Existing tenants paying way below the market rate. What to do?

Existing tenants paying way below the market rate. What to do?

Member since 2021 · 10 posts · 7 votes

I have just bought a new duplex. I have existing long term tenants living in each unit. One tenant is living there for 10 years paying around 1080 and another is living there for 4 years and paying 1265. The current median and average rent is above 1650 according to rentometer and zillow. I bought the property thinking I will be able to increase the rent and bring it to the market rate. But if I increase the rent for tenant_1 to even 1400 it is like 30% increase. I definitely want to bring the rent up to 1550 at least and then gradually increase it to the market rate. I am not sure how to go about this rent increase. I just started being a landlord and this is my first property. Can you guys suggest how should I increase the rent here? Today is my day 1 of owning this property.

3Reply
260 views

Most Popular Reply

Bjorn AhlbladPro Member
Investor · Shelton, WA · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 6k+ votes
4y

@Tarun Mitra Congrats and welcome to BP! First check the leases and end dates. Second check to see if the City or County are enforcing rent control and if it applies to your type of property. If your objective is to raise rent and you don't care about turnover give the tenants the required amount of notice-usually 30 days to pay the new rent or leave.

If you want to keep the tenants, have a talk with them and see if there is a compromise in there someplace. Tenants are usually quite aware of market rents and will know they have been getting a bargain. All the best!

See this reply in the discussion

23 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Bjorn AhlbladPro Member
    Investor · Shelton, WA · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y

    @Tarun Mitra Congrats and welcome to BP! First check the leases and end dates. Second check to see if the City or County are enforcing rent control and if it applies to your type of property. If your objective is to raise rent and you don't care about turnover give the tenants the required amount of notice-usually 30 days to pay the new rent or leave.

    If you want to keep the tenants, have a talk with them and see if there is a compromise in there someplace. Tenants are usually quite aware of market rents and will know they have been getting a bargain. All the best!

  • Member since 2021 · 10 posts · 7 votes
    4y

    @Bjorn Ahlblad The state is Washington, so there is no rent control. The notice period is 60 days and tenants are on month to month lease. I am willing to give them a rental increase notice with 60 days of time to accept. But I am worried about the amount to which I should be increasing. Everywhere I have read people recommend to gradually increase but in my scenario the previous owner never increased the rent according to the market. If I will the rent by 10% every year, I will be at great loss which I don't want. I do want to increase the rent but I am not sure what number sounds reasonable which can benefit me and does not sound super crazy to the renters.

  • Bjorn AhlbladPro Member
    Investor · Shelton, WA · Member since 2017 · 6k+ posts · 6k+ votes
    4y

    @Tarun Mitra you definitely don't want to be subsidizing your tenants at today's property prices. The only problem you may encounter is if your tenants decide they do not want to leave and you have to evict. No way to predict the outcome in that event. 

    You may want to consider joining Wa Land lord's association. Great networking and lots of legal support. Membership is 75 bucks a year. All the best!

  • Real Estate Broker · Rochester Hills, MI · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y

    Put together a book of all the comps.....just kidding.  You need to do two things.  1) take an honest assessment of the condition of the units.  Are they in market condition?  If not, then you can keep the condition and rates below market value.  2) Raise rents (and conditions if necessary).  You can give the tenants the choice of staying at market rates and with a refresh or going.  Lot easier to just start fresh but some like to give the tenants the choice.  

    There is no easy way to do this.  No easy way to tell someone their rent is going up 50% (if your local law even allows that kind of an increase).  Don't try to be cute with 50 a month more for 1 year etc....

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y

    You need to get your rents up to market ASAP...not all at once perhaps, but you gotta do it. If you lose a tenant along the way, so be it.

    Particularly as we get into these high inflation years....you will be losing a LOT of money, and I'm sure that's not why you entered this business.

    At a loss of $1000 a month, you are leaving $12,000 a year on the table! Do you not need that money? If you don't either send it to me, or donate it to a worthy charity, but don't let your tenants keep it, they're not doing anything to deserve that kind of paycheck.

    And you'll say - 'But they're good tenants'....No kidding, they're getting a free ride, everyone will be a good tenant for that kind of discount. Raise them to market and see if they're still 'good tenants'......

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    4y

    What was your plan when you bought the duplex?  You knew rents were below market-you said you planned on increasing them.  Talk to the tenants and introduce yourself.  They need to know who to call and who to pay the rent to come Monday.  You can also let them know their security deposits are now with you.  Do you plan on doing any renos to the place or was it in good condition?

    you said they are month to month and need 60 days' notice, so tell them you plan to bring the rents up to market value and will do it in two increments-one in 60 days and the other in one year.  You can also sign them to a 1 year lease.  If they decide to leave rather than pay the increased rent, then go right to market value when you list it.  Vacancies also cost money in the short term, but if you are way below market value, clean up the unit, paint and do what needs to be done and in the long term you will be further ahead.

