Filtering tenant requests: what’s necessary/what’s not

Filtering tenant requests: what’s necessary/what’s not

Member since 2020 · 6 posts · 3 votes

Hi! 

I’m new to being a landlord. I purchased a duplex with an existing tenant. That tenant is requesting a number of things that I am trying to determine if they are my duty as landlord to address immediately or if they are items of preference. Here are a couple of examples with my general thought associated with each:

1. Replace existing working deadbolt with a heavier duty one. (My duplex has common building entrance and then separate apt entrances. Tenant is asking about their apt entrance. Current deadbolt works, but she says she feels unsafe)

2. Ceiling fan in kitchen

3. Replace outlets that don’t hold a plug

4. Protecting outlet close to bathroom shower.

5. Replacing a working but visually I pleasing toilet.

6. New blinds

7. Painting rooms

8. Fix slight crack in window


I believe numbers (3) and (4) are immediate needs. Outside of that, everything else is preference to me. I am generally trying to get a feel for how to deal with these kinds of requests. What are my legal obligations? What are landlord best practices? How do I properly respond when there’s a request I’m not going to address?

0Reply
78 views

Most Popular Reply

Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
Moderator
Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
4y
Quote from @Damon Raynor:

Hi! 

I’m new to being a landlord. I purchased a duplex with an existing tenant. That tenant is requesting a number of things that I am trying to determine if they are my duty as landlord to address immediately or if they are items of preference. Here are a couple of examples with my general thought associated with each:

1. Replace existing working deadbolt with a heavier duty one. (My duplex has common building entrance and then separate apt entrances. Tenant is asking about their apt entrance. Current deadbolt works, but she says she feels unsafe)

2. Ceiling fan in kitchen

3. Replace outlets that don’t hold a plug

4. Protecting outlet close to bathroom shower.

5. Replacing a working but visually I pleasing toilet.

6. New blinds

7. Painting rooms

8. Fix slight crack in window


I believe numbers (3) and (4) are immediate needs. Outside of that, everything else is preference to me. I am generally trying to get a feel for how to deal with these kinds of requests. What are my legal obligations? What are landlord best practices? How do I properly respond when there’s a request I’m not going to address?


You won't make any money in real estate if you allow tenants to work you over like a sumo wrestler works over a Golden Corral buffet.

Your responsibility is to maintain the home in the condition it was rented. If something breaks, you fix it. If they rented the property with old paint, a functional lock, and an ugly toilet, that means they accepted those things and will continue to accept them until they break.

She rented the apartment in this condition. You're a new Landlord, so she's hoping to talk you into a bunch of upgrades without an increase in rent. I would figure out what market rent would be if all these improvements were made, then I would tell her she can continue renting it "as is" or you can make the improvements and then rent it to her at the higher rate. I would not make the improvements without compensation.

For future renters, you should include a simple clause in your lease that says they are renting it in "as is" condition. You will make repairs, but you will not make improvements. Mine is below. It's also designed to ward off people that rent sight unseen and then complain about wall color, size of rooms, etc. I get dozens of out-of-state renters every year and this has stopped a ton of complaints/fights.

MOVE-IN CONDITION. Tenant acknowledges the rental was represented through marketing materials designed to attract applicants for in-person inspections. Tenant was given the opportunity to inspect the rental prior to signing this Agreement. Tenant elects to accept the property in its current condition and/or they are waiving their opportunity to inspect, at their own choosing and for their own convenience. Landlord shall not be obligated to clean, decorate, alter, repair, or otherwise improve the rental, either before or after the execution of this lease, unless agreed to in writing as part of this Agreement.

The DIY Landlord Book4.7246 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Nathan GesnerBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Real Estate Broker · Cody, WY · Member since 2010 · 28k+ posts · 41k+ votes
    4y
    Quote from @Damon Raynor:

    Hi! 

    I’m new to being a landlord. I purchased a duplex with an existing tenant. That tenant is requesting a number of things that I am trying to determine if they are my duty as landlord to address immediately or if they are items of preference. Here are a couple of examples with my general thought associated with each:

    1. Replace existing working deadbolt with a heavier duty one. (My duplex has common building entrance and then separate apt entrances. Tenant is asking about their apt entrance. Current deadbolt works, but she says she feels unsafe)

    2. Ceiling fan in kitchen

    3. Replace outlets that don’t hold a plug

    4. Protecting outlet close to bathroom shower.

    5. Replacing a working but visually I pleasing toilet.

    6. New blinds

    7. Painting rooms

    8. Fix slight crack in window


    I believe numbers (3) and (4) are immediate needs. Outside of that, everything else is preference to me. I am generally trying to get a feel for how to deal with these kinds of requests. What are my legal obligations? What are landlord best practices? How do I properly respond when there’s a request I’m not going to address?


