Late Rent? What's your "way too late date" to get paid

Late Rent? What's your "way too late date" to get paid

Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2014 · 239 posts · 177 votes
Hey BP, So I've got some tenants that seem to be 3, 4, maybe 5 days late just about every month on rent. Usually it's not too big of a deal because they are great great tenants when it comes to up keep, noise, and overall good people. But this last month I had a situation where my tenant (who's in the unsettling construction industry) couldn't get paid from a job and gave me his notice that he had to move because he was way too unsure about when, if ever, he'd get paid. He told me that he and his family would be out by Sunday the 10th, Well the 9th rolls around and he comes to me late with the rent saying he got paid and they didn't want to move anymore. This is totally all well and good, but I just don't want this to happen time and time again, but I also don't want to lose "well behaved and good tenants". So my long winded question for you is, what's your absolute last date of the month you feel is acceptable to get paid before you've had enough, or want a different set of tenants? Thanks!
0Reply
26 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Northville, MI · Member since 2013 · 264 posts · 183 votes
10y

@Lelith Walker is right on target, you have to be firm and run your rental(s) as a business.  Your lease should spell out exactly when the rent is due, when it is overdue, and what the consequences are for being late.  You must stick with what is in writing, as agreeing to deviations will only invite more deviations, and will undermine your position if you have to move forward with eviction and the tenants challenge the eviction in court.  

Remember, you only have one (I'm assuming) empty property at a time, and at any given time there are hundreds or thousands of potential tenants in that area looking for a home, so among all those potential renters there are many who are exactly what you are looking for.

Good luck!  

See this reply in the discussion

10 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2013 · 263 posts · 141 votes
    10y

    My properties are in different states so I go according to the law.  Each state does differ on how long you should wait before charging late fees and when you can actually give notice to quit.  Also in NY if your lease states to be paid on the 1st and you constantly keep taking late payments without fees then they normally will Not rule in your favor. http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/paying-rent

    Check with lawyer to go over your rights, speak or write to your tenants expressing your concerns.  Make a firm decision, cause at the end of the day this is a business even if you have fallen in love with your tenants.  You can find other good tenants who will pay on time and keep your place clean. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Northville, MI · Member since 2013 · 264 posts · 183 votes
    10y

    @Lelith Walker is right on target, you have to be firm and run your rental(s) as a business.  Your lease should spell out exactly when the rent is due, when it is overdue, and what the consequences are for being late.  You must stick with what is in writing, as agreeing to deviations will only invite more deviations, and will undermine your position if you have to move forward with eviction and the tenants challenge the eviction in court.  

    Remember, you only have one (I'm assuming) empty property at a time, and at any given time there are hundreds or thousands of potential tenants in that area looking for a home, so among all those potential renters there are many who are exactly what you are looking for.

    Good luck!  

  • Investor · Riverside, CA · Member since 2014 · 239 posts · 177 votes
    10y

    Thanks for the responses @Lelith Walker and @Ken P..  I couldnt agree more.  More than anything it just feels good hearing from experienced landlords like yourselves that being more stern and firm is the right path to take.  They really are great people, but as you said, Im thinking I might need to revamp the lease alittle and show them that this is a business.  Im going to look into the laws of when late fees can be applied in my area. I appreciate the input! 

  • Investor · Century, FL · Member since 2015 · 950 posts · 603 votes
    10y

    Late doesn't bother me, part payment doesn't bother me either. Being short isn't also a problem.

    What is important is that the tenant keeps talking, even if their problems are getting worse. When they keep talking to you, they will get back on top of things.

    It's when the tenant goes silent that the problems start. When the tenant goes silent, that's when the three day notice goes up. When they are silent they are shopping for a new property, and the money they should pay you is going towards a new deposit somewhere else.

    And here's the thing, how much money will you lose if the property is empty for a month? Ok, so they mess you around once too many times, they move out, the property is now empty for a period of time. Do you make more money being flexible, or being firm?

  • Financial services executive · Frederick, MD · Member since 2015 · 609 posts · 341 votes
    10y

    I would never put up with this from a tenant. Here as in California rent is due on the date specified in the lease and there is only a grace period if you write one in. We make it clear, in bold type that rent is due on the 1st, a 5% late fee will be assessed on the 5th and we will file an eviction on the 6th.

