Contribute to a Roth SDIRA with rental income only.

Contribute to a Roth SDIRA with rental income only.

Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2015 · 108 posts · 27 votes

So I quit my job in 2022 and so for the last year I have been working strictly on my properties. I never bothered with logging my time (because it was a hassle and I didn't think it would be much benefit) but now I'm realizing that I can't contribute to my Roth SDIRA anymore because all my income is passive. I probably would quality for being a trade or business with the amount of hours I put in remodeling and such but since I don't have logs for the past 4 years (since I've had my rentals for much longer), it would be at least 3 to 4 more years before I'd qualify for that. Or I'd have to try and work up my log hours from home depot & gas station receipts which would be a big pain in the butt. I've heard about people creating Property Management businesses and billing their properties for service... which seams easier but I know that subjects me to self employment tax (but does open up other possibilities of self employed 401ks and such). Anybody have any other suggestions or experience with going the management route? 

4Reply
55 views

Most Popular Reply

Brett SynickyPro Member
Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant · Orange, CA · Member since 2013 · 877 posts · 501 votes
2y

@Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brett SynickyPro Member
    Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant · Orange, CA · Member since 2013 · 877 posts · 501 votes
    2y

    @Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  

  • Accountant · San Diego, CA · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 552 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Brett Synicky:

    @Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  

    One thing I want to mention is to be wary of the pro rata rule. If your going to be mixing all of these accounts and then going for a self directed roth IRA later, this will apply to you.

    The Pro-Rata rule applies if your Traditional IRA contains both pre-tax and after-tax contributions. The Pro-Rata Rule is used to determine the ratio that should be applied in determining how much of the conversion is pre-tax vs after tax. You are not able to choose only the after-tax portion when doing a conversion.

    If you have not contributed post-tax dollars into a traditional IRA, the total amount converted is taxed at your normal income tax rate and the Pro-Rata rule does not apply, but in this case you mentioned you have an IRA so I'm sure it does.

    Best of luck in your journey! 

  • Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2015 · 108 posts · 27 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Brett Synicky:

    @Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  


    So what are the downsides of creating a PM company and paying myself? I think there are self employment taxes. I heard that contributions are limited to 20% for a SEP IRA but are you saying the solo 401K is not limited?

  • Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2015 · 108 posts · 27 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Account Closed:
    Quote from @Brett Synicky:

    @Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  

    One thing I want to mention is to be wary of the pro rata rule. If your going to be mixing all of these accounts and then going for a self directed roth IRA later, this will apply to you.

    The Pro-Rata rule applies if your Traditional IRA contains both pre-tax and after-tax contributions. The Pro-Rata Rule is used to determine the ratio that should be applied in determining how much of the conversion is pre-tax vs after tax. You are not able to choose only the after-tax portion when doing a conversion.

    If you have not contributed post-tax dollars into a traditional IRA, the total amount converted is taxed at your normal income tax rate and the Pro-Rata rule does not apply, but in this case you mentioned you have an IRA so I'm sure it does.

    Best of luck in your journey! 


     Yeah my roth and traditional are separate and I've never comingled the funds. 

  • Brett SynickyPro Member
    Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant · Orange, CA · Member since 2013 · 877 posts · 501 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Corey G.:
    Quote from @Brett Synicky:

    @Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  


    So what are the downsides of creating a PM company and paying myself? I think there are self employment taxes. I heard that contributions are limited to 20% for a SEP IRA but are you saying the solo 401K is not limited?


     If you're incorporated (s-corp) on the employe side you can contribute 25% of what you paid yourself for the year.   Sole prop/single member llc is 20% of the net profit for the year.  This cannot exceed $69k or if over 50, $76,500.  You can contribute up to $23k on the employee side, $30,500 if over 50.  Both of these combined cannot exceed the total of $69k/$76,500, however that entire amount can come from the employer side if you don't contribute on the employee side.   The thing to note is that if you don't need the money to live on you can contribute up to 100% of what you pay yourself/net profit.  Sep works the same on the employer side and does NOT have the employee contribution, among other things.   Hope this helps.  Check with your CPA.  

