math doesn’t lie.  The strategy relies simply on cash flow.  Having a “much” higher income than expenses doesn’t make it work like you’re implying, it just accelerates it.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki, your first point only relates to "flexibility". As well as personal loan or CC, a second position HELOC could be applied for, without foregoing ones very low 3.5-3.75% 30y fixed mortgage.

    Your second point is merely pedantics. You admit that you advocate a first position HELOC for a LOWER amount than ones original mortgage. ie. Paying off some of the mortgage with prior savings.

    Your third point gets closer to the crux of the matter! In real life, those on the mainland cannot get a first position ongoing HELOC at 3.5-3.75% interest (leave alone the idea of that being fixed)!

    So now are you getting my drift?

    Having said all that, if people have paid off their home, why not take out a first position HELOC for as much as their Lender allows? Cheapest Credit Card we'll ever get! Cheers...

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:

    @Nick Moriwaki, your first point only relates to "flexibility". As well as personal loan or CC, a second position HELOC could be applied for, without foregoing ones very low 3.5-3.75% 30y fixed mortgage.

    Your second point is merely pedantics. You admit that you advocate a first position HELOC for a LOWER amount than ones original mortgage. ie. Paying off some of the mortgage with prior savings.

    Your third point gets closer to the crux of the matter! In real life, those on the mainland cannot get a first position ongoing HELOC at 3.5-3.75% interest (leave alone the idea of that being fixed)!

    So now are you getting my drift?

    Having said all that, if people have paid off their home, why not take out a first position HELOC for as much as their Lender allows? Cheapest Credit Card we'll ever get! Cheers...

    If the interest rates are the same I don't see how you can advocate for the first scenario. It just doesn't make sense to live paycheck to paycheck when you can have a first position HELOC and realize the same amount of interest savings. Seems like you're arguing against the concept based solely on interest rates rather than focusing on the math within the strategy. Yes, if you tell me you have a 3.5% mortgage and I can only get a 6% HELOC then I would agree, keep the mortgage. But let other people apply their interest rates to their individual scenarios. I've skimmed other threads where people have low interest rate HELOCs. Doesn't seem like it's impossible.

    And I don't advocate for taking out a lower HELOC than the mortgage... in fact it's just the opposite. I don't get where you keep getting that from. Look at the example I gave to David. I explained that if he got a first position HELOC he could pull a 270K line of credit which is much larger than any second position HELOC he could get. How is that's smaller than the mortgage?

    And the last part of what you said is really baffling. You're saying it makes sense for people to take out a first position HELOC if they've paid off their home, but not to convert their existing mortgage into a HELOC? It's the same thing!

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki, if your original spreadsheet examples were still viewable, I believe they would show that you were quoting $50k savings to lessen the amount needed to pay back a first position HELOC. Nonetheless, if you're happy to have a higher HELOC balance owing than your original mortgage, that fairly much puts paid to any idea of accelerating pay off in a hurry. (But yes, I know that's not necessarily the focus of this thread). 

    I generally agree that if interest rates were the same between HELOC and mortgage, it makes sense to attain the flexibility to hasten pay off with ones extra cash flow - or borrow it back as desired/required.

    As for your last sentence, it's not "the same thing", simply because: interest rates are not the same!

  • Rockville, MD · Member since 2017 · 3 posts · 1 vote
    7y

    I've been watching this thread for the last 9-10 months, so I'm glad to see some new interest in it. I don't have a first lien HELOC, but I'm still convinced this is a good move for my personal situation. Thoughts on why I feel this way are below in case helpful framing for anyone else:

    1. Currently have a mortgage on a primary residence at 75% LTV and 4.7% interest rate.

    2. Currently pursuing a graduate degree for which my company has reimbursed 100% tuition to date. I've been saving cash on the side in case (1) the company changes its mind in future quarters and I'll have to pay my own tuition to finish, and (2) so I can cover the remaining tuition if I choose to leave the company sooner. I prefer not investing this savings in stocks or other vehicles in the near term because I want it to be as available as possible. The 1st Lien HELOC also provides the benefit of a credit line for tuition if needed. I was guarantor on my younger sibling's student loan a few years ago, and it was 9.6% for only $10,000. Quotes for my own prospective student loan are coming in the same ballpark or only slightly better, so I much prefer to save cash then take out a loan at that rate.