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    4y

    H Tarun,

    The first hurdle you have to deal with is "Are the Units up to Market Rent standard" (inside and outside).

    10 year old carpet, appliances, paint, etc....are probably at the end of their service life.

    How much will it cost to turn the unit (down time as well as labor and supplies) to bring it up to Market Rent standards?

    What does a market rent apartment look like for your Class and neighborhood and what is considered dated?

    Good Luck!

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    4y

    @Tarun Mitra These are month to month tenants there is no rule saying you can't increase now and then in 6 months.  Chances are they know they are getting a deal.  Also what @Scott Mac says is very true about condition.   I love those example photos!

  • Member since 2021 · 10 posts · 7 votes
    4y

    Thank you all for responding to the post. In terms of the condition to the property, the previous owner did make some minor upgrades. The unit where the tenant is living there for 10 years has more wear and tear compared to the other unit where the tenants lived only for four years. I am also willing to do little upgrades if tenant requests or if they leave. I just thought if the existing tenants will keep on living, it will reduce a lot of hassle for me but if things come to that I will definitely fix things to bring it to market price.  

  • Chesterton, IN · Member since 2021 · 14 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    Ok - so I'm rather inexperienced. But, do the tenants & their current leases & situation ever come in to play when looking at a property? I'm not saying people should be angels, or anyone deserves anything. I'm just asking the question- you knew these people were living here at a certain rate. You bought the property needing to raise rents. Do people go into properties knowing they're going to significantly change others life? Again, I'm not pretending to know right & wrong here, but this type of scenario seems like asking what is the nice way to screw these people I plan on screwing (since you bought it needing to raise rents).  Just asking about the human element. And this is a general question I've wondered, not really aimed at the OP.

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    4y

    Raising rent is not screwing people. Market prices go up and down. If you want to purchase a good or service, you should expect to pay market price. The fact that the tenants found a seller who was selling something at under market price doesn't mean they are entitled to that great deal for eternity. 

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Ben F.:

    asking what is the nice way to screw these people I plan on screwing (since you bought it needing to raise rents). 

    Not piling on, but as Greg just said, raising rent has zero to do with 'screwing' anyone. Where did you get that concept? If a bar sells beer at happy hour for $2 as a special (loss leader), and a new owner takes over and raises that to $5..is he screwing people? 

    Obviously you have never run a business, but if you intend to, you will do yourself a service by figuring this stuff out early....

  • Chesterton, IN · Member since 2021 · 14 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    Obviously I understand the concept of raising rent & apply it.  In general I don't consider raising rent to be screwing people.  I was wondering since these were so far under market when purchased - does anyone factor in the humans when purchasing a property like this.  Believe me, I want to make money too - but this type of scenario where you know you're going to have to significantly change something for someone - I wondered if anyone considered that.  First two responses tell me "no".  

  • Member since 2021 · 10 posts · 7 votes
    4y

    I agree with Greg here that increasing rent is not screwing people because if I won't increase the rent then technically the tenants are screwing me. I will be very negative on the cash flow and it is like the tenants are taking advantage just because previous owner was ok with not getting to the market price. 

    Also, the only reason previous owner was ok with that price is because when he bought the house he bought is way cheaper than what I paid in this market. He probably was making more money with this rent because he paid half the price that I paid. So, that is why he was fine with not increasing because he was still making good cash flow on it.

  • Rental Property Investor · Clarksville, TN · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Ben F.:

    Obviously I understand the concept of raising rent & apply it.  In general I don't consider raising rent to be screwing people.  I was wondering since these were so far under market when purchased - does anyone factor in the humans when purchasing a property like this.  Believe me, I want to make money too - but this type of scenario where you know you're going to have to significantly change something for someone - I wondered if anyone considered that.  First two responses tell me "no".  

    You can find questions like the OP posted many times on the forum, which tells you yes, people consider the human element often. After a lifetime of investing and experience in these situations, many may have an answer ready that does not require introspective reflection of a period acceptable to you. I've faced this situation both as a new investor and a less new investor. If you don't keep up with market rates, you create an artificial financial environment for your tenant. The longer that period is, the greater that artificial environment differs from the real world. Assuming an average rent price that is $200 under market, over ten years a tenant should be $24,000 ahead. Are you going to find this situation? Never, because someone that seized the opportunity doesn't live there anymore. The only person that stayed has found a way to spend that $200 each and every month. Here's how the tenants that I have had in this situation with have chosen to spend their money:

    Out of my deep respect of my property manager I will disclose these have all been inherited tenants and not tenants that they placed.

    1) Buying sports car for weekend cruiser

    2) Not having to work (daughter living with mom off her social security check)

    3) Paying for movers to leave the property without notice while 2 weeks late on that month's rent

    4) Drugs

    You don't have to count number 3, I'm just still bitter lol.

