Property Manager Expectations

Property Manager Expectations

Laguna Niguel, CA · Member since 2018 · 8 posts · 2 votes

I'd appreciate any input you guys have for me.

I bought an out-of-state SFH rental property in St. Louis back in October through a turnkey provider. They work with a local property manager that does their rehabs and manages the properties on an ongoing basis as well. It took about 45 days to get a renter in, but after that I thought it would be smooth sailing.

Since then, the property manager has failed to send my the renter's basic information after many requests. I've never seen their application, I don't have basic contact information, other than a couple screen shots of their background check I have no idea if there's actually a renter in there or who it is other than a name.

Additionally, it's taken the property manager well past the date that they're supposed to send me the collected rent each month. For example, they told me to expect rent on the 10th (assuming it's received on time) and I didn't receive it until the 17th last month (even though I was told it was paid on the 5th), and I still haven't received anything this month or even notification as to why it might be late (it's the 13th).

I'm also not receiving the monthly reports I was told I would receive while I was vetting them out.

Is this normal? Are my expectations to high? If not, how hard is it to switch?

Thanks everyone!

0Reply
46 views

Most Popular Reply

Ricardo R.Pro Member
Property Manager · Michigan Ctr, MI · Member since 2016 · 663 posts · 581 votes
6y

@Heidi Omans @Blake Wardman my advice on finding a good PM is to focus on services. Where I think most investors go wrong is that they focus on price first and then wonder why the company that is going to carry out those services doesn't perform as expected. For instance if your decision making factor is the monthly management fee between PM companies then you probably have already lost again. Now I'm not saying that just because a PM company has a high management fee it makes them better, but it doesn't make them worse either --- it's all about the services and quality of service. Just to break it down a bit lets just say your rental brings in $800/mo. ... most PM's will probably charge 10% so I'll use that --- that translates into about $80/mo. that you pay your PM to manage that unit. Now... if all you cared about was collecting the rent then it wouldn't be such a big issue.... but I can think of 40+ additional services that you will need or require and that a PM will provide for that fee - collecting the rent is ONE of those 40+ tasks but it is what the management fee is based on. 

The issue always comes down to many owners mistaking the phrase 'property management' for 'all inclusive' - to varying degrees. Don't know about you... but $80/mo. to manage a unit with the abundance of tasks that might be called on is not a money maker or the 'luring' incentive that many owners believe it is. So going back to the 10%...... 10% of what? for what services/quality? .... That is really the question you need to be asking and looking to answer when vetting PM's. Throughout the process keep in mind that your $80 a month is not and will never be 'all inclusive' specifically if your asking PM's to do anything that is outside of their tried and true management system. It is just not worth it for a PM to have an exception to their system just for your property and the next and the next... you're fee only works within the system. So for example, if your PM inspects their units bi-annually with relative success but you'd rather it inspected every month because you believe you know better... expect them to 1) either charge you more or 2) not fulfill your request.. and so it's always best to just continue looking for a PM that fits what you're looking for. 

To recap however, the vetting process would have to address each of those 40+ tasks while under management and even more while for lease --- so really, you can certainly turn away a PM when they do a task differently than you would like but eventually you're just going to run out of PM's to vet and at some point you have to realize that your property is ONE property within a system of management and instead focus on overall customer satisfaction and end results that a PM delivers. Hope this helps. 

See this reply in the discussion

11 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Chris ClothierBusiness Member
    Rental Property Investor · memphis, TN · Member since 2009 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Blake Wardman:

    I'd appreciate any input you guys have for me.

    I bought an out-of-state SFH rental property in St. Louis back in October through a turnkey provider. They work with a local property manager that does their rehabs and manages the properties on an ongoing basis as well. It took about 45 days to get a renter in, but after that I thought it would be smooth sailing.

    Since then, the property manager has failed to send my the renter's basic information after many requests. I've never seen their application, I don't have basic contact information, other than a couple screen shots of their background check I have no idea if there's actually a renter in there or who it is other than a name.

    Additionally, it's taken the property manager well past the date that they're supposed to send me the collected rent each month. For example, they told me to expect rent on the 10th (assuming it's received on time) and I didn't receive it until the 17th last month (even though I was told it was paid on the 5th), and I still haven't received anything this month or even notification as to why it might be late (it's the 13th).

    I'm also not receiving the monthly reports I was told I would receive while I was vetting them out.

    Is this normal? Are my expectations to high? If not, how hard is it to switch?

    Thanks everyone!

    Blake, do you have leasing agreement and management agreement with your property manager?   I assume you do, so pull it out and read it.  It should spell out how you terminate management.  Get versed on that contract and then  commenters can give you better advice on that.

    As for what you should do?  You need to get a new manager asap if they are not meeting your expectations and it doe snot sound like they have met even the the most basic expectation.  If you stay with them, then you are confirming that is the way you expect to be treated.

  • Specialist · New York, NY · Member since 2019 · 22 posts · 7 votes
    6y

    Blake - Chris couldn't have said it better. Read the management agreement and understand the correct way to go about terminating it. This is most certainly not normal and should not be how your investment gets managed! 

