Does this sound like a rental scam? Please help, need to sign lease

Does this sound like a rental scam? Please help, need to sign lease

Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2014 · 10 posts · 0 votes

I've been searching for a rental home for a while now. Finally found one that fit all the criteria via Westside Rentals (I'm in SoCal). There were 2 numbers listed as contacts, for "Rob" or "Katy." Rob did not answer; Katy did. She set up for me to go look at the house, as the owner (Rob) lives in Florida.

I went to look at the house and was greeted by one of the current tenants (his wife was at work, baby was at home). He took me on a tour and seemed very friendly. They are obviously in the process of moving but there is still plenty of stuff everywhere--the kitchen, bathroom, garage, and outdoors are obviously lived-in and full of baby stuff but the bedrooms and living room looked scarce.

He answered all of my questions, explained that Rob lives in Florida but Katy lives here and is the property manager. He says she calls occasionally to make sure everything is okay but otherwise does not come by. He said his wife has taken a job out of state so they are moving, but it's a great house, etc.

I talk to Katy later, tell her I loved the house, and she asks for my email address to have Rob send me the rental application. He emails me later that night with the standard application and credit check forms. I submit with my credit card # to have my credit checked. I didn't even think about how strange this was that I hadn't met the owner or the manager yet, just the tenant. Anyway, Rob has emailed me back today that my credit/application is approved. He will be sending me the lease to fill out and once I send him my check, he will remove the listing and the house is mine. Come October 1st (in one month), he will fly up here to give me keys, do the initial inspection with me, etc. once the current tenants have vacated completely and the property has been cleaned. 

Now, here's where I'm confused:

-There is still another whole month before I'm moving in. I feel weird handing over nearly $8,000 to someone who lives in Florida (via check) whom I've never met or spoken to and then sitting around for a month before I get my keys.

-Can't I just pay Rob come October 1st when we meet in person and inspect the house together? He sort of makes it sound like until he gets my security deposit, the house is still up for grabs. I have excellent credit and high income and have expressed that I am committed to this home; is that not good enough?

-Katy the property manager has not once offered to come show me the house or bring paperwork; everything has been with Rob through email. I have spoken to Katy now 4 times on the phone and she lives 5 minutes away (according to a Google search of her phone number).

Is this all sounding legitimate? I should note that the property is not priced at a bargain, nor is it a "too good to be true" scenario. My credit and income are excellent, so I am not surprised at them accepting me as a tenant either. Just concerned about this long distance setup. I have gone to look at 20+ homes in recent weeks and every one had either a realtor or the owner there to greet me.

I have also Googled Rob's full name, email address, and cell phone number. He does indeed appear to be who he claims he is, and I have seen his personal blog, Facebook account, and also several rental properties with good reviews on vacation home sites based in Florida. Katy's number comes back with 2 different women's names attached to it.

Please help--how do I go forward from here? I don't mean to sound paranoid, but Los Angeles is fraught with rental scams. Normally I'd just move on if I had any doubt, but I kind of have my heart set on this place. THANKS!

0Reply
233 views

Most Popular Reply

Northern, VA · Member since 2013 · 141 posts · 29 votes
12y
Generally when people turn like that and start going crazy and making threats that "you better do the deal or else", it's a scam and this is their last ditch effort to get your money. I would probably get a new credit card too just to be safe. If he's been renting properties for so long, why is he spending hours typing up a lease?
See this reply in the discussion

52 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2014 · 10 posts · 0 votes
    12y

    Ugh, now he is repeatedly emailing me. Every 5 minutes or so. Just saying all sorts of inane things.

    I contacted Westside Rentals and they said they want nothing to do with this. I guess it's stupid of me, but I thought they provided some sort of renter's protection from this kind of thing. Wrong!

    I'm not sure how to safely rent property in this town. I suppose it will have to be through a major company. This has totally put me off my house search.

