Negotiating a specialized deal with a major bank

Negotiating a specialized deal with a major bank

Specialist · Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 75 posts · 7 votes

I know it's quite common that when the owner of a property gives you full permission to negotiate on their behalf, you might find yourself in contact with some person, who is in turn, representing the interests of a major international bank, that holds a significant amount of interest in the property's equity via a mortgage(in this case a securitized, sub-prime, sold and re-sold many times mortgage).

It would be very common in this situation to arrange something like a Short Sale.  However that particular type of arrangement was not suitable, yet the bank is quite keen on liquidating their asset.  So they said to me:   "Give us an offer.  Make a proposal"

It seems as though they are willing to concede anything imaginable, but I have to draft the proposal.  No problem I will.

Question:  When sending a preliminary proposal over email, summarized in layspeak, would adding the standard 'This email in no way shall be interpreted as a contract to.....etc" be sufficient protection from even the most advanced legal 'gotyas' that might get thrown at me?   Has anyone ever experienced anything damaging that survived such a clause?  The party negotiating for the bank is an attorney and is currently in the midst of some rather novel litigation against the property owner.

I already plan to have an attorney that specializes in this field, licensed in my state look over the proposal before i formally offer it.

Can anyone recommend a resource for reading up on best practices and/or precedent for such situations?  Be it speaking with the other side over the phone, via email, in front of a judge, or in lieu of in front of a judge?  (all of these scenarios are plausible in the near future).

Thanks!

0Reply
78 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
6y

@Greg K. So,

The property actually went to the foreclosure sale/auction?

A third party bought it, or the bank got it back?

My assumption is....the bank realized something was wrong with the foreclosure, usually this involves failing to notify a junior lien holder or an error in the legal description, etc. I have many sales here rescinded due to such errors. 

The intent of “reinstating the mortgage”, which was “extinguished by law” (no release/cancelation of the mtg needs to be recorded) is so that the bank can start the foreclosure over, correctly this time. 

I’m not sure what federal statute you are referring to, but often people try to apply some federal statute that doesn’t actually apply to a foreclosure case. 

If no deed/transfer was recorded from the sale, the plaintiff likely discovered their error and had the court halt the recording....in order that they could rescind, then regime the foreclosure. 

If they do rescind the sale, then the original borrower will still be the owner. 

See this reply in the discussion

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y

    I’m not sure what “special” circumstances or novel litigation there is that might alter normal practices, but.....there typically is no way the bank could take a reduced pay off u less done specifically through the short sale process, due to federal law, mortgage insurance requirements, etc.

    Any more details specific to this situation would be helpful.

    The language you proposed would be perfectly fine, and likely fine without it.

  • Specialist · Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 75 posts · 7 votes
    6y

    @Wayne Brooks

    Thank you.  Well the circumstances are unique because the property was sold at a foreclosure auction, and then before the new owner got very far into the process the foreclosure was rescinded.

    The novel litigation is that the banks attorney filed a lawsuit against the owner, the category of the claim is   "Real Property - Other"  and the complaint of the Plaintiff is that they would like to rescind the foreclosure and reinstate the mortgage, providing the original Mortgage areement as evidence, despite the fact that it is:

    1. Still showing as the active recorded mortgage in the county registry of deeds

    2. The registry shows no new owner recorded, no foreclosure, in fact, nothing was recorded at all through out these events.  The attorney claims that this doesn't matter because some judge "by gavel" put the property into its limbo state.  Perhaps a thorough title search would reveal something

    I don't doubt what you are saying at all, but can you reference the federal statute that prevents a note holder from settling on a compromise, via a contract, with the mortgagor?  (this does occur amidst litigation, though the details of such agreements are kept private) I'm not sure there are any mortgage insurance requirements, on their end, if the mortgage is in a limbo state.  This is why I chose my words carefully by saying the bank does hold interest in the property via a note, because that's all I am sure of.

    If this is true, why would the attorney tell me to continue with the plan, and that his client was very interested in the proposal?

    Thank you kindly, 

    Greg

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y

    @Greg K. So,

    The property actually went to the foreclosure sale/auction?

    A third party bought it, or the bank got it back?

    My assumption is....the bank realized something was wrong with the foreclosure, usually this involves failing to notify a junior lien holder or an error in the legal description, etc. I have many sales here rescinded due to such errors. 

    The intent of “reinstating the mortgage”, which was “extinguished by law” (no release/cancelation of the mtg needs to be recorded) is so that the bank can start the foreclosure over, correctly this time. 

    I’m not sure what federal statute you are referring to, but often people try to apply some federal statute that doesn’t actually apply to a foreclosure case. 

    If no deed/transfer was recorded from the sale, the plaintiff likely discovered their error and had the court halt the recording....in order that they could rescind, then regime the foreclosure. 

    If they do rescind the sale, then the original borrower will still be the owner. 

  • Specialist · Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 75 posts · 7 votes
    6y

    @Wayne Brooks

    Your informative response is much appreciated!

    I just typed up a few paragraphs and then all was lost when attempting to insert a quote.  In short, I agree that the current litigation ultimate purpose is to make another attempt at FC, but properly.

    Also many of these procedures and laws are very nuanced and state specific, most of what you are speculating does not apply because the attempted auction occured almost a year ago.  It was rescinded within a week, because the bank really did make a big mistake so state authorities intervened.  And nothing has been recorded, that I was able to find, in 4 years.  Perhaps there's something a local expert would uncover. 

    I mentioned a federal statute in hopes of you elaborating on:

    "

    there typically is no way the bank could take a reduced pay off u less done specifically through the short sale process, due to federal law, mortgage insurance requirements, etc.

    "

    But I think we understand each other, as in , this is not exactly a typical case.

    Thanks again,

    -Greg

  • Real Estate Professional · West Palm Beach, FL · Member since 2012 · 23k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    6y

    @Greg K. One thing I forgot to ask....where is the owner in all this? Have you talked to him? Do you know if he is in communication with the bank?   Without the owner’s cooperation, nothing can happen now, as  the foreclosure was rescinded, the borrower is still the owner, the bank does not have title so therefore they can’t sell the property....only the owner can.  If the bank agrees to a reduced payoff, by whatever means, the owner still has to sign the deed over to you.

  • Specialist · Boston, MA · Member since 2018 · 75 posts · 7 votes
    6y

    The owner is on board with the whole plan, and has authorized me to negotiate on their behalf.  The other methods just don't suit my fancy.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.