    Unlike in California an eviction here costs $20 (including to have it served) so you'll want to play around with when you take them to court.

    I agree with the above advice that you sue them once they've gone silent, but you always enforce your late fees and I would post the 3 day pay or quit notice and most certainly collect your late fee. When you are thinking about them being late they're forcing you to do extra work and the late fee is meant to compensate you for that. In my mostly low income housing portfolio we had 92% pay on time this month. The late fee on the second wears them down into strict compliance. I have never waived a late fee. 

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    10y

    The real question is do you take on the responsibility of being a responsible landlord. Do you train your tenants that due by the first means due by the first. Or do you simply imply by your actions that when ever they can pay is fine because they are such good tenants and you are only operating a business as a hobby.

    Good tenants pay in full on time every time. Bad business owners do not make or enforce rules because they are weak and/or afraid to properly operate a business..

  • Investor · Century, FL · Member since 2015 · 950 posts · 603 votes
    10y

    There's a small hypocrisy going on here.

    Take a previous thread last week about paying tenants to move out rather than getting an eviction. I was rounded on for never even considering paying someone to move out, whilst the spineless landlords would pay out because it lessened their financial loss.

    Yet in this thread, every landlord is hard as nails "evict on the 6th", whereas I'll work with a tenant and most times get paid in full, rather than have a property empty for month after getting rid of a tenant that most of you would get rid of in a heartbeat.

  • Member since 2016 · 13k+ posts · 12k+ votes
    10y

    I personally would never pay any tenant to leave. Just for the record.

    However serving a notice on the 6th, or whenever, is not for the purpose of evicting it is to teach a tenant the harsh reality of being a tenant. You don't actually want to evict you want to put the fear of Landlord into them so they don't pay late again.

    They need to be taught like a new puppy. Only if they are unteachable do you consider finding them a new home (or putting them down).

    Doing the right thing in business can some times be difficult when people mix emotions and business together. Those two things should never go together when money is in the balance.

  • Investor · Henderson, NC · Member since 2016 · 484 posts · 208 votes
    10y

    It really depends on my mood and the tenant to be honest. I don't really have any hard rules on anything. Did they piss me off recently? If the answer is no then I will probably work with them. If they answer is yes I probably won't. Being late one month isn't that big of deal, as long as you pay the late fee, but over and over again is not acceptable. I always make it clear that my units are in demand, and if you aren't going to pay for it I will get somebody who can.

    It's really important if you are going to be late to talk to me about it, BEFORE it becomes late. I'm much more likely to make a deal with you at that time. I had a tenant lose his job and tell me he simply could not afford the last 2 months on his lease. I considered his perfect previous payment history, and the fact that he talked to me first, and let him pay 50% for 4 months instead of full price for the last two months. I didn't even add a late fee.

    On the other hand, I have a tenant who constantly says something like "I'll pay $700 on Tuesday", then Tuesday comes, he conveniently only has $500 on him, he'll bring the rest tomorrow. Or some other day after I've asked 6 times. Same thing every time any payment is due, like I must have forgot he did that last month. I plan on evicting him.

  • Investor · New York City, NY · Member since 2013 · 263 posts · 141 votes
    10y

    @Todd Fithian I do not mean to come down on you but the lease may not be the only thing that needs to be revamped.  You can have a strict lease but if you do not reinforce it and stick to your guns then your tenants may run over you.  You give some people an inch and they will take a yard.

    @James DeRoest I value peace of mind over money others might not.  On the otherhand, I guess it also depends on your market and location plus if you still have a job.  I am in NYC and Atlanta.  I do not have a hard time finding tenants.  So far people ask me if I am renting without me even advertising.  I never worry too much about vacancy. 

    As to your other statement I was not familiar with the other post and I do not feel that I am hard as nails either. There are going to be times when I have let my tenants slip. For example, several years ago I had one that was an insurance fraud investigator who had to travel for work.  She told me before hand she did not know how long one particular case was going to be for.  She paid the current and the following months rent upfront.  She came on the third month late.  I dropped the late fee on her for the third month.  She was never late again.  It depends on the situation. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.