3/1 vs 3/2

Most Popular Reply

Noah WrightBusiness Member
Lender 路 USA, Nationwide 路 Member since 2024 路 641 posts 路 185 votes
1d

Yes, a 3/1 rents fine in plenty of markets, and asking this before you buy is the right order. What matters is what the other three-bedrooms around it have, because tenants compare your house to the ones they could rent instead. If most nearby 3-beds are 3/2, you'll sit vacant longer or take less rent. If most are 3/1, yours is normal. Pull rented comps from the last few months, not just asking prices, and see what a second bath actually adds in that neighborhood. It also matters for financing, since a DSCR lender's rent estimate usually comes from similar rentals, so the bathroom count can move the number the loan is judged on. Do the 3/1s near yours lease quickly?

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • John RacinePro Member
    Rental Property Investor 路 Casselberry, FL 路 Member since 2008 路 296 posts 路 154 votes
    1d

    Bill, every property can rent. A 3/1 just takes more planning and better marketing than a 3/2.

    Start with who the unit actually fits. On a long-term lease, think about remote workers. A couple or a single person working from home may only sleep in one bedroom and use the other one or two as offices. To them, a 3/1 isn't missing a bathroom. It's a home with dedicated office space, often at a lower rent than a 3/2. On the furnished side, I see a lot of work crews, so I'd market a one-bath to a crew of two or a single traveler, not four adults.

    Then price and market to that person. Look at what one-bath comps are actually renting for, not 3/2 comps. Write the listing for the tenant you picked: for a remote worker, lead with the office space, the internet speed and a quiet workspace. Planned that way, the missing bathroom becomes a pricing decision, not a reason it won't rent.

  • Real Estate Agent 路 Kansas City 路 Member since 2018 路 5k+ posts 路 3k+ votes
    1d

    Plenty of 3/1s rent. You'll have a lower rent compared to a 3/2 but I wouldn't avoid them. Just analyze the rent based on the current set up.

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender 路 USA, Nationwide 路 Member since 2024 路 641 posts 路 185 votes
    1d

    Yes, a 3/1 rents fine in plenty of markets, and asking this before you buy is the right order. What matters is what the other three-bedrooms around it have, because tenants compare your house to the ones they could rent instead. If most nearby 3-beds are 3/2, you'll sit vacant longer or take less rent. If most are 3/1, yours is normal. Pull rented comps from the last few months, not just asking prices, and see what a second bath actually adds in that neighborhood. It also matters for financing, since a DSCR lender's rent estimate usually comes from similar rentals, so the bathroom count can move the number the loan is judged on. Do the 3/1s near yours lease quickly?

  • Developer 路 Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida 路 Member since 2026 路 206 posts 路 46 votes
    19h

    @Bill Vaughan, good day. Three bedrooms and one bathroom teach a household scheduling very fast 馃檪

    If you ever want that half bath, the builder's question is where the pipes already are. A closet that backs onto the existing bathroom or kitchen wall shares the drain and vent, so the job stays small.

    When the drain has to cross the house, or a concrete slab has to be cut, the same half bath can cost several times more.

    So before you buy, look at what sits behind the bathroom wall. Is the house on a slab or a crawlspace?

  • Michael GonzalesBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent 路 San Antonio 路 Member since 2018 路 38 posts 路 14 votes
    18h

    @Bill Vaughan 3/1s rent fine. You just have to price them against other 3/1s, not 3/2 comps. We have a lot of older one-bath homes in San Antonio, and they lease to the same people every month: couples, single parents, folks who'd rather save a couple hundred bucks than have a second bathroom.

    A few things that help: keep the one bathroom in great shape (it gets twice the use), and be honest about the layout in the listing so you don't waste showings on families of five. One of my properties is actually a 2/1 and I was concerned it would have issues renting, and it actually rented very quickly and the overall feedback I got when I was showing it, didnt have anything negative to say about having just one bathroom

    If you're buying, the bigger question is whether there's room to add a half bath later - as well as the type of foundation it is on (slab, probably not worth it vs pier and beam, which is a lot easier to add one). That can be one of the better forced-equity moves on a rental, but get a plumber's quote before counting on it.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager 路 Royal Oak, MI 路 Member since 2012 路 13k+ posts 路 9k+ votes
    13h

    When did you look at how many 3/1 properties are on Zillow in your area?

  • Mechanicsburg, PA 路 Member since 2013 路 3k+ posts 路 2k+ votes
    8h

    In our experience 3/2 get better rents than 3/1. We have converted several properties. We had a 3/1 that we converted to a 3/2 by converting the pantry into a 3 piece bath with a shower. At another property, a 2 story, it had a full bath on the second floor and a full bath in the basement, but nothing on the first floor. We converted a closet into a 1/2 bath. We had a 4br with 3 baths where we even added another 1/2 bath. We're working on a project now where are converting a 2/1 into a 4/3, doubling the sq ft and doubling the price. All of our current 3 br have at least 2full baths. And our current buy box is 3br, detached with at least 2 baths and built since year 2000. The only properties that we have with less than 2 baths are 1 br apts.

  • Property Manager 路 Denver, CO 路 Member since 2026 路 36 posts 路 13 votes
    8h

    I'd compare how long the 3/1s sat, not just what they rented for. Everyone's right that you price against other 3/1s, but the rent gap is usually the smaller number. If a 3/2 gets $150 more a month that's $1,800 a year. One extra month empty on a $1,700 house costs about the same, so a 3/1 that takes 3-4 weeks longer to fill at every turnover is really giving up about twice what the rent comps show.

    Easy way to check: on Zillow filter rentals to 3 beds and exactly 1 bath in that zip and look at days listed on the active ones, then do the same for 2 baths. If the 3/1s are going in about the same time I wouldn't worry about it. If they're sitting noticeably longer, that's when the half bath math Michael and Vladimirs mentioned starts to make sense.

    Is this one you already own or one you're looking at buying?

  • Realtor 路 NJ 路 Member since 2023 路 224 posts 路 100 votes
    6h

    Agreed with the conversations above. 3/1s will sit longer if your comps are 3/2s but really depends on your market. Location plays a big factor, along with any other lifestyle amenities.

    Why not invest and create that 2nd bath? Adding a bathroom will increase your ARV (more than it will cost in most cases) and you can charge higher rents after. And down the line, when it's time to sell, you'll have a larger pool of buyers too.

  • Realtor 路 Columbus, Franklin County 路 Member since 2026 路 214 posts 路 77 votes
    3h

    @Bill Vaughan Agree with the comp advice above. I'd add one step: price the half bath and compare it with the rent gap. Check plumbing access first (basement or crawl is usually far cheaper than cutting a slab), get a real bid with the permit, then look at leased 3/2 vs. 3/1 comps nearby. As an example, if a half bath costs $12K and leased comps show 3/2s getting $100 a month more, that's $1,200 a year, about a 10% return on that money, plus possibly faster leasing. If it needs $25K of slab work for the same rent bump, it usually doesn't pencil. Is the house on a basement, crawl space or slab?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.