Renting a unit to someone in coast guard with no credit history

Renting a unit to someone in coast guard with no credit history

Member since 2020 · 404 posts · 235 votes

Wanted to get some advice. I have a 1 bdroom unit for $1,650/mo in the city of Long Beach California. A 19 year old female from out of state who is currently in the coast guard and will be transferring to San Pedro on a 3 year rotation.  She has no credit history but is able to show me a pay stub of $1,700 biweekly and also a $2,700/month housing allowance from the coast guard.  Also will be showing some bank statements from her mom and herself. 

She is willing to sign a lease without physically viewing the unit and will need to sign a lease electronically. Her mom is willing to co-sign for her since she does not have any credit history. 

Typically I would like to meet a person face to face but since this is not possible I wanted to ask if there is any red flags or big risk here? It is a low end unit here in my area and most of the people I am getting are either bad credit or trying to move a family of 3 into there. She did get a video tour of the unit and wants to proceed. The government salary sounds safe but with basically no rental/credit history I am basically got not much to go on.  I never actually done a co-sign before. Would it just be another name and signature on the lease?

2Reply
238 views

Most Popular Reply

Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
8mo

Well, your are giving up essentially a full month of rent. Unless you at least obtain a "Hold" (good faith) deposit in good funds now, she can keep looking and potentially find something she likes better. People are generally poor at judging room sizes based on vids or pics; nor can they get an honest "feel" for the property and neighborhood as a whole. They also do not have the opportunity to check things out operationally, which could unnecessarily cause multiple service calls for issues that could have been better handled if noted at a showing beforehand.

Personally, I would never hold a unit that long intentionally, for anybody.

Yes, deployments happen without much warning. You should always ask for a copy of their orders prior to deployment, or if they need to vacate early. The SCRA details the lawfully allowed timelines and process they must follow. 

One additional item to be aware of, often, when on deployment, they might let another service member stay in their unit "while" deployed. Make it clear prior to initial signing, that you have a process to add or remove additional people on the Rental Agreement, and this would be an instance that requires that. You always need applications from every adult that will be living in a unit, but with Mil folks, for this specific type of temporary circumstance, I would not require more than a current LES and copy of their Mil ID. There IS always the possibility that they do not come back from a deployment.

Be sure your Local LL/Tenant laws allow the Sec Dep plus first/last; also if they have any rules/restrictions on "hold" deposits.

See this reply in the discussion

19 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2021 · 4 posts · 4 votes
    8mo

    Military tenants are potentially the most income-stable tenants in America. I wouldn't worry about lack of credit history when dealing with them. If you can confirm her military status (orders, physically seeing her cac, DMDC SCRA) I would proceed. Are you requiring a co-signer based of credit history alone? If she qualifies based on income I wouldn't even trouble yourself. I say this all as a past service member and current landlord in high military areas.

  • Real Estate Broker · Hyde Park Tampa, FL · Member since 2019 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8mo

    Do it...but decide what to do with the cosigner should the tenant be deployed (and it happens even when given orders are for extended assignment) which enables them to cancel the lease with 30 days notice. If you will be releasing 'mom' as well, all good - but if not, just to play it safe, put a clause that early cancellation due to any cause including deployment will not release the cosigner from the terms of the lease. 

    My client and I have had great experiences in renting to military officers; they leave the property in the same or better shape and are respectful tenants.  Hope this helps.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8mo

    You are asking for problems both in not meeting the person prior to approving, and in allowing her to accept the unit without her seeing it in person. My advice, never do either of these things. 

    If she will be arriving soon, you can wait and hold the unit for her to inspect it and the neighborhood, but do not commit without an in-person meet. If she is not arriving soon, what is your plan for charging her rent? Waiting for arrival without charging for the days you would be losing? Better off to keep showing and processing applications of people that are on location.