    You won't make any money in real estate if you allow tenants to work you over like a sumo wrestler works over a Golden Corral buffet.

    Your responsibility is to maintain the home in the condition it was rented. If something breaks, you fix it. If they rented the property with old paint, a functional lock, and an ugly toilet, that means they accepted those things and will continue to accept them until they break.

    She rented the apartment in this condition. You're a new Landlord, so she's hoping to talk you into a bunch of upgrades without an increase in rent. I would figure out what market rent would be if all these improvements were made, then I would tell her she can continue renting it "as is" or you can make the improvements and then rent it to her at the higher rate. I would not make the improvements without compensation.

    For future renters, you should include a simple clause in your lease that says they are renting it in "as is" condition. You will make repairs, but you will not make improvements. Mine is below. It's also designed to ward off people that rent sight unseen and then complain about wall color, size of rooms, etc. I get dozens of out-of-state renters every year and this has stopped a ton of complaints/fights.

    MOVE-IN CONDITION. Tenant acknowledges the rental was represented through marketing materials designed to attract applicants for in-person inspections. Tenant was given the opportunity to inspect the rental prior to signing this Agreement. Tenant elects to accept the property in its current condition and/or they are waiving their opportunity to inspect, at their own choosing and for their own convenience. Landlord shall not be obligated to clean, decorate, alter, repair, or otherwise improve the rental, either before or after the execution of this lease, unless agreed to in writing as part of this Agreement.

    The DIY Landlord Book4.7246 Reviews
  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    4y

    Hi Damon,

    What Nathan says,

    [OR]

    DO THIS ASAP

    3. Replace outlets that don’t hold a plug

    4. Protecting outlet close to bathroom shower.

    8. Fix slight crack in window

    Offer this for an extra $25 a month.

    1. Replace existing working deadbolt with a heavier duty one. (My duplex has common building entrance and then separate apt entrances. Tenant is asking about their apt entrance. Current deadbolt works, but she says she feels unsafe)

    2. Ceiling fan in kitchen

    Offer this for an extra $50 a month.

    5. Replacing a working but visually I pleasing toilet.

    No these are Turn Items--do not let the renter paint the rooms.

    6. New blinds

    7. Painting rooms

    Good Luck!

    (How did I come up with this $ numbers--I winged it!)

  • Investor · Clairemont, CA · Member since 2011 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y

    If this was my rental here would be my responses to those specific issues:

    1. No, the deadbolt that is currently there works and will not be replaced

    2. No, the home was rented without a ceiling fan and one will not be installed.

    3. I would likely have already replaced all the outlets as this is a cheap visual improvement. Since this is a function of that item not working as intended I'd do these...personally I'd probably do all of them at one time and use the square face outlets which look cleaner. The outlets and covers are less than $2 total for each outlet, so this is to me a cheap resolution to her problem and at the same time would actually be a small upgrade to the unit since the new outlets will have a nice fresh look. If the outlets weren't loose already then I would wait and do this at a turnover.

    4. You're welcome to purchase outlet baby proofing covers to install if you feel that is needed. (I may reconsider this one depending on how close the outlet is to the shower, or would install a GFCI if this is old enough that it doesn't already have one. It's fairly common for there to be an outlet nearby and it is safe as long as you're not showering like Shamu in the splash zone at Seaworld)

    5. No, this is the condition the property was rented in. 

    6.No, this is the condition the property was rented in.

    7.No, this is the condition the property was rented in.

    8. I'd likely do this one as even if you say no, the reality is in most jurisdictions a cracked or broken pane of glass is considered a violation for building habitability. Common sense says a small crack doesn't effect the integrity of the window, but codes aren't written to differentiate between small and large cracks, just that a broken window creates an uninhabitable condition. 

  • Specialist · Easton, PA · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    4y

    Ok so since I am a contractor and do my own work- here’s how I’d play this list:

    Replace outlets/bathroom gfi- yes 

    Kitchen ceiling fan- if they want to buy one I’d be happy to install

    Cracked window- yes 

    Deadbolt- why not, it’s $15 and 5 mins 

    Toilet- if it lost it’s glazing inside and looks hideous, sure. $100 and 20 mins  

    Blinds- nope 

    Painting- nope 

    But they would definitely see an increase when the lease allowed  

  • Member since 2020 · 6 posts · 3 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Nathan Gesner:
    Quote from @Damon Raynor:

    Hi! 

