Tenant screening questions

Tenant screening questions

Member since 2023 · 6 posts · 1 vote

Hi everyone, 

Renting for the first time and I have a few questions for seasoned landlords:

1. Which tenant screening app/website gives the most comprehensive results? 
2. What questions you are asking tenants before renting? 
3. Any other suggestion recommendations are appreciated. 

For the context I live in jersey city and it is an owner occupied two family and I'm renting the second unit. 

0Reply
257 views

Most Popular Reply

Drew SygitBusiness Member
Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
1y

@Leo Parshukov it's NOT the screening app that makes a difference, it's knowing how to interpret the data!

FICO scores and other risk scores can be misleading if there's not enough tradelines over at least a 48 month period. For some reason, FICO appears to recognize students loans in deferrment:(

Best questions to ask prosepects;
1) When are you looking to move?
2) Why aren't you renewing your exisiting lease? (lease ending is NOT an acceptable answer!)
3) How many people & pets?

Do yourself a favor and Google, "Rental Application Fraud" and read to learn.

One of the frauds we see most often is applicants claiming they live with relatives - when in fact their behind on their rent with their current landlord. 
- A screening app should provide their last several years of reported addresses. Research those in the last 2 years to find owners and use Whitepages to get owner phone numbers. 

Best advice: assume every applicant is lying until they provide documentation to prove otherwise.

See this reply in the discussion

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Melanie ThomasBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · San Antonio · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 491 votes
    1y

    I’d recommend finding a local property management company that offers a Leasing Only service. They’ll handle the marketing, take all inquiries, screen applicants, and write a strong lease for you. It’s a great way to learn the process while ensuring everything is done correctly and legally.

    Be sure to ask questions along the way so you’re better prepared when it’s time for the next tenant. And remember, screening is the most important part, taking the time to properly vet applicants can save you a lot of stress down the road. Happy to share my screening criteria if you message me. Good luck & happy investing!

    RentWerx Property Management4.73219 Reviews
  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    1y

    @Leo Parshukov it's NOT the screening app that makes a difference, it's knowing how to interpret the data!

    FICO scores and other risk scores can be misleading if there's not enough tradelines over at least a 48 month period. For some reason, FICO appears to recognize students loans in deferrment:(

    Best questions to ask prosepects;
    1) When are you looking to move?
    2) Why aren't you renewing your exisiting lease? (lease ending is NOT an acceptable answer!)
    3) How many people & pets?

    Do yourself a favor and Google, "Rental Application Fraud" and read to learn.

    One of the frauds we see most often is applicants claiming they live with relatives - when in fact their behind on their rent with their current landlord. 
    - A screening app should provide their last several years of reported addresses. Research those in the last 2 years to find owners and use Whitepages to get owner phone numbers. 

    Best advice: assume every applicant is lying until they provide documentation to prove otherwise.

  • Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    Go to the screening forum. Search screening.

  • Michele FischerPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Seattle, WA · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1y

    There are a lot of standard questions that are readily available, or the screening site you choose may have their own application forms that you can't customize.

    Determine how you are going to identify which application is the strongest and ensure you are asking those questions.

    A few less common questions we ask:

    - How long do you plan to live here?

    - Have you ever sued anyone?

    - Have you been sent to collections?

    - Do you have any issues with consistently paying rent on the first of the month?

    - Do you currently own a prior landlord or utility company any money?

    And we pay attention to past addresses (for length of stay and how well they know this neighborhood) on the credit report.

  • Member since 2025 · 13 posts · 10 votes
    10mo

    Try Verento, they're new but I liked the simplicity of it.
    I don't ask anything out of the ordinary (move in date, occupants, pets, etc). I tend to trust the documents Verento provides (but still double check) since the tenant can't actually upload their docs, it's pulled from the sites they would source them from (example: bank statements come direct from the bank) which give less room for fraud.


  • Member since 2026 · 2 posts · 1 vote
    10mo

    @Drew Sygit knowing how to interpret data and identify fraud is huge. The documents are the weak link. Pay stubs and bank statements are easy to edit now, especially with AI tools. One thing that helped me with self-employed applicants specifically: instead of trusting uploaded PDFs, use a tool that connects directly to their bank through Plaid. You see the real transaction data, not a document they could have edited. Can also compare what's on their PDF to the actual bank balance to catch mismatches. For first time landlords, I'd add these questions:

    - Are you W2 employed or self-employed/1099?
    - Can you provide 6 months of bank statements?

    Self-employed applicants are trickier to verify but not impossible if you know what to look for.

    • Drew SygitBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
      10mo
      Quote from @Patrick Genevich:

      @Drew Sygit knowing how to interpret data and identify fraud is huge. The documents are the weak link. Pay stubs and bank statements are easy to edit now, especially with AI tools. One thing that helped me with self-employed applicants specifically: instead of trusting uploaded PDFs, use a tool that connects directly to their bank through Plaid. You see the real transaction data, not a document they could have edited. Can also compare what's on their PDF to the actual bank balance to catch mismatches. For first time landlords, I'd add these questions:

      - Are you W2 employed or self-employed/1099?
      - Can you provide 6 months of bank statements?

      Self-employed applicants are trickier to verify but not impossible if you know what to look for.


       What tool you using to access Plaid?

      Haven't seen that allows individual owners to access Plaid...

    • Member since 2025 · 13 posts · 10 votes
      10mo
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:
      Quote from @Patrick Genevich:

      @Drew Sygit knowing how to interpret data and identify fraud is huge. The documents are the weak link. Pay stubs and bank statements are easy to edit now, especially with AI tools. One thing that helped me with self-employed applicants specifically: instead of trusting uploaded PDFs, use a tool that connects directly to their bank through Plaid. You see the real transaction data, not a document they could have edited. Can also compare what's on their PDF to the actual bank balance to catch mismatches. For first time landlords, I'd add these questions:

      - Are you W2 employed or self-employed/1099?
      - Can you provide 6 months of bank statements?

      Self-employed applicants are trickier to verify but not impossible if you know what to look for.


       What tool you using to access Plaid?

      Haven't seen that allows individual owners to access Plaid...


      You’re right, from what I’ve seen Individuals can’t access plaid directly - only businesses that apply and are approved can offer access to plaid to their users. 

  • Dominic RosatoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Jersey City, NJ · Member since 2022 · 82 posts · 61 votes
    10mo

    Hi Leo, for our landlords we require that applicants show a minimum of 40x the monthly rent in annual income and have credit 680+. The documents at a MINIMUM that we require from all persons over 18 are:

    - 2 most recent pay stubs

    - 2 most recent banks statements (showing proof of funds and paystub deposits)

    - Last year's 1040

    - Government ID

    There's many credit check systems that operate similarly (you can try simply using Zillow), but just as important as the score is making sure you verify there are no current collections owed, outstanding balances, etc.

    Assuming you are renting it out yourself, here's a few things that I do for my listings in JC:

    1) Pay the $30 for a Zillow Premium listing. Most agents/landlords don't know about this, but it helps get more eyes on the listing. 

    2) Professional photos are a must. We also usually do virtual staging on the first photo or two - it helps get more clicks.

    3) Require renters insurance. I'd say at least 500k in liability coverage.

    4) Since it is January, I would recommend aiming for at least a 14-15 mo lease. This helps avoid a winter renewal, when you typically have less negotiating leverage on the renewal price and if the tenant vacates, it can be more challenging to secure a quick replacement.

    Feel free to reach out if you need photographer recs or if I can help in any way.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.