  • Investor · Phoenix, AZ · Member since 2015 · 108 posts · 27 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Brett Synicky:
    Quote from @Corey G.:
    Quote from @Brett Synicky:

    @Corey G. you’re on the right track.  You can definitely create a pm company like you mentioned.  It isn’t hard to qualify for a solo 401k.  Drive Uber, door dash, sell things on eBay/amazon.   Network marketing.   There are many benefits to solo 401ks over sdira, one of the biggest being the high contribution limits so with my examples you likely won’t make very much but for 2024 you can contribute up to 100% of what you make up to $23,500 and since you don’t need the money to live on this would be a good way to add more money to a Roth solo.  


    So what are the downsides of creating a PM company and paying myself? I think there are self employment taxes. I heard that contributions are limited to 20% for a SEP IRA but are you saying the solo 401K is not limited?


     If you're incorporated (s-corp) on the employe side you can contribute 25% of what you paid yourself for the year.   Sole prop/single member llc is 20% of the net profit for the year.  This cannot exceed $69k or if over 50, $76,500.  You can contribute up to $23k on the employee side, $30,500 if over 50.  Both of these combined cannot exceed the total of $69k/$76,500, however that entire amount can come from the employer side if you don't contribute on the employee side.   The thing to note is that if you don't need the money to live on you can contribute up to 100% of what you pay yourself/net profit.  Sep works the same on the employer side and does NOT have the employee contribution, among other things.   Hope this helps.  Check with your CPA.  


    I don't have a CPA at the moment so maybe I should try to find one. However, what you said confused me a little because you said that I could contribute 25% or 20% depending on if it's an S-corp or LLC but if I'm reading you correctly, those limitations are only on the employee side? Employers side doesn't have that same restriction and so they can contribute 100%? Is that what you meant by "if you don't need the money to live on".

    Ideally what I would want to do is pay myself about 7000-10000 per year or so, pay self employment taxes out of there and then contribute the remainder to a retirement account. But if I'm limited to 25%, I wouldn't be able to contribute nearly as much to make it worth it due to paying self employment taxes on the other 75%. Additionally, as the sole person running this business do I need to set it up for my properties to pay the PM company and then the company pays me as an employee or since I'm the owner of the company I don't have any employees and so there would technically be no employee side? 

    I asked this question elsewhere and someone said that they do this but do not have an LLC and are a sole proprietorship and just file with a schedule C. Does that sound like it would work? I'm concerned about losing the QBI deduction because then the "management company" would be the one active in managing the business.

  • Brett SynickyPro Member
    Solo 401k and SDIRA Consultant · Orange, CA · Member since 2013 · 877 posts · 501 votes
    2y

    @Corey G.Sorry I mistakenly left the r off employer.  

    Sole Prop/single Member LLC example: If your net profit on the business (PM) that adopts the 401k is $100k then you can contribute $20k to the 401k. This is the employer side. On top of that you could contribute up to $23k on the employee side. For a total of $43k. Obviously there has to be enough revenue and profit to do this.

     S-Corp example: You're on payroll and you pay yourself $100k.  On the employer side you could contribute $25k and $23k on the employee side for a total of $48k.  

    Either of these set ups would be eligible as long as no w2 except you and a spouse.  

    What I meant by the 100% is that if you only paid yourself $23k through payroll you can contribute 100% of that to the 401k assuming you don't need that money to live on.  In that scenario the employer contribution would be $5750.  

    The employer contributions are a tax write off for the business.  

    Hope that clears it up, sorry I wasn't clear.  

    For the proper set up of the PM biz and QBI and any other tax/legal questions you'll want to consult a CPA.  @Michael Plaks may be able to assist.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.