    I’m new to being a landlord. I purchased a duplex with an existing tenant. That tenant is requesting a number of things that I am trying to determine if they are my duty as landlord to address immediately or if they are items of preference. Here are a couple of examples with my general thought associated with each:

    1. Replace existing working deadbolt with a heavier duty one. (My duplex has common building entrance and then separate apt entrances. Tenant is asking about their apt entrance. Current deadbolt works, but she says she feels unsafe)

    2. Ceiling fan in kitchen

    3. Replace outlets that don’t hold a plug

    4. Protecting outlet close to bathroom shower.

    5. Replacing a working but visually I pleasing toilet.

    6. New blinds

    7. Painting rooms

    8. Fix slight crack in window


    I believe numbers (3) and (4) are immediate needs. Outside of that, everything else is preference to me. I am generally trying to get a feel for how to deal with these kinds of requests. What are my legal obligations? What are landlord best practices? How do I properly respond when there’s a request I’m not going to address?


    You won't make any money in real estate if you allow tenants to work you over like a sumo wrestler works over a Golden Corral buffet.

    Your responsibility is to maintain the home in the condition it was rented. If something breaks, you fix it. If they rented the property with old paint, a functional lock, and an ugly toilet, that means they accepted those things and will continue to accept them until they break.

    She rented the apartment in this condition. You're a new Landlord, so she's hoping to talk you into a bunch of upgrades without an increase in rent. I would figure out what market rent would be if all these improvements were made, then I would tell her she can continue renting it "as is" or you can make the improvements and then rent it to her at the higher rate. I would not make the improvements without compensation.

    For future renters, you should include a simple clause in your lease that says they are renting it in "as is" condition. You will make repairs, but you will not make improvements. Mine is below. It's also designed to ward off people that rent sight unseen and then complain about wall color, size of rooms, etc. I get dozens of out-of-state renters every year and this has stopped a ton of complaints/fights.

    MOVE-IN CONDITION. Tenant acknowledges the rental was represented through marketing materials designed to attract applicants for in-person inspections. Tenant was given the opportunity to inspect the rental prior to signing this Agreement. Tenant elects to accept the property in its current condition and/or they are waiving their opportunity to inspect, at their own choosing and for their own convenience. Landlord shall not be obligated to clean, decorate, alter, repair, or otherwise improve the rental, either before or after the execution of this lease, unless agreed to in writing as part of this Agreement.


     Hey Nathan! Coming back here to say that I greatly appreciate your reply. it was super helpful for me. Thank you!

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    4y

    Why does she suddenly feel unsafe when she's live there for a while? Chances are if you changed it, she wouldn't like the new one.

    replacing the ceiling fan (unless it isn't working), toilet, new blinds, painting rooms I'd say no.  She knew what was there when she moved in.  

    If the crack in the window is cosmetic, I'd leave it until the weather warms up.

    If the outlet close to the shower isn't a GFI, I'd replace it.  For outlets that don't hold a plug check that it isn't the item being plugged in that is a problem. Often you can gently bend the two prongs (not the ground) out a tiny bit.

  • Member since 2021 · 6 posts · 2 votes
    4y
    Quote from @Scott Mac:

    Hi Damon,

    What Nathan says,

    [OR]

    DO THIS ASAP

    3. Replace outlets that don’t hold a plug

    4. Protecting outlet close to bathroom shower.

    8. Fix slight crack in window

    Offer this for an extra $25 a month.

    1. Replace existing working deadbolt with a heavier duty one. (My duplex has common building entrance and then separate apt entrances. Tenant is asking about their apt entrance. Current deadbolt works, but she says she feels unsafe)

    2. Ceiling fan in kitchen

    Offer this for an extra $50 a month.

    5. Replacing a working but visually I pleasing toilet.

    No these are Turn Items--do not let the renter paint the rooms.

    6. New blinds

    7. Painting rooms

    Good Luck!

    (How did I come up with this $ numbers--I winged it!)


     Hi Scott-

    Thanks for this.  It was very validating.  I am in a similar situation (just bought a duplex and the upstairs tenant is paying below market rent).  She also wants new blinds, new insulation, and new windows.  It seems to me that most of these requests are good opportunities to get more rent.   I've got my fingers crossed that it will work out that way out here.  Anyway, just wanted to pipe in and glad to hear that others are thinking the same thing.  

    Best, 
    Gila

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.