    3. I did try making extra payments on my mortgage to Brent's point, but after my 2nd extra payment, my lender instituted a flat admin fee for each extra payment so it's a deterrent for paying anything except large lump sums. I was able to switch to bi-weekly mortgage payments to accelerate my payoff at no extra cost, but the odd week payments don't get applied to my mortgage until the even week payments round off the total sum, so it's like I'm giving my lender a free loan for a few weeks each month. This irks me.

    My primary goal is to pay as little money in interest as possible, and the advantage of the 1st Lien HELOC is that it gives me the opportunity to use my sitting cash to help achieve that goal. I appreciate Lane's thought on needing to sell to get the equity working. My own feeling is that I'll have gained significantly more equity in my home if/when I sell, or if I end up paying the mortgage off early, I'll have pre-purchased flexibility for my future self to take a lower paying job or even a sabbatical because I'll no longer have the monthly mortgage to pay each month. Also, when I finish grad school and I decide I want to reinvest some cash elsewhere (eg a rental property), the HELOC provides for that opportunity as well.

  • Rental Property Investor · Honolulu, HAWAII (HI) · Member since 2011 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki its a bit of a bate and switch. They will not use a AMC appraisal they will use sort of in house appraisal so 90% of a low appraisal.

    Reach out if you like a heloc cheat sheet for hawaii.

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Lane Kawaoka:

    @Nick Moriwaki its a bit of a bate and switch. They will not use a AMC appraisal they will use sort of in house appraisal so 90% of a low appraisal.

    Reach out if you like a heloc cheat sheet for hawaii.

    Sure, I'll take whatever info you have for HELOCs in Hawaii. But I've never had an issue with low appraisals. Not sure what an AMC appraisal is, but all my appraisals came out at or above the property value.

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Brent Coombs

    That was the HELOC balance.  Not the HELOC limit.  In the example, the $50K was being used to pay down the HELOC immediately after obtaining it.  Therefore the available balance will be at least $50K - the same amount that was available in your bank account.    The difference is that for whatever period of time that money is sitting in your HELOC it is essentially earning you the percentage of your HELOC since your balance is that much less.  You can't fully replicate this with the mortgage because it is not revolving.  

    The part that you're saying you agree with has been my main point for the entirety of this argument.  Given equal interest rates, the first position HELOC strategy will put you in a better spot financially than keeping the mortgage. The two comparisons that keep coming up are:

    1) You pay extra to the mortgage to try and keep up with the first position HELOC strategy. Depending on what percentage of your excess income you put towards additional principal payments, the difference can range from a small amount to a significantly large amount but keeping the mortgage will never pay less interest nor will you ever have access to more funds. Additionally there is an opportunity cost associated with this since whatever extra money you allocated towards principal only payments are not available to be used without refinancing or selling. This is for the people who say "just pay extra to the mortgage".

    2) If you want to make the interest savings the same while keeping the mortgage you need to zero your bank account and take out a personal loan, CC debt, or a second position HELOC as you said a couple posts ago. Interest savings in this comparison are essentially a wash, but the first position HELOC provides much more convenience, flexibility, and investing capability given that all your finances will run in and out of that HELOC and you'll have access to more funds due to the limitations of the backup funds you mentioned. This is for the people who say "you can realize the same savings by keeping the mortgage - there's no magic here."

    If you're saying you have no issue with both comparisons and agree that the first position HELOC strategy is better in both cases then we may have just wasted hours of hours of our lives arguing about something we actually agreed on.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y

    @Nick Moriwaki, all anyone has to do do see where both of us are at is to check out this other thread: https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/61/topics/269...