    Having said that, Military folks are awesome, at the E-5 paygrade and above. E-4's can be fine, but not automatically so. Below an E-4 are basically teenagers, with teenager issues to manage. No disrespect intended, just based on 30 years with LOTS of Mil Tenants.

    Here is a link that will decipher the LES (Mil pay stub) information for you.

    • Member since 2020 · 404 posts · 235 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Richard F.:

      You are asking for problems both in not meeting the person prior to approving, and in allowing her to accept the unit without her seeing it in person. My advice, never do either of these things. 

      If she will be arriving soon, you can wait and hold the unit for her to inspect it and the neighborhood, but do not commit without an in-person meet. If she is not arriving soon, what is your plan for charging her rent? Waiting for arrival without charging for the days you would be losing? Better off to keep showing and processing applications of people that are on location.

      Having said that, Military folks are awesome, at the E-5 paygrade and above. E-4's can be fine, but not automatically so. Below an E-4 are basically teenagers, with teenager issues to manage. No disrespect intended, just based on 30 years with LOTS of Mil Tenants.

      Here is a link that will decipher the LES (Mil pay stub) information for you.


       Good to know. She showed me that she is currently an E-4. She said people below an e-4 are typically get the barracks.

    • Member since 2020 · 404 posts · 235 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Richard F.:

      You are asking for problems both in not meeting the person prior to approving, and in allowing her to accept the unit without her seeing it in person. My advice, never do either of these things. 

      If she will be arriving soon, you can wait and hold the unit for her to inspect it and the neighborhood, but do not commit without an in-person meet. If she is not arriving soon, what is your plan for charging her rent? Waiting for arrival without charging for the days you would be losing? Better off to keep showing and processing applications of people that are on location.

      Having said that, Military folks are awesome, at the E-5 paygrade and above. E-4's can be fine, but not automatically so. Below an E-4 are basically teenagers, with teenager issues to manage. No disrespect intended, just based on 30 years with LOTS of Mil Tenants.

      Here is a link that will decipher the LES (Mil pay stub) information for you.


       I would ask for first, last and security deposit to hold the place if she is starting the lease in April 1st. What is the main risk without her seeing the place in person? I think she is mostly concerned on price. She mentioned there might be months she maybe on a ship but won't be living there so I think she just needs a place to leave her car and her belongings. 

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      8mo
      Quote from @David P.:
      Quote from @Richard F.:

      You are asking for problems both in not meeting the person prior to approving, and in allowing her to accept the unit without her seeing it in person. My advice, never do either of these things. 

      If she will be arriving soon, you can wait and hold the unit for her to inspect it and the neighborhood, but do not commit without an in-person meet. If she is not arriving soon, what is your plan for charging her rent? Waiting for arrival without charging for the days you would be losing? Better off to keep showing and processing applications of people that are on location.

      Having said that, Military folks are awesome, at the E-5 paygrade and above. E-4's can be fine, but not automatically so. Below an E-4 are basically teenagers, with teenager issues to manage. No disrespect intended, just based on 30 years with LOTS of Mil Tenants.

      Here is a link that will decipher the LES (Mil pay stub) information for you.


       I would ask for first, last and security deposit to hold the place if she is starting the lease in April 1st. What is the main risk without her seeing the place in person? I think she is mostly concerned on price. She mentioned there might be months she maybe on a ship but won't be living there so I think she just needs a place to leave her car and her belongings. 

       This is the second item I have seen posted by you that likely is illegal in Ca.   You cannot by explicit law charge first month, security deposit and last month.  Research the law.

      On an earlier post you implied you were turning down tenants that had 3 people for the one bedroom.  This is a bit more gray than your up front fee collection, but the CA courts seem to interpret the laws that it is illegal to restrict a unit to less than 2 per BR plus one.   This implies a 1 br cannot restrict the unit to less than 3 people.

      I also question the legality of what @Patricia Steiner suggested of holding a co-signer responsible when vacancy is terminated by a transfer.   By law, military people suffer no consequence for early lease termination the result of orders.   I am fairly confident this would apply to any co-signer.  I have had a tenant terminate a lease early based on orders.