  • Ricardo R.Pro Member
    Property Manager · Michigan Ctr, MI · Member since 2016 · 663 posts · 581 votes
    6y

    @Blake Wardman  you have received good advice on here from @Chris Clothier and @Jeff Weaver. You need to find your management agreement, read through and find out how to cancel it. If you're supposed to be getting monthly reports and they're dropping the ball that's no good. On the tenant background information however, you should at least be provided with the lease and the names of your tenants however, we nor most reputable PM's will share sensitive tenant background or contact information with owners. You should certainly be getting your disbursements for rent sent to you on schedule however, I wonder if you're receiving them late because the Tenant's are either missing or paying their rent late - either way however, your PM should be keeping you in the loop if that's the case.  

  • Laguna Niguel, CA · Member since 2018 · 8 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    @Ricardo R.  @Chris Clothier@Jeff Weaver Thank you all for the thoughtful responses. This gives me some good guidance and direction for next steps. I received some updates today, with some intervention from the turnkey company, so hopefully this gets us back on the right foot. This is strike two, but you've given me some good direction if/when strike three happens.

    Thanks again.

  • Rental Property Investor · Augusta, GA · Member since 2019 · 129 posts · 112 votes
    6y

    Blake, couple of things here.  Chris and some other folks gave solid advice in knowing your management agreement and how to cancel.  Depending on how you read it, sounds like they're not holding up their end of the agreement and should be easy to get out of.

    From the PM standpoint, I wouldn't expect information on the resident background or credit check, but your PM should share their rental criteria and your comfort is knowing they screened through this criteria.  You should certainly get a copy of the lease if requested.

    In regards to continuing down the road, I don't think it's the best idea.  There's really no excuse for them to miss their owner payouts in back to back months (or ever for that matter).  

    Also, not sure what you mean by a turnkey provider as it sounds like they're outsourcing their rehabs and property management?

  • Investor · Worcester County, MA · Member since 2016 · 122 posts · 72 votes
    6y

    Good advice above.  Obviously you need to start identifying, vetting, and interviewing other property managers, before you make a move and terminate.  Good property managers are not real easy to find.

  • Member since 2019 · 6 posts · 0 votes
    6y
    I would appreciate any advice on how to find a good property management company.   I also have rental property in the St. Louis area and it is almost ready to lease.  I am having difficulty finding a property manager.  Thanks.
  • Laguna Niguel, CA · Member since 2018 · 8 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    @Heidi Omans I'm in the process as well but my best advice would be to network and get referrals. I'll let you know if I find one and maybe you can do the same.

  • Real Estate Agent · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2014 · 683 posts · 317 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Heidi Omans:
    I would appreciate any advice on how to find a good property management company.   I also have rental property in the St. Louis area and it is almost ready to lease.  I am having difficulty finding a property manager.  Thanks.

     Hi Heidi, You probably want to call them and interview them. Here are the area that I'm looking to know.

    1. What technology are they using to show the house. There are smart lock (Rently) solutions out there that make showing a lot easier. 

    2. Where they're going to list your property? 

    3. Ask for references. 

    4. Ask them what to expect in the area your house is located. What's their track record of leasing a house out in the location you are in.

    5. Read their agreement and make sure you understand what's their responsibilities/due dates. 

    Hope these helps.

  • Ricardo R.Pro Member
    Property Manager · Michigan Ctr, MI · Member since 2016 · 663 posts · 581 votes
    6y

    @Heidi Omans @Blake Wardman my advice on finding a good PM is to focus on services. Where I think most investors go wrong is that they focus on price first and then wonder why the company that is going to carry out those services doesn't perform as expected. For instance if your decision making factor is the monthly management fee between PM companies then you probably have already lost again. Now I'm not saying that just because a PM company has a high management fee it makes them better, but it doesn't make them worse either --- it's all about the services and quality of service. Just to break it down a bit lets just say your rental brings in $800/mo. ... most PM's will probably charge 10% so I'll use that --- that translates into about $80/mo. that you pay your PM to manage that unit. Now... if all you cared about was collecting the rent then it wouldn't be such a big issue.... but I can think of 40+ additional services that you will need or require and that a PM will provide for that fee - collecting the rent is ONE of those 40+ tasks but it is what the management fee is based on. 

    The issue always comes down to many owners mistaking the phrase 'property management' for 'all inclusive' - to varying degrees. Don't know about you... but $80/mo. to manage a unit with the abundance of tasks that might be called on is not a money maker or the 'luring' incentive that many owners believe it is. So going back to the 10%...... 10% of what? for what services/quality? .... That is really the question you need to be asking and looking to answer when vetting PM's. Throughout the process keep in mind that your $80 a month is not and will never be 'all inclusive' specifically if your asking PM's to do anything that is outside of their tried and true management system. It is just not worth it for a PM to have an exception to their system just for your property and the next and the next... you're fee only works within the system. So for example, if your PM inspects their units bi-annually with relative success but you'd rather it inspected every month because you believe you know better... expect them to 1) either charge you more or 2) not fulfill your request.. and so it's always best to just continue looking for a PM that fits what you're looking for. 

    To recap however, the vetting process would have to address each of those 40+ tasks while under management and even more while for lease --- so really, you can certainly turn away a PM when they do a task differently than you would like but eventually you're just going to run out of PM's to vet and at some point you have to realize that your property is ONE property within a system of management and instead focus on overall customer satisfaction and end results that a PM delivers. Hope this helps. 

  • Member since 2019 · 6 posts · 0 votes
    6y
    Thank you all for the excellent advice.  I will certainly consider all of the suggestions while looking for a property manager that fits my needs.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.