    The last post to date there (by me, to you) 12 days ago says: 

    "Yes, we're on the same page. I don't know why it took so long for you to get that. My complaint with your constant mentioning that a HELOC "does not limit ones flexibility to use his/her money for future investments" is only that: using it that way goes against the topic of this (ie. that) thread!

    And you know I'm also against HELOCs being promoted to people who don't have savings or excess cash flow! I just don't get why you seem offended each time I say that. [No need to respond again]..."

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y

    @Brent Coombs

    The issue I have is that when people keep saying they’re going to employ the strategy or show any interest you keep jumping in and saying “why would you get out of your low interest mortgage?”   If we’re truly on the same page that question should be answered by the two scenarios I presented in my previous post.  

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:

    @Brent Coombs

    The issue I have is that when people keep saying they’re going to employ the strategy or show any interest you keep jumping in and saying “why would you get out of your low interest mortgage?”   If we’re truly on the same page that question should be answered by the two scenarios I presented in my previous post.  

    Their existing fixed mortgage will (afaik) invariably have a lower interest rate than they could get by replacing it with a first position HELOC (except for promotional/temporary lower interest).

    I'm always against promotional low interest rates presented by lenders (for long-term loans), as if they're going to be on the losing end of such a "give-away product"! Whereas, you and I both know that those lenders are not giving away temporary low rates in order to lose money!

    [Your two scenarios want us to assume a theoretical (read: fanciful, unicorn) same interest rate]...

  • Investor · Honolulu, HI · Member since 2015 · 106 posts · 50 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:

    @Brent Coombs

    The issue I have is that when people keep saying they’re going to employ the strategy or show any interest you keep jumping in and saying “why would you get out of your low interest mortgage?”   If we’re truly on the same page that question should be answered by the two scenarios I presented in my previous post.  

    Their existing fixed mortgage will (afaik) invariably have a lower interest rate than they could get by replacing it with a first position HELOC (except for promotional/temporary lower interest).

    I'm always against promotional low interest rates presented by lenders (for long-term loans), as if they're going to be on the losing end of such a "give-away product"! Whereas, you and I both know that those lenders are not giving away temporary low rates in order to lose money!

    [Your two scenarios want us to assume a theoretical (read: fanciful, unicorn) same interest rate]...

    What you're talking about is the second part of the discussion. Once we get past the fact that, on an even playing field, the HELOC strategy wins out, people need to crunch their own numbers, research what kind of rates are out there, do their due diligence on the risks, and then identify if the strategy is for them. But they can't get there if every time they ask a question about it people like you criticize them and tell them it's just a play on numbers and they're not actually saving anything.

  • Investor · Cleveland, OH · Member since 2015 · 6k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:
    Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
    Originally posted by @Nick Moriwaki:

    @Brent Coombs

    The issue I have is that when people keep saying they’re going to employ the strategy or show any interest you keep jumping in and saying “why would you get out of your low interest mortgage?”   If we’re truly on the same page that question should be answered by the two scenarios I presented in my previous post.  

    Their existing fixed mortgage will (afaik) invariably have a lower interest rate than they could get by replacing it with a first position HELOC (except for promotional/temporary lower interest).

    I'm always against promotional low interest rates presented by lenders (for long-term loans), as if they're going to be on the losing end of such a "give-away product"! Whereas, you and I both know that those lenders are not giving away temporary low rates in order to lose money!

    [Your two scenarios want us to assume a theoretical (read: fanciful, unicorn) same interest rate]...

    What you're talking about is the second part of the discussion. Once we get past the fact that, on an even playing field, the HELOC strategy wins out, people need to crunch their own numbers, research what kind of rates are out there, do their due diligence on the risks, and then identify if the strategy is for them. But they can't get there if every time they ask a question about it people like you criticize them and tell them it's just a play on numbers and they're not actually saving anything.

    Yes they can. You making assertions, then me tempering those assertions, does not hurt the debate.

    Again, we've reached the stage of: no response required... 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.