  • Yreka, CA · Member since 2014 · 8 posts · 5 votes
    12y
    Sounds like "Katy" is apart of this scammers web. I'd be sure to notify the police about her/ post tenants beware
  • Investor · Vancouver, WA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y

    @Lola C. I commend you for checking this character out and standing up to him with dignity. Thank you for sharing your experience with others. It is educational and a wake up call. It's possible this scammer hijacked a legitimate landlord's advertisement and the house that interests you is actually owned by someone else. Did you check property ownership through the county records? Is Westside Rentals a front? Please don't give up hope. If you are a solid candidate, there will be many legitimate and ethical landlords out there who would be glad to rent to you!

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2013 · 47 posts · 12 votes
    12y
    Wow! I'm sorry you had to experience this. As the saying goes...always trust your instincts. It's sad that we live in a world where people can't earn their money in a legitimate manner. This my friend was a TOTAL scam and you're lucky you didn't give into the pressure of this scam artist and end up losing your money. I'm from Los Angeles, but I currently live in Texas. Don't let one bad apple spoil the bunch. You will find a place and it will be better than the one you had your heart set on. Everyone in LA isn't a scammer, but you're wise for going with you gut and reaching out to the BP community for advice. Good luck with your search and thank you for sharing. I didn't even know scams like this exist.
  • Nicole A.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Baltimore County Maryland and Tampa Florida · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    12y

    Wow, yeah, as you know, do not move forward with this. Never give money without both parties signing something. Even for a "holding fee", I wrote up an agreement that the applicant and I signed.

    The guy is crazy. Plus, any experienced landlord wouldn't spend "hours" typing up a lease for you. They would have a template where they just plug in specific details like your name, date, address, rent amount, etc. Takes a few minutes. 

    Block his email. Do not respond.

    Besides your credit card info, did you also give him your social security number? Monitor your credit card; in fact, perhaps call your credit card and ask for a new CC number.

    Sorry you had to miss out on a house you liked.

    Also, even for Cali, $8K to move in sounds crazy high. You might as well purchase your own place.

  • Investor · Middletown, NJ · Member since 2008 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    Run, @Lola C. , run! As Al Bundy once said, "Run like Mexican water through a first time tourist - but just run!!"

  • Wholesaler · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2014 · 8 posts · 1 vote
    12y

    This does sound like a scam.  Why would they have your credit card, SS# and continue to contact you.  Once you tell someone to stop and not interested, that should be it.  Since you already notified your bank, ask them if there is any other group that you can notify to Red Flag this group and / or individual.  Best of luck.

    Richard

  • Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2013 · 354 posts · 98 votes
    12y

    @Lola C. 

    Wow... I'm so sorry you went through this!  I'm a landlord and I would not have done what this guy is doing to you with the ridiculous responses.  Do keep an eye out on your credit reports.  Sorry that Westside Rentals is not taking any responsibility in this.  Best of luck to you and thank you for sharing this story.

  • Investor · Middletown, NJ · Member since 2008 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    I lived in LA in the early/mid '80s, and rental scams were all the rage then too. Rental companies would take the ads from newspapers and a free weekly paper called the Recycler, and then advertise them as their own rentals. They wanted all kinds of up front money and I heard stories that they double and triple dipped potential tenants for the same properties. It scared me then, and it's just as scary now that it's still prevalent.

    LA is a desirable place to live, and there will always be people looking to take advantage of that.

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Chicago Suburbs, IL · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 594 votes
    12y

    Sounds like a scam. Unless this guy is stuck in 1982 he shouldn't be dragging out his Smith Corona to type up a lease from scratch. And the fact he is now emailing you every 5 minutes; once any normal landlord is told a potential tenant isn't interested, they move on, especially if they have tons of other interest as he says. Maybe the guy is a legit but certifiably nuts, it’s hard to tell. You were at the property and did meet current tenants who obviously live there.

    Also, in our state now, you need to have some type of license to show and manage rental property, either a licensed real estate agent, leasing agent, or property manager. Given that this is California I wouldn’t be surprised if they didn’t have the same type of law in already in place.If that’s the case, you could get this Katy person in a whole world of trouble with huge fines.You can look up licenses in California, just google "license lookup California.”If you are interested in protecting others from a scam, I would contact whatever website his listing is at (Zillow, Trulia, Craigslist) and let them know what happened to you and that you believe the listing is a scam. Who is Westside Rentals, btw??