      If you are going to self manage, it is important to know the laws.   Ca can be very punitive for LL mistakes.   If you are not prepared to know the rules, you will be best served hiring a professional PM.

      As to your initial question, I find military to be reliable tenants but recognize orders can result in early lease termination.   Having a co-signer would alleviate any concern about not having a credit score.  

      good luck

  • MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8mo

    I had 2 Navy that were solid tenants. They paid on time and took care of the place but both also ended up breaking the lease to move out earlier than anticipated. Like @Richard F. said however I would be hesitant to offer a lease to someone who hasn't seen the property. 

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8mo

    Well, your are giving up essentially a full month of rent. Unless you at least obtain a "Hold" (good faith) deposit in good funds now, she can keep looking and potentially find something she likes better. People are generally poor at judging room sizes based on vids or pics; nor can they get an honest "feel" for the property and neighborhood as a whole. They also do not have the opportunity to check things out operationally, which could unnecessarily cause multiple service calls for issues that could have been better handled if noted at a showing beforehand.

    Personally, I would never hold a unit that long intentionally, for anybody.

    Yes, deployments happen without much warning. You should always ask for a copy of their orders prior to deployment, or if they need to vacate early. The SCRA details the lawfully allowed timelines and process they must follow. 

    One additional item to be aware of, often, when on deployment, they might let another service member stay in their unit "while" deployed. Make it clear prior to initial signing, that you have a process to add or remove additional people on the Rental Agreement, and this would be an instance that requires that. You always need applications from every adult that will be living in a unit, but with Mil folks, for this specific type of temporary circumstance, I would not require more than a current LES and copy of their Mil ID. There IS always the possibility that they do not come back from a deployment.

    Be sure your Local LL/Tenant laws allow the Sec Dep plus first/last; also if they have any rules/restrictions on "hold" deposits.

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8mo
    Quote from @David P.:

    Wanted to get some advice. I have a 1 bdroom unit for $1,650/mo in the city of Long Beach California. A 19 year old female from out of state who is currently in the coast guard and will be transferring to San Pedro on a 3 year rotation.  She has no credit history but is able to show me a pay stub of $1,700 biweekly and also a $2,700/month housing allowance from the coast guard.  Also will be showing some bank statements from her mom and herself. 

    She is willing to sign a lease without physically viewing the unit and will need to sign a lease electronically. Her mom is willing to co-sign for her since she does not have any credit history. 

    Typically I would like to meet a person face to face but since this is not possible I wanted to ask if there is any red flags or big risk here? It is a low end unit here in my area and most of the people I am getting are either bad credit or trying to move a family of 3 into there. She did get a video tour of the unit and wants to proceed. The government salary sounds safe but with basically no rental/credit history I am basically got not much to go on.  I never actually done a co-sign before. Would it just be another name and signature on the lease?

    David, the lack of credit is not unusual at 19, especially in the military, so it’s not necessarily a red flag. The main things to verify are her active duty status (request a copy of orders) and confirm the housing allowance. If the mom is co-signing, make sure to thoroughly check her credit and ensure she fully understands that she is jointly and severally responsible for the lease. A co-signer isn’t just another name on the lease — they should be legally liable for any unpaid rent or damages. The fact she’s willing to sign without seeing the unit isn’t necessarily a problem, but be sure to do a detailed move-in condition report, take lots of photos, and maybe even record a video walkthrough. With secure e-sign software and proper verification, this could be a good setup compared to other risky applicants. Just tighten up documentation and screening to be safe.

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8mo

    @David P. No previous rental history to check? this can help. No credit score at all.  You can always do facetime or similar but sometimes it isn't the apartment that makes people back out but area so make sure that she is familiar with the area before you go off-market. If she is coming soon meet her, I don't think it will change your mind but she might waffle if she is coming from a different kind of area. A plus is you are getting her at the beginning of her orders although orders change.

