Investor · Willow Spring, NC · Member since 2009 · 5k+ posts · 3k+ votes
I'd like BP Nation's input on your tenant's view of you (as a landlord, leasing agent, resident manager, etc.) as seen through your tenant's eyes. 'A' to 'F'. I'd also be interested as to the hows and whys relating to your answer.
So, just like the title says. If your tenants could give you a grade, what would it be? You can include current tenants, prior tenants, and 'near'-tenants (applicants who turn your property down... maybe because they thought you were a 'D'-type landlord???)
If you're getting an A from your tenant, you are spending far too much time socializing with them and being their whipping boy. Your tenants should not be your friends. Some people view them as customers, but I don't see them that way either. Customers are always right. My tenants are rarely right. My tenant's job is to take care of my property and pay rent on time. My job is to fix things that need fixing and charge them for things they break. The relationship never goes any further than that. I honestly don't care what they think of me as long as they pay the rent on time, don't cause me problems and don't mess up my properties.
Regarding "Because this depends on the reasonableness of the tenant, there can't be an objective rating." That's very true.
My overall thoughts are mostly aligned with @Aaron Mazzrillo 's first post.
I got the idea for posting this topic after having a short conversation with a prospect for one of our rentals. The conversation went something like this (paraphrasing):
'I went to the BBB and looked up your company. Do you know your score?'
I replied, 'I have no clue.' 'Your company has an A+. My current manager has a 'C'. My lease is up soon and I want to get a better manager...'
I'm thinking... seriously? That was a new one for me. I was going to try to explain that the BBB score had little to do with anything, but she kept talking and talking about her rental problems. After 60 or so seconds, I had to politely interrupt her. Luckily our property was not close to where she worked, so that was that. In the bit bucket.
"Because this depends on the reasonableness of the tenant, there can't be an objective rating."
We gotten several calls in the last month from a tenant in an SFR regarding heat. It's been a severe winter in the northeast, and it's an old house. We had the utility company come out and find there was nothing wrong with the boiler, we've had the plumber come out and bleed the radiator, our contractor insulated the windows and doors on the first floor, and we even bought the tenant a $200 "Amish fireplace" room heater. After each thing we did, the calls became more frequent, insisting it was still too cold in the house and her heating bills were too high.
We did not get a thank-you for the room heater, and each service call cost us money. When a tenant is getting extra service, do they pay extra rent as a thank you? Nope. What they tend to do is call more frequently, wanting more effort to make them comfortable, with no thought to expense. Our heating bills this winter have been very high too - we just wear more clothes.
We live far from all our tenants, so we've never been invited to a bbq ;)
A tip from another landlord near me. He sends his tenants to that rating website right after he has done something that really pleased the tenant - what better way is there to get a high rating :)
I would guess I would get a B or C rating. I try to be responsive but some little things do not get done until I am there on a bigger thing. I fix a fridge or a stove usually within 24 hours, the my faucet leaks out the top when I turn it on make take months.
I'd like to think we're usually a B, but clueless tenants would give us an F I'm sure.
One thing I've been toying with as an idea to help with revitalization in my low income neighborhood is some sort of program that matches responsible tenants to responsible landlords and possibly pools deposits. But it's just a germ of an idea at this point, and part of it is how bad do tenants and landlords need to be before they would be off the program. Interesting to ponder.
Some of these responses amuse me. "If they give me an A, I'm doing something wrong, and letting them take advantage of me. The only way I'd get an A is if I let them stay for free."
Nonesense. Renters are consumers. I was just asked to rate the dealership where I recently bought a new car. I gave them an A. I assure you, they did not give me the car for free.
The answers a tenant gives will be dependent on if they are in good standings or not. There are companies like www.rentrange.com that are comming out with rating systems that are based on the comanies numbers, such as vacancy, reserves, trust account violations, and so on. Those scores will be based more on the company ability to turnover and be reasoable on maintenance.
Nonesense. Renters are consumers. I was just asked to rate the dealership where I recently bought a new car. I gave them an A. I assure you, they did not give me the car for free.
Would you still give them an A if they repo'd your car?
Look below this Window, and you will see a list of names of people that have posted in this thread.
Click on the name of the person that you want notified via an email, that you responded to them.
If you are a Colleague with anyone that has NOT posted in the thread, and you want them to see your post, hold down the shift key, type the @ and the first 4 letters of their First or Last Name.
Then look below this Window and click on that person's name.
Interesting post - as with our modes or models of investing, most of us have different approaches. I'd say we would be rated a solid B+....many of our tenants refer new tenants to us. What we do is much more personalized and we include tenants in the selection process for new renters. We have a sitdown and everyone gets to know each other some. Shared housing requires this to be successful. We have had some tenants have to leave us due to job loss or transfers but we've also helped a few get back up on their feet by providing temporary housing at no charge in units that I personally own. It's my form of charity. Each renter has found employment and been able to pay me in full or is in the process of making payments...and all remained tenants.
We would only be rated a D or lower by those who we screen out on the front end. Not everyone is a good fit for shared housing. Like the others, we respond immediately to emergency repairs...we had a couple units with frozen pipes this year. We tend to clump the smaller repairs together so we can knock them out in one trip. In over two years, we haven't had a single eviction for non-payment...doesn't mean it won't happen. Happy Investing!
Well, James, I suppose if they just repo'd the car because I hadn't paid for it, I would probably slink off and not rate them at all.
If I paid my money as agreed, and they refused to fix "small" items until there were enough of them to bundle together and make it more convenient for them to schedule a time...you had better believe that they would get a "C" at the absolute best.
And, importantly I think for some people on this thread, if I paid as agreed, they provided the car as agreed, and they generally had an unfriendly attitude and treated me like something they needed to scrape off their shoe...they also wouldn't be getting an "A". Or a referral.
I wonder how many of the chest-thumpers are landlords in densely-populated areas where there is always a pool of potential tenants who have't heard of them, and how they interact with tenants. The combined total population of the three towns where I own properties is less than 10,000. Word gets around right quick-like. If you don't have a customer service attitude, you're toast.
I was a long time renter. I'm 36 years old and was a renter up until 10/31/2013. since that time my fiance and I have moved 1000 miles, bought our primary home, and just last month closed on our first investment property. I've had great landlords and I've had some real azzholes and there is no other way to describe them. I was essentially evicted one time about 9 years ago. I came upon some hard times. I was in the fitness business and tore up my knee requiring surgery along with going through a messy break up. my income was dwindled down and it was a struggle to pay rent on time. I was in and out of housing court 3 months straight always managing to scrap up the money to present to the judge and save my ***. My landlord was understanding; he knew I was a good guy, he didn't judge me as a bad person, he nicely asked me to just give up the apartment, swallow my pride and go rent just a room or something even cheaper til I got back on my feet and ultimately that is what I did. I would rate him a solid B+ landlord. I understood that he was doing his job. Then I had my last landlord who I thought was good until we moved out and she started trying to charge us for lightbulbs, alleged water stains on the sink cabinet and other ridiculous things that clearly fall under the category of wear and tear. I would certainly rate them a D now.
Now that I'm a landlord, I hope to be understanding of my tenants yet firm because I understand that being a landlord isn't about keeping them happy, it's about providing a quality of life for me and my fiancee through these investments. I too am trying to make our places nicer and go after higher rents than average in our area and it was a huge success in this first rental and I think by being understanding and accessible to reasonable requests since the tenant is paying a premium price is only fair.