    Since the guy has your social security number, DOB, and current address, it may be in your best interest to sign up for one of those credit monitoring services to make sure some new cards don't pop up under your name. And to be safe you may just want to get a new credit card issued with a new number.

  • Northern, VA · Member since 2013 · 141 posts · 29 votes
    12y
    I would definitely invest the small amount of money to protect your credit now. Existing Credit cards aren't that big of a deal because, like you said, you just report it and they refund you. But if they use your SS# and personal info to open accounts, that crap takes FOREVER to fix on your credit reports. Trust me.
  • Involved In Real Estate · Winston-Salem, NC · Member since 2013 · 277 posts · 188 votes
    12y

    It sounds like Rob is a long-distance landlord and Katy is assisting him.  She can't 'show' you the property or sign the lease with you if she is not licensed (at least that's the rule in NC).  Could be legitimate but it's too much money on the line to take a chance.  I'm a long-distance landlord and had a similar situation play out a few years ago, where I never actually met one of my former tenants.  But they only had $900 on the line and of course, I am legitimate.

    The response from Rob would make me run away fast.  As a long-distance landlord, the last thing I want is a 'pain in the a**' tenant, so if I thought someone was being too high maintenance before the lease was even signed, I'd move on to the next applicant.  Sounds like you may be the only applicant and Rob is trying to lock you in with a not-so-nice attitude.

  • Real Estate Investor · Panama City, FL · Member since 2012 · 265 posts · 58 votes
    12y
    What about the people actually living in the house? Are they apart of it? Is that actually rob and Katy????
  • Real Estate Investor · Panama City, FL · Member since 2012 · 265 posts · 58 votes
    12y
    I have a feeling you may have already meet them! Maybe send the police to investigate, if they will...
  • Rehabber · Smyrna, GA · Member since 2013 · 864 posts · 510 votes
    12y

    OK, so I haven't read every post so forgive me if this is redundant.

    First off, no way do you send $8k anywhere to reserve a house.  A few hundy is all it should take prior to move in to hold it.   You pay the real money when you get the keys.

    The owner is going to fly in from Florida to do a lease?  That doesn't happen.  If he was legit, he'd have an authorized agent in place to handle it for him.  No landlord has a business plan to spend that kind of coin to rent each house.  

    The "you better give me money or you'll lose" stuff is a huge red flag.  

    I get copies of driver's licenses from people when I do certain things that involve money with people I just met.  Small thing, but it tends to keep them on the up and up knowing I can track them down if I need to.  If they balk at that kinda thing, not only should you run, but you should get as much info on them as you can and tell the police about it.

  • Rehabber · Smyrna, GA · Member since 2013 · 864 posts · 510 votes
    12y

    OK just read the rest of this.  Sounds like you've got a winner on your hands.  I'd bring this up to someone, and seriously make an effort to end this game so they don't shaft other people.

  • Property Manager · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2014 · 7 posts · 0 votes
    12y

    Most definitely a scam Lola. Rob became too angry, too quickly. 

    Good thing you you're following your intuition and asking for feedback. 

    Great post!

    Regards, 

  • Mark B.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Morgan Hill, CA · Member since 2012 · 212 posts · 64 votes
    12y

    Check your credit report and dispute the credit check - if anyone is investigating this it would be one way for them to track down where Rob really is.

  • Investor · Lansing, MI · Member since 2014 · 86 posts · 31 votes
    12y

    I live in Florida, and I have a few rental properties in Michigan.  I get this situation a lot, and for me, I have my brother on site that shows the property.

    To me, this sounds like scam for the following reasons:

    1) If the landlord is in a different state, he will most likely get someone trustworthy to show his properties. His money is at stake, and he won't take a chance on this. If he can't do this, his house will be on the MLS for under market value so he can get it rid of it asap.

    2) No landlord will get angry if you question their authenticity.  If any tenant ever asks me if I'm legit or not, I would tell them contact the city assessor to find out who owns the properyt, and it will match up with my name.  my name matches with my email and mailing address, and phone numbers.  