  • Jeff IsaacsPro Member
    Member since 2025 · 36 posts · 17 votes
    8mo
    One benefit of military tenants is that if there was some serious issue I’ve heard you can go to their commanding officer. I would check around in your area.
    • Member since 2020 · 404 posts · 235 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Jeff Isaacs:
      One benefit of military tenants is that if there was some serious issue I’ve heard you can go to their commanding officer. I would check around in your area.

       The potential tenant said they do need to send the lease so they can qualify for the housing allowance so ya you might be rught in that with a lease violation they could lose their monthly allowance

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    8mo

    We do this several times annually.

    Be sure to get a nonrefundable Holding Fee from her, NOT a deposit. 
    - Deposits are legally refundable, fees are not.

    You should identify the cosigner as a non-occupying guarantor on your lease. Be sure they are also responsible for any damages.

    Also recommend you get the name & contact info for their commanding officer. This may be useful if the tenant causes too many noise complaints, etc.

    • Member since 2020 · 404 posts · 235 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:

      We do this several times annually.

      Be sure to get a nonrefundable Holding Fee from her, NOT a deposit. 
      - Deposits are legally refundable, fees are not.

      You should identify the cosigner as a non-occupying guarantor on your lease. Be sure they are also responsible for any damages.

      Also recommend you get the name & contact info for their commanding officer. This may be useful if the tenant causes too many noise complaints, etc.

       Question. For the non-refundable deposit it would still be applied towards the security deposit once its determined she is staying right?

      FYI, I have done my due dilgence and everything is good so far. I have face time the mom who is a real estate agent in Denver CO. Verified her credit score, bank statements. Main issue i have right now is she is asking if she can venmo me the security deposit and hold off first months rent until the day of arrival. Even after giving her my drive licence, closing escrow statement, proof of insurance and video time at the property she is still worried about sending money without meeting. What is the risk there with taking a venmo as security deposit and having a lease signed?

    • Drew SygitBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
      8mo
      Quote from @David P.:
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:

      We do this several times annually.

      Be sure to get a nonrefundable Holding Fee from her, NOT a deposit. 
      - Deposits are legally refundable, fees are not.

      You should identify the cosigner as a non-occupying guarantor on your lease. Be sure they are also responsible for any damages.

      Also recommend you get the name & contact info for their commanding officer. This may be useful if the tenant causes too many noise complaints, etc.

       Question. For the non-refundable deposit it would still be applied towards the security deposit once its determined she is staying right?

      FYI, I have done my due dilgence and everything is good so far. I have face time the mom who is a real estate agent in Denver CO. Verified her credit score, bank statements. Main issue i have right now is she is asking if she can venmo me the security deposit and hold off first months rent until the day of arrival. Even after giving her my drive licence, closing escrow statement, proof of insurance and video time at the property she is still worried about sending money without meeting. What is the risk there with taking a venmo as security deposit and having a lease signed?


       You have to be careful with Holding Fees. You don't really want to specifically state what they will be credit to, other than "all move-in funds".

      Do NOT let the mother send you a "security deposit", call it a Holding Fee.

    • Member since 2020 · 404 posts · 235 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:
      Quote from @David P.:
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:

      We do this several times annually.

      Be sure to get a nonrefundable Holding Fee from her, NOT a deposit. 
      - Deposits are legally refundable, fees are not.

      You should identify the cosigner as a non-occupying guarantor on your lease. Be sure they are also responsible for any damages.

      Also recommend you get the name & contact info for their commanding officer. This may be useful if the tenant causes too many noise complaints, etc.

       Question. For the non-refundable deposit it would still be applied towards the security deposit once its determined she is staying right?