    So if a humane approach is to slowly increase the rents, which you have described as a normal occurrence and acceptable practice eventually you will still reach a point with 99% of people where you have priced them out of your property. Are you responsible to keep them housed? Pay to help them move? Pay the deposit on their next property? Let them stay a couple months free so they can afford it on their own?

    If he does it in 60 days by raising the rent quickly or in another ten years by raising the rents slowly, the result will be the same. The tenant will not be able to afford to live there.

    In my experience most people are just living by the consequences of a series of decisions they made during their lifetime. I've met very few that are uncontrollably victims of circumstance.

    Those observations have led to my advice for the OP:

    Give the tenants a couple months to figure it out but let them know what the rent is going to either eventually or all at once and let them know you've given them the extra time because you know they've lived there for a while and given them plenty of time to move. You could give them six months, but I don't think anyone looks for a new rental six months out so at that point you are just subsidizing their rent more. Landlords that don't raise rent for ten years usually have done out of necessity because they don't maintain anything and won't be able to get the property re rented. Expect substantial capital expenses and repairs until you get caught up on all the deferred maintenance.

    That took forever, next time my response is going to be. "Just raise the rent"

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Ben F.:

    does anyone factor in the humans when purchasing a property like this.   but this type of scenario where you know you're going to have to significantly change something for someone - I wondered if anyone considered that. 

    You really can't Ben - now that doesn't mean go out and be an ahole about it, there are many other ways....but to keep the rent artificially low does both the tenant and landlord a huge disservice.

    You are running a business not a charity. The tenant is taking advantage of you and they know it. That doesn't mean they are aholes either, everyone loves a deal. If you are going to enter this REI business you have to be tough. If you feel really altruistic, you can keep the extra $ you are collecting and give it to a deserving charity....?

  • Chesterton, IN · Member since 2021 · 14 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    Actually I appreciated the longer version fwiw. Especially the part that stated 60 days vs 10 years. 

  • Chesterton, IN · Member since 2021 · 14 posts · 4 votes
    4y

    Thanks Bruce - I'm not suggesting anyone give anything away. My question was more pre-purchase which most are ignoring.  I wondered does anyone decide for or against a property in a situation like this...especially if their only 2 actions would be raise rent 50% or not be able to afford it.  Would you buy in this situation or pass?

  • Member since 2021 · 10 posts · 7 votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Ben F.:

    Thanks Bruce - I'm not suggesting anyone give anything away. My question was more pre-purchase which most are ignoring.  I wondered does anyone decide for or against a property in a situation like this...especially if their only 2 actions would be raise rent 50% or not be able to afford it.  Would you buy in this situation or pass?

    I am not sure how every one else did but when I was about to make an offer, I did check what kind of tenants are there. What kind of leases are they on? In the property description itself it was mentioned that the rent is below the market. I honestly did not check whether the existing tenant would be able to afford the new rent. If I will ask that information to the seller, I am not sure how he will answer. I am pretty sure he is not going to tell me whether the tenants can afford the new rent or not. 

    The only things I liked to know was how did you vet the tenants. Will there be an issue evicting them in case they don't agree to the rent increase. 

  • Investor · Newark, DE · Member since 2014 · 246 posts · 198 votes
    4y

    I bought a couple of properties with below market rent tenants last year. Both long term tenants, like 4th year M2M after their annual lease expired. I offered them to sign a lease with me for a period of their choice (up to 1 year) at the current rent, and informed them that after the expiration of that lease rent is going up. 

    One tenant signed for 9 months, and then for another year at a higher rent. The other signed for 6 months and then moved out, and I re-rented it at market rent. 

    I could have given them 60 day notice right away. I probably lost a few hundred dollars by not doing it. Or maybe I avoided a protracted eviction by treating them like people, and saved a few thousand... I guess I will never know. I have no regrets though. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland OR · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    4y

    There is no law that says you must increase rent to "market rate" ....  You had a number you had in mind when you purchased the property - what was that number? 

    How much work do these units need if tenants vacate? How much will it cost you to bring up to "market condition' and how much will you loose in vacancy costs while you renovate and then search for a tenant?   Do you know GCs are very very hard to find and they are scheduling 6 months out? 

    I think you need much more info to make a decision.   An increase of say 3-7% might be a reasonable increase if you just want to do nothing and raise rent. 

  • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
    Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
    4y
    Originally posted by @Ben F.:

    Thanks Bruce - I'm not suggesting anyone give anything away. My question was more pre-purchase which most are ignoring.  I wondered does anyone decide for or against a property in a situation like this...especially if their only 2 actions would be raise rent 50% or not be able to afford it.  Would you buy in this situation or pass?

     Ah ok, that's your question.....so personally, I would probably not buy a property that had tenants so far behind the market. Just a hassle to get them even close to market and yes, I would feel bad about that sort of impact on someone's life. But at the same time knowing that I had to raise rents to stick to my good business model...

    I would pass and go find another property - yes probably pay more, but in the end, might be ahead. Certainly ahead in terms of stress.....

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.