    3) No landlord "spends hours" typing up anything.  Even during the very first rental I did, I got a template on the internet and fillout the blanks.  Since then, I've updated my lease agreements to add specific terms to fit my situation, and now it's a 5minute job to change the tenant's name and lease dates.

    4) I make all prospective tenants give me a deposit to hold a property for them.  The most I charge is 1 months' worth of rent for the hold - it's like I've rented the unit for a month if the prospect cancels.  Unless your rent is $8000/month, this deposit is too steep, and unreasonable, to hold the unit for a month.  

    Sounds like a scam, but I could be wrong.  Perhaps these investors are really that dis-organized and unprofessional.  I've not met too many disorganized and unprofessional investors that owns properties that commands $8000 worth in move-in costs.

    But if you really want this property, I'd wait until the move-in date to sign the lease, and pay all move-in costs/first month's rent.

  • Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2014 · 10 posts · 0 votes
    12y

    Hi everyone,

    Just wanted to say thank you for all of your input and support. This is such a wonderful community!

    I only received 2 more emails from "Rob" after the one I posted in the comments. They were full of more rambling, swearing, and insults towards me. I didn't reply to any of them. This man has my personal information and I think it's best not to taunt an angry lion.

    To be clear--the property was renting for $2,500/month. He wanted a $7,500 deposit plus extra for my dog, so the total would have been around $8,000. Which is a lot of money, but according to him, it's "pocket change" and he "couldn't care less" about my "measly $8,000."

    I'm going to sign up for a credit monitoring service today just to be safe. I've seen peoples' lives temporarily ruined by identity theft and do not want to fall victim to this man.

    As to the tenant who showed me the house, he was not "Rob." I have spent some time Googling Rob and have seen dozens of photos of him. He is in his 50s and looks very sleazy. His wife looks about 15. All of their Facebook photos are public and are of the two of them gallivanting about the Bahamas and Paris. Something about the look of them REALLY rubs me the wrong way. Not the age difference, but just the two of them look like couples you see on the 10 o'clock news. The tenant in the house was a guy about my age, late 20s, with a 1 year old baby. He seemed fairly normal. I Googled the home's address and had hits for our local papers' recent Yard Sale sections; the photos showed the belongings in the house. So I do think these tenants indeed have been renting the property and are indeed moving out and trying to sell some of their stuff before they go.

    Lastly, Westside Rentals is a rental service here in L.A. They charge a fee for landlords to list their properties, and a fee for tenants to look at "exclusive" rentals that can't be found on other sites. They are not necessarily high end. They used to be more popular (10 years ago?), but it seems they don't provide any real support to their customers any more, so I see why they're losing customers. My situation is the perfect example of how little they care. Back when they started, they handled all of the applications, leases, and money exchanges to protect both parties. They no longer do this apparently.

    Anyway thanks again everyone!

  • Dawn AnastasiPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 6k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Lola C.:
    To be clear--the property was renting for $2,500/month. He wanted a $7,500 deposit plus extra for my dog, so the total would have been around $8,000. Which is a lot of money, but according to him, it's "pocket change" and he "couldn't care less" about my "measly $8,000."

     I have never in my life heard of a deposit that high.

  • Queen Creek, AZ · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    I would check with the local police.  

    If this guy is a scam artist he will be in the system as will his assistant.  If they are a threat to your credit the police can tell you and you may do the good deed of stoping these people before they "rent" to someone else.

    They can also call this guy and ask a few questions, if he is legit it might teach him some manners. 

    I don't know CA law but Arizona limits deposits to 1 1/2 or 2 times monthly rent, way less then what this guy was asking.

  • Queen Creek, AZ · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    I you are looking for a legit property manager with rentals check here:

    National Association of Residental Property Managers

  • Northern, VA · Member since 2013 · 141 posts · 29 votes
    12y

    @Lola C. Glad to hear you stayed away and are taking the time to protect your identity.  I seriously had heart burn when I read this the other day!

  • FL · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 357 votes
    12y

    @Lola C.,

    I strongly recommend that you do  a Credit Freeze.

    Credit freezes are one of the most effective tools against economic ID theft available to consumers.

    Here is Information concerning a Credit Freeze

    Raymond

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.