      FYI, I have done my due dilgence and everything is good so far. I have face time the mom who is a real estate agent in Denver CO. Verified her credit score, bank statements. Main issue i have right now is she is asking if she can venmo me the security deposit and hold off first months rent until the day of arrival. Even after giving her my drive licence, closing escrow statement, proof of insurance and video time at the property she is still worried about sending money without meeting. What is the risk there with taking a venmo as security deposit and having a lease signed?


       You have to be careful with Holding Fees. You don't really want to specifically state what they will be credit to, other than "all move-in funds".

      Do NOT let the mother send you a "security deposit", call it a Holding Fee.


       With a signed lease, in the event she shows up the day of and decides not to move in wouldnt the lease entitle me to use the security deposit for missed out rent until i can find a tenant to fill? They are signing a 1 year lease

    • Drew SygitBusiness Member
      Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
      8mo
      Quote from @David P.:
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:
      Quote from @David P.:
      Quote from @Drew Sygit:

      We do this several times annually.

      Be sure to get a nonrefundable Holding Fee from her, NOT a deposit. 
      - Deposits are legally refundable, fees are not.

      You should identify the cosigner as a non-occupying guarantor on your lease. Be sure they are also responsible for any damages.

      Also recommend you get the name & contact info for their commanding officer. This may be useful if the tenant causes too many noise complaints, etc.

       Question. For the non-refundable deposit it would still be applied towards the security deposit once its determined she is staying right?

      FYI, I have done my due dilgence and everything is good so far. I have face time the mom who is a real estate agent in Denver CO. Verified her credit score, bank statements. Main issue i have right now is she is asking if she can venmo me the security deposit and hold off first months rent until the day of arrival. Even after giving her my drive licence, closing escrow statement, proof of insurance and video time at the property she is still worried about sending money without meeting. What is the risk there with taking a venmo as security deposit and having a lease signed?


       You have to be careful with Holding Fees. You don't really want to specifically state what they will be credit to, other than "all move-in funds".

      Do NOT let the mother send you a "security deposit", call it a Holding Fee.


       With a signed lease, in the event she shows up the day of and decides not to move in wouldnt the lease entitle me to use the security deposit for missed out rent until i can find a tenant to fill? They are signing a 1 year lease


      That would be up to a judge - who are usually more tenant-friendly than landlord-friendly.

      I'm done helping you as you just seem to want to question all the advice I post. 

      Good luck with that approach with people trying to help you.

  • Ryan SpathBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Boise, ID · Member since 2017 · 614 posts · 389 votes
    8mo
    Quote from @David P.:

    Wanted to get some advice. I have a 1 bdroom unit for $1,650/mo in the city of Long Beach California. A 19 year old female from out of state who is currently in the coast guard and will be transferring to San Pedro on a 3 year rotation.  She has no credit history but is able to show me a pay stub of $1,700 biweekly and also a $2,700/month housing allowance from the coast guard.  Also will be showing some bank statements from her mom and herself. 

    She is willing to sign a lease without physically viewing the unit and will need to sign a lease electronically. Her mom is willing to co-sign for her since she does not have any credit history. 

    Typically I would like to meet a person face to face but since this is not possible I wanted to ask if there is any red flags or big risk here? It is a low end unit here in my area and most of the people I am getting are either bad credit or trying to move a family of 3 into there. She did get a video tour of the unit and wants to proceed. The government salary sounds safe but with basically no rental/credit history I am basically got not much to go on.  I never actually done a co-sign before. Would it just be another name and signature on the lease?


     I'm in Idaho, we have folks move here from out of state and it isn't uncommon for them to want to get housing sight unseen. We have had great luck with this type of tenant.

    I have no person experience with the service member tenants, however I have had friends in the service and the govt paid the rent. It seems like it would be extremely stable. The one consideration would be if they become deployed you will likely have to let them out of the lease. 

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    8mo

    @David P.  Do not call it a non-refundable deposit. Call it a holding fee.  It is just more clear and in the rental environment people will understand better that they won't get it back if they don't take the unit.  Any time they hear deposit they think they will get it back.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.